One MIND-BLOWING Secret From Every WWE SummerSlam

8. 2018 | Dream Sequel Not Possible In Nightmare World

Bayley Sasha Banks
WWE.com

NXT fans adored Bayley Vs. Sasha Banks from the inaugural TakeOver: Brooklyn precisely because it was so beyond the WWE norm. 

An ultra-rare young and cool and precocious female wrestler announced herself as a future megastar in defeat to an equally unthinkable WWE character: a pure earnest babyface. The match itself was astonishing, too; tonally violent and emotional to a staggering extent, well before the PWG influence took over, Bayley drilled Sasha with an avalanche poison ‘rana. WWE fans barely saw the traditional version in 2015. The entire presentation was jaw-dropping, and for many people, this was the definitive NXT match. Bayley Vs. Sasha embodied everything about the idealised future: timeless character dynamics and futuristic, heart-pounding action. Naturally, fans wanted to see Vince McMahon run it back on the main roster, where it really counted. Why couldn’t this take place at WrestleMania? Why couldn’t Bayley become the most universally loved wrestler in the world? 

Probably because Vince was so far gone that he could not recognise goodness without finding it weak. Bayley was typecast as a geek too timid to use weapons and so sexless that she couldn’t hold onto a boyfriend in high school. 

Fan-driven rumours pointed towards a SummerSlam 2018 match. We were back at the Barclays Center. Bayley needed the match to rescue her gimmick. Cageside Seats reckoned in July that it was on. 

The match didn’t happen. The opposite of something good happened because Bayley and Sasha underwent counselling and formed a corny tag team instead.


7. 2019 | Who Wanted To Pick A Fight With Aleister Black?

Aleister Black
WWE

Aleister Black loves WWE more than Vladimir Kozlov, Vladimir Abouzeide, and Michael Hamflett. If the social media scuttlebutt is to be believed, Ally spent his entire AEW run waiting for Triple H to ring him up and book him in a nine-month programme against Damian Priest that nobody gave a toss about. 

And yet, in 2019, the Aleister Black character didn’t seem to grasp how WWE worked. He stuck himself in a darkened room, with only his head visible, and asked various members of the roster if they wanted to “pick a fight” with him. Silly Aleister. If you want a match in WWE, you simply interrupt somebody’s promo! 

According to the August 9, 2019 issue of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Sami Zayn was going to pick a provisional fight with Aleister at SummerSlam. 

Usually, when you fantasy book a pro wrestling match between two very talented performers, you tend to be optimistic. You think of their respective movesets and dream up the coolest counters. You might even go as far as simulating the warfare on WWE 2K, knowing that it’s not the same, but you’re so jazzed over the prospect that it will have to do.

In WWE in 2019, even a daydream was impossible. You can almost see the short, poorly promoted and likely impromptu match unfold at 0.25 speed as thousands of eerily silent fans create a mere hum for the duration. 

You don’t need to imagine it; this exact scenario played out on the preceding SmackDown in a nothing match that nobody remembers. 


6. 2020 | Glorified Backlash

Edge Randy Orton
WWE.com

SummerSlam has lost its appeal in recent years. CM Punk Vs. Gunther (2025) and Drew McIntyre (2024) are the only truly massive-feeling first-time meetings between two huge, established names to have taken place at the so-called Biggest Party of the Summer of late. The Punk/Drew match was also very obviously the first in a trilogy too. 

SummerSlam 2023 was the site of the dismal Tribal Combat meeting between Roman Reigns and Jey Uso. WWE ran back Roman Vs. Brock Lesnar at SummerSlam 2022 for the mindnumbing seventh time on PLE. This was the second SummerSlam meeting; they also did the same Paul Heyman match in 2018. WWE booked a sequel to Roman Reigns Vs. John Cena in 2021. 

What’s basically happened here is Saudi Arabia. There is far more in the way of financial incentive for WWE to book unique matches for the regime as opposed to the public. The glue factory-bound horses aren’t getting out of bed for a SummerSlam these days. If the Undertaker is going to put his life in the hands of concussion fetishist Goldberg, he’s going to do it in Jeddah.

