14 Biggest Premier League Transfer Mistakes Of Summer So Far

Premier League clubs have sanctioned some highly dubious deals this summer...

The summer transfer window is in full swing as we enter the final month before September 1st's deadline with Premier League clubs being more active than ever before. In the first two months of the window alone an astonishing £360 million was splashed out by England's top tier teams - up £60 million from the year before, according to Deloitte's Sports Business Group. That means that we could see spending surpass the record of £630 million set last year by the time we reach the transfer cut-off point at the end of the month as clubs put their money where their mouths are in a bid to secure title glory or simply survive dreaded relegation come next May. Chelsea and Liverpool have been the window's biggest spenders so far with the Blues splashing out a combined £62 million on Cesc Fabregas and Diego Costa, while the Reds this week unveiled their seventh signing of the summer in the form of defender Javier Manquillo. Manchester United aren't too far behind having splurged on Luke Shaw and Ander Herrera, of Southampton and Athletic Bilbao, respectively. But just how successful have English clubs been in the market? Already we've seen a few dubious deals - be it due to a perceived inflation in transfer fee or a move that leaves a club notably light in a key area. Here, we take a look at the 14 Biggest Premier League Transfer Mistakes of the Summer So Far. Click 'next' to get started.

14. David Luiz - Chelsea To PSG

Chelsea laughed themselves all the way to the bank earlier this summer after selling Brazilian hot-head David Luiz to Paris Saint-Germain in a deal that could climb to £50 million. That's a world transfer record for a defender and PSG fans must have been crying themselves to sleep after watching their new signing in action at the World Cup. Luiz was absolutely all over the place at the back as Brazil were slaughtered 7-1 by Germany and unceremoniously booted out of the World Cup they were hosting, leaving a nation, and Luiz, in floods of tears. The Brazilian is prone to abandoning his defensive duties in favour of bombing forward in attack and though this reaps goals it leaves his team looking highly susceptible - one of the reasons why Chelsea got rid. PSG paid far, far too much for Luiz this summer - especially given the fact they are currently under investigation from Uefa for breeching Financial Fair Play Rules - and they could be left to count the cost of their profligacy in the transfer window this season.

13. Tom Ince - Blackpool To Hull City

Tom Ince's agent must have had some interesting phone calls this summer. The Blackpool winger was in demand following a highly-impressive couple of seasons in the Championship, where he scored seven league goals in 2013-14 and 18 in the campaign prior, to earn himself a place in the PFA Championship Team of the Year for 2012€“13. Former club Liverpool were keen on taking him back - four years after he began his career as an Anfield academy star - while a number of other Premier League clubs were also interested, including Everton and West Brom. Ince could have had his pick of suitors when his contract at Bloomfield Road expired earlier this summer, and Italian giants Inter Milan even came calling. Most players would jump at the chance of playing for the Italian giants but not Ince, who preferred he'd much rather ply his trade for Hull City instead. This bonkers decision has got to put the midfielder right up there on any list of transfer mistakes and he definitely makes ours. Surely the option of playing European football has to win out over the offer of muddling through relegation battles... Apparently not.

12. Thomas Vermaelen - Arsenal To Barcelona

Thomas Vermaelen was touted as one of Manchester United's main transfer targets this summer but left Red Devils fans disappointed this week when he instead opted for a move to Barcelona. On the face of it, you might not consider this a bad move at all - after all, Barca are one of Europe's most successful club teams any play in front of record crowds every week. However, he would surely have been better off moving to Old Trafford. At United, the Belgian centre-back would have walked straight into a team crying out for defensive reinforcements following the departures of Rio Ferdinand and captain Nemanja Vidic. Instead, he is going to the Nou Camp where there are no guarantees of first-team football. The Catalan club have just signed Jeremy Mathieu, who appears first choice for the left-sided centre-back role, while Vermaelen will also have to compete with the likes of Javier Mascherano and Marc Bartra for the right to play at the heart of Barca's defence. The defender spend a lot of time warming Arsenal's bench last season and could find himself playing a similar role in 2014-15.

