10 Most Surprising Transfers In Premier League History

Not all football transfers are predicted by the press...

File photo dated 04-02-2011 of Chelsea new signing Fernando Torres (right) and manager Carlo Ancelotti.
Nick Potts/PA Wire

The modern football world loves a big transfer story. Tabloids and online news sources around the globe often tout numerous rumours around during the now famed transfer windows, before laying claim to being the ones who called it from the start when a move does eventually come off.

Over the years we have seen long drawn out sagas like that of Cristiano Ronaldo to Real Madrid, or more recently Romelu Lukaku's move away from Everton this summer.

However, not all football transfers can be claimed to have been called by someone in the know. Many times during Premier League history we have been taken aback by a transfer which has come out of the blue and surprised everyone in football.

Whether it be someone moving to a club they swore never to join, a huge and seemingly unnecessary transfer fee being paid, or a club making a move for a player we all thought had simply no chance of happening, there have been plenty of occasions where the Premier League has produced a switch totally out of left field.

10. Nemanja Matic - Chelsea To Man United

Nemanja Matic Chelsea Sub
Andrew Matthews/PA Archive/Press Association Images

One of the more recent surprising moves comes in the form of Serbian international Nemanja Matic being allowed to jump ship from Chelsea and join title rivals Manchester United.

The midfielder had been a key part of Chelsea's dominant title winning team, sitting in the midfield and allowing the Blues' more creative players to express their talents further up the pitch to influence the game.

However, manager Antonio Conte saw fit to allow Matic to move on, and when he became available, former Chelsea manager Jose Mourinho snapped him up for around £40m to the surprise of many in football.

Given how he had been such a pivotal part of the club, that he is still in his prime years, and that it strengthened one of Chelsea's title rivals significantly, it definitely goes down as one of the biggest shocks of the transfer market in recent times.


9. Robin Van Persie - Arsenal To Man United

Manchester United's Robin Van Persie (right) celebrates scoring his side third goal of the game during the Barclays Premier League match at Old Trafford, Manchester.
Martin Rickett/PA Archive

The move of Robin Van Persie from Arsenal to Manchester United back in 2012 proved a pivotal moment for both Van Persie and United, as the Dutch international would go on to have one of the biggest impacts the Premier League has seen from someone in their first season at a new club.

It was a shock move at the time and one which caught Gunners fans off guard, but United manager Alex Ferguson knew exactly what he was doing. Moving from the Gunners to United in a £22m deal, Van Persie would go on to fire in 30 goals across all competitions, including 26 in the Premier League in a stellar first campaign for the Red Devils.

Not only did he bang in the goals, but he delivered United their 20th league title, setting himself firmly on a pedestal in United fans' eyes and further increasing the gap in quality between United and former club Arsenal.

That would be his only trophy at United as the goals didn't flow quite so frequently in his following two years at the club, but the surprise of the move at the time and the immediate impact he would have at Old Trafford make this transfer stand out.


8. Alan Smith - Leeds United To Manchester United

Leeds United's James Milner celebrates at the end of the game with teammate Alan Smith after scoring a goal during the game against Chelsea
John Walton/EMPICS Sport

2004 would see one of the most heart wrenching and surprising transfers we have ever seen in England, as Leeds born and bred striker Alan Smith was almost forced into a move to Manchester United.

As Leeds were relegated at the end of the 2003/04 campaign, the club were in dire need of finances or faced a winding up order and the potential of going out of business all together.

Smith, the homegrown star of the team and pictured crying when the club's relegation was confirmed, had earlier in the season publicly stated he would never sign for Man United - Leeds' long term rivals.

However, faced with the prospect of seeing his club go under or moving on, Smith opted to sign for United in a £7m deal which shocked football, but ultimately saved Leeds.

Smith spent three years at Old Trafford, picking up a Premier League title and League Cup in the process before a horror injury curtailed his progress. For Leeds and Man United fans especially, it remains one of the biggest surprises they have seen in terms of transfers.


7. Eric Cantona - Leeds United To Man United

Eric Cantona, Manchester United gives a gaulic shrug of the shoulders
Neal Simpson/EMPICS Sport

Back in 1992, the Premier League would see one of its first big money moves, one which caught many off guard and would go on to shape the initial few years of the new division.

When Eric Cantona moved to Man United from Leeds for what now looks like a paltry £1.2m, few would have known the impact it would have. The surprise in the move came as Leeds were not known for selling their best players, and Cantona had just played a key role in the club winning the First Division Championship title before the switch over to the Premier League in 1992.

However, the move was completed, much to the dismay of manager Howard Wilkinson and Leeds United fans.

The magnitude of this move cannot be understated, as Man United under Alex Ferguson would go on to wrap up the first two Premier League titles, before adding two more after Blackburn had snatched it away from them, all with Cantona as the main man.

Often shrouded in controversy - his kung fu kick on a fan springs to mind - the enigmatic Frenchman was the key player as United dominated. One can only guess what might have been had Leeds United stood firm and kept hold of their star man.


6. Esteban Cambiasso - Inter Milan To Leicester City

Inter Milan Argentine midfielder Esteban Cambiasso celebrates after scoring during a Champions League, Group B, soccer match between Inter Milan and CSKA Moscow at the San Siro stadium in Milan, Italy, Wednesday, Dec.7, 2011. (AP Photo/Luca Bruno)
Luca Bruno/AP

In one of the most surprising moves in modern times, newly promoted Leicester City pulled off one of the major coups in Premier League history when they captured Argentinian international Cambiasso.

The Foxes had only just won promotion to the Premier League, and Cambiasso had been instrumental in a successful period at Inter which had seen them win the Champions League and Serie A title under Jose Mourinho.

