The WORST Wrestling Moment Every Year (1989 - 2025)
Wrestling fandom is a long national nightmare: featuring Vince McMahon, Vince McMahon, and Vince McMahon.
Dishonourable mentions are vast. Somehow, there is no space here for Muhammad Hassan: WWE’s appalling dual exercise in gaslighting and xenophobia.
AEW crops up here, but as bad as that Dark Order angle was, Tony Khan was competing with 2019 Vince McMahon. That was like early 1970s Ajax taking on a non-league Scottish outfit with a starting XI composed entirely of fetuses. WCW once produced an angle that took the dumbest part of the Dark Order fiasco, but did it on purpose. That is included here.
Was there something even worse than the debut of RETRIBUTION? Ric Flair getting his ass kicked in the desert? The introduction of Dustin ‘Seven’ Rhodes? The various objects placed atop poles in Vince Russo’s WCW? The WWF Kennel From Hell match, which was also dreamed up by Vince Russo? The Finger Poke Of Doom? Claire Lynch? Bobby Lashley’s Sisters?
Yup.
Triple H gets away with murder, too, because none of his interminable, library-quiet WrestleMania matches make the list. On one level, the mandatory ‘Triple H gets the longest match at the biggest show of the year’ annual deal was worse than some goofy, poorly-acted wrestling angle. It’s the principle behind it as much as the dismal, tedium-inducing experience: Triple H received opportunity after opportunity to steal PPVs because of who he was and how he procured his spot - and yet he bored everybody into submission because he was only ever that damn good in his own damn mind-uh.
What follows is the absolute worst of the worst…
37. 1989 | The Debut Of The Ding Dongs
Realising that the end is near is almost worse than the end.
A down period is bad, but you’re stuck with it. You’re able to enjoy and savour the good bits. There’s nothing worse than watching a great product start to fall apart because some idiot doesn’t get it. The dread is an awful feeling. But enough about late 2000 WWF - this is about Pizza Hut executive Jim Herd, and how his harebrained attempt to make WCW kid-friendly ultimately killed one of the all-time great wrestling promotions.
The timeless animosity of Ric Flair Vs. Terry Funk, the futuristic awesomeness of Sting Vs. Great Muta, the state-of-the-art wonder that was Flair Vs. Ricky Steamboat: 1989 NWA was so unbelievably great. The dread that set in when the Ding Dongs debuted in July was intense as all hell, because that was when you knew it was over. Cool. They feel the need to be the WWF because that’s what’s in. Great.
The Ding Dongs was the NWA’s attempt to reach the kids. (Kids love bells, everybody knows that.) The teams loved bells and were actual bells. Whichever human bell was stationed on the apron would - just for the one match before the bells tolled, mercifully - ring a giant bell in an apparent bid to alert their partner into a state of readiness.
This was poetic, if absolutely nothing else. The sound of a bell is ominous, in some contexts, and by the end of the match, the tag team quite literally fell apart; the small bells affixed to the team’s boots were scattered across the mat.
So bad it's good, but also so bad it was the beginning of the end.
36. 1990 | What’s In The Egg?
Ahead of Survivor Series 1990, the WWF wheeled out a gigantic egg prop on television and promised that it would hatch at the pay-per-view itself.
This sounds and in fact was very stupid, but the WWF preyed upon the most basic psychological hook there is. When you withhold information from people, people are desperate to learn it.
It was a gigantic egg. You don’t even need hindsight to realise that nothing cool was going to emerge from it. It was hardly as if Stan Hansen was going to hatch out of the bastard and lariat Hulk Hogan into next week. Putting something in a box and teasing the contents is very easy - WWE got people excited over some mysterious shots of shoes in December 2025 - but delivering a great reveal is the hard bit.
The Gobbledy Gooker reveal was as bad as it gets. Inside the egg was Hector Guerrero dressed up in a turkey mascot outfit. Under the guise, the guy could not wrestle. He wore stupid claw boots and a novelty head mask that was at least a 6 on the McDonagh scale. This anthropomorphic turkey was an abomination. It danced with Mean Gene Okerlund as Roddy Piper very optimistically said that the Gooker had won the hearts of Stamford. Turns out Piper started saying deranged nonsense well before the mid-1990s.
