10 Most Expensive Transfer Flops In Everton History

Will Koeman's summer recruits go the way of this lot?

Everton's Andrew Johnson rues a missed chance
Joe Giddens/EMPICS Sport

Boosted by Farhad Moshiri's millions, Everton spent big over the summer. Ronald Koeman was handed a war chest to rival any of the top four, not that you'd know it based on the team's league position heading into the international break.

The Dutchman's latest wave of recruits, which cost more than £150 million combined, are yet to offer much in the way of a return on their hefty price tags, but it's too early to write the likes of Davy Klaassen and Gylfi Sigurdsson off as bad business.

That said, Koeman's new boys need to gel sharpish to ensure they salvage something from their faltering Premier League and Europa League campaigns, and avoid joining a growing list of expensive flops at Goodison Park.

Although spending power was never one of Everton's strong points prior to the Moshiri era, by their own standards they've broken the bank only to squander its contents on numerous occasions in the past, bringing in players that did little to justify their beefy fees or help the club end its lengthy trophy drought.

10. Ramiro Funes Mori (£9.5m)

Everton's Ramiro Funes Mori celebrates victory after the Emirates FA Cup, Quarter Final match at Goodison Park, Liverpool.
Martin Rickett/PA Wire

Everton played attractive, attacking football under Roberto Martinez, something that's in short supply at Goodison in 2017, unless the opposition are firing on all cylinders.

While blistering counters were the Spaniard's bread and butter, defensive frailty soon crept into his team's repertoire and the cracks in his backline only widened over time, until the Blues were shipping goals like nobody's business.

In a bid to steel up his rear guard, Martinez brought in Argentine defender Ramiro Funes Mori from River Plate in a deal worth £9.5 million. The leg-biting centre-half was hailed as the answer to Everton's defensive woes, but his presence largely exacerbated the problem in the long run.

Although Mori has never shied away from a tackle and even chipped in with a few goals during his debut season in blue and white, glaring errors hinted at the ugly part of the South American's game, and he eventually became just another part of the leaky defence that cost Martinez his job as head coach.

Under Ronald Koeman, Mori is no more than a squad player when he isn't battling long-term injury.


9. Diniyar Bilyaletdinov (£9m)

Diniyar Bilyaletdinov, Everton
Peter Byrne/PA Archive

Everton landed one of Russian football's top prospects when they snapped up Diniyar Bilyaletdinov from Lokomotiv Moscow in 2009, but even some of the most talented foreign players fail to make their mark on the Premier League.

The towering winger's career in England got off to a positive start. He exploded onto the scene with three assists during a 4-0 Europa League demolition of AEK Athens and went on to net seven times in his first season, a haul which included a memorable strike against Manchester United at Goodison Park.

But Bily, as he came to be affectionately known to fans and teammates, soon showed signs of struggling with the pace of Premier League life and often faded into the background during matches. Then-manager David Moyes would often substitute him first when things weren't going the Toffees' way.

The Russian's starting place became less secure over the course of the next two seasons until a £5 million bid from Spartak Moscow spirited him back to his homeland.

Bily's playing career is still going today (just about). He's on the books at Lithuanian outfit FK Trakai, who knocked St Johnstone out of this season's Europa League.


8. Andy Van Der Meyde (Undisclosed)

Andy Van Der Meyde Everton Dejected
Peter Byrne/PA Archive/Press Association Images

To say Andy van der Meyde's Everton career is one of the least productive is an understatement, yet it was one of the most colourful, a scandal punctuated by booze, drugs and strip joint visits just days before matches.

The former Dutch international arrived in Merseyside from Italian giants Inter Milan in 2005 for an undisclosed fee that seriously inflated the club's wage bill, but he only ever made back-page headlines with his off-the-pitch antics.

During a four-year stint at Goodison, Van der Meyde played just 24 times and often clashed with David Moyes. If he wasn't being chastised for missing a training session, he was putting his liver through its paces at a Liverpool watering hole.

The winger's life in England was dogged by personal problems, so nobody was surprised to see him released on a free transfer when his contract expired in June 2009. The warning signs were there when he was sent off in his first Merseyside derby for a reckless tackle on Liverpool's Xabi Alonso.


7. Per Kroldrup (£5m)

Per Kroldrup Everton
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

The mighty Thomas Gravesen aside, Everton have never had the best of luck with Danish imports. Nobody was on David Moyes's case too much over the questionable signing of Lars Jacobsen on a free transfer, but paying £5 million to Udinese for his compatriot Per Kroldrup several years earlier is harder to justify.

Kroldrup solitary Premier League appearance during a 4-0 defeat to Aston Villa goes down as one of the most expensive in the history of the club, and the defender's name frequently crops up during discussion on the topic of worst. Signing. Ever.

In fairness to the Dane, half of his brief Everton career was marred by injuries, with groin surgery delaying his debut by more than six months, but the player himself admitted that he never got a handle on the physical aspects of the game in England.

Kroldrup remained in Italy for several seasons and enjoyed success at Fiorentina, including Champions League qualification. A short stint with Pescara followed before he saw out his career in Portugual with Olhanense.


6. James Beattie (£6m)

Everton's James Beattie rues a missed chance
Joe Giddens/EMPICS Sport

It goes without saying that becoming a club's record signing comes with certain expectations. Some players, usually world-class ones, take them in their stride, while others are crushed beneath the weight of them.

