11 Transfers That Prove English Players Are Hideously Overpriced
No wonder Premier League clubs are looking more overseas for talent.
Peter Byrne/PA Archive/Press Association ImagesThe recent transfers of Luke Shaw (£30 million from Southampton to Manchester United) and Adam Lallana (£25 million from Southampton to Liverpool) were a frightening reflection of how much money gets thrown around in football these days - and how nonchalantly clubs do it. It came as no surprise when those deals were completed and those fees were confirmed - especially not given the fact that the players in question are both English. What exactly is it about English players that make them so expensive? This is a country whose national side are perennial underachievers - they were knocked out of the current World Cup in the group stage, having scored a meagre two goals in three games, having amassed a single point from three games and having finished rock bottom of their group. England are becoming renowned for dismal showings. Now, the top domestic league in England - the Premier League - is a decent league, but it's certainly no longer the best in the world. La Liga in Spain boasts players like Cristiano Ronaldo, Lionel Messi, Gareth Bale and Andres Iniesta and teams like Barcelona, Real Madrid and even Atletico Madrid are leaving the Premier League behind in terms of quality. In fact, most of the reasons that the Premier League is considered a top league are foreign players like Luis Suarez, Yaya Toure and Eden Hazard, and the simple, head-turning issue of money. Simply put, England have no world class players, and yet even fringe international players are selling for ludicrous amounts of money and, after seeing two of those players sell for a combined £55 million in the last couple of weeks, now could be a good time to look back at eleven transfers that prove English players are hideously overpriced. On that note, here we go...
11. Nedum Onuoha To Queens Park Rangers (£80,000 per week)
Daniel Hambury/EMPICS SportLet's start off, rather than focusing on a transfer fee, with a player whose utterly insane wages (given his level of talent) set tongues wagging in January 2012. Queens Park Rangers signed Nedum Onuoha from Manchester City for an undisclosed fee that was believed to be in the region of £3 million - not an unreasonable sum for any Premier League squad player in this day and age - but the wages of £80,000 that he was offered were absolutely unbelievable. At the time, Onuoha was 25 years old and hadn't fully established himself as a Premier League first-team player. He only made 72 league starts in eight years at Manchester City and a season-long loan at Sunderland did not turn him in to an £80,000 a week player. Bearing in mind Onuoha was - and still is - uncapped, that kind of weekly wage is crazy.
10. Andrew Johnson To Everton (£8.5 Million)
Joe Giddens/EMPICS SportAndrew Johnson represents a number of problems with English players - the main ones being the over-inflated prices, the misconception that one good season makes you a star and the deceptive nature of some statistics. In 2006 he joined Everton for £8.5 million, having played a single season in the Premier League with Crystal Palace and remained with them for a further season in the Championship following their relegation. His season in the top flight with Crystal Palace was a relatively successful one on a personal level - he scored 21 Premier League goals, but it was a deceptive statistic. Eight of those goals came from the penalty spot and, while thirteen goals from open play is decent, one season with that figure doesn't confirm your status as a top Premier League striker (or an international one, but he still got eight caps - without scoring, incidentally, which kind of proves the point). After that season - and having spent a season in the Championship, where he scored fifteen goals (hardly world class, especially given the length of the Championship season) - Everton coughed up the aforementioned £8.5 million and, moreover, Fulham went on to pay £10.5 million for his services in 2008. At least, by that point, he'd spent more than one season in the Premier League, however, but Johnson has never been anything more than a good Championship level striker.
9. Francis Jeffers To Arsenal (£10 Million)
Tony Marshall/EMPICS SportThese days, £10 million for a Premier League striker is arguably below the going rate - even for average players - but bearing in mind this was in 2001, that Francis Jeffers was only 20 at the time, and particularly bearing in mind the path his career has taken since then, £10 million was extortionate. Arsene Wenger made the Everton youngster one of Arsenal's most expensive signings at that time, after he had only started 37 Premier League games for the Goodison Park club. Granted, he had a decent scoring record, but an eight figure sum for a 20 year old striker in 2001 was crazy. His potential was never fulfilled - he did make his England debut in 2003, scoring against Australia, but never played for his country again - and his career went downhill in emphatic fashion. He went back on loan to Everton, but failed to find the net once, and was sold to Charlton for a mere £2.6 million in 2004. He has since gone on to play for the likes of Newcastle Jets in Australia, Floriana in Malta and Accrington Stanley back in England - all of which he performed poorly for.
