10 Hardest Men That Ever Played For Man Utd

Today's era of prima donna, poney-tailed, glove-wearing-if-it's-a-bit-chilly footballers are a far cry from the good old days when you'd warrant a slap for having the temerity for diving in the penalty area or wearing a vest in the middle of April. Football's gone soft - particularly at Manchester United - that is, if you choose to buy into our dearly-departed ex-manager David Moyes's recent claims that certain individuals were "playing like girls". To be fair, he probably has a point. Whether it's the sight of Ashley Young taking a tumble in a light breeze or a group of millionaires failing to score from 12 yards out four times against Sunderland in one of the worst shootouts ever, some of our players have hardly covered themselves in glory this season. Indeed, it's easy to miss the good old days of Roy Keane et al when United gave everything for the cause and fought until the very last breath week in and week out. In honour of those players, who (sometimes literally) left their blood, sweat and tears on the pitch at full time, we've decided to round up a list of the 10 Hardest Men That Ever Played For Man United. Click 'Next' to get started.

10. Eric Cantona

You need nerves of steel to join one of your former club's rivals and win them over, and that's what Eric Cantona did when he swapped Leeds United for Man United in 1992. Cantona's time at Old Trafford was marred with controversy, which, in hindsight, should have been expected considering he had punched a team-mate, took out an opposing player, smashed a referee with a football and labelled each member of the French Football disciplinary body 'idiots' during his stint in France before moving to England. And when he did arrive in the Premier League, he was soon walloped with an eight month suspension for losing his rag and launching into a sensational karate kick on a Crystal Palace fan. Yet despite playing for our fierce rivals Leeds, and despite assaulting a supporter, Cantona has still retained his 'King' status and we still sing his name, which is a real measure of the man.

9. Paul Ince

There aren't many players who rock up at a new club and insist upon being called 'the Guv€™nor', and there certainly aren't many who threaten Sir Alex Ferguson with a gun and live to tell the story. Yet that's exactly what Paul Ince did when, at just 22, he joined United from West Ham, and wasted no time in making waves. Steve Bruce, who captained the United side in the early 90's, once remembered how Ince turned up to training one day and pulled a gun on Ferguson. €œPaul was nuts when he was a kid,€ said Bruce. €œI don€™t think Fergie was ever attacked by a rifle before.
€œI remember when he brought in his gun. He poked it around the door and it was a big air rifle. Fergie must have shouted at him or something like that to provoke it. Incey was larger than life and a good character to have around. He must have had something about him to threaten Fergie with a gun. We saw him do it. He poked the gun through the door and he was only 22 at the time. It was just tongue in cheek, though. He just knocked on the door and said something like, €˜You€™d better stop picking on me€™ or, €˜You had better play me on Saturday€™.€
You've got to be pretty hard to rail against one of the biggest disciplinary figures in the game, even though doing so did ultimately mean being sold off to Inter Milan. Since hanging up his boots, the former midfielder appears to have lost none of his edge. Last October, as manager of Blackpool, Ince pushed a match official against a wall and threatened to knock him out, being hammered with a five-match stadium ban as a result.

8. Peter Schmeichel

Standing at an impressive 6'4", and tipping the scales at 16 stone, Peter Schmeichel is one of the hardest men to have ever played for Manchester United. The Great Dane was a mountain of a man, and wore specially-made XXXL shirts. He used his dominating physique to scare the living daylights out of anyone who dared enter his penalty area, and was uncompromising in closing those players down, putting his head where others would be afraid to put their feet. It wasn't just the opposing team who would be intimidated by Schmeichel - more than a couple of Red Devils players received one of his trademark rebukes for not marking their men properly, and the legendary goalkeeper was certainly not afraid in making his feelings known. Schmeichel gave absolutely everything for the cause, and if ever there was nothing for him to do in goal, he would bomb forward for corners and hurl himself into the mix - most famously against Bayern Munich as we won 2-1 to clinch the 1999 Champions League crown.

7. Steve Bruce

Throughout his career, Steve Bruce's occasionally... 'over enthusiastic' playing style was best described as "rampaging", and as a result the centre-back understandably suffered with disciplinary problems. But Bruce later developed into one of our most solid and dependable players during the late eighties and early nineties, and even became known for his strangely-high proportion of goal scoring - he netted 19 in the 1990-91 season - largely due to his powerful heading of the ball and bravery (and even willingness) to take knocks from opposition players. Bruce is best remembered for his indomitable spirit and was famous for playing on even if he was injured - in 1992 he returned to the team at short notice even though he was still awaiting surgery on a hernia. It was these traits that made him the heart of the defence during his time at Old Trafford and an obvious candidate for our Manchester United Hard Men List.

6. Norman Whiteside

"The scourge of the scousers", "The Shankill Skinhead" - these kind of nicknames aren't just handed out to anyone and Norman Whiteside was fully deserving of each moniker. Don't be fooled by his movie star good looks - it's easy to assume that Whiteside was a dainty, midfield maestro skipping and hopping past tackles - the reality was anything but. The youngest player since Duncan Edwards to play for Man Utd, Whiteside made his debut at just 16, but quickly became a fan favourite due to his non-negotiable attitude in going into tackles fully expecting to win each one. At 6'2", he was the best tackler in the game in his day, and his physical style of play was as good as his eye for goal - the midfielder scored 47 goals in his 206 appearances between 1982€“1989. Sadly, and maybe even predictably, Whiteside's career was ended at just 26 by a combination of injury and drinking problems following a two-year stint at Everton.

