12 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE Raw From 2005
Welcome to the year when Monday Night Raw became John Cena's flagship.
Raw has been many things to WWE over the years. It's been 'War' and 'Jericho', for example. In 2005, it became a vehicle to push John Cena to the forefront as the brand new poster boy of his generation. 'Super Cena' moved to Mondays during the 2005 Draft, and there was a real good reason for that - he'd been on SmackDown for years, and it was clear that John's next step was dominating the 'A' show.
Cena wasn't the only fledgling main event mainstay on Raw though. Edge was right there with him, and the Canadian planned to seize the very title JC had been holding. He'd become WWE Champion alright, but not until 2006. The patience creative types showed with their blossoming 'Rated-R Superstar' is really quite special looking back.
It wouldn't be the kind of patience WWE would show Money In The Bank too often.
2005 had a little bit of everything. Whilst Batista settled into a groove on top of SmackDown, Raw put on borderline PPV quality episodes over in Japan, rushed back into the waiting arms of the USA Network with a memorable Homecoming, dropped the ball on an easy push that would've been grounded in gritty realism, and even went 3 hours for the first time in its lifespan.
There's a lot to unpack here, so get ready. We've got forgotten onscreen romances that ended with a literal thump, teary tribute shows that had more to offer than some might've expected inside the ring, and missed opportunities wrecked by ego behind the curtain.
Raw Is War? Nah, Raw is everything.
12. WWE Dropped The Ball On Matt Hardy
News of Matt Hardy's April 2005 release hit his fanbase like a sledgehammer. It was so unexpected, but then details started to leak out about the circumstances behind it. Matt found out that his girlfriend Lita had secretly been seeing Edge, and he was naturally distraught by it. Eventually, due to fan pressure and knowing they could make some dollars here, WWE brought Hardy back into the fold.
People were right behind Matt’s story in the summer of '05. He was a jilted lover who wanted revenge on Lita and to tear Edge apart. His 11 July return was the hottest thing in the biz at the time, but then Edge beating him in less than 5 minutes at SummerSlam muddied the waters and a lot of the magic was gone. Vince McMahon blatantly didn’t want to push Matt as a main eventer because that wasn’t his plan, but he probably should’ve pivoted and ran with Hardy as a ’Stone Cold’ style rebel.
The fan support was there, and Matt carried an air of legitimacy when he was encouraging fans to watch him in ROH on WWE TV. Things like that didn’t happen at the time. This was pre-CM Punk "Pipebomb", after all. Watching all of this play out with the benefit of hindsight makes it pretty obvious that Hardy could've been booked better than he was.
He needed to give Edge the ultimate comeuppance, and he needed to use his real-life heartache as fuel to become akin to WWE's very own Punisher. Instead, they raced through the most tangled up emotions then moved him over to SmackDown just like that.
Talk about missed opportunities to create a new headline star.
11. There’s A Forgotten WWE Romance
Today on, 'WWE Couples You've Completely Forgotten About"...
A fresh faced Randy Orton and Stacy Keibler were an item onscreen right up until Randy hit her with an RKO on the 21 March 2005 Raw. They'd been running around flirting like high school lovers for a while before WWE put that angle on the format sheets. If it felt sudden, then that's probably because it was.
The RKO on Stacy was all part of a plan designed to put across just how far Orton would go when trying to end The Undertaker’s streak at WrestleMania 21. In fairness, the spot looked great, but this writer had honestly forgotten all about Randy and Stacy’s romance until rewatching Raws from this era. They don't exactly pop up when people talk about the greatest power couples in the biz, do they?
This was a pretty strange period in Orton's career. He'd been excellent as a cocky young brat in Evolution, then threatened to breakout as the next big babyface sensation before turning heel all over again. WWE knew they had someone special on their hands, but they didn't quite know what the best way to use him was.
Yet. That'd change over the next couple of years.
In March '05, the writers used Keibler's misfortune as a means to thrust Randy right into the clutches of 'The Deadman'. That's a little story nugget many might've misplaced in their brain boxes over the years. Technically, Stacy could've been an even bigger part of the story heading into 'Mania 21's now annual 'wrestler tries to end the streak' match.
10. Randy Orton’s Injury Comeback Was Odd
What was that about Vince McMahon not really being 100% sure on the best way to use Mr. RKO? That was never more evident than when Randy returned from an injury layoff on the 16 May '05 edition of Raw to proudly announce that his shoulder issue meant he simply couldn't be involved in the upcoming 2005 Draft.
