15 MORE Wrestlers WWE Debuted In The Worst Way Possible

WWE is no stranger to disastrous debuts. These are 15 of the most egregious entries in WWE history.

Becky Lynch NXT
WWE

A pro wrestler's debut is one of the most important moments in their entire career. They say there's no second chance to make a first impression, and with how quickly fans make up their minds on a superstar, a stinky debut can put a performer back years, and sometimes sink them on their very first appearance.

WWE has struggled with this for years. For far too long, NXT would create a character and build a solid reputation for them with fans, only to see everything they had all worked towards decimated by WWE's main roster creative on night one. This isn't just a recent phenomenon either. For decades, superstars have been coming to WWE from the independents, rival federations, and even different sports, only to have their life's work compromised from the moment they arrive on Monday Night Raw or SmackDown.

Some of the best performers have managed to overcome the odds and survive their terrible debuts and the gimmicks or unpalatable partners they found themselves saddled with. Others were never able to claw their way back from a disastrous debut, and these are just a small sample of some of the most questionable debuts to ever hit our screens, courtesy of WWE.

15. Adam Rose

Adam Rose
WWE.com

During the early days of NXT, Leo Kruger was one of the more left-of-centre gimmicks to find its way onto that roster. Looking like a hunter and having a threatening demeanour, it didn't ever feel like it was going to set the world on fire, but it did have a certain retro charm and menace to it (especially if you remember a similar gimmick existing in the 90s with Skinner).

His repackaging as Adam Rose for the main roster was one of the most bizarre and unlikeable to ever occur. Rose himself would talk like Austin Powers if he had a South African accent, sucking on a lollipop and telling whoever was in earshot, "don't be a lemon, be a rosebud." 

Before he hit the entrance ramp, Rose would send out members of The Exotic Express, including a man in a bunny suit, a woman dressed as Snow White, and an assorted cast of goons who look like they'd been kicked through the discount aisle at a fancy dress store, all of whom would come out dancing to his music (which also oddly shifted from a sitar intro to a completely different sounding song). This gimmick was dead as soon as it soft-launched on NXT, before completely tanking on the main roster. It was every bit as rubbish as this sounds, and made Leo Kruger seem like a potential Hall of Famer.


14. The Ascension

The Ascension
WWE.com

Even to this day, The Ascension are one of the most dominant tag teams ever to step foot in an NXT ring. With more than a dash of the formula that made Demolition and The Road Warriors so popular in years gone by, Konnor and Viktor wore face paint and tore through their opponents with powerhouse moves and a then-record setting NXT Tag Team Championship reign across 2013 and 2014.

This felt like one of the easiest transitions WWE could ever make when it came to elevating them to the main roster. The gimmick is something that felt familiar to the wider audience, their pedigree in NXT was something to build on, and they were a bruising force in the ring. 

Instead, they became a regular figure of ridicule for heel commentator JBL and proceeded to lose with alarming regularity, despite defeating The Miz and Damian Sandow on their Raw debut on December 29, 2014. JBL would constantly berate the pair for being knock-offs of The Road Warriors, and the pair were jobbed out to old timers The New Age Outlaws and JBL's own, The APA, on only their second week on SmackDown. The Ascension never recovered from this nonsensical beatdown, with all momentum going up in smoke.


13. Cain Velasquez

Cain Velasquez
WWE

Cain Velasquez is a two-time UFC Heavyweight Champion and a mountain of a man. He also unfortunately lacked any kind of charisma or a face that's recognisable to WWE fans in the same way as Conor McGregor or pre-WWE Ronda Rousey might have been. 

With WWE striking a five-year, billion-dollar deal for the Fox Network to air SmackDown in the US, the October 4th, 2019 debut show for that needed something huge to kick off that partnership. There was a cameo from The Rock, before fans were enraged by Brock Lesnar defeating Kofi Kingston for the WWE Championship in less than 2 mins. The episode then ended with Rey Mysterio bringing Velasquez to the ring to confront 'The Beast Incarnate'.

