How Good Was 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin Actually?
Some people don’t think Steve Austin was good between the ropes. What?
Bret Hart, legendary WWE champion, years ago devised a system with which to appraise a professional wrestler - and, in typical, humorous Bret fashion, he revealed this as a thinly-veiled excuse to bury somebody.
He wrote in his autobiography ‘Hitman’ that Dino Bravo - “that lethargic boulder” - was one of the very few wrestlers whose clumsiness and lack of ability put him on the injured list. Hart suffered a bruised heart, cracked ribs, and a fractured sternum when working Dino in October 1989. Hence the burial.
Dino, who “sure wasn’t great”, had “low numbers”, Bret said - but in which categories?
Bret’s three categories are thus: presence/look, promos, and in-ring ability, all rated from 0-10. Bret used examples to expound his findings. Hulk Hogan, a living, tanned, muscular demigod, was awarded a 10 in ‘look’. Even the Iron Sheik would’ve agreed with that.
While the WWE Hall of Famer also rated Hogan’s promos a 10, Bret was “not hot!” on Hogan’s in-ring ability, scoring him a 2. Bret later said Triple H was a 4, so he mustn't have rated Hogan much at all. That, or he overrated Levesque. Many do, in Bret’s defence.
Using a helpful comparison, Bret said that the Dynamite Kid was a 10 in the ring, but - and this is funny as “fook” - he’d have to work to get a 2 on promos. That’s beautifully harsh, not that Dynamite deserves anything less, the idea that Dynamite would have to practise in front of a mirror night after night after night, just to get bad.
Jey Uso’s recent World title push caused much divide in the - eurgh - ‘IWC’. Does it matter that Jey Uso is no Volk Han? He’s charismatic. He’s a star. Other wrestlers who weren’t great in the ring became big stars, too. Just look at Steve Austin!
To quote the man himself: What?
Steve Austin was better than Jey Uso. A damn sight better. But how good was he, actually…?
Presence/Look
Every pro wrestler should prioritise developing a look that sets them apart. In a world overstuffed with clones of AJ Styles, the onus should be getting people to rip you off. Nobody could ever borrow Steve Austin’s look, because they’d look like a pale imitation of Steve Austin.
And that’s the point.
Austin was basically the antithesis of Seth Rollins, who seems too desperate to prove he’s a star by dressing like one. Austin got an unforgettable character over by wearing black trunks and boots. That is a reflection of pure substance.
The knee braces, oddly, helped. He looked battle-worn, conveying that he’d seen and fended off many a worthy opponent. It was like the pro wrestling equivalent of the eye patch or grisly scar far easier to pull off in action movies and video games, in that regard. His leather waist coat wrapped around a bare chest was a big swing - you just don’t think about it in those terms because he pulled it off with no question. Austin was bald, which made him look meaner, unpretentious, like he didn’t care about impressing you. That element of his look also allowed well over half of the male population to relate to him as a working class avatar. The goatee beard is the one aspect of his look you could argue has aged, but it suited him. It was manly.
None of it would have worked without his fixed, intense eyes. Austin’s range of facial expressions was incredible, but nobody was better at conveying the all-important sense of “You f*cked up” than Austin. He was frightening.
Austin’s physique was perfect for his character. You were meant to believe in him. You were meant to think he could kick anybody’s ass - but it was also crucial that he wasn’t ridiculously proportioned. It was always a daft, fun fantasy, but Austin getting one over on Mr. McMahon every week wouldn’t work if he looked like the Ultimate Warrior. You were meant to put yourself in his mudhole-stomping boots.
Austin was a brick sh*thouse, with traps big enough to carry the company, but if he was too defined and tanned, nobody would have bought him putting so many beers away.
Promos
“If you put an ‘S’ in front of the word ‘Hitman’, you have my exact opinion of Bret Hart.”
