10 Newcastle Heroes Whose Careers Nosedived Since Leaving

Sometimes, the grass isn't always greener...

Players leave football clubs - that is just a fact of life. For some, they can't have gotten away from St. James' Park faster - having fallen afoul of managers, being forced to play out of position and generally enduring a miserable time at Newcastle United. Once away from the cauldron of chaos up north, they were allowed to thrive and force their way into the reckoning for international call-ups and Champions League football. There are quite a number of footballers who have walked through the exit door and thus watched their career crumble before their very eyes. Whether they walked or were shoved, they will no doubt admit that they failed to replicate their Toon form anywhere else, and were consequently never adorned with the same level of affection from any of their new-found supporters. Some Newcastle United heroes left the club in search of furthering their careers and subsequently turned into the laughing stocks of the country, resigned to spending more time on the bench than on the pitch whilst punters and supporters alike clutched their sides with laughter regarding their sizeable transfer fees. Others were let go by the club as 30-something-year-olds after over a decade of service and were understandably unable to command the same level of suitor as ten years previously. Take a look at the ten Newcastle United heroes whose careers took a downward slump as soon as they left the club.

10. Andy Carroll

Three years ago, Andy Carroll was one of the hottest prospects in English football and was being touted as Alan Shearer€™s natural heir at both club and international level. Built like a traditional strong and burly centre-forward, the 21 year old hit-man was an intimidating presence in the air, possessed a dynamite left foot, and had already struck 11 league goals during the first half of Newcastle€™s 10/11 season. His excellent run of form subsequently led to a first ever English cap in November 2010, and prompted the likes of Spurs and Liverpool to table big-money bids for Tyneside€™s prized asset. As everybody knows, the Geordie number nine quickly destroyed his reputation in the north-east by forfeiting a potentially fruitful Newcastle legacy to become one of the world€™s most expensive transfers, with Liverpool foolishly parting with £35 million for his services. He subsequently scored eleven goals in 58 appearances for the Reds, before a loan deal at West Ham was made permanent in the summer of 2013 for a hefty fee of £15 million. Injuries have blighted his time in London, and he has scored just nine goals in 43 appearances for the Hammers. As far as his international ambitions go, he hasn€™t played for his country in over two years and will have been disappointed to lose out to the 32 year old Rickie Lambert in a battle for a place in the 2014 World Cup squad. If Carroll was honest with himself, he wouldn€™t deny that he regrets leaving St. James€™ Park in 2011.

9. Shay Given

Perhaps the timing of his decision to leave the sinking ship could be questioned, but nobody could really blame Shay Given for finally calling time on his Tyneside career in February 2009. It had been five years since the club were seriously challenging for Champions League places and he had consistently been forced to witness first-hand some of the most calamitous attempts at defending the Premier League has ever seen. Indeed, it was the 5-1 drubbing at home to Liverpool in December 2008 - a game where the Irishman still picked up the man-of-the-match award - that prompted his exit, citing it €˜as the lowest point of his career€™. Most Newcastle supporters wished their departing stalwart the best of luck in his new endeavours, having given twelve years of his career to the club, and he must have thought he would finally be challenging for major honours when money-bags Manchester City signed him for £6 million. Given spent 18 months in the first-team at Eastlands, before watching from the sidelines as Joe Hart returned from a loan spell to win the FA Cup during the 10/11 season. Unimpressed at being a deputy, the 35 year old signed a five-year contract at Aston Villa in July 2011 - a move that looks all the more bizarre now considering he hasn€™t spent more than one season as first-choice at Villa Park. Having been ousted by US goalkeeper Brad Guzan at the start of the 12/13 season, the veteran goalkeeper has yet to feature in the Premier League again.

8. Obafemi Martins

Since he left Newcastle following their relegation to the second tier of English football in 2009, Obafemi Martins has achieved something Geordies will have wished he had in the black and white of the Toon - scored the winner in a cup final. Capitalising on a Laurent Koscielny mistake, the Nigerian tapped home a last-minute winner for Birmingham City against Arsenal in the 2011 League Cup Final - it was more or less the only notable thing he has done since leaving Tyneside five years ago. Having signed for Bundesliga champions Wolfsburg, he scored just six times in 25 appearances before being shipped off to Russia via Rubin Kazan in July 2010. He scored just twice in 17 games for the Russian outfit, before a six-game loan spell at Birmingham City transpired, and then managed a marginally superior total of three strikes in 17 games upon his return to Russia. In 2012, he signed for La Liga side Levante and bagged nine goals in 27 games during his only season at the club before signing for MLS side Seattle Sounders the following season. The former Inter Milan prodigy seems to have found his level, returning to form with 27 goals in 55 appearances for the club, but considering the fact that he has only just turned 30 years of age, one would have expected more of a player who had scored 49 goals for Inter Milan before he was 22.