Even now WWE been acquired by the owner of the UFC, TKO, the Venn diagram of fans who like both the UFC and WWE is a tiny pool. Hardly anybody recognized Velasquez, and everybody learned very quickly that the legendary MMA fighter was a terrible fit for pro wrestling. He was released within 6 months of his deal starting, with one loss to Brock Lesnar serving as his only match in WWE.


12. Xavier Woods

Xavier Woods R Truth
WWE

Xavier Woods is a vital part of what has made The New Day one of the most popular WWE factions of all time. He is a future Hall of Famer who has excelled at everything from in-ring brilliance and content creation away from the squared circle, to getting a trombone over with millions of fans around the world.

Things didn't start out so great for Woods though. After a fairly impressive run in NXT, he arrived on Monday Night Raw in November 2013, copying the Power Rangers "it's morphin' time" catchphrase before hitting moves, and being billed as R-Truth's friend and tag-team partner to face teams such as 3 Man Band and Tons of Funk.

Woods and R-Truth would stick together for around 6 months, with Xavier not given the platform to get his massive personality across, before he made the move that changed his life forever. Teaming with Big E and Kofi Kingston, things might have got off to a rocky start for the babyface New Day, but it wasn't long before Xavier left his rocky start in the dust for good.


11. Batista

Deacon Batista
WWE.com

Dave Bautista is a legend both in WWE and in Hollywood. With a glittering in-ring career as a former WWE Champion and member of Evolution, he has also gone on to have one of the biggest movie careers of anyone who made the jump from pro wrestling to the silver screen. As this piece is being written, he has only ever played one deacon, though.

It's one of wrestling's great mysteries as to what WWE creative saw in Batista that made them think he'd be the perfect sidekick for D-Von Dudley's first post-Dudley Boyz gimmick, Reverend D-Von. Deacon Batista is a gimmick straight out of the mid-90s. A man who wore a chain around his neck with a metal collection box attached, this mountain of muscle had to play this character for a few months, debuting on the May 9th, 2002 episode of SmackDown.

After assisting D-Von for around two months, including a feud with Randy Orton, the Deacon saw the light and turned on Reverend D-Von before being switched from SmackDown to Raw, starting his true rise as Batista and joining Evolution shortly after.


10. Becky Lynch

Becky Lynch NXT
WWE

Becky Lynch is one of the greatest pro wrestlers of the 21st century (and it's not just us saying it etc.). A true all-rounder, Becky Lynch is great on the mic, superb in the ring, and exceptional at keeping her character alive on social media in the moments that she isn't on air, but things didn't start so smoothly.

A lot of the early days of NXT are praised because they avoided so many of the stereotypes and bad gimmicks that befell WWE superstars, but Becky Lynch was not so lucky. Somebody in the creative department observantly noticed that Becky is of Irish descent, and so what better way to get her over than by having her really lean into that and make Becky Irish jig.

Not content with having this ridiculousness foisted upon her, she would also do the jig in the middle of her matches, and be given the task of shouting "diddly diddly dee" while doing so. Thankfully, this idea was given the shove shortly after her 26th June, 2014 NXT debut, and we are now blessed to have Becky be treated as a superstar in her own right, instead of being pigeonholed by her nationality. 


9. JC Mateo

Jeff Cobb JC Mateo LA Knight
WWE.com

It's easy to forget that a lot of people who consume WWE television do not engage with wrestling outside of that product. Jeff Cobb has been a champion in NJPW, Lucha Underground, and Ring of Honor, as well as winning numerous other accolades on the independent scene. He is a hot commodity to those in the know, but was never going to receive a hero's welcome just by arriving in the WWE.

When Cobb signed with WWE and debuted on the May 10th, 2025 as JC Mateo, it is the company's job to showcase what makes him so brilliant to those unfamiliar with his game. A hard-hitting powerhouse known for explosive physicality, his talents are worthy of him being booked as a monster who feels like a giant hurdle for WWE's litany of superstars to overcome.

Instead, JC Mateo has been booked as the weakest link in Solo Sikoa's MFT stable. WWE's audience has seen next to none of the crushing offense that made him such an attraction before setting foot in sports entertainment. It's a crying shame to see him making little-to-no impact since his arrival, because the audience that watches him every week is being deprived of what made him the hot commodity that made WWE want to sign him in the first place.


