10 Man Utd Youngsters Who Never Fulfilled Their Potential

Despite brief flashes, they never established themselves at Old Trafford.

Manchester United are famed for their progression of youth through their ranks. Unlike the likes of other clubs who plunder endless financial resources into assembling their squad every season, the Mancunian side pride themselves on allowing youth the opportunity to flourish at Old Trafford - often to their detriment, however. While the likes of Cristiano Ronaldo, David de Gea and of course, the class of 92, have repaid Sir Alex Ferguson's faith and trust, with the latter ramming Alan Hansen's famous last words straight back down his throat, there have been examples of those who Ferguson should have dispensed with earlier than he did. In a bid to replicate the success he enjoyed with the starlets of the past, there have been youngsters who sparkle before the Old Trafford faithful at first, brimming with potential and promise, before everybody begins to grow impatient at their lack of progress and development as the years tick by. Now, in this list, there may be one or two players who have flourished since leaving the club, but here are the ten players who failed to live up to their potential at Old Trafford.

10. Chris Eagles

Chris Eagles may currently be stuck in purgatorial limbo with regards to his career, having failed to find a club upon his release from Championship side Bolton Wanderers at the end of last season, but it was only seven years ago, that a 21 youngster curled home a sumptuous to wrap up a 4-2 comeback victory at Goodison Park in April, as the Red Devils took a giant stride towards the title. For Eagles, it was a moment to build on, with Ferguson having been particularly enamoured with his work ethic. Unfortunately for Eagles, that exquisite solo at Goodison Park was as good as it got for the left-winger. Despite the promise shown in pre-season friendlies and in League Cup outings, Eagles was never quite able to cut it in the first-team and was farmed out on loan four times before Ferguson finally cut the chord in 2008, with Burnley boss Owen Coyle taking a punt on the 22 year old. It€™s a shame how a career once filled with so much promise and enthusiasm has withered away into mediocrity, struggling for work at an age where he should be enjoying the best years of his career.

9. Darron Gibson

Darron Gibson€™s career may have been obstructed by injury woes one wouldn€™t wish on their worst enemy, but make no mistake about it - he was showing no sign of becoming the next Roy Keane before then. A Manchester United trainee, he was another Royal Antwerp alumni, and took in a loan spell at Wolves before finally being granted a chance to stake his claim in the first team during the 08/09 season as a fresh-faced 21 year old. To his credit, Gibson took his chance with aplomb, gaining plaudits for some decent displays in the centre of the park. However, he hadn€™t won the trust of Ferguson just yet, and his 14 appearances included just three outings in the league, but he still managed to find the back of the net on the final day of the season with a sizzling 25 yard scorcher at the KC Stadium. The 09/10 season was where Gibson really made a case for a future at the club, making 15 appearances in the league, and hammering home five goals in all competitions, including a 25 yard thumper against Bayern Munich in the Champions League. By the following season, however, his performances began to grow stale, and punters began to realise that he wasn€™t developing quick enough for a Man United starlet. 20 appearances were turned in, and there were further goals, including a Champions League semi-final strike against Schalke 04, but even his international manager knew Gibson needed to leave the club for the sake of his career. Eleven months later, he was an Everton player, where he has been plagued by injury demons ever since.

8. Fraizer Campbell

Six years ago, Manchester United were in an incredibly healthy position. Arguably Europe€™s elite side, having lifted the Champions League that season, not only were the club well stocked in attacking options with the likes of Cristiano Ronaldo, Carlos Tevez and Wayne Rooney, but they had a long line of young and hungry strikers waiting in the wings for their moment. Among them was a 20 year old Fraizer Campbell, who had surpassed the ritual loan at feeder club Royal Antwerp with flying colours, netting 20 goals in 31 appearances, before becoming a Hull City hero by bagging 15 goals as they sealed their first ever promotion to the top-flight. Predictably, speculation was rife with regards to the England U21 international€™s future, with Campbell becoming the subject of a club record £7 million bid from the Tigers. Ferguson, however, was adamant that the youngster was needed at Old Trafford.
''We do not have any strikers apart from Wayne Rooney and Carlos Tevez and Fraizer plays in that area. He is quick and determined and he can do very well in the game. Frazier۪s future is here.۪۪ - Sir Alex Ferguson, August 2008.
By the end of the season, however, it had become abundantly clear that Campbell was not going to succeed at Old Trafford, having been shoe-horned to White Hart Lane on loan as part of the deal which took Dimitar Berbatov the other way. His first season in the top-flight proved a troublesome one, as he managed to find the back of the net just once in a struggling Spurs side, leading Ferguson to advise Campbell to find a permanent switch more suitable to his level. Since tying up a £3.5 million move to Sunderland in 2009, Campbell has spent the majority of the last six seasons battling injury, with a paltry 21 goals to show for his efforts.

