11 Players Who Stole A Living From Celtic

The biggest wastes of fees and wages in modern Bhoys history.

Not every signing can be as impressive immediately as the likes of Kris Commons, nor go on to make the kind of incredible impact as the Englishman, whose £300,000 fee now looks like one of the steals of the century. Some, who came into Celtic for considerably more than Commons, and with significantly more fanfare in some cases, failed to inspire at all, flopping badly and proving rather unfortunately that far too much money is wasted on mediocre or downright abject "talents". Unfortunately, given the difficulty of competing with the greater financial pulling power of the English leagues, SPL clubs, and particularly the Old Firm have been forced to take some gambles in the transfer market, investing heavily in the hope of making some headway in the Champions League. And gambles in football rarely favour the unprepared, which is why there have been so many players over the years who have clearly robbed the club of a livelihood, hoodwinking everyone into wrongly believing them worthy of many thousands of pounds a week. To celebrate that unlikely band of charlatans, we're looking back at the biggest wastes of money in recent Celtic history.

11. Adam Virgo

Signed From: Brighton & Hove Albion Fee: £1.5 million Having won the Championship Player Of The Year immediately before becoming Gordon Strachan's first signing for Celtic, big things were expected of Adam Virgo. He had been a key figure for Brighton, and as such his £1.5m transfer fee looked a smart bit of business for the Bhoys. Sadly, injuries and a bizarre set of circumstances completely ruined the player's chance of making an impact at the club. The signs weren't good immediately as injury meant he missed the start of his debut season, and after he eventually made his debut (good though not exceptional) he pretty much just faded into obscurity. He was so underused that the next season he was sent out on loan, to first Coventry and then Colchester, before the club just gave up and effectively threw their £1.5m down the toilet by releasing him in 2008. He had made just four starts in 3 years.

Virgo later came out to claim that his failure had not been as simple as it seemed; he was promised a first-term starting position, but was dropped despite being named Man Of The Match on his debut. And then. when the opportunity came up to cover Bobo Balde in the Scottish Cup, Virgo was snubbed in favour of playing Du Wei, the Chinese defender, because of lucrative opportunities with TV in Asia.

The club claim that isn't true and it could merely be sour grapes from an at times unfairly snubbed player.


10. Jiri Jarosik

Signed From: Chelsea Fee: £2 million Despite the fact that Czech international Jarosik had looked badly out of his depth at Chelsea - as well as at Birmingham on loan - in June 2006 Gordon Strachan followed his trend of signing European midfielders by snapping him up for a cool £2m. That might not seen a massive fee in terms of Chelsea, but to Celtic, it was a lot, considering the lack of impact the Czech had at the club over eighteen mostly dour months. A raft of midfield options available to Strachan - including the all too relied upon Evander Sno - meant that competition was fierce for a starting position, and though Jarosik managed 33 appearances for the Bhoys, had he looked remotely interested as a sub, he might have had more. He did make some notable impressions in the Champions League, winning both the free kicks for Shunsuke Nakamura to scor against Man Utd and helping the team through to the last 16, but it was all too little, and further midfield signings pushed him further down the pecking order. He left after an uninspiring period for Russia.

9. Juninho

Signed From: Middlesbrough Fee: Free Celtic fans would have been excited to sign the mercurial Brazilian who had shone at Middlesbrough twice in the late '90s and brought a slice of samba brilliance to the unlikeliest of British towns, even despite the club's relegation during his first spell. But then, the player who signed for Celtic in August 2004 wasn't the same player. Having left Middlesbrough after a third spell, Juninho had clearly decided to give up on his tenacity and skill, and looked a timid, push-over of a midfielder who went from playing with hulking Premier League defenders to being unable to cope with the rigours of the SPL. His legs had obviously gone, which made the decision to play him out wide on the right, instead of his favoured central position all the more baffling when he actually got on the pitch. He might have been free, but in terms of wages, he was still a rip-off.

8. Du Wei

Signed From: Shanghai Shenhua Fee: Loan Though he never actually signed for the club permanently, Chinese international Du Wei cost the club a lot - especially if you believe the role his presence played in Adam Virgo's failure in Scotland. On the face of it Du Wei was a good prospect: he was the former Asian Footballer Of The Year, had played at the 2002 World Cup, captained China to victory at the 2010 East Asian Champsionship and came with a dining endorsement from Diego Maradona:
"Du Wei has the perfect sense of how defending should be played. His speed is unparalleled."
And if you can't trust Diego, who can you trust? Sadly, Du Wei's signing proved unfortunately comical: with accusations of publicity for Asian TV markets coming from more than just Virgo, he made his debut against Clyde in the Scottish Cup and impressed so much he was unceremoniously hauled off at half-time. And that was that, he failed to ever make a full appearance for Celtic and was shipped back to China.

7. Glenn Loovens

Signed From: Cardiff City Fee: £2.5 million Tony Mowbray did a lot of things wrong during his time at Celtic - starting when he said yes to the job offer - but spending £2.5m on Cardiff's Glenn Loovens has to rank pretty highly on his list of misdemeanours. Now, £2.5m is not a massive amount of money if you're investing in a good talent who can have an immediate impact on the first team, and Loovens had proved himself a dependable part of Cardiff's play in the Championship. But when you're investing that in a player who suddenly seems to remember that he's a clumsy, in-elegant and injury-prone waste of time, it looks like a big amount. Over 4 years and more than 90 appearances, Loovens somehow outlasted more talented defenders like Stephen McManus and even Gary Caldwell, despite never really looking the part, and he ultimately left in 2012, without much of a legacy at all.