8. Ashley Young To Manchester United (£17 Million)
Dave Thompson/PA Wire/Press Association ImagesThe epitome of an overrated winger, Ashley Young cost Manchester United £17 million when he joined the Old Trafford club from Aston Villa in 2011. Young had performed very well at Villa Park - there's no denying that. He regularly racked up impressive assist tallies, scored a decent amount of goals for a winger and made it in to the Premier League Team of the Year on two occasions (2007/08 and 2008/09). However, given that he was a month away from being 26 when United signed him, it seemed as though much of his ability stemmed from his speed as a youngster and, with that starting to wane, the high fee was too much and would never be returned from a future sale. Young simply hasn't performed for Manchester United and cheating/diving seems to be a big part of his game. He lacks the true quality and technique of a footballer who demands a £17 million fee and his international showings epitomise that. He was part of England's 2014 World Cup preliminary squad, but didn't make the final cut - and rightly so. And, let's be honest - if you play for Manchester United and are English, but still can't get in to the England squad, you're not as good as you think you are (see the inclusion of Jones, Smalling and Welbeck for comparison).
7. Glen Johnson To Liverpool (£17.5 Million)
Media Image LtdGlen Johnson isn't a bad player per se, but £17.5 million for a right back who can't defend epitomises why English players are so overpriced. Moreover, it's reported that he was handed a £139,000 a week wage to ward off interest from his former club Chelsea when Liverpool splashed out to sign him from Portsmouth. Johnson has been England's first choice right back since 2010, having made his debut in 2003 and having previously been understudy to the likes of the legendary Gary Neville and even Luke Young, and he has since amassed 54 caps, scoring one goal. It's hard to say whether he would have been first choice in the current World Cup had Kyle Walker been fit, but Walker was injured and that made Johnson an automatic choice - his mediocre performances epitomised England's and epitomised why his price is reflective of the inflated nature of English players.
6. Stewart Downing To Liverpool (£20 Million)
Media Image LtdDowning is another of those annoying players who flattered to deceive for a relatively short amount of time, before being sussed out and hardly having any impact. As a young, keen left winger, Downing stood out at Middlesbrough - but, then again, any naturally left-footed players in this county immediately stand out due to the fact that there is a distinct lack of them - and, as such, he was soon called up to the England team as the answer to our long-standing left wing prayers. Or so we thought. Downing's impact at international level was a return of zero goals in 34 appearances and a string of extremely average performances, but that didn't put Aston Villa off paying £12 million for his services and, even more bafflingly, Liverpool paying £20 million for them two years later. He had the remarkable feats at Anfield of being the first player in seven years to miss three penalty kicks in a row and going a full season with no goals and no assists. The Middlesbrough-born man - who now plays at West Ham United - is only 29, but his last game for England came more than two years ago in May 2012. He is the prime example of someone who peaked, was hyped, then spiralled in to insignificance - and a typical English waste of money to boot.
5. Jordan Henderson To Liverpool (£20 Million)
Nick Potts/PA Archive/Press Association ImagesCurrent England starter Jordan Henderson signed for Liverpool in 2011, just a few days shy of his 21st birthday, for a massive £20 million fee. The move came a few months after another extortionate Anfield purchase (which we'll get to later) and just a month prior to the aforementioned Stewart Downing deal, as Liverpool splashed out no less than £75 million in six months for a trio of underwhelming and incredibly overpriced Englishmen. Henderson joined from Sunderland - his home town club and the club he had been with since he was a trainee - having made sixty league starts for the Black Cats and having made his England debut in the November of the previous year. He epitomises the terms "steady" and "underwhelming" and, while he doesn't make horrific mistakes very often, his contribution to any given match is not worth the sum paid out for him - and his running technique and general speed is questionable to say the least. His anonymous performances for England in the current World Cup were quite typical of the player.
4. Shaun Wright-Phillips To Chelsea (£21 Million)
Mike Egerton/EMPICS SportThe route Shaun Wright-Phillips' transfer history took is the archetype for overpriced and over-hyped English players. After impressing at Manchester City, he caught the attention of Jose Mourinho's Chelsea and, with the relatively new status as football's rich team, they were able to fork out £21 million of Roman Abramovich's money to take the pacey England winger to Stamford Bridge. His time at Chelsea was relatively uninspiring. In 2005-06, he won a Premier League title medal, despite only making fifteen starts for the club, and he was generally in and out of the team and, as such, he ended up returning to Manchester City in 2008 - when he was still only 26 years old - for a fee of only £8.5 million. This was a loss of £12.5 million on a man who was still in his peak years and only three years after being sold for the fee of £21 million - stark proof that it was a huge over-valuing of the player (really, his pace was all he ever had going for him). Three years later in 2011, he joined Queens Park Rangers, where he remains to this day, having spent last season playing in the Championship.