5. Jaap Stam

Jaap Stam was a tough guy, and he knew it. Once, in an interview, when asked if he was a hard man, his answer was honest and to the point:

€œA player recently came at me with a head-butt, so I grabbed him and put him in a head-lock€ he looked a bit blue when I let him go.€

Stam's United career was brief but he packed a lot into it, winning three Premier League titles, the FA Cup and the Champions League in his three year spell, and it's definitely not a coincidence that in each of those three seasons at Old Trafford we were English champions when he was in the side.

The Dutchman's importance to the side was such that veteran BBC football commentator Mike Ingham once famously said: €œWithout Jaap Stam, Sir Alex would still be Alex.€

At 6'3" Stam was a tough, rough around the edges centre-back who packed surprising bursts of speed and was renowned for his sometimes precision-perfect interception skills and tackling.

The reason however for his time at United being so brief was due to him being one of only a handful of players to dare cross Sir Alex Ferguson, by making allegations in his autobiography Head to Head about Ferguson and the club.

As a result Stam was controversially sold to Lazio, but has the rare distinction in that he was also one of only a few players Ferguson has admitted regretting letting go.


4. Nobby Stiles

Nobby Stiles was so scary that his hair ran away and his teeth jumped out of his mouth. Bald at a young age, Stiles gave fans a glimpse of what was to come on his Manchester United debut when he punched in the temple the player who had the temerity to take the ball away from him. But it wasn't just his actions that made him a hard man, Stiles was scary just to look at. He famously had his teeth ripped out during a match early in his career and wore dentures from that point on, taking them out prior to matches, lending to this gap-toothed photo. Stiles scored 17 goals in an 11-year playing career for Man United, winning the Football League First Division in 1964€“65, and again in 1966€“67. But he is best remembered for his success with the national side. His highly combative and physical style of play is owed by many to England's 1966 World Cup success, virtually bullying Eusebio out of the game as we went on to beat Portugal in the semi-finals. And, after beating West Germany in the final, the sight of Stiles dancing on the Wembley pitch, with the World Cup trophy in one hand and his false teeth in the other, will always go down as one of the most iconic images in Three Lions history.

3. Nemanja Vidic

"He comes from Serbia, he'll f***ing murder ya... Nemanja!" It's the terrace chant for none other than Nemanja Vidic, of course, who's hard man status has been fully recognised and appreciated by fans throughout his eight trophy-laden years at Old Trafford. And for good reasons, too. Vidic has proven himself on the pitch and has shown he is not afraid to put his body on the line for the team. Take for example last season's game against Swansea. Chico Flores is about to let fly from the edge of the area and, without even thinking about it, Vidic throws his head towards the blast. That's dedication. On that occasion his eye-watering levels of bravery were not needed, as the danger passed, but there have been plenty of occasions where Vidic has felt the consequences of his actions, with the sight of him shedding blood on the field not at all that rare. Like Stam before him, everything about Vidic's appearance evokes fear. From the disjointed nose through to the thousand yard stare, the Serbian is definitely not one to be messed around with, and the thought of Stam and Vidic lining up at centre-back in a dream team scenario really is the stuff of nightmares.

2. Frank Barson

There may be a few United fans out there who have never heard of, or are not familiar with Frank Barson, but the Sheffield-born half-back was the quintessential hard man of football in his day. Barson played for United between 1922€“1928, but his time at the club was plagued by injury. When he did play however he was singled out for his leadership skills and was named captain, leading us to promotion to the First Division in 1925. For this, he was honored with a pub in Manchester, and afforded cult hero status, but resenting the fame this brought, legend holds that on the opening night of his pub he gave the business to his head waiter. Barson was also known for spells at Barnsley and Aston Villa, and whoever he played for, opposing crowds loathed him. The Times once noted that "On frequent occasions Barson was escorted out of grounds by policemen to protect him from groups of angry opposition fans." Beginning his career as a blacksmith, Barson would often use his upbringing to defend his sometimes-unsavory style of play, protesting that he was "brought up to play hard and saw nothing wrong with an honest to goodness shoulder charge." Unfortunately for him, referees of the day did not share the same philosophy, and Barson was once hammered with a seven-month ban for a violent challenge in a match against Fulham. He left United to join Watford in May 1928 and stories of him are still told today in the same way Chuck Norris memes adorn Facebook walls.

1. Roy Keane

Widely regarded as the hardest man to ever play football in the modern day, it perhaps won't come as a surprise to learn that Roy Keane was a young apprentice boxer before discovering his true calling as a footballer. Signed from Nottingham Forest in 1993, Keane shunned a then-dominant Blackburn Rovers to join us and has been rewarded with cult-hero status ever since. The Irishman was the complete midfielder at the height of his powers, and was nearly single-handedly responsible for our dominance of English football in the 1990s. But he also had a darker side to him. The infamous, career-threatening tackle on Alf-Inge Haland is a regrettable footnote of what was otherwise a distinguished career, with Keane 'taking revenge' on the Norwegian with a knee high lunge after being accused of feigning injury. Keane's talk was also as tough as any tackle. He constantly rounded on his own teammates if he thought they weren't pulling their weight, just ask Rio Ferdinand and Darren Fletcher. But what Keane will be best remembered for is his legendary rivalry with Arsenal's Patrick Vieira. Their televised spat in the tunnel prior to a typically fiery encounter between the two sides is one of the most iconic moments from the Premier League era, with Keane spitting "I'll see you out there!" after taking issue with something Vierra had said. And it is incidents such as these (and they were numerous) that rightly make Roy Keane the hardest man who has ever played for Manchester United.

Contributor
Contributor

Joseph is an accredited football journalist and has interviewed nearly all of the current 20 Barclay's Premier League managers. He is also a correspondent for Bleacher Report and has written for Caught Offside and Give Me Football.