9 Wrestlers Who Fell Off HARD In 2025
Wrestling is a cruel business. Who got laughed at in 2025?
Dishonourable mentions are vast in a year that, pandemic aside, was the least inspiring period of time in the business since things got really interesting in 2018.
In WWE, Solo Sikoa was relegated from major upper midcard heel to prelim clown. He was very handily defeated by Roman Reigns on the Raw Is Netflix premiere, and fans were never asked to take him seriously again. The dumbass bit actually suited Solo - but this was a guy built up to be one of the first names on the WrestleMania whiteboard. He headlined SummerSlam 2024!
The novelty of Nia Jax as a credible monster faded. Carmelo Hayes didn’t get anything from Triple H.
Is CM Punk a candidate here? He’s still great on his day in this strange, mellowed-out chapter of his career, but the feud with Seth Rollins was a bland, protracted exercise in long-term storytelling for the sake of it. His renewed rivalry with John Cena was embarrassing. Punk wasn’t even that great on the mic against Gunther.
In AEW, the Paragon were nowhere near the Tag Team title scene. Roderick Strong lost a lot, AEW indulged Kyle O’Reilly’s irksome goofy side too often, and while they were often good in the ring, they had a nightmare against FTR back in April. Scorpio Sky embarked on yet another dud of a comeback. Daniel Garcia feuded with former AEW Champion MJF in 2024; in 2025, he was a permanent “little bro” constantly being mentored by somebody or other. Wrestling has a problem, generally, pushing young wrestlers as ready-made stars. Garcia feels like an awkward wayward teenager, not a prodigy. Same goes with HOOK.
The state of falling off is not permanent. Virtually everybody wrote off Kota Ibushi at the start of 2025, and while he ended it on the AEW injury list yet again, his superb Dynamite match opposite Kazuchika Okada was an elegant, mature performance - a cruel glimpse of a great old man wrestler run.
The following wrestlers aren’t finished forever - but it will take some doing to repair their reputation…
9. R-Truth
On June 1, to intense fan and peer backlash, R-Truth announced on X that WWE would not be renewing his contract.
This was the first time that the relationship between Triple H and his new, massive audience felt strained. Nick Khan, the merciless corporate shark of a WWE President, actually folded. He was instrumental in bringing back R-Truth after his WWE release, but R-Truth didn’t want to play R-Truth anymore: he wanted to be Ron Killings. He wanted to go on a run as a serious player tired of playing a clown.
A vengeful, all-business Killings returned at Money In The Bank, on June 7, as the major headline emerging from the PLE. On the September 19 edition of SmackDown, back under the dimwitted guise of R-Truth, he attempted to charge his smartphone using a toaster. A whopping 104 days passed by between Ron Killings asking you to take him seriously and R-Truth nearly electrocuting himself to death.
There’s something really sad about Killings using his leverage, a real good-on-ya moment, only to receive almost nothing in the way of promotional support and revert to his old caricature of a self. This was bad in a way the wrestling landscape hasn’t really reckoned with - a creative disgrace the longer you think about it. Truth, for one night, was the most talked-about wrestler on the planet. And then Triple H fumbled.
The story told at Money In The Bank was a self-own on WWE’s part. The promotion essentially said that they’d made a massive mistake and was pressured into correcting it.
WWE never likes doing that, ever, which probably explains why, instead of committing to the idea, they behaved like none of it had actually happened and made you forget.
8. Eddie Kingston
At time of writing, Eddie Kingston has barely returned - but what an abysmal comeback. His return match against Big Bill was poor, and he subsequently played the role of HOOK’s dad. Isn’t that what Taz is for?
AEW marginalised Eddie on Collision, making the process of promoting a star far more difficult than it needs to be. Who’s to blame? Which party doesn’t care anymore, and is it both?
Eddie Kingston’s role in AEW is under-discussed generally. Since returning from injury, and for some time prior to that, his persona was “arguably the best talker of the 21st century gets annoyed when the production team asks him to cut promos in order to promote his matches”.