James Beattie looked like a sure-fire addition to the latter category following his £6 million move from Southampton in 2005. The striker struggled to settle in Merseyside and his early woes were compounded when sent off for a head-butt on Chelsea defender William Gallas on only his fifth Premier League appearance.

Beattie threatened to come good during his second season in blue, finishing as the club's top scorer for 2005–06 with 10 strikes, but his improved form was short lived.

He was in and out of David Moyes's starting XI in his third season, eventually leaving Goodison Park for Sheffield United in search of first-team football, with the Blues recouping £4 million of the record sum they coughed up in the deal.

The forward netted 13 Premier League goals in 76 appearances across three seasons, which isn't exactly the kind of return you shatter your transfer record for.


5. Andy Johnson (£8.6m)

Andrew Johnson Everton
Joe Giddens/EMPICS Sport

Okay, so this one is a tad harsh since there are positives to draw from Andy Johnson's Everton career, but the chrome-domed striker did fall marginally short of his potential.

Four successful years at Crystal Palace, one of which included 21 Premier League goals, catapulted the pacey forward into the England setup and inspired the Toffees to smash their transfer record to secure his services for £8.6 million.

Johnson started with a bang at Goodison, winning over the fan base with a brace during a 3-0 win over local rivals Liverpool, and finishing as the club's top scorer for 2006–07 with 11 league strikes plus one in the FA Cup.

But things threatened to turn sour when diving accusation from opposing managers seemed to get to the striker, leading to a 13-match barren spell. He was, however, later cleared of such allegations by the Professional Game Match Officials Board.

Many factors conspired against Johnson towards the end of his Everton career. An injury layoff coupled with the arrival of Yakubu and a formation change saw his first-team opportunities limited, and an eight-figure switch to Fulham followed in 2008.

Perhaps the most successful aspect of Johnson's Everton career is the fact they made a slight profit on him.


4. Ashley Williams (£12m)

Swansea City's Ashley Williams
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

When a club manages to prise a key player away from a rival team it either goes down as a coup, or a case of 'they offloaded him at exactly the right moment'.

Many of Ronald Koeman's signings are misfiring at the moment, but it's too soon to dismiss his summer captures as failures. Ashley Williams, however, has been a regular fixture in the team for over a year now and is failing to live up to his billing as a top-class international centre-half.

Everton paid £12 million to Swansea City for the 33-year-old's services, which is the equivalent of shelling out at least twice that sum for a player in his prime.

After a string of solid performances during his first season at Goodison, the Welsh captain is showing signs of being past his best, already having made a clutch of serious blunders during the 2017-18 term.

The timing of Swansea's decision to offload Williams is looking shrewd indeed. Will Gylfi Sigurdsson's big-money move to Goodison similarly benefit the Welsh club?


3. James McCarthy (£13m)

Everton's James McCarthy
Peter Byrne/PA Archive

This is another one than could be considered somewhat harsh, but James McCarthy's time at Everton doesn't hold up well under close scrutiny.

The Republic of Ireland midfielder followed Roberto Martinez to Goodison Park from Wigan Athletic in 2013 and, although he initially made a positive impact at the club, his influence has gradually waned since then.

During his early days in a blue shirt, McCarthy worked like a Trojan, covering every inch of the pitch during matches, and he became known for his reading of the game and as a calming influence among the squad.

These qualities have faded over time and persistent injuries have marred his career under Ronald Koeman, who will likely offload him at the next opportunity.

Despite glimpses of greatness, the man who was once tipped as a future Everton captain will likely leave the club without ever reaching his potential.


2. Simon Davies (£4m)

Although £4 million is peanuts by today's standards, for a cash-strapped Everton that had to sell to buy in 2005, it was a significant portion of their transfer kitty.

It also turned out to be a significant portion wasted when David Moyes handed it over to Spurs to bring playmaker Simon Davies to Goodison Park in May of that year.

Davies was known for his creativity but he failed to channel it at every turn in a blue shirt. His only notably contribution for the club in two seasons was a winning goal against Birmingham City, which gave the Blues their first win for two months and inspired a reversal in their fortunes.

The Wales international's fortunes would only reverse when he joined Fulham in January 2007 for an undisclosed fee.


1. Oumar Niasse?

oumar niasse everton
© Alan Martin/ActionPlus/Corbis

A huge question mark surrounds the final player on this list, Oumar Niasse, a man who frequently featured on 'worst signing of the Premier League era' lists until recently, when he threatened to prove everyone wrong.

Nobody knows the full story behind the Senegalese striker's Goodison plight. He was signed by Roberto Martinez for a cool £13.5 million in 2016, but the Spaniard seemed reluctant to play him and Ronald Koeman was dead against that idea when he first took charge of the club the following season.

Was Niasse absolutely shocking in training? His desire to impress while on loan at Hull City last term and willingness to battle against seemingly insurmountable odds for a place in the Everton team this season suggests otherwise.

Clearly something went horribly wrong for Niasse at Everton, since he managed just five Premier League appearances in 2016 and Koeman was adamant he wasn't good enough for his team, despite probably having never seen him kick a ball. Could it simply be a case of nobody giving this man a chance?

Three goals in two recent sub appearances against Sunderland in the EFL Cup and Bournemouth in the league have threatened to revive the forgotten man's career, but living up to his £13.5 million price tag is going to be a big ask after such a rocky start.

And how much longer he will remain at Goodison after Everton sign another striker in January is anybody's guess.


Contributor
Contributor

Been prattling on about gaming, movies, TV, football and technology across the web for as long as I can remember. Find me on Twitter @MarkLangshaw