11. Morgan Schneiderlin - Southampton To Spurs (Rejected)

Southampton have sold a series of stars this summer with the likes of Luke Shaw, Adam Lallana, Calum Chambers and Rickie Lambert all leaving the south coast side. However, one player who will be staying put is Morgan Schneiderlin. The midfielder has been linked with a move to Spurs in recent weeks but his club have insisted he is not for sale. This prompted an outburst from the player on Twitter with the irate Frenchman raging: "6 years of an amazing journey #saintsfc DESTROYED in 1 hour !!!" Southampton warned Schneiderlin of his conduct and last week reiterated that he would stay put at St Mary's - whether he liked it or not. Southampton's determination to keep hold of the want-away star could backfire with Schneiderlin effectively going on strike this week by claiming he is "not mentally or physically ready" to play. One bad apple could spoil the proverbial bunch and such an obvious showing of dissent could sink morale at the Saints. To roll out another cliché, no one player is bigger than the club, and perhaps Southampton would be better off selling Schneiderlin before things get any more out of hand.

10. Patrice Evra - Man Utd To Juventus

Manchester United handed veteran defender Patrice Evra a new, one year contract back in May but the Frenchman shockingly left the club earlier this summer to join Juventus. The move sparked a complete turn-around with Evra previously happy to stay at Old Trafford for another 12 months prior to the Italian's interest. Having already sold Alexander Buttner to Dynamo Moscow, sanctioning Evra's sale as well could be a bad move from United. They now have only one recognised left-back at the club in teenager Luke Shaw, who at 19 is still a bit green. Shaw could have benefited from learning under Evra during his debut season at the Theatre of Dreams but the departure of the veteran defender has now heaped pressure on the youngster's shoulders to hit the ground running. New Red Devils manager Louis van Gaal has a distinct lack of defensive options now that Evra has gone and should Shaw sustain injury or get suspended at any point in the season the Dutchman will struggle to find cover on the left hand side of his defence. It's a perplexing decision and unless United sign cover for Shaw they could be in real trouble.

9. Luke Shaw - Southampton To Man Utd

You could argue that Manchester United have made yet another mistake in this summer's transfer window following the big-money signing of Southampton starlet Luke Shaw. At £27 million Shaw becomes the world's fourth-most expensive defender in history and eyebrows have been raised over the size of the fee and the player's reported wage demands, while there are concerns United have paid over the odds. Shaw is on wages of around £130,000-a-week and Chelsea manager Jose Mourinho recently said that signing the defender "would have killed his club". The Blues were also interested in the fullback - a Chelsea fan - but the size of the fee along with Shaw's wages put them off. Mourinho said:
€œIf we pay to a 19-year-old boy what we were being asked for, to sign Luke Shaw, we are dead. We would have killed our stability with financial fair play and killed the stability in our dressing room. Because when you pay that much to a 19-year-old kid €“ a good player, fantastic player €“ but when you pay that amount of money, the next day, we would have had players knocking on our door."
There are concerns the size of the fee will put undue pressure on Shaw to be a success at the club while there are also suggestions his purchase could lead to dressing room disharmony at Old Trafford with more senior players now looking for a wage increase themselves. Mourinho continued:
€œThey would have been saying, €˜How is it possible I play 200 games for this club, won this and that, yet a 19-year-old comes here and gets more money than I get?€™"

8. Rickie Lambert - Southampton To Liverpool

Rickie Lambert is not a good fit at Liverpool and will spend the majority of the season on the bench at Liverpool - according to former Queens Park Rangers and Manchester City forward Rodney Marsh at least. Marsh this week questioned the wisdom behind Lambert's purchase this summer and believes the striker is destined for failure at Anfield. And he might have a point. At 32 and in the winter of his career, Lambert's signing was a strange one. The former Southampton player doesn't have a great deal left in the tank and will probably have gotten more first team opportunities this season had he stayed on the south coast. With Liverpool boasting Daniel Sturridge, and also in the market for a big-money replacement for Luis Suarez, you can only really see Lambert playing second fiddle on Merseyside. The England international will probably be a bit-part player at Liverpool in 2014-15 and while the move represents something of a swansong before retirement - he is a boyhood Reds fan - he may well come to regret it when he looks back on his career.