McMahon interrupted him to say he bloody well could be involved in the Draft, injured or not. That's when things got funky and almost counterproductive. Vince also ridiculed Randy’s appearance by saying he’d dropped weight and was on “some kind of anorexic diet”. Orton looked miffed by all of this, defended his inability to lift weights because of the injury, then stood around awkwardly as Vince left.
It was such an odd segment from beginning to end.
Firstly, it looked for all the world like WWE had picked out a suit that was a size or so too big for Randy. Did they do that just so McMahon could cut him down with some cruel verbal jabs that verged on the boss saying: 'Get on the juice, son'?! If not, then why didn't Orton have any real comeback for some of the stuff Vince was saying? He seemed caught off guard by it.
The segment closed with McMahon strolling off (in typically comical fashion) as Randy wondered what the future held for him, and WWE's cameras zoomed in to catch him pondering what the boss had said. It'd be awesome to find out if Orton even remembers this face to face, and if he knew in advance everything Vince was going to fire his way.
It sure didn't look like it.
9. Eddie Guerrero’s Tribute Was More Than Tears
There were a lot of tears on show during the Eddie Guerrero tribute Raw on 14 November. Understandably so. Wrestlers in the locker room, staff in the office and wrestling fans around the world had lost somebody they held dear. For the workers specifically, a close friend and peer had been ripped from their midst without warning, and now here they were on TV talking about it.
WWE scrapped a lot of their plans for the night and just let some folks go out there to wrestle or talk about Guerrero. It shows the strength of the roster and their resolve that the show had some cracking matches on it. No, really. Most recall the emotion most of all, which is fair play, but a few bouts on the card are well worth your time.
Kurt Angle vs. Shelton Benjamin was a battle of former 'Team Angle' mentor and protege. Throughout, Kurt was fired up and likely found it cathartic to go as hard as he could inside the ring. Using wrestling to deal with powerful emotions is something Angle has spoken about before - he did it back in 2003 when grieving the death of his sister.
Then, there was Shawn Michaels vs. Rey Mysterio. That had a little more emotional weight than Angle vs. Benjamin due to Rey's involvement, and it truly is remarkable that he was able to function as well as he did between the ropes that night.
What a historic episode of the show. It's a dangerous one to revisit, because the tears will come whether you want them to or not, but some of the wrestling was top notch in spite of the circumstances.
8. HBK’s Second Run Was A Gift
In 2005 alone, Shawn Michaels proved why everyone would’ve been robbed had he never returned for a second stint from 2002 onwards. His 8 year reprieve that ended in 2010 was masterful, and it made up for some of the frankly rotten backstage behaviour HBK had exhibited when feeling the pressure in the 1990s.
By '05, Shawn was in a giving mood.
Check these cherry picked classics out: Michaels vs. Edge (a fiery ‘Street Fight’ on 28 February), vs. Shelton Benjamin (2 May) and vs. Kurt Angle (Raw Homecoming on 3 October) alone proved to be some of the biggest highlights on Raw all year. That superkick spot with Shelton will be replayed forever, but don’t sleep on the Edge match.
Of course, HBK's overselling for Hulk Hogan at SummerSlam was petty, but Michaels had a ridiculously robust year generally. The stuff with Hogan was perhaps the only time when he fell into old bad habits, but it's be unrealistic to pin the full blame on Shawn for that. Hulk wasn't exactly innocent when it came to backstage politics!
Forget all of that for now. This entry is fully focused on the good that Shawn Michaels achieved in 2005. He deserved a golden handshake for that Shelton match alone, and it's amazing that Benjamin didn't use that as his springboard (perhaps literally) to the top of the industry. He honestly looked so, so good in there vs. Michaels.
Oh, the Kurt bout was a 30-minute 'Iron Man' match too. More on that to come.
7. Hulk & HBK Could’ve Been One Hell Of A Team
Privately, Shawn and Hulk got along until they...didn't get along. They were reportedly set to work a 3 match series as rivals, but SummerSlam 2005 would wind up being their only pay-per-view showdown. Egos ran wild, brothers got to brothering, brother, and Michaels didn't really fancy finding out if he could gel with the red and yellow after all anyway.
That's a pity. Y'know what else is a shame? The fact that Shawn and Hogan only worked 3 televised matches as tag-team partners: They beat Muhammad Hassan and Daivari at Backlash, teamed with John Cena vs. Chris Jericho, Christian and Tyson Tomko on the 27 June Raw, then beat Carlito and Kurt Angle on the 4 July episode.