Apparently, the Gooker was meant to be the WWF’s mascot. It didn’t take, and after an apparent disaster at a house show, in which Guerrero fell on his ass after attempting a handspring, the turkey was killed off.
35. 1991 | The Finish Of Horrors
1991 was a bleak time for pro wrestling stateside.
The WWF’s output was uneven, peaking with some legitimately unsettling major heat angles, but the year will always be remembered for its commercial decline and ghastly exploitation. Extreme Championship Wrestling was still Eastern. The territories were dead. About 99% of the people who have watched the Jerry Lynn Vs. Lightning Kid hidden gem early indie series did so after the fact. It was also a spectacularly bad year for WCW. The prophecy of the Ding Dongs was realised; WCW had become a total mess of cartoonish gimmickry. WCW’s wider philosophy reached a nadir at Halloween Havoc. Sting, El Gigante and the Steiner Brothers defeated Abdullah the Butcher, the Diamond Studd, Cactus Jack, and Vader.
There was some talent in the field, if you discount Gigante, and even a very limited Abdullah, if nothing else, knew his way around some plunder. An uncomplicated cage match involving all eight men might have kicked ass, but that wasn’t WCW’s style.
The match was legendarily awful. It was mostly an indistinguishable mess of brawling broken up by awful plunder spots, executed between the ring and the cage walls, involving straight-to-video horror props. Inexplicably, WCW launched a “ref cam” feature during this match.
Watch the action through the lens of the guy whose deliberately flawed POV you’re meant to ignore!
Capital idea.
The objective of the match was to electrocute one member of the opposing team. This happened when Cactus Jack confused Abdullah for Scott Steiner, and flipped a switch that had already - to no effect - fallen into place accidentally.
34. 1992 | A Very High-Profile Botch
You can’t botch the main event of WrestleMania and not walk away with Worst Moment.
It’s crazy how narrative works. It’s almost enough to make you believe in fate, karma, or some otherworldly force. The WWF was in deep sh*t in 1992. The walls were closing in. Scandal was about to engulf the entire promotion. Was the main event of the biggest show of the year really going to go well?
Not at all. It was omni-botched to a hilarious extent.
Papa Shango was meant to interfere in the match between Hulk Hogan and Sid Justice. He missed his cue, and what was so wonderful about this particular botch is that he looked tentative when making his belated entrance. He looked like he wasn’t sure where to go, like a new timid starter at the office working out which chair is theirs. Shango’s chair shouldn’t have been so difficult to spot, though. He had to go to the ring, which tends to be in the middle of every single arena since the dawn of time. Just in case this wasn’t obvious, there was a spotlight leading the way. Shango was meant to be a dark, mystical character, which this rather undermined. Shango missing his cue meant that Sid had to kick out of Hogan’s leg drop, which was funny. Absolutely less than ideal, but funny.
Shango’s interference was neutralised by Ultimate Warrior, whose soccer mom haircut was so awful that a generation of kids didn’t even believe it was him.
The layers to this farce were something else. This scene wasn’t just risible in and of itself; it led to the worst story of the year.
33. 1993 | Hulk Hogan Saves The Day
WrestleMania IX was an almost tragic denial of the good times going away.
The feds were closing in and the audience was drifting away. The WWF, a major pop culture player in the 1980s, had resorted to promoting its biggest show of the year in the car park of a Las Vegas casino. Hulk Hogan was bound for Hollywood, or at least his hilariously ill-fated attempt. The bodies, those prized, oiled bodies, were shrinking. The money wasn’t flowing and the tickets weren’t selling. The company was heading towards TV tapings at high school gyms. WrestleMania IX, despite its strangely endearing chintz, was a bleak afterparty for the Golden Era.
What tends to happen, when long-term relationships become untenable, is that those involved give it one last halfhearted go. That was Vince McMahon and Hulk Hogan in Vegas.
When Bret Hart lost the WWF title to Yokozuna, a relatively noodle-armed and monstrously black-eyed Hogan made good on his promise to challenge the winner of the main event. Reflecting just how rushed the decision was, and how little effort was put into convincing fans that Hogan was properly back, the impromptu match lasted just 22 seconds.