This was the moment - that, and “I think you are completely pathetic” - when fans started to really believe that this Steve Austin fella was really about to do something major. Nobody talked to, of all people, Bret Hart like that. Some questioned Bret’s moral facade, Some came after his family. Others might have suggested that Bret wasn’t quite as good as he said he was. But to say Bret was outright bad? A relic?
The sheer disdain Austin felt towards his main event gatekeeper was electrifying. The build to Survivor Series 1996 was an almost scary drift into darker, unknown terrain. This of course followed what is possibly the greatest promo ever cut: Austin 3:16.
At King Of The Ring 1996, Austin was crowned. He was interviewed by Dok Hendrix as Jake Roberts shuffled to the back. Austin’s invective was frightening. He buried Roberts as a past-it drunk before outlining his mission statement. The promo lasted all of two minutes. In that time, he mangled the phrase “WWF Superstars” to tell everybody watching closely enough that was indeed going to tear through all of them. He also, spontaneously, invented two of the best catchphrases ever: Austin 3:16 says I just whooped your ass, and That’s the bottom line, ‘cause Stone Cold said so.
The intensity, unwavering conviction, brutally caustic wit, the blue eyes glaring with power: Austin took another 18 months to evolve into a megastar, but Jesus Christ, son, if he started a religion right then and there, some people would have worshipped him.
Hell, Austin was in such phenomenal, driven form, when he was rising to the top of the card, that he cut better promos on Livewire than most wrestlers cut on national television. In an absolutely fantastic moment, totally improvised, Austin responded with utter disgust when a caller questioned Austin’s use of foul language. “I really think,” the caller said, “that this could hinder your chances of success in the World Wrestling Federation”.
Austin’s quick-witted, blackly hilarious response was outrageous: “I will hinder your life.”
Austin was still an amazing promo in his peak drawing years, but Vince Russo’s wild creative approach allowed Austin to soar, and sell his most famous matches, with stunts, swerves, and angles.
Austin’s mic work declined as he crept towards the end of his career. Understandably, he no longer had to try that hard. He became reliant on catchphrases, but his catalogue of soundbites was incredible, and that’s what the fans wanted to hear when they paid money to see it. Austin was also plain annoying at times. Of course, there’s the “What?” chant. Austin wasn’t to know that he had sparked the most profoundly irritating and obnoxious crowd interaction of all-time, but even before it plagued virtually every WWE event thereafter, it was crap on its own terms. It was as if Austin knew how easy it was to get a reaction and simply indulged himself with it, knowing that his days as the most determined man in wrestling were all but behind him. Austin was doing panto.
Austin didn’t book his own material. He can’t be blamed for his output across 2001, necessarily - but the fire inside of him was extinguished before he lashed out at the creative team on Byte This a year later.
In-Ring Ability
Steve Austin’s in-ring legacy is divided between two chapters: pre- and post-neck injury.
Pre-neck injury, Austin was a dazzling technical wrestler who knew his way around a massive bump. He was always very well-rounded - his performance in the 1992 WarGames match at WCW WrestleWar was a red-hot display of his brawling prowess - but he was super-fit and beyond motivated. Moreover, he knew the audience he was wrestling in front of. WCW fans actively loved pro wrestling. Austin located the exact intersection between sophisticated craft and unvarnished scrap. It was fancy, his work, but not too fancy. He could work a labyrinthine chess match with Ricky Steamboat that also felt like a real, hard-hitting fight. There was a strategic purpose to everything Austin did, an immersive cause-and-effect. He never wrestled a great match for the transparent purpose of doing so.
In late 1996 and the first half of 1997, he reached his perfect form between the ropes. His ‘Stone Cold’ character was far more likely to aggressively and directly kick your ass than draw you into a tactical mistake, but against Bret Hart, he could do both. The motor on early WWF ‘Stone Cold’ was outrageous.