The latter match there showed the full extent of their potential as a double act.
Imagine how good a sustained run could’ve been had egos not got in the way. Sure, WWE wanted to book them as rivals for SummerSlam and beyond, but man - we missed out on an all-timer of a tag title run there. 'The Heartbreak Hulkamaniacs' could’ve been special had they been able to stay on the same page behind the curtain and had creative pressed pause on their plans for a while.
All going well, Hulk and Shawn could've worked as tag partners before splitting around Royal Rumble time then readying themselves for a blowoff at WrestleMania 22. That would've meant that Michaels vs. Vince McMahon in a 'No Holds Barred' encounter would've been delayed too, but that wouldn't have been a massive problem.
'Prayers N' Vitamins', baby. Picture it. Right, this writer will stop talking like Jimmy Hart now.
6. 2005’s Version Of Austin/McMahon Worked
WWE had already run with the same formula they used for Steve Austin vs. Vince McMahon a bunch of times by 2005, but the promotion went with it all over again once John Cena jumped over to Raw in the Draft. The new poster boy of the flagship instantly fell foul of GM Eric Bischoff, and Bisch tried to install various challengers who could take the WWE Title from John.
Chris Jericho and Kurt Angle were both inspired picks for that role.
Cena, as a true rising star, worked well opposite Bischoff. They had a good dynamic on TV, basically, and warring with the GM made Cena feel like an even bigger deal than he'd already been on SmackDown. Reliving all of this shows the true value of Eric as a TV character. He didn't mind coming up short, especially if it furthered someone else's career.
Bischoff had a job to do, and even his harshest critics have to give it up for him - there were few better at playing the smarmy heel boss who deserved comeuppance than 'Easy E'. Casting Cena in the 'Stone Cold' position opposite him was actually inspired rather than lazy. His quick-witted style and growing popularity with the fanbase ensured that this was always gonna work a treat.
Somehow, Cena and Bischoff even meshed well inside the ring too. OK, so they weren't working 25 minute WrestleMania matches, or anything, but they could get by on a few mins with some bells and whistles. Backed by a solid, easy to follow story, they nailed their feud in '05.
5. First Ever 3 Hour Raw Got It Right
Anyone who has tuned into one of them knows that WWE would eventually struggle to fill 3 hours on Raw every Monday over a sustained period, but the ‘Raw Homecoming’ for WWE’s return to USA Network on 3 October 2005 was different. It felt exciting back then to think that the flagship might be souped up by an extra hour.
That wasn't the norm, so it was fresh.
Knowing they'd still need to rely on superior in-ring work to carry them through, the company put Shawn Michaels and Kurt Angle in a 30-minute ‘Iron Man’ match earlier on the card. That was a shrewd decision, not least because HBK and 'Sexy Kurt' had already torn the house down several times in 2005.
Elsewhere, Edge and Matt Hardy contested a ladder bout that also determined where the former's Money In The Bank briefcase would end up, and John Cena worked a brief ‘No DQ’ main event vs. Eric Bischoff that never tried to be something it wasn't. Everything seemed to go off without a hitch.
As if that wasn't enough, various legends stopped by to have a few laughs. That concept wasn’t played out back then either, so fans were delighted to see the likes of Roddy Piper and Mick Foley sharing screentime on 'Piper's Pit'. Being honest, by October '05, Raw badly needed a show like this to reignite interest in the brand.
A few of the episodes before Homecoming were a little so-so, and it was the right call to make the jump back to USA Network feel like appointment television by tacking on that bonus third hour.
4. Raw In Japan Could’ve Been A PPV
Good lord, this was unreal.
WWE went international for the 7 February 2005 edition of Raw, and they knew some of the usual fare wasn't going to endear anyone to a more hardcore, wrestle-centric audience. So, when the card opened with Chris Jericho vs. Chris Benoit meeting one another in a ‘Submission Match’, fans in the Saitama Super Arena knew they were in for a treat.
Other bouts on tap? Oh, nothing special, just Ric Flair vs. Shawn Michaels, Tajiri and William Regal winning the tag titles from La Resistance, and Triple H vs. Edge for the World Heavyweight Championship. At times, this was a pay-per-view quality show with a completely different flavour compared to most Raws in the United States.
Batista beating Maven in 30 seconds and Randy Orton vs. Tyson Tomko were nothing to write home about, but those were fillers. Ditch them, stick a better match in there and this could’ve been a ‘B’ tier PPV easily. That's not something one could say about a lot of Raw episodes of the era.