7. Sebastien Bassong

It may have been a dismal season that resulted in an ignominious relegation to the Championship, but if there was one shred of light in a bleak tunnel for Newcastle supporters it was the form of the find of the season - Sebastien Bassong, whose only experience of professional football had been 79 games in the second tier of French football. Remarkably, it was £10 million-rated former AC Milan centre-half Fabricio Coloccini€™s incompetence that brought about the problems at the back, with the 23 year old Bassong looking far more assured and composed. Of course, Bassong€™s loyalty did not match his ability and he was one of the first to jump ship when relegation was confirmed, completing an £8 million move to Spurs. Although his career at White Hart Lane got off to the perfect start, bagging the winner against Liverpool, he quickly fell down the pecking order at Spurs and made a total of 45 league appearances during his three seasons at the club. He has since suffered two more relegations - once on loan at Wolves in 2012 and another last season with Norwich City - and currently finds himself out of favour at Carrow Road. His potential top-flight career looks to be in tatters, with Norwich manager Neil Adams deeming him not good enough and having sent him out on loan to Watford.

6. Peter Beardsley

Former Newcastle wing wizard can lay claim to having left the club twice. Both times yielded polarising and differing outcomes. When he left St. James€™ Park in 1987 after four years, he proceeded to spend six years in Merseyside with both Liverpool and Everton, winning two league titles, an FA Cup and three Charity Shields along the way. The second time he left, however, was in 1997 after yet another four years with the Tyneside outfit. By now, the wide-man was 36 years old so it makes sense that he wasn€™t at the peak of his powers. The 97/98 season was spent at both the Reebok Stadium and at Maine Road - on a loan deal - where he amassed 23 appearances and scored two goals in total. He subsequently played 21 appearances for Fulham under old boss Kevin Keegan in 1998, before finishing his career with Division Three strugglers Hartlepool United during the 98/99 season. His two appearances at the age of 38 with A-League side Melbourne Knights hardly count as a proper curtain-closer on a wonderful career.

5. Rob Lee

Rob Lee spent ten years with the club, and amassed nearly 400 appearances for the club. A pivotal member of the sides who finished as runners-up in the Premier League and FA Cup, Lee was certainly a memorable figure at St. James€™ Park. Perhaps it was inevitable that the midfielder was never going to scale the heights of his Tyneside era when he finally left the club midway through the 01/02 season - after all, he was 35 years old. Nevertheless, he still felt that he had a few years left in the tank and played four more seasons of professional football, taking him into his fifth decade of life. Having signed for Premier League strugglers Derby County in January 2001, Lee was unable to prevent the side from slipping out of the top-flight, and despite appearing 35 times in the First Division the following campaign, was unable to help them achieve promotion. A switch to Upton Park was tied up at the end of the 02/03 season, but with West Ham harbouring serious ambitions of achieving promotion to the Premier League, the 37 year old Lee found it hard to establish himself in the side and appeared just 16 times before signing for League Two side Wycombe Wanderers at the end of the season. To his credit, the veteran played 42 times in two seasons for the Chairboys before finally hanging up his boots at the end of the season.

4. Faustino Asprilla

The 90€™s answer to Mario Balotelli, aside from the playful antics, Tino Asprilla will forever be remembered on Tyneside for his match-winning hat-trick against European giants Barcelona during the autumn of 1997. While it has been levelled at the Columbian that his impact at St. James€™ Park has been overstated somewhat considering he never bagged more than four league goals in either of his three seasons, the playful hit-man will always be remembered fondly on Tyneside. If some thought the Columbian was inconsistent at Newcastle, his post-St. James€™ Park was on an entirely different level, as he amassed eight clubs over the next six years. Following a return to Italian side Parma in 1998, where he scored just once, he relocated to South America and struggled to find the back of the net for the likes of Palmeiras, Fluminense, Atlante, Atletico Nacional, Univesidad de Chile and Estudiantes de La Plata. There was a brief moment where Asprilla came to the fore in the eye of the English media once more, with the Columbian paraded in front of the Division Three side Darlington€™s supporters in 2002. However, much to the club€™s annoyance, Asprilla backed out of the deal at the last minute, leaving chairman George Reynolds €˜absolutely gutted€™. He retired as a washed-up 35 year old in 2004, having never played a game for his new team, Columbian side Cortulua.