7. Kieran Richardson

Nine years ago, Kieran Richardson was a revelation in English football. Not only had he been West Brom€™s saviour, adding the instant impetus needed to miraculously keep them in the top-flight, but he had seemingly announced himself as England€™s solution to the left-wing problem, with two goals on his debut in a summer friendly with USA. Richardson had been a fixture in the Man United reserve side since 2001, but he was given sporadic opportunities to stake a claim in the first team in League Cup fixtures before he enjoyed a breakthrough 02/03 season, appearing on nine occasions and scoring his first goal for the Red Devils. He was also played a pivotal role in the youth team€™s FA Youth Cup win of 2003. But it wasn€™t until that loan spell at the Hawthorns, where he scored three goals in 12 games, including a vital last-day strike, that outsiders began to take notice of the 21 year old€™s talents. Richardson would go on to make 60 appearances for the Red Devils in all competitions over the next two seasons, often appearing at left-back. However, England€™s once-bright hope for the left wing slot would only feature seven more times for the national side, as he slowly slipped into the abyss of Premier League mediocrity, following a move to Sunderland in 2007, where he has ambled between mid-table clubs, before eventually ending up at Aston Villa, as a 29 year old journeyman.

6. Gabriel Obertan

He arrived as an up-and-coming starlet with bags of potential and promise, who had been tracked by the likes of Arsenal, Inter Milan and AC Milan. He would depart Old Trafford, bag in hand, two summers late, with any semblance confidence having been well and truly shattered.
''Gabriel is a player we have tracked for a few years now. But because of his educational programme our efforts to get him have been delayed. We are delighted to get him now as he is an exciting prospect.۪۪ - Sir Alex Ferguson, July 2009.
It may have been exciting for the club when the 20 year old winger arrived from Bordeaux for £3 million on a four-year contract in the summer of 2009, but that adjective could not be used to describe any part of Obertan€™s Manchester United career. Demonstrating an inability to get the basics right, including misplacing passes, overhitting crosses and displaying the sort of frenetic ball-chasing that a headless chicken would be proud of. To Ferguson€™s credit, it didn€™t take him long to see where he had erred, pawning the seemingly useless Frenchman off on Alan Pardew€™s Newcastle in the summer of 2011, where Obertan has once again flattered to deceive, spending the majority of the time warming the bench.

5. Giuseppe Rossi

Maybe Manchester United should just stop selling players to Villareal. There were quite a number of similarities between Diego Forlan and Giuseppe Rossi€™s respective careers at Old Trafford, and their subsequent success once they found a way out. With both players having failed to settle in England, they flourished once Man United sold them to Spanish side Villareal. In the case of Giuseppe Rossi, he had been lauded as the club€™s most natural finisher amongst the reserves, and was tipped as a future star by many. An Italian U21 international, the 20 year old had been begging for more first-team opportunities at Old Trafford, but was only ever granted five outings in the league for the Mancunian outfit. Of course, a goalless eleven-game loan spell stint at St. James€™ Park might not have helped state his claim for a break at Manchester United, but Ferguson maintains that he did not want to have to sell the American-born striker.
''He wanted to have a go at first-team football. We۪ve got a clause in his contract where he could come back to us at some point.۪۪ - Sir Alex Ferguson, August 2007.
While Rossi has endured his fair share of injury problems in recent years, he has still scored an impressive 99 goals in 217 outings for both Villareal and Fiorentina, with seven goals scored for the Italian national side to boot. For Rossi, his undoubted potential is being fulfilled. It just wasn€™t in Manchester.

4. Eric Djemba-Djemba

So good they named him twice. Eric Djemba-Djemba has become a bit of a running joke in Premier League folklore - not just for the aforementioned hilarious punchline, but for his far more ridiculous displays in the centre of the park for Manchester United. If ever there are examples of warnings to managers about signing them based on good international tournaments, the name Djemba-Djemba would stand out in big neon letters. Having impressed for Cameroon during their victorious 2002 African Nations Cup triumph and their decent showing in the World Cup six months later, the 21 year old was subsequently courted for the next year by Manchester United, as they sought Roy Keane€™s eventual replacement. They really should have kept looking.
''Eric is a young player we۪ve watched throughout the season, and he۪s impressed us each time with his understanding of the game. He۪s quick, aggressive and a good passer of the ball, and is the kind of athletic footballer we are looking for. In the last few months, he has shown his development playing in a very good Cameroon team, and he looks like a Manchester United player in every sense.۪۪ - Sir Alex Ferguson, July 2003.
Arriving at the club full of promise and with bags of potential, the Cameroonian youngster flopped in dramatic fashion, making just 20 appearances over the course of two seasons before he was dumped on the hands of Aston Villa, where he continued to unimpress.