Kicking things off with 2 guys who had history in the country was delicious decision making. Benoit was slightly more popular than Jericho with the local fans on the day, but both Canadians had everyone gripped mere minutes into their match, and they set a brilliant tone for what could be expected from the rest of the show.
Tajiri and Regal getting their flowers was another genuinely heartfelt moment. They were one of the best odd couple tag-teams going.
3. The Patience On Edge’s MITB Run Was Insane
Today, the Money In The Bank concept is arguably hackneyed and a bit of a struggle for writers to make interesting. That struggle has less to do with dilution (due to the addition of a women's briefcase) and more to do with the general idea that...well, almost every kind of cash in has been done. It rarely feels all that shocking or satisfying these days, and many of the pushes after don't last either.
That wasn't the case in 2005 when Edge won the first Money In The Bank ladder match at WrestleMania 21. Nobody knew for sure what would happen next once that match was over with. Edge won big on 3 April, but he didn’t cash in until New Year’s Revolution in January 2006. Throughout '05, WWE showed a ton of patience, which is something that’d lessen over time with the MITB briefcase.
It's possible that they hadn’t really figured out how to book it yet, or maybe they just wanted to bide their time with Edge's push towards main event status. However you look at it, it’s kinda incredible to look back on this patient approach now.
Edge even defended the briefcase vs. Matt Hardy on the 3 October Raw, and it wouldn't have been outlandish for him to lose it. WWE probs knew they'd be better off protecting the plan with the guy they'd put over at 'Mania 21. Edge's King Of The Ring push in 2001 didn't elevate him the way he'd hoped, so Vince McMahon was leaving nothing to chance 4 years later with Money In The Bank.
2. ‘The Funeral Of ECW’ Is Still Goosebumps Inducing
Raw's 23 May 2005 episode sticks out as historic.
Tyrannical brand GM Eric Bischoff planned to present a funeral for ECW (and gloated as he hyped it), but then Vince McMahon cut him off to say he partially funded ECW whilst killing WCW right at the turn of the millennium. Adding to the occasion, the ever-outspoken Paul Heyman then came out to run Bischoff down some more, put ECW over and hype the upcoming One Night Stand show.
This was phenomenal character work from all 3, and you’ve got to give it to Bisch. He was at his best whilst being torn to shreds, and he subtly put ECW over throughout by being horrified by the thought of Heyman’s brand getting recognition from McMahon. It was a fantastic segment to watch again; it's easy to find on YouTube if you fancy checking it out in isolation.
'05 was a year of takedowns for Bisch. He wanted to dance on ECW's grave but didn't get the chance, he wanted to flex his power muscles against John Cena but ended up fired, and Eric looked like he was having a blast no matter how much egg was thrown his way.
Meanwhile, Heyman was on top form as he spat venom at Bischoff/WCW (there was surely some truth to his intensity), and McMahon cleverly acted as more of a background overseer who decided not to jump in and tell both guys to shut the hell up.
It's easy to forget how amazing it was to see the WWE, WCW and ECW boss in the same ring on TV.
1. It Was A Poor Year For Women On Raw
Women's wrestling was in a sorry state in 2005, at least on WWE's watch. The company was still obsessed with Divas over everything, but that was fine if the talent levels were high. Unfortunately for all concerned, linchpin star Trish Stratus was out with injury for 4 months between May-September.
Despite that, WWE kept the belt on her, which meant the brand didn’t really have a Women’s Champ for a third of the year. Further, the ongoing Diva Search stuff was just painful to sit through. Ashley Massaro won the contest to bag a contract, but she was visibly out of her depth and way behind the likes of Trish, Victoria etc.
In hindsight, the whole “Vince’s Devils” idea with Torrie Wilson, Candice Michelle and Victoria was also regrettable and told the tale that the entire women’s division was just an ego trip for McMahon at times. It’s remarkable that Stratus was able to brave face a lot of this era, to be honest. She’s never shied away from her own sex appeal, but the content was poor and the lack of true opportunities to shine must’ve been irritating.
Massaro's story is a tragic, controversial and depressing one, and her on-screen role felt rigged against her achieving longterm success. WWE expected her to run before she could even walk.
What else did you learn from watching every episode of WWE Raw from 2005? For more wrestling, check out 10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE SmackDown From 2005 and 11 MORE WWE Returns That IMMEDIATELY Backfired!