Isn’t this the last thing you’d do with Eddie Kingston, arguably the best talker of the 21st century?
The guy, arguably the best talker of the 21st century, is put out by talking. He just wants to wrestle. Everybody wrestles in AEW!
This worked at first - Eddie’s open disdain towards the television format was a neat way of getting his authenticity across - but this weirdly became his thing, and it was taken much too far. He’s now picked up where he left off - which is to say, acting like he’s above it all.
This guy was the heart and soul of the promotion for a couple of years, and was so beloved that many fans identified him as the man to take the World title from MJF.
What happened to the guy who sold his wrestling boots to pay for the rent before getting the call from AEW? The guy so adamant that he’d never put himself back in that situation that he’d never stop fighting? The guy who shared the best face-to-face confrontation of 2021 opposite CM Punk?
7. Jeff Jarrett
AEW seemingly had grand plans for Jeff Jarrett in 2025 - a Sting-esque retirement run on a smaller scale. It had potential.
Jeff was dismissed by AEW fans as a pollutant when he first rocked up, but he was a revelation as a heel. Jarrett, inordinately thrilled by his own cheating ways in knowingly overbooked midcard fare, was one of the lone highlights of 2023. His act was massively entertaining, and it won fans over. Jarrett then turned face in 2024, vowing to win the Owen Hart Cup. His heartbreaking pre-tournament promo, his brutal loss to Hangman Page, an absolute war with Bryan Danielson: Jarrett was on his way to becoming another Dustin Rhodes. The pathos of the grizzled old man wrestler is very powerful.
What the hell happened here, Jesus.
Jarrett promised to win the AEW World title before the sun set on his career. This magnetised him towards MJF, who held championship aspirations of his own. The resulting feud was a disaster. It was shocking, because it wrote itself: despicable cocky young heel trying to rattle an older, wiser dude who had seen and survived true adversity.
Two incidents saw it retconned into oblivion.
Firstly, Jarrett made the incredibly dumb decision to trade edgelord barbs with MJF in their infamously bad face-to-face confrontation. Jeff should have taken the high road; instead, he came off like a sexist dinosaur.
Secondly, and this is the blame of Tony Khan’s otherwise underrated matchmaking, Jarrett lost to Claudio Castagnoli. The match was rubbish, the result bizarre. It actually scanned as punishment booking, which might make sense of Jarrett’s subsequent disappearance.
6. The Rock
As the Final Boss, the Rock was sensational in 2024.
WWE was peaking creatively under Paul Levesque’s regime, but one thing about Levesque’s approach is that it is a little patterned and formal. When it works, Levesque shows you the destination - but makes you want to go there. As refreshing as this is, in contrast to Vince McMahon’s inscrutable slop anyway, it’s a bit boring isn’t it?
The Rock, morphing into the Final Boss, brought a very real anxiety and edge to what might be the best build to a WrestleMania show this side of 1989.
He toyed with the idea of taking Cody Rhodes’ spot - which if nothing else elicited real emotion - before backtracking and taking his bruised ego out on the uncrowned WWE champion. The Rock’s blood-soaked, foul-mouthed, vicious campaign was incredible, and he was so locked-in that he performed free of charge on Instagram just to swear his head off for the love of the game.
On the Raw after WrestleMania 40, Rock essentially confirmed that he’d return to face Cody at WrestleMania 42.
On the Raw Is Netflix premiere, the Rock revealed that he was Cody’s good mate in real life.
On the first show on the fabled road, the Rock blocked his own path to WrestleMania. In his defence, all he did was remove himself as a distraction from your fantasy booking. It was good that he clarified his status.
Still, opening the show with a curtain call was a breathtakingly dumb choice - as was the Rock appearing to cancel, not merely postpone, the Cody match. Rock then appeared on NXT (!) and basically said that he wasn’t owned for 15 minutes straight before somehow running out of time. He said nothing of substance; he swore for some cheap pops and kept saying he was getting emotional. The cynics reckon that the Rock has an origami ego and does things just to feel good about himself. It was hard to argue with them here.