3. Ravel Morrison

When Sir Alex Ferguson pinpoint a 14 year old as the best he€™s ever seen at that age, one would expect that player to have reached loftier heights than Cardiff City by the age of 21. The trouble with Ravel Morrison was that while he is undoubtedly a supremely gifted player, it looks like his behavioural problems and attitude malfunctions will erode his promising career. It doesn€™t matter how talented a player may be - without the proper dedication and application, they will never make it, and Ferguson could see that. Indeed, it were ultimately off-field indiscretions that curtailed his Old Trafford career, having been involved in several controversies including an FA charge for homophobic abuse via social media, an assault charge, and two counts of witness intimidation, amongst others. Having kept the wrong company in Manchester, Ferguson knew that he was never going to realise his potential while he remained in the city.
''Sir Alex let Ravel go for his own benefit. He said that if he comes down to you, hopefully he will find a new life and a new way of living. His ability will then start to come through because all he asks and all he wants in his life is to play first-team football, that was all he said he wanted to do and why he wanted to leave. Somewhere along the line, the lad has woken up and I think he۪s changed himself and delivered.۪۪ - Sam Allardyce, December 2013.
It may have been wishful thinking on the West Ham manager€™s part. Having signed the Mancunian in 2011, Morrison looked to have finally knuckled down last season, before he was remanded in custody at the end of the season after being charged with two counts of common assault against his mother and a former girlfriend. Allardyce was clearly not impressed, and swiftly sentenced him to a season-long loan at Championship side Cardiff City.

2. Federico Macheda

It was an entrance that couldn€™t have been scripted by the hacks in Hollywood. With Manchester United€™s title bid having been under threat following successive defeats to Liverpool and Fulham in March 2009, they suddenly found themselves staring down the barrel of another defeat, as they trailed 2-1 at home to Aston Villa. Three defeats in a row? It would have been a crisis on the same wavelength as Kevin Keegan€™s collapse in 1996. With ten minutes left, Cristiano Ronaldo levelled matters with a blistering 25 yarder, leading a thunderous Old Trafford to urge their troops forward and put the Villains to the sword. With the clock ticking into injury-time, not even the 17 year old Italian himself could have dreamt what would happen next. With Ryan Giggs threading a ball into him, Federico Macheda pulled off the most exquisite turn to evade his marker before curling a glorious shot into the net from just inside the area. Wheeling away in delirium, the atmosphere blew up, as Villa players sunk to the turf, wondering who on earth had just netted that wondergoal. There were probably certain sections of the Old Trafford faithful who hadn€™t a clue who this greasy-haired youngster was, at the bottom of the celebratory pile-on, but they certainly knew his name now. Having hit a rich vein of goalscoring form for the reserves, including a hat-trick against Newcastle the previous week, Ferguson drafted him onto the bench for the Villa game, before handing him a debut he would never forget.
''I told him €˜well done€™. It€™s important to keep his feet on the ground. He€™ll need to handle lots of publicity over the next few days.€™€™ - Sir Alex Ferguson, April 2009.
The wily Scot wasn€™t wrong. Macheda had burst forward into the limelight, and was suddenly at the forefront of the media. Another winning goal the following week was to come against Sunderland for the Italian, as everything he touched seemed to turn to gold. Had a star been born? The answer is no. He would take in five loan spells, as he failed to establish himself in the first-team, and would only score three more goals for the club in all competitions. Having finally been released from Man United at the end of the season, he linked up with Cardiff City, where he is yet to find a league goal.

1. Liam Miller

He was supposed to be Roy Keane€™s heir apparent, a tough-tackling midfielder from Cork, and had Old Trafford supporters falling over themselves with excitement when he clinched a move from Celtic to Manchester United in January 2004. The 22 year old had broken into the midfield of the Scottish champions during the 03/04 season, and had produced some stellar performances both domestically and in the Champions League, but as soon as the Mancunian giants took an interest, the writing was on the wall for the Scottish giants.
''We recognised the potential of Liam, he has had a great season at Celtic. He is very much part of our progressive thinking of developing a young team over the next few years.۪۪ - Sir Alex Ferguson, January 2004.
What transpired since has been nothing short of nightmarish for the boy who had the world at his feet. He failed to establish himself at the Premier League title contenders, making just nine league appearances for the first-team, before leaving for Sunderland on a free transfer in August 2006 to work for the man who he was supposed to replace at Old Trafford.
''You don۪t have a crystal ball to see how things like that are going to work out. Even so, I can۪t say I have any regrets. It was a great environment to be around. Training every day, learning from some of the players there. I still look back on it as a tremendous experience. But I did think I would be playing a bigger part. I played more on the right wing than I ever had in my career. It was not a role I enjoyed and by the end I wasn۪t playing. I suppose I could have just sat on the bench for five years, but there comes a point when a player has to say enough is enough.۪۪ - Liam Miller, April 2013.
Liam Miller is now 33 years old, and has spent the last three years of his life plying his trade in Australia, first with Perth Glory and now with Brisbane Roar, following failed stints at QPR and Hibernian. It€™s certainly a far cry from Old Trafford, but at least he is finally getting a bit of game-time. So that's a wrap - do you agree? Have there been any glaring omissions? As always, feel free to leave your thoughts and opinions in the comment section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Recent Journalism & New Media graduate. Insatiable thirst for all things football, and hopes to break into the field of sports journalism in the near future. Have made a significantly insignificant playing career out of receiving several slaps around the head for not passing the ball.