7. Bacary Sagna - Arsenal To Man City

Bacary Sagna became the latest in a long line of players to jump the good ship Arsenal for Manchester City by moving to Etihad Stadium on a free transfer following the end of his contract with the Gunners. Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger pleaded with him to stay and even offered the 31-year-old a new, three-year deal. Instead Sagna became the fifth Arsenal player to make the switch to City in recent years following the likes of Emmanuel Adebayor, Kolo Toure, Gael Clichy and Samir Nasri. And Wenger recently questioned the defender's decision to leave the club where he made his name. The Frenchman said:
"What is tiring is to lose players to City or ­somebody else. You will have to ask Sagna why he chose City. I made him a proposal to stay for three years, but he chose them. Had he chosen a long time ago? Maybe €“ it looks to me like he agreed it a long time before. It is disappointing because he came here as an unknown and he became a French ­international. But I also respect Sagna because, until the last day of his contract with us, he was super-professional."
Indeed, Sagna's decision to leave Emirates Stadium looks a strange one. At Arsenal he could have continued as the club's undisputed right-back while at City he will have to compete with Pablo Zabaleta, and the Argentine has made right-back his own at the Etihad recently, meaning the ex-Gunner will likely have to settle for substitute appearances in 2014-15. You also have to wonder why City felt they needed him in the first place.

6. Hatem Ben Arfa - Newcastle Utd To ?

Hatem Ben Arfa looks as though he is on his way out of Newcastle this summer after manager Alan Pardew stripped him of the No.10 shirt and consigned him to the humiliation of playing with the reserves for an alleged lack of professionalism. Ben Arfa has fallen out of favour under Pardew and will likely never play for the St James' Park outfit ever again. Which is ridiculous considering the winger is a quality player. The Frenchman is a player capable of moments of magic and has scored some wonderful goals in the past, like the one against Bolton two years ago. He is also one of the Magpies' most skilful players and finished as the club's fourth-highest goalscorer in the Premier League last season. According to Who Scored, Ben Arfa has also averaged more successful dribbles per game (3.2) than any other player in the last two Premier League seasons and he gives Pardew options that no other player currently provides. Yet he is being forced out of the club and will probably be sold this summer, with a move to French side Lyon on the cards. It's disappointing, and another sorry chapter in the controversial Mike Ashley era, with Newcastle being made to look more and more like a laughing stock.

5. Loic Remy - QPR To Liverpool (Pulled Out)

Liverpool are in the market for a new goalscorer this summer following the £75 million sale of Luis Suarez to Barcelona and it looked as though they had signed one at the end of July. The Reds agreed an £8.5 million fee with Queens Park Rangers for Loic Remy and his move to Anfield appeared to be set in stone. Remy travelled to Boston to meet up with his future new teammates on their pre-season tour of the United States and underwent a medical. It was surely only a matter of formalities before he was snapped holding aloft the famous Red jersey alongside manager Brendan Rodgers. However, Liverpool incredibly pulled out of the deal, claiming the player had failed his medical. The football world reacted in bewilderment in the wake of the news, after all, Remy had just scored 14 Premier League goals while on loan at Newcastle and looked as fit as a flea. Even QPR manager Harry Redknapp questioned the claims, saying: €œReports have come out that he failed a medical. That€™s not possible. He is a very fit lad, there has to be another reason.€ Redknapp's claims only added to the mystery of the failed medical and if Liverpool did turn the striker down for some other reason, it's folly. They still haven't replaced Suarez following his departure to Spain and need to sign a top-class forward in the three weeks remaining of the transfer window or else face the prospect of missing out on another top four finish in 2014-15.