Austin was unreal at selling, too. He was note-perfect at WrestleMania 13. He sold his battered leg for almost 20 minutes, but, to tell the story of your new babyface badass who never gives up, Austin never stopped moving. It remains the most dynamic, lengthy display of selling in wrestling history. The crowd were never not convinced that Austin was in a state of abject agony, but the indefatiguable Austin literally never bored them nor prevented them from believing he could fight his way back in. He was hurt, pissed off and vengeful. His performance was blissfully anti-methodical.
Austin’s physical prime was cut short when, at SummerSlam 1997, he broke his neck as an Owen Hart seated piledriver went awry. This actually allowed Austin to showcase his character, and by the time was as healthy as he was ever going to be again - i.e., not very - his primitive take on arena-wide shortcut brawls endeared him to a new young adult male audience that didn’t much care for thoughtful layers of drama. The lack of true movement was actually a feature, not a bug; Austin doing more bumps might have detracted from his ultra-credible hard bastard persona.
Even then, from 1998-onwards, Austin found the “intestinal fortitude” to go all-out, when the occasion demanded it, in lung-bursting spectacles against the Rock and Kurt Angle. Austin was limited, understandably. Certain pay-per-view main events, many against the Undertaker, were lifeless and repetitive. But they were rarely not over, which is the most important aspect of any match. When the Attitude Era caught ablaze, Austin was confined to the Greatest Hits - but what a repertoire. His frenzied stomps, the “f*ck you” hand gesture, resuming the attack with even more intensity: Austin got a lot - the most, you could argue - out of the least.
There is one noticeable flaw to Steve Austin’s in-ring work - and, since it’s the primary weapon he wielded in his twilight years as a megastar brawler, it’s less than ideal. Steve Austin was not amazing at the worked punch, and he threw roughly four million of them in the faces of Mr. McMahon, The Rock, and Triple H during WWE’s Attitude Era.
Austin’s technique was a little bit weird, frankly. He didn’t appear to blast his knuckles directly into his opponent’s jaw, ramming his forearm forward with rapid, metronomic, Memphis force. He’d sort of flick his wrist from side to side, grazing their cheeks with the middle phalanx. His driving footwork was near-perfect, but scrutinise the actual strike, and you’ll understand why Jeff Jarrett once described it as phony.
But how much does this matter? The fans went crazy for and very much believed in Austin’s punches, regardless. But if Bobby Eaton and Jerry Lawler are a 10, Austin might be a 6 at best.
He was a 10 or close to it at everything else.
Austin was generally and most often incredible, but if there’s one more flaw to his game, it’s that his paranoia and desperation to hold onto the top spot sometimes informed selfish, standoffish matches. He was guilty of giving selected opponents very little in the ring. The Three Stages of Hell match at No Way Out 2001 was fabulous, but his work opposite Triple H in 1999 was counterproductive. If a great wrestler can carry a broomstick - wrestling parlance for their inability to have a bad match - Austin doesn’t quite meet that criteria. Very few wrestlers got a thing out of Attitude Era Undertaker; Austin was no different. The Rock and Triple H displayed far better chemistry with Chris Jericho.
There’s more than one category Bret omits when he critiques a wrestler, and the first is box office drawing power…
Drawing Power
Other wrestlers can boast more longevity in the top guy role than Steve Austin.
Hulk Hogan was on top of the WWF for longer, drew comparable business as a babyface, and was infinitely more successful at the box office in the heel role. Hogan elevated WCW business between 1996 and 1998 as the leader of the New World Order; Austin, woefully miscast as a heel in 2001, sparked the decline. Vince McMahon’s decision-making was to blame, primarily, but Austin’s choices didn’t help. Then again, even a more focused Austin wouldn’t have drawn as a heel, because nobody wanted to see him play it.
Ric Flair was a monster draw for years and years and years, a fact often lost to WWE’s revisionist history. How well could he have drawn, when he didn’t get to New York until 1991?
Bruno Sammartino drew more consecutive sell-outs than Austin, but his bonafides are only questioned by the metrics he was too early to crack: national television and pay-per-view. This problem also extends to the likes of the Sheik and Superstar Billy Graham, who obviously can’t be blamed, either. Bill Longson and Jim Londos were essentially in a different business to Austin.