3. Joleon Lescott To Manchester City (£22 Million)
Lynne Cameron/EMPICS SportJoleon Lescott is a solid defender who was already a full England international when his move to Manchester City came about it 2009 but, given that he had moved to Everton just three years earlier as a 23 year old for £5 million (with only £2 million being paid up front), the increase to £22 million for a 27 year old Lescott just over three years later seemed absolutely crazy - not least because of the fact that central defenders costing that much in any instance is pretty insane (and don't Paris St. Germain know it after paying £50 million for David Luiz, given his showing against Germany in the World Cup...). Lescott has never been anything overly special. At 31 years old and with 26 England caps to his name, it's clear to see he was never an automatic first choice for his country. £22 million defenders need to be world class to justify that kind of fee and Lescott simply isn't. His best trait was his ability to score more goals than the average centre back, but he was by no means prolific and goalscoring is hardly the first trait you want your defenders to have or to be thinking about. But, then again, Manchester City do have more money than sense, as this next entry proves...
2. James Milner To Manchester City (£26 Million Part Exchange)
Manu Fernandez/AP/Press Association ImagesIf ever there was a ludicrous amount of money paid for someone who is essentially a utility man and a workhorse, this is it. Milner is mainly a midfielder, but he can operate all over the pitch - in very average fashion all over it, incidentally - and Manchester City paid Aston Villa the princely sum of £26 million for him in 2010, with around £6-8 million of that believed to be represented by the inclusion of Stephen Ireland in the deal. Don't get us wrong, Milner has his moments - his goal against reigning European champions Bayern Munich at the Allianz Arena in the 2013/14 UEFA Champions League was not only brilliant, it also proved to be the winner - but most of the time he looks like a confused wild animal and he is prone to misplaced passes and clumsy errors. He finds himself, typically, in almost every England squad - another sign that the national team is in decline - but he has lost his place at Manchester City and is expected to move on. God knows how much the team from the Etihad Stadium will want for the 28 year old, but we're damn sure they'll get nowhere near what they paid for him.
1. Andy Carroll To Liverpool (£35 Million)
Lynne Cameron/PA Archive/Press Association ImagesThe absolute pinnacle of overpriced English players - and someone we touched on earlier without actually mentioning his name - is Andy Carroll. In 2011, after the Gateshead-born striker had only scored 34 professional goals - 19 of which came in Newcastle's season in the Championship and one of which came in a loan spell at Preston North End - Liverpool saw fit to smash their transfer record by shelling out £35 million for the striker. And if the next fact doesn't emphasise just how overpriced Carroll is - and indeed all English players are - then nothing will... Carroll arrived at Liverpool only a few hours after Luis Suarez and the Uruguayan cost £12.3 million less than he did (£22.7 million). To top it off and make matters worse, Carroll's time at Anfield was hugely unsuccessful. He scored six Premier League goals in 44 appearances (18 of which came from the bench) and only managed five goals in cup competitions. In total, he scored 11 goals for the club in 58 competitive appearances - that's less than a goal every five games and just over £3 million per goal. Absolutely outrageous. He went on loan to West Ham and then the Hammers signed him permanently for less than half of what Liverpool paid (£15 million). Since joining, initially on the aforementioned loan spell, he has played 40 league games for the club, scoring just nine times. He's hardly been great at international level either - his two goals in nine games for his country don't exactly make for impressive reading. It really makes you wonder - in a world where Luke Shaw's "potential" sees him valued at £30 million, how much would Duncan Edwards be worth in this day and age? More to the point, with Joleon Lescott going for £22 million, Bobby Moore would be priceless. And £35 million for Andy Carroll would mean Gary Lineker and Alan Shearer would be completely unaffordable. Of course, the likes of Wayne Rooney and Rio Ferdinand have fetched transfer fees as high as £27 million and £30 million respectively, but at least their performances for Manchester United over the years went some way to paying those fees back. So there you have it - eleven transfers that prove English players are hideously overpriced. Did you like this list? Do you agree? Which other English players have been hideously overpriced (there have been plenty, so don't be shy)? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below. And please feel free to follow me on Twitter!