The combative midfielder could have signed for a whole host of Europe's top clubs, but arrived in the East Midlands and created quite a stir among Leicester fans. It would turn out to be a fairy tale season for Cambiasso, as his performances endeared him to the Foxes faithful and he picked up the player of the year award at the King Power, voted for by fans.

He rejected the chance to stay on, but his move to Leicester showed the club they could attract big names and compete, and the club would go on to win the Premier League title the following season under Claudio Ranieri.


5. Juninho - Sau Paulo To Middlesbrough

Juninho Middlesbrough
Owen Humphreys/PA Archive

One of the most well respected and adored players of the Premier League era, Juninho made his original move to England back in 1995, when he signed for Middlesbrough following their promotion to the Premier League.

The skillful and diminutive Brazilian midfielder was courted by a whole host of Europe's top clubs at the time, and his decision to sign for Boro was a shock to everyone at the time.

He would soon settle in though, quickly harnessing the nickname of 'The Little Fella' on Teesside, where he would go on become adored by the Middlesbrough faithful due to his passion, commitment, and exciting performances week in week out.

Juninho would ultimately leave the club after two seasons when Middlesbrough were relegated thanks to a points deduction. The image of Juninho sat sobbing is one of the most heart wrenching moments we have seen in Premier League history, with the player himself knowing he would have to leave the club to pursue his dream of playing in the World Cup.

A move to Atletico Madrid followed, but he would return five years later for a second permament spell in Teesside to much fanfare.


4. Fernando Torres - Liverpool To Chelsea

FILE - In this Sunday, Oct. 27, 2013, file photo, Chelsea's Fernando Torres celebrates after scoring the winning goal during the English Premier League soccer match between Chelsea and Manchester City. Chelsea says it has agreed terms with AC Milan fo
Alastair Grant/AP

January 2011 would see the British transfer record smashed and shockwaves sent through the Premier League, as Chelsea splashed out £50m to take Liverpool favourite Fernando Torres to Stamford Bridge.

In a move which looked like being excellent business for the Blues at the time, Torres moving to Chelsea sent a shock through football in England as the £50m mark was breached for the first time.

Torres was a 'darling' in the eyes of Liverpool supporters, and despite only having one goal to his name that season, he was still very much worshipped in a similar ilk to that of Robbie Fowler and Michael Owen had been at Anfield. The move set in motion a chain of events which would see Andy Carroll arrive at Anfield for £35m, a move which would also, like Torres', turn sour.

Torres would go on to have a miserable time of things for Chelsea, missing numerous easy chances during his spell at the Bridge and often being ridiculed by opposing fans. He did have his moment with the club though, tearing away to score the crucial winning goal away at Barcelona to the sound of Gary Neville's infamous 'goalgasm'.


3. Robinho - Real Madrid To Manchester City

De Souza Robinho, Manchester City
Anna Gowthorpe/PA Archive

The transfer of Brazilian forward Robinho to Manchester City in 2008 would go down as one of the most surprising and ground breaking moves in Premier League history.

The Real Madrid forward looked all set to join Chelsea that summer, with Blues Chief Executive Peter Kenyon even publicly stating he was confident of the deal.

At the 11th hour though, and on the same day Manchester City were taken over by the Abu Dhabi investment group, the club announced they had come to an agreement for the transfer of Robinho. A fee of over £30m was agreed, and it sent shockwaves through the league as a signal of intent from the club's new owners that they were to be taken seriously.

The move set a precedent at the time and was only the beginning for City, who have gone on to spend big year on year since, splurging over £1bn in transfer fees paid out since that takeover.


2. Sol Campbell - Spurs To Arsenal

FILE - This is a Wednesday, Feb. 17, 2010 file photo of Arsenal's Sol Campbell as he celebrates after scoring against FC Porto in a Champions League round of 16 first leg soccer match at Porto's Dragon Stadium in Porto, Portugal. Campbell announ
Paulo Duarte/AP

In one of the most shocking and surprising transfers in football history, not just in the Premier League, Arsenal managed to convince Sol Campbell to join them on a free transfer from bitter rivals Spurs.

After a full summer of rumours surrounding his future, it became clear Campbell was not going to stay with Spurs, seemingly having the pick of Europe when it came to where his future would lie. Real Madrid, Barcelona, and Juventus would all try to sign Campbell, but he would shock the world when he turned up with Arsene Wenger at Arsenal.

The move came as a complete surprise to the world's media. Not one story had been leaked about Campbell potentially signing for Arsenal, and it caught everyone off guard.

Campbell would have success with the Gunners to justify his move, including two Premier League titles, but he wiped away any relationship he had ever built up with Spurs, with many Spurs fans branding him a 'judas' from that day forth.


1. Carlos Tevez And Javier Mascherano - Corinthians To West Ham

Carlos Tevez Javier Mascherano West Ham
Sean Dempsey/PA Archive/Press Association Images

2006 saw one of the most bizarre transfers we have seen in the Premier League era, as West Ham United pulled off the surprise capture of Carlos Tevez and Javier Mascherano in a double deal.

The then 22-year-olds both signed for the Hammers out of nowhere, moving to the club from South America on permanent contracts under then manager Alan Pardew.

The move was littered with controversy due to third party ownership issues and an agent who seemingly just wanted to get his clients into Europe before shipping them off elsewhere. Indeed the controversy would not stop there, as Tevez would score the goal on the final day of the season which saw West Ham survive and Sheffield United relegated, leading to a court case what would rumble on for a good few years between both clubs.

Both would go on to have superb careers at the highest level, but looking back now, it remains one of the most surprising and eye catching transfers of the last 20 years.


Contributor
Contributor

Football, WWE, NBA, Pokemon, Star Wars, Breaking Bad. Father to two humans and one dog. At my most stressed when getting beat on NBA2K and blaming 'laggy internet' for all losses.