Watch it back now, and you’ll hear a pop, but that, too, is halfhearted. There is no overwhelming sense of real jubilation, because what was there to celebrate?
The whole thing is just off. Even young kids could detect it, even if they were unable to articulate it; the sad sight of Bret Hart’s demotion is cited by many fans, who would return, as their first dropping-out moment.
32. 1994 | The Old Generation
WCW is often (and accurately) remembered as a wildly dysfunctional promotion so mind-boggling in its stupidity that you can never comprehend how certain decisions were made. The WWF, meanwhile, only developed that reputation years and years later. The Fed wasn’t nonsensical in its mainstream wilderness years of the mid-1990s - just very behind the times and in need of a full tonal reset.
Except it was nonsensical at times. It was nonsensical at the worst possible time.
Vince McMahon had an idea in 1994, one that allowed him to both promote the younger, smaller wrestlers he was burdened with and bury WCW at the same time: he marketed the WWF roster as ‘The New Generation’. Hulk Hogan was out, that ancient orange geezer, and Bret Hart was in. If you want old fogeys, like Ric Flair, tune into WCW. Or us seven years later, when he’s seven years older. One of the two.
This initiative was formally launched at King Of The Ring 1994. What was the main event?
A match between WrestleMania 1 headliner Roddy Piper and Jerry ‘The King’ Lawler, comfortably past his late 1970s-to-mid-1980s Memphis peak. They were both in their forties, and this was a time before that was the median age for a WWE headliner. This was a time when Hulk Hogan was considered a fossil.
Piper looked shredded, in fairness, but the match was an interminable bore that felt at least three times as long as its 12 minutes. It was a fitting end to a rubbish show infamous for the worst commentary of all-time, in which a guy expressed incredulity that certain lighter wrestlers could do stuff that would hurt.
No, not AEW Jim Ross; this was Art Donovan.
31. 1995 | The Flatulent Clown
1995 WWF was terrible.
Immune even from the vast power of nostalgia, beyond some timeless bangers, it’s as awful to revisit as it was to endure at the time. It’s bleak, small fry, unfashionable. It’s a dying glorified regional promotion that by default is #1 stateside and in Europe because Vince McMahon killed everything else. Everytime you go back and see it, the lack of scale is astonishing. It looks absolutely pitiful. The two years either side of ‘95 were, variously, excellent in the ring and or creatively adventurous and exciting. 1995 deserved those TNA-sized high school gym crowds because it was neither.
Doink the Clown did not define 1995, but he was as good an emblematic mascot as anything else. Long removed from the sinister heel originally and brilliantly portrayed by Matt Borne, babyface Doink was ironic, in that the prankster was himself a joke. Doink was used more sparingly, as an enhancement talent, but the few times he was on the winning end of things about summed the WWF up.
The character, already lamentable, reached a nadir in 1995, when a certain sound effect accompanied his Whoopee Cushion finisher.
“The stupid clown isn’t getting over.”
“No, he isn’t. Perhaps we should experiment creatively, perhaps by promoting realistic characters more attuned to the cultural zeitgeist and booking more outrageous angles designed to make best use of the episodic TV format.”
“No. The clown should fart.”
“Masterful gambit, sir.”
30. 1996 | The Doomsday Cage Match
The Doomsday Cage Match is almost too funny to include here, but equally, it was the worst moment of 1996. Even worse than the first 45 minutes of the Bret Hart Vs. Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania 12.
Hulk Hogan was notorious for being a narcissist, fantasist and compulsive liar. Amongst countless other outrageous claims, Hogan fancies himself a real hard man. A real shooter.
He claimed to have beaten up PRIDE fighters in the 1970s (even though the MMA outfit was founded in 1997). He reckons he body-slammed Andre the Giant for real at WrestleMania 3, in a feat so arduous that he tore every muscle in his back. Hogan, and this might be the most mental one of the lot, once claimed that he killed Antonio Inoki in the middle of the ring, but luckily, Inoki was resuscitated at the last second. (Inoki did once get knocked out in a match against Hogan, but he was not clinically dead lol).
