10 Wrestlers Who Jumped Ship & Changed Absolutely... NOTHING!
These WWE, AEW, WCW, TNA and ECW jumps achieved precisely SOD ALL. Mission failed.
One of the greatest things about a wrestling war is the prospect of a given performer on one side of the divide showing up on the other. From the great AWA exodus to the many back and forth leaps of the 'Monday Night Wars', to talent jumping between WWE and AEW today, it's always fun to know that any of your favourite stars could be a turncoat.
Whilst a number of huge stars have changed the very face of wrestling by changing allegiances, other big names have tried to do this and failed spectacularly. Their defections made headlines when they first happened, but they quickly stopped being newsworthy at all.
These stars all had the potential to change the companies they joined, but most of them made little-to-no difference whatsoever. Some of them quickly discovered that the promised land wasn't so promised and ended up going back to the promotions they'd been with in the first place!
The following could be considered case studies, and they're all examples of how potential can be discarded so easily in wrestling. If you're planning on making a big defection in your own life, make sure you think it through...
10. Rick Rude
Here’s something you probably already know.
On 17 November 1997, ‘Ravishing’ Rick Rude became the first notable name to appear on WWE and WCW TV shows at the same time. Outraged by the 'Montreal Screwjob', Rude defected to Ted Turner’s side. By some quirk of fate, his final pre-taped appearance on Raw aired the very same night as his debut on a live episode of Nitro.
Rude’s best in-ring days were long gone, but he had still been a prominent part of federation programming. He was a member in the original incarnation of D-Generation X, serving as a bodyguard to Shawn Michaels, Triple H, and Chyna; because nothing screams "anti-authority" quite like a middle-aged bloke in a suit.
The man with the famous moustache never wrestled for WCW, but he was part of the New World Order. He lasted 2 years in the promotion before leaving in April 1999, sadly just a few weeks before his untimely death.
There wasn't much WCW could've done with Rude from an in-ring perspective, but he was still a big name who had joined under newsworthy circumstances. A little bit more would have been nice.
9. Ed Ferrara
In October 1999, whilst the rest of the company was away on a European tour, WWF head writer Vince Russo slipped away in the dead of night to join their rivals. Wonder how that turned out…
It’s easy to forget that Russo wasn’t the only one who switched sides. He was joined by Ed Ferrara, a former television writer and part-time wrestler who had only joined the creative team in 1998. Ed worked alongside Russo during the company's boom period and was an integral part of their eventual victory in the 'Monday Night Wars'.
Ferrara and Russo had a strong working relationship in Connecticut, but once they moved to Atlanta, the latter's wild ego quickly took over. At least the former got some screen time, albeit in one of the worst gimmicks in WCW history.
Oklahoma was a painfully obvious parody of Jim Ross. He was a comedy character who spoke with an exaggerated Southern accent and blinded his enemies with BBQ sauce. Ferrara also contorted his face while playing the character, which was a tasteless mockery of JR’s Bell’s Palsy.
Russo might have been more responsible for WCW's death, but Ferrara's hands aren't clean either.
8. Monty Brown
In the early days of TNA, many top stars were either WWE castoffs or Jeff Jarrett's old buddies from WCW. One clear exception to this was 'The Alpha Male' Monty Brown.
A former NFL player who had made it to the SuperBowl, Brown exploded onto the wrestling scene in 2004. His impressive physique, fiery in-ring style and charismatic promos instantly struck a chord with fans. Many believed it was only a matter of time before he was made World Champion, but for some reason that never happened.
After 2 years of trying his luck under the Jarrett regime, Brown decided to switch sides to WWE's bespoke version of ECW. Under his implausible new name of Marcus Cor Von, he competed in WWE's bastardised version of the Philadelphia promotion and even landed a match at WrestleMania 23 as part of the 'New Breed'.
Everything about Brown should have made him a huge star in WWE. Instead, he was relegated to a brand nobody cared about, given a stupid name, and sacrificed at the altar of older stars. The once-promising powerhouse abruptly retired from wrestling in 2007, aged just 37 years old.
What could have been.
7. Chris Harris
When Monty Brown was tearing it up as a singles wrestler, another TNA employee was making waves in the tag-team division. ‘Wildcat’ Chris Harris had risen to fame as one half of America’s Most Wanted alongside James Storm. With their valet Gail Kim, the pair got wildly over and captured the NWA Tag Team Championships no less than 6 times.
Following a breakup feud that culminated in a 'Blindfold Match' (of course it did), Harris embarked on a brief solo run in TNA before deciding to try pastures new. His WWE debut came on 8 July 2008 and is now the stuff of legend, just not in the way he would've wanted.
Under the name Braden Walker, Harris approached Armando Estrada and delivered the most terrifying thing in the English language: A knock-knock joke. After telling Estrada that he was going "knock his brains out" in a painfully half-assed manner, it was clear that Mr. Walker was not long for this world.
Harris wrestled just 2 televised matches for his new home before being released. This served as a stark warning to all TNA stars that the WWE grass was definitely not greener.
6. Aleister Black
You could start a new country with all of the breakout NXT stars that Vince McMahon wasted on the main roster. It wouldn’t be a very big country (think Andorra or Monaco-sized), but you get the idea.
One name in contention for President of this new land would be Aleister Black. After dominating the independent scene as Tommy End, the Dutchman embarked on an NXT run that included capturing the brand's top title. Then, after doing diddly squat following his call-up, he was released in 2021.