He was unavailable for WrestleMania, but still played a part in John Cena’s heel turn. His verbal performance when persuading Cody to part with his soul was yet more evidence of that thin skin; the man simply could not play an evil man without dropping in a few one-liners.
The Rock’s head fell clean off in 2025.
5. Adam Copeland
Adam Copeland had a shocker in 2025, and he set the tone early by renaming himself ‘Cope’. This was a disastrous nickname on at least three levels.
It’s an insult used by young people, and since Copeland actually had to “cope” in that infamously awkward exchange with Ricky Starks, it was all too fitting. It sounded like a name he’d have to use in TNA, since ‘Edge’ is WWE’s intellectual property. Also, and this is the worst of it, he gave himself the nickname. AEW fans seem to like the guy - or they like Alter Bridge - but they don’t love him like they love Hangman Page, Will Ospreay, Orange Cassidy and the like. Nobody else shortened his surname affectionately - which made it seem as if he was in love with himself.
Is he in love with himself?
This is a wrestler obsessed with his own lore, making constant callbacks to his history…in WWE. If Cope left AEW and returned a few years down the line, he’d still be referencing Edge. There’s not much ‘Cope’ has done on his own to warrant a reference.
His self-important streak notwithstanding, Cope’s performance level verged on awful at times. His intense, dour promos continued the charade that the Ultimate Opportunist was actually Jack Reacher all along. He wanted to work a “gritty NWA” match against Jon Moxley at Revolution, which made his decision to do a 2004 WWE main event a particularly boring mystery. He was mean-spirited and very unfunny in his mini-programme against Stokely Hathaway. And while his team-up with Christian Cage was fun, it wasn’t amazing, was it?
Also, Cope referenced Edge’s history in WWE in the match against FTR because he can’t help himself.
4. Minoru Suzuki
Credit to Minoru Suzuki: the man enjoyed a sensational post-prime run for a shocking number of years there.
Suzuki is such an incredibly expressive, tough-looking dude that all he had to do to get a reaction was glare with sadist relish at the opponents stupid enough to try him. Other times he’d just laugh at them, pissing himself at the idea that their stuff could actually hurt. Suzuki’s very real and very influential MMA credentials legitimised his act - but he mastered pro wrestling theatre.
His facial expressions are among the greatest in wrestling history - so scary and funny and animated that he’d pull one, and you’d forget in that moment that Suzuki would almost invariably lose, and thus wasn’t that hard after all. The magic finally deserted him a few years ago, in truth, and in 2024, he lost in nine minutes to Jack Perry on Collision. He had operated as a rent-a-face for ages, a guy brought in for his entrance, a scowl, and a job. He worked about as hard as shindie-era Honky Tonk Man, and who could blame him?
2025 was a yet more drastic nadir.
While the match was far more bleak than a mere artistic misfire - his opponent was not fit to be in the ring - Suzuki’s “effort” against Butterbean at Wrestlecon in April was so bad that Dave Meltzer said it was the absolute worst wrestling match he had ever seen; worse, even, than the Bushwhackers Vs. Iron Sheik & Nikolai Volkoff at Heroes Of Wrestling.
Even Jey Uso was doing better stuff than that. On the subject of whom…
3. Jey Uso
Is there an argument that one of the absolute best wrestlers in the world right now is actually implicit in the creative downfall of the industry?
Why is everybody Hangman Page?
Hanger caught fire in AEW as a rare character with real emotional complexity. He was a funny badass and surefire World champion - but he didn’t believe that himself. He was plagued by self-doubt in a relatable and resonant character arc. He didn’t think he was good enough to one day beat Kenny Omega; when he did, his brilliant, bold approach informed one of the best moments in AEW history.