What happened at Uncensored 1996 was Hulk Hogan’s unchecked ego running wild. This was so ridiculous, so untenable, that it actually shattered the forcefield that was Hogan’s mind and forced him to turn heel for the good of everything. This was Hulk Hogan performing as the man he pretended to be: the most invincible hard nut superhero ever born. Alongside Randy Savage, he took on eight heels - originally nine! - in a farcical triple-decker cage match in which Ric Flair was portrayed as a video game baddie you can kill in one hit. Meanwhile, an untrained muscle freak, Jeep Swenson, was cast as the final boss.
Hogan prevailed - after the Booty Man handed him a frying pan, and after Lex Luger mistimed an accidental punch aimed at Ric Flair so badly that it looked like he did it on purpose.
Hogan hoisted a dying Make-A-Wish kid on his shoulders in celebration as Cher and Madonna threw their panties at him.
29. 1997 | Roddy Piper’s Family
What they write about WCW in 1997 is largely true. It was cool, it was chaotic, it was revolutionary. The idea that it was so cool that all the kids at school wearing nWo t-shirts were cheeks magnets is very much overstated. WCW was a lot cooler than it was in 1995, but it was still WCW. It was still overflowing with dumb, bad bullsh*t.
Roddy Piper as Hulk Hogan’s chief rival was hardly Tokyo Dome Atsushi Onita. Piper, after some very strong work in the build to Starrcade, entered his “what in the f*ck is this guy banging on about here” era. Piper never said a single coherent thing between 1997 and his last, bleak WWE appearances.
Piper needed himself a stable with which to fight the respective threats of the New World Order and a team of WCW representatives at the upcoming PPV. This led to one of the worst and most inexplicable segments in peak Nitro history.
On the March 3 Nitro, Piper said there were six guys in the back - and he was going to take them all on to prove their worth. The trialist wrestlers that the fans endorsed with a thumbs up would join his new ‘Family’ - quite possibly the worst idea for an impromptu stable made up of random strangers. Piper went on a lengthy, schmaltzy speech about the meaning of family before submitting a kelp-green Power Plant trainee within seconds - the future Luther Reigns, in a fun trivia note.
A guy in boxing gloves came out after this, as the awkward commentary team expressed bemusement throughout. Unable to sell it but obviously unwilling to bury it, Tony Schiavone et al. said variations of “Have you ever seen anything like this?”
The answer was “no”, and for good reason. In no other segment would a main event star sell for a complete unknown. You wouldn’t see anything like it ever again, either: the idea was instantly retconned, and Piper simply tagged with the Horsemen at Uncensored.
This complete unknown boxer guy gave Piper quite a bit of trouble. Remember that infamous Dark Order segment, in which the overzealous unknown Creepers started battering the Elite when that wasn’t in the plans?
WCW did AEW’s worst ever segment on purpose!
28. 1998 | Hawk’s Fall
Vince Russo wasn’t a good guy.
What helps Russo, reputation-wise, is that there is a tier of rancid men in wrestling history, and he’s nowhere near the top. He’s not even where Paul Heyman is, since Russo was never his own boss. Russo is loathed by many for his putrid ideas and even worse-smelling values, but he was never in control of anybody’s fate. He didn’t have the power to ruin anybody’s life.
However, while he didn’t personally set up any of the stunts used throughout the Attitude Era, Russo scripted several scenarios - none of which enhanced any match or story - that involved wrestlers taking unnecessary risks for which they were not trained.
One wrestler was the Legion of Doom’s Hawk, whose real-life struggles with addiction were incorporated into storylines because that’s what you want to see out of an apocalyptic ass-kicking powerhouse. This was gross and exploitative, since the hook to return to Raw and not change the channel was Hawk, at best, making a sad spectacle of himself.
The Hawk character became so depressed at one point that, on the November 16, 1998 episode of Raw, he scaled the scaffolding that propped up the TitanTron. Hawk, kicked out of LOD 2000 for costing his team multiple wins, threatened to end it all before Droz tried to do it for him.
Hawk, who was actually an addict and thus hardly guaranteed to have his bearings, completed the first part of the stunt without any safety equipment. This wasn’t just in spectacularly bad taste and removed entirely from pro wrestling: it was unspeakably dangerous.