This explains why the first draft of the SummerSlam 2020 card was essentially Backlash; Drew McIntyre Vs. Brock Lesnar was pencilled in for August, per WrestleVotes, but Brock was never going to work again in 2020. Before Edge went down with a triceps injury at the actual Backlash, he was set to conclude his trilogy with Randy Orton at the glorified Backlash. WWE had already promoted the second meeting as the Greatest Wrestling Match Ever. How were they going to market the third?

‘It Probably Won’t Be As Good, But We Only Know How To Book Trilogies Here’?


5. 2021 | WWE Almost WCW 2000’d The Biggest Title Change Ever

John Cena WWE Title 2025
WWE.com

Roman Reigns held the WWE Universal title for 1,316 days. Because he won the WWE title at WrestleMania 38, and held both concurrently, WWE promoted it as the modern day equivalent of Bruno Sammartino’s 2,803 stint - which, since very few people really care about that anymore, positioned Roman as the most successful WWE wrestler ever. It worked. You have to forget that virtually all of 2021 was bobbins, and that any “real” promoter would have booked a proper Cage match to prevent the Usos from interfering every bastard time, but it worked. People engaged with and bought into the idea that Roman was the kayfabe most dominant guy ever, and Cody Rhodes’ WrestleMania 40 win felt like a landmark coronation and the very height of WWE’s third boom period. None of this happens to quite the same effect in a timeline very similar to that which unfolded. 

That is because, according to the man himself, when speaking to the No Contest Wrestling podcast in March 2026, John Cena was meant to win his 17th World title at SummerSlam 2021. If you forget about Ric Flair, Cena was gunning for the record. It’s a massive deal, isn’t it? So much so that a desperate John Cena turned heel ahead of WrestleMania 41 just to stand a chance of breaking it. 

Cena - confirming that plans do indeed change on the day of a WWE show - revealed that he was going to lose the title seconds after an immediate restart. Yes, under Vince McMahon, the record-breaking 17th World title win was not going to be some lovely feel-good moment. It was not going to matter at all. The plan apparently only changed when Brock Lesnar agreed to come back at 5PM on the day of the show. 

Were it not for a last-minute breakthrough in negotiations, WWE almost WCW 2000’d its World title record. 


4. 2022 | Does It Count As A Dream Match If Only One Person Dreamed Of It?

Austin Theory
WWE.com

He’s a handsome guy with a terrific physique overflowing with the composure and slickness beloved by WWE management, but he’s also very bland and seems cursed to never truly connect with the public. He’s actually decent at playing a dumbass. He displayed some semblance of personality when paired with Johnny Gargano in NXT. But the next Randy Orton? Nope. The first Randy Orton took two decades to finally become a guy that fans were truly desperate to see headline WrestleMania. Perhaps Theory will get there by WrestleMania 60. 

Theory was meant to be a focal point of SummerSlam 2022, per the Wrestling Observer Newsletter. He was scheduled to wrestle John Cena. Few people believed Dave’s reporting at the time, because that was a waste of a Cena match with his part-time schedule, no? 

As it happens, the match did end up taking place, but it was pushed back to WrestleMania 39. 

This is less “mind-blowing secret” and more “funny albeit in a very tragic way”. This was Vince McMahon’s grand plan to get Theory over. McMahon was certain that Theory was his next Roman Reigns. It’s amusing that WWE sat on this thing for nearly a year, desperate to roll it out at the perfect time, only for Cena to coast through the ultimate nothing match when it finally happened. 

Austin Theory, as simply ‘Theory’, did wind up on the SummerSlam 2022 card. He was very handily defeated by Bobby Lashley on a show mostly remembered for being Paul Levesque’s first main roster PLE.


3. 2023 | The Dream Match That Was Never Booked

Gunther WWE
WWE.com

Wrestling fans are forever fascinated by the idea of a torch being passed. It’s not hard to see why; the shows never, ever end, even during the terrifying early days of a pandemic in which literally the only live entertainment available to watch was AEW or Aleister Black going 27 minutes with Apollo Crews in an empty gymnasium. 