WWE lifted the blueprint, casting Roman Reigns as the gaslighting heel overlord and his cousin Jey as the sympathetic, ambitious babyface. We’re five years deep into a story that, in 2025, is truly pushing it. The people do love Jey Uso, and have persisted with him despite multiple PLE disasters, but what do they love about him, really?
Jey Uso is such a wild choice to cast as a character with such supposed emotional depth. He does a cool and fun thing with his hands, and is not a particularly good wrestler. It’s a bit like Bushwhacker Luke constantly questioning his sense of morality.
Jey peaked as the underdog babyface at WrestleMania. It was a nice story, which if nothing else cast doubt over future Royal Rumble matches. He’d made it. No more self-doubt. After that, it was back to his various, poorly-acted crises of confidence. Back to a teased feud with Jimmy, for some inexplicable reason.
If you can believe it, Jey actually regressed further in the ring, too. He was so unskilled in 2025 that he hit somebody else with a steel chair and took the most damage. Was wrestling better when goodies and baddies just go on with the business of hating one another?
Yes.
2. Jacob Fatu
WWE in almost every way is better than it was under Vince McMahon’s rule. It is almost entirely devoid of baffling weirdness. Triple H isn’t stupid enough to conceive of something like Erick Rowan befriending a giant spider - but he isn’t interesting enough to do that, either. A lot has changed. WWE’s TV is a lot better, but a lot less fascinating to discuss.
Not everything has changed. Triple H is mostly different to Vince McMahon, but he has inherited his infuriating habit of doing things the WWE way, even if that way fails to harness the best attributes of certain wrestlers.
Jacob Fatu - and it’s irritating that this word has been overused to a point of meaninglessness, because it’s accurate - has aura. He has aura coming out of his ass 24/7. He looks dangerous, his best stuff is dangerous, and he’s an actually aggressive badass dude in a landscape of people with conflicted feelings as wrestling continues to overthink itself.
Or at least, he was.
Fatu was a revelation when he debuted as a throwback savage pro wrestler. This year, because it’s apparently the law, he started to act. Solo Sikoa tormented him and called him stupid. You were meant to feel sad for Jacob Fatu - WWE might as well have piped in the “Awww” sitcom sound effect - and the monster eventually realised that Solo was manipulating him. Instead of saying “I love you, Solo!”, when Jacob turned his back on Sikoa at Money In The Bank, he said “I hate you, Solo!”
This made mere exposition look like subtext.
A diabolical, shenanigans-littered cage match with Solo Sikoa at SummerSlam did nothing for him either. If you can’t let the best ass-kicker on your roster kick ass, what are we doing here?
1. The New Day
The New Day turned heel on Big E on their 10th anniversary as a unit. This was a spectacular angle, possibly one of the very best in WWE history.
The timing was particularly cruel, since Big E was obviously hoping for a celebration of sorts. The tension was built gradually, even before the night itself; the longstanding nature of the relationship needed a rift before the break-up. Also, Big E is famously a hell of a guy; it would have been a heartbreaking scene even if he hadn’t been forced onto the WWE injury list indefinitely.
WWE failed, dismally, to capitalise on it. The follow-up was too cute. Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods were ostracised by the roster, even the heels, in what first felt like a neat touch. The issue is that the New Day, who would never have more heat than in the immediate aftermath of the angle, barely cut promos in the middle of the ring.
You could argue that, with Big E effectively retired, the New Day lacked a ready-made feud. It was a more difficult turn than most to navigate, with no protagonist, but Triple H should have either positioned a team for the role of Big E sympathisers - #DIY maybe, given Tommaso Ciampa’s history with neck issues - or not followed through with a flawed idea in the first place. This concerning, baffling lack of follow-up was an omen for the wider state of 2025, in retrospect.
Eventually, the New Day settled into the role of a mildly amusing midcard heel team having done nothing of significance at WrestleMania. Xavier Woods did a bit with a preposterously-sized hat. He then put a hat on the joke by wearing a hat that was much too small.
It was funny - but if ever there were a metaphor for how the arc turned out…