At a time when the business needed a top star - before the monopoly, before inflated rights fees didn’t punish poor performance, before the idea of a home team brand made it more difficult to determine who truly moves the needle - Austin was demonstrably an absolutely gargantuan megastar. Across 1998 and 1999, Austin was the biggest star ever in the medium. Nobody’s peak was bigger than Austin’s. And, while you could argue that many superstar wrestlers did not have the same opportunities to boast their case - PPV only became widely available in the mid-to-late 1980s - the counter-argument is that Austin was under more intense pressure to deliver numbers across more mediums.
He had to entertain you on primetime TV week-to-week, deliver the goods in the ring to convince you that his main event spectacles were worth the eye-watering money on Sundays, sell the t-shirts you could wear without feeling the very real wrestling fan shame, and get you to come along to the house shows domestically and abroad.
Austin twice broke the record number of buys for WrestleMania, and was the first to draw a seven-figure amount. Drawing a 9.5 for a Raw main event against the Undertaker on June 28, 1999, Austin is also responsible for the highest-rated segment in the history of wrestling on cable - a feat, surely, that will never be beaten.
Time’s Test
On Twitter, or X, the Wrestling Observer Newsletter’s Dave Meltzer finds himself at odds with almost everybody. The man who implored his readership to vote Paul Levesque as 2024 Booker of the Year summons bile for his supposed AEW bias. Dave’s star rating system is ever controversial, but devotees of women’s wrestling might hate it even more than the WWE ultras.
Dave’s most recent battle is against the wrestling historians, who fiercely dispute Dave’s take that wrestling is in a constant state of improvement.
Dave reckons the wider accessibility of tape to study, and a greater emphasis on great matches as a selling point, has informed a golden artistic era. The counterargument is that a formulaic cynicism has crept into the structure of many matches.
Dave also believes that the very best matches of yore haven’t aged particularly well, since the wrestlers were performing to ensure return business as opposed to building a timeless legacy. This isn’t mutually exclusive - great art can endure regardless of authorial intent and time and place - but what of Austin’s?
Austin’s twilight years TV work often isn’t worth the bother. This is where Meltzer has a point: so many peak Austin matches were in fact designed as a backdrop to an angle. The action in many matches, while hot in the buildings, was by design immaterial and inconsequential. He had to wrestle to get screwed, allowing him to exact vengeance on Mr. McMahon, before the cycle began anew. Austin’s Attitude Era output was a cynical, ephemeral exercise in getting the viewers to tune in the following week.
On pay-per-view, mostly, Austin’s work holds up. He was the biggest star of the 1990s, but he doesn’t feel like a product of the decade in the way, say, Hulk Hogan feels like a babyface that could only belong in the glossy 1980s. Austin made his entrance to a Rage Against The Machine soundalike, a very ‘90s composition, but he could have rampaged down the aisle to a classic rock or punk track. Any loud racket from any era of rock n’ roll would have fit him.
Austin, as Stone Cold or some persona close to it, could have torn up All Japan Pro Wrestling as a wild man in the 1980s. He could have sent the fans into frenzied bloodlust, taking on the Four Horsemen in Jim Crockett Promotions that same decade. Austin did in fact make a huge impression in Extreme Championship Wrestling; he could have headlined there at his leisure, if it weren’t for the money being so poor.
Wrestling appeals on a primal level. Since the dawn of the very form, people have wanted to watch a guy they like beat the sh*t out of a guy they don’t. Nobody did that as successfully as ‘Stone Cold’ in his prime.
Moreover: if he turned up to peak Ring of Honor as ‘Stunning’ Steve Austin, he’d have elevated the promotion with his cocky personality while keeping up with the very best it had to offer as one of the best wrestlers in the world.