A month later, the rechristened Malakai Black showed up on AEW Dynamite and laid out Cody Rhodes. It turns out that WWE forgot to update his contract, so instead of a 90-day non-complete clause he only had a 30-day one instead.
Hilarious.
Black won the Trios Titles with Brody King and Buddy Matthews, but that was about it. He also reportedly refused to be pinned in singles matches, which made booking him a total nightmare. He'd return to WWE once Triple H took over. Once again, things didn’t go his way, and he was released for a second time in 2026.
Oh dear.
5. Paige
The career of Saraya-Jade Bevis is full of incredible highs and depressing lows. Somebody should make a movie about it. Oh wait!
Following a career-ending injury in 2018, the woman known as Paige in WWE spent years in various non-wrestling roles. Then, at AEW Grand Slam 2022, the unthinkable happened. Under her real name, Saraya stepped into the ring and made it clear that she was here to wrestle.
Here was someone who had helped revolutionise women’s wrestling in the US. She was still relatively young and had a great story to tell. AEW couldn’t possibly screw this up, could they? It quickly became clear that wrestling had left Saraya behind. She got a big moment at the first All In, winning the AEW Women’s Championship in her home country, but she just wasn’t able to keep up with the rest of the roster.
Paige returned to WWE at WrestleMania 42 and won the Women’s Tag Team Titles with Brie Bella, but she is very much a nostalgia act now. It’s clear that Paige’s best in-ring days were taken from her through injury, which must be an incredibly bitter pill to swallow.
4. Ruby Soho
The 2021 edition of AEW All Out is widely recognised as one of the greatest pay-per-views in modern times. The show famously saw the in-ring return of CM Punk, as well as the shocking debuts of Adam Cole and Bryan Danielson, but there was another debut on that show.
As part of the women’s 'Casino Battle Royal', Ruby Soho (formerly Ruby Riott in WWE) came out as the final ‘Joker’ entrant. She eliminated Thunder Rosa to win the match and earn a shot at Women’s Champion Britt Baker. Although Soho’s debut felt like a big deal at the time, it was quickly overshadowed by the surprises at the end of the show.
Over the next few weeks, it didn’t take long for Tony Khan to tire of his tattooed newcomer.
Soho lost her title match against Baker and almost immediately became an afterthought. She reached the finals of the TBS Title and Owen Hart Cup tournaments, but was more often than not found on shows like Rampage or Dark. She's still with the company now, having taken maternity leave, but you get the feeling that Ruby's ship has very much sailed.
3. Tazz
If you wanna talk about great debuts that went nowhere fast, then there’s only one name to mention…"IT’S TAZZ".
That was the iconic call made by Jim Ross at Royal Rumble 2000. Kurt Angle’s obnoxious demand for an open challenge was met by the former ECW Champ, who tore the roof off Madison Square Garden the moment he stepped onto the walkway. The 'Human Suplex Machine' made quick work of the Olympian, handing him his first ever loss with his patented Tazzmission.
Sadly, the WWF wasted no time in cutting Tazz’s legs out from under him. Firstly, his win over Angle was overruled on account of him using an “illegal” hold. Secondly, his first proper feud was against Big Boss Man. Many old-school fans love them a bit of Boss Man, but he’s hardly Kurt f'n Angle is he?
By WrestleMania 2000, Tazz had been reduced to a bit-part player in the Hardcore Title Battle Royal. Then, by late 2001, he was a semi-retired colour commentator. His rough-and-tumble style and short stature just weren’t made for the WWF/WWE system, and he became yet another ECW stalwart to get lost in the shuffle.
2. Brian Pillman
The story about how Brian Pillman quit WCW and joined the WWF in the mid-90s is like something out of a spy novel. The 'Loose Cannon' managed to persuade Eric Bischoff to legitimately terminate his contract as part of a storyline. This worked shoot turned into a straight-up shoot when he used his newfound freedom to join Vince McMahon just a few months later.
A plan this brilliant deserved a better payoff, but Pillman’s fed career was mediocre at best. His feud with ex-teammate 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin might've given us the infamous 'Pillman's Got a Gun' moment, but a car accident earlier in the year had severely impacted his wrestling ability.
Brian's career was cut tragically short when he died in October 1997 at the age of just 35. There's every chance he could have made more of himself once the 'Attitude Era' got fully under way, but that's pure speculation at this point.
The remarkable nature of Pillman's departure from WCW and connection to Austin should have primed him for greatness. He remains a cult hero, however, mainly due to the fact that he had so much untapped potential.
1. Mike Awesome
Let's end how we started: With a story that has been told many, many times before.
Mike Awesome debuted on WCW Nitro on 10 April 2000 and immediately attacked Kevin Nash. There was just one problem: Mike was still the ECW Champion at the time. Owing to legal issues with Paul Heyman (quelle surprise), Awesome had jumped ship without officially dropping the belt, thus setting off a chain of events that we won't go into here.
Not only was this a major embarrassment on ECW's part, but Awesome was...well, awesome. An impossibly acrobatic big man with the strength to match, he was a totally unique prospect and could have been a world-beater. So, what did WCW do with him? They dressed him up in 70s gear and made him fall in love with plus-sized women.
These 2 infamous gimmicks ('That 70s Guy' and 'The Fat Chick Thriller') destroyed any credibility he might've otherwise had. Nobody's saying Awesome was going to single-handedly win them the 'Monday Night Wars', but he could have helped a damn sight more had WCW treated him with the respect he deserved.