8. Mike Kanellis

Maria Mike Kanellis
WWE.com

Sometimes a gimmick is so baffling that it defies belief. Mike Bennett had done pretty well for himself in TNA, holding the X-Division Championship, as well as being a former tag team champion in Ring Of Honor. It's not an honors list that made him signing to WWE feel like it was going to shake up the industry, but it's far more respectable than the gimmick he found himself saddled with when he reached wrestling's largest platform. 

Making his debut alongside his wife Maria at Money In The Bank 2017, Mike Kanellis's massive pile of bonkers gimmick seemed to be that he was a married man in love. His entrance theme was modelled on a bombastic 80s power ballad, he was flanked by cascading hearts all over the screen behind him, and he posed holding hands with his partner. They both had headsets on instead of holding mics, while they promised to "educate everyone on the power of love" and twirled together like the first couple being sent home from Strictly.

Safe to say, nothing about this gimmick was ever going to work, and things completely fell apart as Mike had to go to rehab after four appearances on SmackDown before Maria Kanellis fell pregnant, writing her off of TV for months. The whole thing feels like a bad fever dream. 


7. Bo Dallas

Bo Dallas
WWE

Bo Dallas always felt like he had the love of the front office more than he ever had the people behind him. Nevertheless, he enjoyed a successful run in NXT, which included beating Big E for the NXT Championship and a memorable feud with Sami Zayn. His inherent smugness was undeniable, but when he hit the main roster, this went into overdrive (and not in a good way).

Bo debuted on Monday Night Raw on April 7th, 2014, with a motivational speaker gimmick not unlike the one that failed with DDP a decade prior. His catchphrase of "all you have to do is Bo-lieve" was enough to put fans' teeth on edge, with the kind of "go away" heat that is no use to anybody.

He went on a 14-0 winning streak, in which he would stand his opponent up afterwards to give them a patronizing handshake and a hug. A heel's job is to be booed and generate negative feelings from the audience, but this sickly gimmick felt so icky that it's an albatross that Dallas carries to this day, with Solo Sikoa mocking Dallas for it while Bo plays his latest role as Uncle Howdy in The Wyatt Six. 


6. The Spirit Squad

Spirit Squad
WWE.com

Even when you consider that The Spirit Squad debuted nearly 20 years ago, making their first appearance on Monday Night Raw on January 23rd, 2006, this awful gimmick felt dated. For the longest time, authenticity has yielded the greatest results, and so this group of male cheerleaders felt doomed from the start.

Sporting matching green and white tank tops and tracksuit pants, these 6 rookies were chiefly used as a group of goons for Shane and Vince McMahon (quelle surprise) in their feud with the dad joke era of D-Generation X. They made up lame cheers insulting whoever they were feuding with, in a way that came off as unfunny and annoying more than raising chuckles or generating heat.

The only reason this gimmick is even slightly remembered is that one of the Spirit Squad was Dolph Ziggler. He managed to escape the clutches of this ridiculous gimmick, reducing it to a footnote in an otherwise respectable career, while his fellow stablemates were all eventually let go without making a dent on the main roster. 


5. EC3

EC3 Impact
Impact Wrestling

It is rare that a talent is signed by WWE who feels so effortlessly ready to be a superstar. In a company that values character and personality as much as in-ring work, EC3 should have been the easiest of home runs to translate to their audience. His smug, self-serving, and cocky attitude, combined with a comedic ability to make himself the butt of any joke, felt like a match made in heaven for WWE.

After a great run in TNA, things started OK for him in NXT in 2018. His character was given enough airtime for him to gain a growing reputation with fans, but he felt like he was better suited to the main roster instead of the indie-lite product that NXT was pushing during this era.

Whether he pissed off somebody important in the back or got involved in some other kind of ridiculous backstage politics, EC3 was robbed of everything that made him great when he arrived on SmackDown on February 4, 2019. Given nothing in the way of mic time, he was even reduced to being an actual mute before being relegated to losing regularly on Main Event just a few months later. He was gone from the company entirely inside 14 months of his main roster debut, completing one of the most confusing WWE hires in recent memory.