In the exceedingly low chance that his act wouldn’t get over today, that would be an indictment of the industry, and its obsession with counters, athleticism, and melodrama, and not Austin. Austin’s work is so timeless and universal, in fact, that modern wrestling could really do with trying to somehow recapture it.
Cultural Significance
This is rarified air. Very few wrestlers achieve it, even the biggest stars known within our bubble. Press the average member of the general public on who Roman Reigns is, and they’ll look at you like Ryback has just been asked to solve a Rubik’s cube.
Austin crossed over, to an extent; his claymation avatar was a beloved fan favourite on MTV’s Celebrity Deathmatch, but that show has only yielded the one, ill-fated reboot. It was very much a product of its time. Austin was all over the place in 1998 and 1999, from the cover of TV Guide to Regis & Kathy Lee. Obviously, his mainstream star power has since waned.
Austin does get referenced in pop culture on occasion; the protagonist of The Good Place, a critically acclaimed high concept sitcom that aired on NBC between 2016 and 2020, has a crush on him.
He wasn’t such an actual real-world star that Hollywood was willing to hand him chance after chance after The Condemned bombed in 2007. Austin has however carved out a neat little niche for himself as the host of various reality TV shows.
Interestingly, his episode of ‘Hot Ones’ has generated a massively impressive 27 million views on YouTube. Austin has out-drawn episodes, uploaded around the same time (August 2019), guested on by names who are or were considered A-listers. Austin opened a can of whoop-ass on Ashton Kutcher (12 million), Shia LeBeouf (25 million), and Aubrey Plaza (25 million). In fact, Austin is still ranked #9 on the list of most-viewed eps.
He’s not the Rock, but a lot of people who don’t like wrestling know who he is, and seem to find him funny. Heavily memed to this day, Austin endures as sort of beloved mascot of dirtbag ‘Murica chic.
Rivalries
Not to come across like the worst bad faith actors, but - and this is becoming a real issue - anybody can work a great match. A true all-time great is only as great as the stories they tell.
Austin’s record, again, is seminal. He is renowned for several great in-ring programmes, and was the protagonist in what many insist is the greatest, or most entertaining, episodic TV rivalry of all-time.
In the ring, his 1994 series with Ricky Steamboat fully established him as a future legend; the brash upstart learning lessons against the upstanding technical doyen was fabulous, a basic premise grappled with such thought and elegance that it will continue to be comfort wrestling several decades from now. His textured, violent, landscape-shifting war with Bret Hart was the absolute zenith of animosity. The layers in those matches, the sophisticated narrative and plotting, may be as close as U.S. pro wrestling has come to perfecting the “show, don’t tell” storytelling maxim. The Rock Vs. Steve Austin rivalry was a sensational feud that spanned and defined the Attitude Era. It was incredible. Initially, it was big, bombastic TV, in which the Rock attempted to drown Austin before holding a mock funeral for him. The rivalry then evolved into a sporting tenor, as the egos, pride and ambition of each megastar collided in a masterclass of parity and tension. Together, they wrestled one of the biggest and best matches of all-time, at WrestleMania X-Seven.
Austin’s weekly exploits with Mr. McMahon have not aged well. Watching Vince show ass in 2025 is not fun anymore, since he deserves a far worse and very real fate. At the time, though, it was deliriously entertaining. The awesome juxtaposition of Austin’s “gotcha” cackle and Vince’s red-faced conniption fits; Vince’s smug grin as an enraged Austin was led away in cuffs, fuelling the desire for his customary return to the arena at the close of the show; the delightful noise that bedpan made: Austin Vs. McMahon was the most cathartic, entertaining wrestling bullsh*t ever.
Moments
“Oh, I’ll take it from here, nurse.”
“Tyson and Austin! Tyson and Austin! Tyson and Austin!”
“I need to beat you, Rock. I need it more than anything you could ever imagine.”
“Hell, it’s already 10 o’clock in the morning. I don’t drink coffee at 10 o’clock in the morning where I come from. I’ll take a cold beer instead.”
The Corporation beer bath.