6. David Fernandez

Signed From: Livingston Fee: £1 million Inevitably, Celtic have a mixed history of picking up the best talent from lesser teams in the SPL. Occasionally other clubs' fans will suggest skulduggery; that the club are doing more than weakening their potential opponents to preserve their status in the league, and sometimes you have to think there might be something in those claims. Spanish star David Fernandez had initially come to Scotland to play for Steve Archibald's Airdrie, but then moved to Livingston when he failed to buy the club and the foreign players all left. He became their star man, almost effortlessly, and helped fire the team to third in the league, catching the attention of Martin O'Neill. Despite paying a million for him, O'Neill restricted Fernandez, who could have stayed at Livingston and become a legend, to just 11 league starts in 3 years, including a year long stint back at Livi, where his style was far more suited.

5. Massimo Donati

Signed From: AC Milan Fee: £3m It's not often a player of the calibre usually associated with AC Milan will be convinced to swap the bright lights and glitter of the Italian league to come to Scotland, but that's precisely what happened as the 26-year-old Italian was brought in as Neil Lennon's replacement in June 2007. His start wasn't bad, but as that first season drew onwards, Donati badly lost form and was dropped in favour of Barry Robson, amidst rumours that he wanted to high-tail it back to Italy. The next year he made only a handful of appearances, but he saw his stock rise with the appointment of Tony Mowbray who clearly fancied him a bit more as a player. He played all of the pre-season, impressively so, and had started to show some form at the start of the season, which is precisely when Celtic decided to cash in their chips on him and sell him to Bari, after only 13 performances in his last 18 months at the club.

4. Mo Bangura

Signed From: AIK Fee: £2.2 million Like Adam Virgo, Bangura's case might have been a lot different if he hadn't been so susceptible to injury, but sadly, the player never lived up to his high billing - having been apparently recommended by Henrik Larsson - and crashed and burned at Celtic. The Sierra Leone international actually came into Celtic on the crest of a wave of excitement, having caught the attention of bigger clubs when he scored 12 goals in 13 games for IFK Värnamo, before moving to AIk where he scored 13 goals in 33 games. But rumours persisted about his injury record, which Celtic should perhaps have heeded, as Bangura went on to make only 16 appearances, scoring precisely zero goals despite a monumental ego and missing a hateful of easy chances along the way. He will mostly be remembered for his distasteful confession that he saw Celtic only as a stepping stone to a bigger move after a year, which so far has gone so well that he was released in January, and is currently playing for Turkish second-tier side Istanbul BB, in the same league as Shola Ameobi.

3. Thomas Gravesen

Signed From: Real Madrid Fee: £2 million Like Massimo Donati's move from AC Milan, the bald Dane's move from Real Madrid - a move which in itself was baffling for most of the football community - was cause for excitement. Even ignoring the fact that he was comically unsuited to the Galactico label, he had been a great player for Everton, and he would surely make a great addition to Celtic's squad. Sadly, Gravesen left something in Spain when he signed for Celtic in August 2006 for £2m. He looked a shadow of the player who had bossed the midfield for Everton, and went horribly missing in way too many games, aside from scoring in an Old Firm game and a hat-trick against St Mirren. Unfortunately, accusations of a bad attitude further blighted his time in Scotland, as Gravesen was kicked out of the first team in favour of Evander Sno and was then publicly criticised by Gordon Strachan for not trying harder to get his place back. Perhaps it was because of his bumper salary...

2. Morten Rasmussen

Signed From: Brondby Fee: £1.8 million Like Mo Bangura, Morten Rasmussen had attracted the interest of Celtic thanks to an impressive goal-scoring record in Scandinavia, though this time it was in his native Denmark. During spells as AGF and then Brondby, Rasmussen had scored 72 goals in 187 games, including an impressive run of 12 goals in 15 games at the start of the 2010 season. That January, Tony Mowbray decided to waste a bit more of Celtic's money, by paying close to £2m for the Dane, who expressed himself delighted at the big opportunity. Unfortunately for Celtic, Rasmussen had taken the nickname Duncan in Denmark due to an apparent resemblance to Duncan Ferguson, but dropped it when he came to Celtic. Despite having been impressed by his Brondby scoring rate, Mowbray quickly changed his mind, benching Rasmussen before Neil Lennon decided he also wasn't good enough and sent him out on loan before releasing him. Another couple of millions well spent.

1. Rafael Scheidt

Signed From: Gremio Fee: £5 million!! When your name sounds so much like a rude word you probably have to work extra hard as a footballer: just ask Danny Shittu, or Rod Fanni. Sadly Rafael Scheidt clearly didn't get that memo. Signed for a massive £5m by the ill-conceived management "dream team" of John Barnes and Kenny Dalglish, the player found himself playing for a new manager almost immediately, and failed to justify even a tiny slither of his transfer fee. He was plagued by injury in a first season that saw him start just one game, and he was sent out on loan to Corinthians for two years by Martin O'Neill who comically apparently told the player that "I like footballers who are not like you... I like footballers who play well." Though he expressed his desire to be a success in Scotland after his second loan spell at Corinthians, he no longer met work permit requirements, and Celtic were forced to pay off his contract and let him go. For good reason, the Guardian named him as the second worst transfer in football history in 2001. Which other rejects and flops deserve to be on this list? Share your own picks below.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.