Naturally, fans grow bored of seeing the same wrestlers all the time. This is compounded by the fact that, with a far less arduous schedule in place these days in tandem with a more clean-living lifestyle, wrestlers do a Decade of Destruction run all the bloody time. Thus, when Brock Lesnar and Gunther exchanged a series of moves in the 2023 men’s Royal Rumble match, people ran away with the idea. In fairness to them, it was brilliantly done. Brock killed every other participant in the match, at least two times over, before Gunther squared up to him and blasted him with a chop. For a few electrifying seconds, it felt like you were watching a tease of a real dream match. You weren’t making it up in your head. WWE positioned Gunther as the one guy in the match that spooked Lesnar. Drew McIntyre was in there at the time, too. He might as well have still been in 3MB for how much stronger Gunther was booked. 

So when was the match happening? WrestleMania? Nope, that was Omos. That was a Vince McMahon call. SummerSlam is when Gunther is going to chop Lesnar out of WWE for good. 

Sadly, this put the fantasy in fantasy booking; Dave Meltzer put out a rumour killer in April 2013. And he was right. 


2. 2024 | A Sobering Statistic

Solo Sikoa
WWE.com

WWE pushes wrestlers at a glacial pace. There are several explanatory factors at play here.

Despite the existence of the Performance Center, wrestlers from NXT are expected to learn the supposed intricacies of the main roster. This flawed and prolonged system is the byproduct of WWE’s mentality. Both Triple H and Road Dogg have spoken about this in years past. Triple H, when at the helm of NXT, often talked about WWE’s “playbook”, and how new signings are required to learn it and run it. Road Dogg was altogether less subtle when asked about scripted promos, saying that WWE must trust a wrestler before allowing them any leeway. A wrestler seems to take forever to headline a big show; more often than not, they are trialled at the B-level pay-per-view. To put into perspective just how slow WWE is, SummerSlam 2024 yielded a sobering statistic. 

Randy Orton headlined his first pay-per-view in a singles match at SummerSlam 2004, where he dethroned World Heavyweight champion Chris Benoit. Even then, there’s a caveat. 

Cynical whispers suggest that Orton only won the belt so that he could take another title from persona non grata Brock Lesnar: that of the youngest WWE World champion ever. It took 20 years - two full decades - for another male WWE wrestler to make their singles PPV main event debut at SummerSlam. That man was Solo Sikoa, who lost to Cody Rhodes in the headline attraction of 2024.

At this rate, Trick Williams will only get his chance to headline a PLE at SummerSlam 2044.


1. 2025 | WWE Took The Safe Option

WWE Raw Bron Breakker
WWE

WWE, at time of writing, is in a lull period. The boom is over. The beginning of the end was initiated at the big Raw Is Netflix premiere, a masturbatory show that weirdly congratulated itself for accomplishing very little. Both WrestleMania 41 and WrestleMania 42 were savaged critically for no less than three awful celebrity involvements in two main events. TKO panicked, overcomplicating the simple-but-effective booking that drove the resurgence in the first place, and now that same simplicity feels very stale. It’s as if Triple H knows that he’s dropped several clangers, and prefers now to play things safe. Cody Rhodes and Roman Reigns are still on top. The next line of potential headliners, namely Bron Breakker and Jacob Fatu, no longer feel like guaranteed ‘Mania main eventers. They’ve absorbed a few too many losses. 

WWE had several opportunities to go with Breakker. You could easily argue that he isn’t ready - he botches at a very inopportune moment in every one of his big matches - but WWE fans are growing disenchanted and frustrated regardless. One such opportunity arose at SummerSlam 2025.

In July 20025, Dave Meltzer reported that WWE scrapped the original idea to book Reigns Vs. Breakker in a singles contest; instead, Roman teamed with Jey Uso to take on Breakker and Bronson Reed. 

This didn’t happen, and it’s not hard to infer the reason why. WWE is a risk-averse company, and Triple H seems to lack the authority and cojones to issue bold creative to his top stars. 


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!