4. The Red Rooster

Red Rooster, WrestleMania V
WWE.com

Terry Taylor was a journeyman wrestler who held championships in Mid South wrestling, World Class Championship Wrestling and more across the 1980s, and WWE's master plan was to turn him into a human rooster. The 1980s had so many gimmicks and larger-than-life characters, but the idea of asking a man to be a human cockerel may have been pushing it just a touch.

His stint as The Red Rooster would involve him strutting his arms and jutting his head like a man doing "the funky chicken" in an attempt to generate heel heat when making his debut in 1988. He was then asked to do the same, while smiling and donning a sequinned jacket, to try and make it work as a babyface.

Suffice to say, neither of these things worked for a man who'd previously had great regional feuds with the likes of Kevin Von Erich. This may have had a disastrous impact on Taylor's in-ring career, but there is something of a happy ending for the former man-sized rooster, as Taylor has worked for WWE since 2017 as part of Shawn Michaels' NXT team.


3. Matt Morgan

Matt Morgan
WWE.com

To say that Vince McMahon lacks compassion is to say that the desert lacks moisture. Even still, the idea that a pro wrestler's entire gimmick can be that he's a guy with a speech impediment is as insulting to the performer and WWE's audience as it is callous and ridiculous. Of all of the things that can define a performer, this is what Matt Morgan was saddled with and told to make work.

Morgan had enjoyed a few previous stints on the main roster, first under a mask as Kane's brother Abel (of course), and then as part Team Lesnar, a hastily put-together stable initiated to take on Team Angle at Survivor Series 2003. He also competed in the 2004 Royal Rumble match, but things were about to sink to a new low.

After being sent back to OVW for further training, Morgan would re-debut on SmackDown in April, 2005 with an extreme stutter as he spoke. The whole thing stunk, and this obscenely crass gimmick lasted less than 3 months before he was let go by the company for good on July 5th, 2005.


2. Scotty Goldman

Scotty Goldman
worldwrestler90.blogspot.com

Through his Art Of Wrestling podcast, Colt Cabana has become something of a household name within wrestling. His sharp-wit bleeds into his in-ring work, where his natural sense of comedic timing and how in-tune he is with audiences has seen him become a beloved wrestler on the independents and an occasional member of AEW's Dark Order.

His lovable personality was given absolutely no chance when Colt Cabana landed in WWE, performing under his actual name, Scotty Goldman. Debuting on the August 12th, 2008 episode of SmackDown, Goldman would manage to lose in less than 3 minutes to The Brian Kendrick. He was then beaten by The Great Khali and lost a two-on-one handicap match against Vladimir Kozlov while teaming with Funaki inside a month, before being kept off of WWE TV until February 17th, 2009, losing to Umaga.

What was most deflating about this run is that WWE's audience would have no idea that he possessed excellent comedic chops. When the height of his comedy was to use a paper bag as a ventriloquist dummy to insult The Great Khali, this all represented a great wasted opportunity for WWE.


1. Kizarny

Kizarny WWE
WWE.com

Nobody is going to argue against the idea that carnies are a scary proposition. Known for their manipulation and questionable morals, there are plenty of phobias that can be triggered an evil carnival character. If you're writing a horror movie, that's a damn good concept, but the idea of a carny being a WWE wrestler is something so cataclysmically bad that it could only come from the Vince McMahon era. 

Vignettes began airing for Kizarny, the heel carny superstar, on the October 10th, 2008 edition of SmackDown. Various freaks, sword swallowers, and circus folk were shown on these promos as creepy clown music played in the background, as wrestler Sinn Bodhi (real name Nicholas Cvjetkovich) debuted the character, Kizarny.

Cutting a promo for his vignette using a lot of words involving the "iz" kayfabe pig latin hybrid, Kizarny's words came across as absolute gibberish. Things didn't improve once he debuted on the first SmackDown of 2009 either. He defeated MVP on that occasion, but getting zero reaction from the crowd meant that the character had no chance of making any impact whatsoever. He was let go by WWE just two months later.


Contributor

Terry Bezer hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.