To be chosen as the captain is a unique honour and privilege for a player with it being an indicator of their status as the emblematic leader of a football club. But the connotations of wearing the armband for Newcastle United can sometimes make the role a daunting challenge to its newest incumbent. Many who've held the club-captaincy at St James' Park have embraced the heavy prestige that comes with commanding the Toon vessel on the pitch and have flourished as a result. With the armband proudly wrapped around their bicep they are the nuanced leaders who came fully understand the expectations of being our captain and are revered as a supreme motivator. But we've also had to tolerate a plethora of cowardly captains who were, fundamentally, not good enough to even pull on a black and white shirt never mind wear the armband that we worship with unrelenting passion. Others have been weighed down by the pressure of the position in his hotbed of football. The less said about them, the better in our book. Thus we've put together the five BEST and WORST captains ever to pull on the armband for Newcastle.
5 Best...
5. Kevin Nolan
Although, officially, Nicky Butt was Newcastle's club captain and Alan Smith his deputy, Nolan regularly wore the armband in their absence - which was effectively the entire campaign - during our one-season stopover in the Championship. Nolan, old fashioned in his approach to the morals of being a captain, was the inspiration behind our immediate return to the Premier League and a vocally influential player behind the scenes. Never more so than in the aftermath of relegation when he stepped in to help Chris Hughton bring stability to a dressing room gripped by strife and off the field distractions. It was this action that provided the stimulus for our resurgent march back into the top-flight. Weighing in with 18 goals from 48 appearances in all competitions, including a brilliant volley against Sheffield United that sealed our promotion, the Liverpudlian was named the Championship's Player of the Year and assumed the club captaincy on a full-time basis following Butt's retirement. The subsequent campaign would be a memorable one for Nolan with his unnerving ability to time is runs into the penalty area seeing him score 12 times from midfield and etch his name into Geordie folklore with a stunning Tyne-Wear derby hat-trick in our 5-1 demolition of Sunderland at St James' Park. Little did we know it would be his last in a black and white shirt. I love everything about the football club and the city," he said in February 2011 just a few months before he was forcibly sold to West Ham after failing to agree terms on a new contract with Mike Ashley. It's fair to say we're a poorer side without Nolan's leadership.
4. Brian Kilcline
Considered by Kevin Keegan to be his most important signing as Newcastle manager, "Killer" Kilcline was immediately installed as club captain after heeding a desperate call from Keegan to toughen up a fragile reagured and spearhead our fight for survival in Division Two. The grizzled centre-back, his look complimented by a untamed caveman beard sprouting from his granite jaw, was a menacing spectre to any and every striker that dared to cross his path with opponents regularly browbeaten into complete submission by Kilcline. For a team requiring an motivational catalyst to save its skin and pull itself away from the foot of the table he was the ideal candidate. Kilcline's experience and no-nonsense approach was vital in leading a cash-strapped team full of kids to a lazurus-like feat of escapology in 1991/92 and he's still revered to this day by Toon fans who regard him as one the players who saved the Club from relegation and probable financial ruin.
3. Alan Shearer
A genuine leader of men and the archetypal Geordie captain, Shearer was a warrior who led from the front in black and white, wearing the armband predominantly during Sir Bobby Robson's five-year reign and skippering us through an unforgettable Champions League campaign. Shearer's playing style was often characterised as that of a classic English centre-forward and he was a captain we could so often rely on when to situation required him dig us out of a very deep hole. When in peril we'd always dial the number nine. 206 goals only tells half the story of his impact for Newcastle during his six years as our commander-in-chief. And he would so often oblige in our hour of need with a textbook Shearer goal or a combative performance that would leave many a centre-back nursing some painful bruises following a 90 minutes of being physically tormented by the greatest striker ever to wear a black and white shirt.
2. Joe Harvey
The club's longest serving captain and a bonafide legend; Harvey was Mr Newcastle during his eight years at St James' Park and skippered us during our glory days mid-way through the twentieth century when we lifted consecutive FA Cups in 1951 and 1952. Harvey was a distinguished and authoritative captain who always commanded the utmost respect from his Magpies team-mates throughout his occupancy of the armband he seized early on in his Toon career following an impressive display on his debut against Barnsley. After retiring in 1953 at the relatively young age of 34 Harvey returned 'home' eight years later when he took up the managerial baton on Tyneside and guided us to the Fairs Cup in 1969 which still stands as the last major trophy to be deposited into our trophy cabinet.
1. Bobby Moncur
Hailed as "the supreme sweeper and a most valuable asset both to Newcastle United and Scotland" by legendary Joe Harvey and rightly considered to be our greatest ever captain. Moncur served the armband with supreme distinction in the seven years he skippered the Magpies and remains the last to get his hands on a major piece of silverware. Moncur lifted the Fairs Cup in 1969 and no captain since has led us to a trophy triumph in a black and white shirt with the Perth-born centre back scoring three of his eight career goals in the two-legged tie with the Upjesti Dozsa, which included a brace in front of the 60,000 adoring Toon fans crammed into the Gallowgate. In 12 years at St James' Park he racked up 346 appearances for the Magpies before swapping Tyneside for Wearside in a shock transfer to Sunderland. Still, Moncur is ensured his place amongst the pantheon of greats to captain the Club and wear the no. 6 shirt that became synonymous with him. Click "next" below to read the 5 that sucked...
And 5 That Sucked...