The pop he generated when he returned to help Mankind win the WWF title.
The first time he blasted Vince McMahon with the Stone Cold Stunner.
Every other time he blasted Vince McMahon with the Stone Cold Stunner.
Wrestling isn’t about trying to make moments; it’s about doing great work that yields them. Not everything Austin did was outstanding. His late 2000 programme with Triple H was goofy. His vengeful, moody persona around the same time actively detracted from the vibe surrounding the product. Even at his peak, Austin was lumbered with some dreadful material, often throughout his never-ending programme with the Undertaker. The attempt at embalming him alive, the crucifixion angle, the invariably dire and overlong matches: all utterly rotten.
But, when you don’t pore over every detail with a forensic deep-dive, Austin’s career is possibly the most highlight-studded compendium of “moments” ever, all of which converge to make him the most unforgettable pro wrestling character there ever was.
Range
Is there anything Steve Austin could not do? Is there anything Steve Austin could not do brilliantly, for that matter?
Austin was one of the very best technical wrestlers of his generation, and one of the better brawlers.
Austin’s character range was so good that, if you first knew him as ‘Stone Cold’, hopping onto the Attitude Era fad in 1998 after cooling off during the New Generation years, the very sight of ‘Stunning’ Steve Austin was positively surreal when you first encountered him. That’s the same guy? The stooging, cocky, wannabe pretty boy?
This wasn’t some daft, early misadventure, either, like Oz becoming Diesel. Austin was incredible and convincing in both wildly different roles.
Austin was really funny when he was ‘Stunning’ in WCW, too - in a very different way to his gruff ‘Stone Cold’ deadpan. As part of the Hollywood Blonds alongside Brian Pillman, his taunts were a riot. With an obnoxious cackle, he’d pretend he was a camera operator on a film set, getting right in the faces of his opponents. This worked to particularly comedic effect during the programme with Ric Flair and Arn Anderson - the idea being that no director would want to cast the old-looking Arn as a leading man in the early ‘90s.
Austin was no high-flier, but then, recognising one’s limitations and carving a distinctive, more credible specialist persona should be an asset. Austin knew what he could do, stressed his best attributes, and was not self-conscious.
Austin could wrestle and brawl. He was great as a heel, and was so transcendent as a babyface that nobody could ever jeer him with a full heart ever again. Austin was funny in a way that delighted the most broad of minds, but was also funny, on occasion, in such a weird way that he could probably star in an experimental high-brow comedy. He enjoyed creeping people out. Strange guy, but also: funny.
Austin is probably the best all-rounder ever, and while he was legitimately hilarious, there were times when he overdid it.
He was self-indulgent during 2001. His snivelling toady character, while well-performed - he was so quick to repeat endorse everything that Mr. McMahon said - collided with the dour psycho character he tried to portray in the ring. Also, that ‘Margaritaville’ segment with the Rock ahead of Survivor Series 2001 was better left to the bar after the show. Austin’s self-indulgent streak was detrimental to what the WWF was trying to achieve - but then, the promotion had no idea itself. Perhaps Austin couldn’t be blamed for trying to have some fun while the ship sank.
Conclusion
Austin is a 10 in almost every single conceivable category. Bret wrote, when elaborating on his theory, that if a wrestler scored in the high 20s across his three categories, they’d be great.
In the U.S. scene, is anybody closer to the fabled 30 than ‘Stone Cold’?
The Rock is close, but does he have a match anywhere near as good as the WrestleMania 13 Submissions war? Kurt Angle and Eddie Guerrero are candidates that warrant a deeper dive.
Hangman Page is closer than most in AEW to dominating Bret Hart’s trifecta, and while he has the moments - burning down Swerve’s house, the “You need need a hat to be a cowboy” Dark Order entrance, spraying Swerve’s blood - he’s lower than Austin, considerably so, in every extra metric analysed above.
So how good was Steve Austin, actually?
He wasn’t merely good. He has the strongest case for the greatest of all time.