4. Michu - Swansea To Napoli (Loan)

In one of this summer's most surprising transfers, Swansea City decided to loan out Michu to Napoli. The move is perplexing for a number of reasons, the obvious one being that just a season ago the Spaniard was named the Welsh club's Player of the Year, as well as the supporters Player of the Year after scoring 18 Premier League goals. His loan is also mad because the Swans are scarcely blessed with an embarrassment of attacking options at the moment, with Wilfried Bony and new signing Bafetimbi Gomis the club's only remaining senior strikers. Rookie Rory Donnelly has been loaned to Coventry City while Marvin Emnes didn't play a single league game last season. There are also fears Bony could leave, with the Ivory Coast international being linked with moves to either Liverpool or Spurs, and that would make the loaning of Michu look even more bizarre, even if the forward did suffer a disappointing and injury-stricken second season at Liberty Stadium in 2013-14.

3. Michel Vorm - Swansea To Spurs

Another bizarre transfer involving Swansea City this summer was the sale of Michel Vorm to Spurs. The Swans decided they no longer needed the Netherlands goalkeeper having signed ukasz Fabia„ski from Arsenal despite Vorm making 26 Premier League appearances last season as their No.1. Vorm moved to White Hart Lane alongside Swans teammate Ben Davies on 23 July with Tottenham's Gylfi Sigurdsson moving the other way but you have to wonder why the Lilywhites felt they needed another goalkeeper. Manager Mauricio Pochettino already has Brad Friedel as cover for No.1 Hugo Lloris and Vorm will almost certainly be third choice this season. Had he continued at Swansea he might have been able to continue vying for the No.1 spot despite the arrival of Fabianski and his decision to join Spurs will surely prove a mistake, with a season of playing as a squad member now beckoning the Holland keeper.

2. Frank Lampard - Chelsea To New York City To Man City (Loan)

Frank Lampard's move from Chelsea to New York City FC looked pretty inconspicuous. The England midfielder had left the Blues at the end of his contract and was seemingly set to follow in the footsteps of former England teammate David Beckham in jaunting off to the United States to play out what remained of his career. Yet the transfer took a dramatic twist at the beginning of August when it was revealed the legendary midfielder had been loaned out by the MLS club to Manchester City until the New Year during the USA's off-season. New York City are jointly owned by the Citizens, who have registered Lampard to play in this season's Premier and Champions League. The move could very easily turn out to be a mistake for Lampard, who risks alienating himself from Chelsea fans - some of whom have accused him of betrayal and have promised to burn shirts with his name on. Until now, Lampard was an undisputed Chelsea hero having made 648 appearances for the Blues, overtaking Bobby Tambling's all-time goalscoring record in the process by netting 211 times. However, that legacy is now in question following the transfer to one of his former side's biggest rivals.

1. Romelu Lukaku - Chelsea To Everton

Chelsea's decision to sell Romelu Lukaku to Everton could go down as one of this summer's biggest transfer mistakes, however. The Blues accepted a £28 million bid from the Toffees at the end of July, bringing to an end the striker's three-season stay at Stamford Bridge. That stay was punctuated with loan moves to West Brom and Everton, and though Lukaku wasn't handed the opportunities to impress in west London, he did excel during each of his temporary spells away from the club, scoring 17 and then 15 goals for Albion and the Toffees in 2012-13 and 2013-14, respectively. And that makes Chelsea's decision to sell look like a mistake. Especially as they are currently struggling in the striker department. Demba Ba has left and joined Besitkas, Samuel Eto'o was released at the end of his contract and Fernando Torres continues to flounder. Torres endured the biggest goal-drought since the beginning of his career last season, netting a paltry five goals, yet the Blues continue to insist on standing by him while moving prolific players such as Lukaku on. Had Chelsea not lavished £50 million on Torres to make him a British transfer record in 2011, owner Roman Abramovich would surely have washed his hands of the misfiring star years ago, but is continuing to stubbornly refuse to accept he made a mistake in signing him from Liverpool. Meanwhile, Lukaku will probably go on to outscore the Spaniard yet again this season - but at one of Chelsea's top four rivals rather than at Stamford Bridge. Madness. What do you think are the biggest Premier League transfer mistakes of the summer so far? Share yours in the comments thread, below.

Contributor
Contributor

Joseph is an accredited football journalist and has interviewed nearly all of the current 20 Barclay's Premier League managers. He is also a correspondent for Bleacher Report and has written for Caught Offside and Give Me Football.