5. Jermaine Jenas
After an impressive beginning to his Newcastle career, that included winning the 2003 PFA Young Player of the Year award, Jenas' later years at St James' Park were marred by inconsistency and a series of inexplicably lacklustre performances.
Jenas temporarily regained his form under the management of Graeme Souness and was handed the responsibilities of vice-captain, deputising for Alan Shearer during his frequent injury lay-offs during the 2004/05 season. But, as it turned out, he was unable to shoulder the burden of leading the Magpies and eventually buckled under the pressure despite Souness sensationally remarking that he would have preferred Jenas to have worn the armband instead of Shearer during his reign. That would have been a categorical disaster given Jenas, 21 at the time, didn't possess a leadership bone in his body. 'I may be biased, but I think a captain should be in the centre of midfield," he acknowledged to Sky Sports in November 2004. "But I don't think that will be taken off Alan Shearer at this time - I'm not that brave." Another dramatic dip in form led Jenas to admit that he was struggling to cope with like in the Newcastle "fishbowl" and craved a move to London. That wish was granted on transfer deadline day in the summer of 2005 when he joined Tottenham for an initial £7 million where he once again failed to cope with the demands of being a vice-captain.
4. Yohan Cabaye
Naturally, there was only one viable candidate to take over the armband from Fabricio Coloccini after the Argentine centre-back was stricken by injury during the 4-2 victory over Southampton in February 2013. And Jonas Gutierrez wasn't the name on the lips of the Toon faithful. Many supporters theorised that Cabaye would be handed the captaincy in lieu of Gutierrez, who'd already deputised for Coloccini beforehand, after becoming an influential figurehead in a largely Francophile dressing room and it was a deduction that proved to be accurate when Alan Pardew installed him as our temporary leader for the next match at Swansea. The swaggering France international skippered us in 11 games during 2012/13 but it quickly became apparent that he didn't have the mental strength to cope with the elevated authority that comes hand-in-hand with the captaincy. His influence from the centre of midfield rapidly decayed and the armband seemed to weigh increasingly heavy upon his arm as the level of expectancy on his shoulders became too much to bear. So we weren't surprised to learn that Cheick Tiote had been given the vice-captain duties for the 2014/14 campaign in his place, although we suspect that Cabaye was secretly pleased.
3. Scott Parker
It was Glenn Roeder who appointed Parker as Newcastle captain in 2006 and gave him the unenviable task of following in the enormous footsteps of Alan Shearer in the aftermath of the Geordie striker's retirement. And it was accepted that whoever stepped into Shearer's shoes would face an uphill battle - as Obafemi Martins found out when becoming the first to wear the fabled no.9 shirt - but there was a strong feeling that Parker was the outstanding candidate to succeed our all-time record goalscorer in the role. Little did he know that he was on a hiding to nothing. The England midfielder soon discovered the pitfalls of being the Magpies skipper and that raw on-field enthusiasm which made him such a fan favourite quickly became his downfall. For starters Parker didn't carry the presence of Shearer and was far from the type of leader to organise the rest of the team on the pitch, while he was forced to issue a grovelling apology after gesturing to the Toon supporters during the humiliating home defeat to Sheffield United. Parker, for all he was a dependable lynchpin in midfield, was not captain material.
2. Geremi
Has it ever felt like we overpaid for a free transfer before? Sam Allardyce thought he'd snapped up a bargain when he persuaded Geremi to join him at St James' Park in 2007 with the Chelsea midfielder a free agent after running down his contract at Stamford Bridge. Allardyce immediately thrust the club-captaincy upon the Nigerian international in the hope that his diplomatic nature and peerless experience - he'd won the Champions League twice with Real Madrid - would bring an air of tranquility to a midfield that would consist of the perennial ragamuffin Joey Barton and an ageing Nicky Butt. Not to mention he'd be an excellent mediator in the dressing room should things become heated. But it didn't quite work out as Allardyce had planned. In his short incumbency of the armband Geremi demonstrated himself to be a captain unable to motivate the players around him and it was clear that it was clear to us that he was past his sell-by-date by the time he came to Newcastle despite only being 28. Whilst he still had the technique and vision to pick out a pass he was hamstrung by a general lack of mobility and fitness. Long story short; his legs were gone. By January he'd lost the armband to Michael Owen following Kevin Keegan's self-indulgent return to Tyneside. Which leads us on to...
1. Michael Owen
If the signing of Brian Kilcline ranks as one of Keegan's greatest decisions as Newcastle manager then bestowing the captaincy on Owen has to be the worst. Never has a player been reviled so ferociously on Tyneside but the former England striker is more than deserved of his villain sobriquet in these parts. Owen's diabolical conduct as we sank into the Championship will forever stick in the throat of Toon supporters. As our captain at the time he showed little inclination to inspire and rouse the players around him on the pitch and will forever be regarded as the captain who abandoned the black and white ship before it had even sunk. Despite an admirable goalscoring record - 30 goals in 79 games - at Newcastle his four-year stint at St James' Park was pockmarked by various injuries and in the end it looked he'd lost all desire to play for the Club never mind be the inspirational figure we required. And his scurrilous behaviour didn't end there with Owen releasing a nauseating 34-page brochure advertising him to several Premier League clubs before aiming a cowardly jibe at Newcastle saying"I think I'd rather play less and train with top players, rather than playing every minute of every game," after signing for Manchester United in 2009.