3. Laurent Robert

Laurent Robert, fan favourite at St. James€™ Park for half a decade, spent the last three years of his career bouncing between clubs struggling to hold down regular starting spots and desperately clambering for a bit of stability. The French left-winger was known for his impeccable crossing ability, dead-ball skills and jaw-dropping goals during his time at St. James€™ Park but having been kicked out of the club by boss Graeme Souness in 2005, Robert€™s career never truly recovered. Having fallen afoul of the volatile Scot in the wake of Sir Bobby Robson€™s dismissal, Robert€™s stroppy antics weren€™t tolerated for longer than a season and he was sentenced to a season-long loan deal at Portsmouth. It proved to be an unhappy time for the Frenchman on the south-coast, as he scored just one goal in his 17 appearances for the struggling side and stormed out of Sunderland€™s Stadium of Light having been named on the bench. He soon penned a permanent deal at Ronald Koeman€™s Benfica, and played just 13 league games before being shipped off to La Liga strugglers Levante after just one season. A goalless thirteen appearances were churned out for the Spanish outfit during his two seasons at the club, before signing for the worst side in Premier League history in Derby County. Robert played just four times for the pathetically assembled excuse for a top-flight competitor, and spent the remaining two seasons his career at first MLS side Toronoto and then Greek team Larissa.

2. Habib Beye

A cult hero at St. James€™ Park, former Marseille captain Habib Beye was one of Sam Allardyce€™s only positive signings during his ill-fated time at the club. Having been signed for £2 million, the Senegal defender produced a series of impressive performances at right-back for the Tyneside outfit and quickly endeared himself to the Toon faithful. He was even voted the 07/08 Newcastle United Player of the Year by those same supporters, which is why it was all the more disappointing for them when he decided to leave the club in the wake of their relegation from the top-flight in 2009. Despite both Hull City and Newcastle having agreed a fee for the 31 year old, Beye instead signed for Aston Villa and was subsequently sent off in his third game for the club. It didn€™t get any better for the Senegal international during his time at Villa Park and found first-team opportunities hard to come by. After making just nine appearances for the club, he signed on loan for Doncaster Rovers in November 2011 in a desperate bid at salvaging his evaporating career. Following the cancellation of his Villa contract in February 2012, he penned a permanent deal at Doncaster and played 13 more times for the club before announcing his retirement from the game at the age of 34.

1. Kieron Dyer

There is no doubt that Kieron Dyer played the best football of his career at St. James€™ Park. Since being snapped up as a 20 year old starlet from Ipswich Town in the summer of 1999 for a fee of £6 million, Dyer went on to play 250 games for the Magpies during his eight seasons at the club, scoring 36 goals in the process. Injury problems dogged his time at the club, however, and he only played more than 30 league games in two of his seasons. Still, his sparkling performances under Sir Bobby Robson earned international recognition, of which he has 33 England caps to his name. If he thought his injury problems were bad at St. James€™ Park, the 28 year old was about to endure the worst spell of his career when he linked up with West Ham in August 2007 for £6 million, signing a four-year deal. However, within ten days of his debut, he was stretchered off after a tackle from Bristol Rovers defender Joe Jacobsen in a League Cup match that left his right leg broken in two places. The England international subsequently missed the rest of the 07/08 season, with many speculating that the injury-plagued midfielder€™s career might be over at the tender age of 28. On January 2009, Dyer made his long-awaited comeback after 17 months out, although he was struck down by yet more injury curses over the coming months, leading West Ham co-owner David Sullivan to unhelpfully comment that he should follow former Hammer Dean Ashton into retirement. The £83,000 p/wk midfielder was released at the end of the 10/11 season, having made just 34 appearances for the club and never having completed a 90-minute game during his four seasons at Upton Park. Indeed, he actually cost the club around £450,000 per match for every game he played in. He has since taken in unhappy spells with Ipswich Town, QPR and Middlesbrough. He lasted just three minutes in his return to the top-flight for QPR in August 2011 before being stretchered off with an injured foot which ruled him out for the remainder of the season. Story of his post-Toon career. Dyer has completed just one full 90 minute games since 2010 - it€™s no wonder nobody wants to offer the bag of damaged goods another shot. So, that's a wrap - what do you think? As always, feel free to leave your thoughts and opinions in the comment section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Recent Journalism & New Media graduate. Insatiable thirst for all things football, and hopes to break into the field of sports journalism in the near future. Have made a significantly insignificant playing career out of receiving several slaps around the head for not passing the ball.