5 Reasons Why Celtic Are Out Of Europe

So I sat on my couch with my friends on Tuesday night with my head in my hands for about 15 minutes. Van Dijk had just missed a glaring opportunity to equalise against the mighty (if not currently mighty) AC Milan and 30 seconds later it was 2-0. That feeling of such deflation is almost unbearable. I couldn't figure out where it all went wrong.

I've suffered through every group Celtic game this year and I'll try to dissect 5 key elements to our disappointing Champions League campaign. After the dizzy heights of beating Messi & Co and reaching the last 16 it's hard to believe we lost 4 of 5 games after performing so courageously. Celtic are swamped in oppositional quality in the Champions League which is a direct role reversal to Scottish league football, and for such a financially dwarfed club in Europe Celtic supporters could be forgiven for expecting to struggle in the Champions League. Prior to last season's campaign I lost count of the amount of journalists who had written Celtic off as 'wont score a goal, won't get a point' and Neil Lennon proved them all wrong. So to expect such a performance this season after losing a number of important players could be a little naïve. I firmly believe that this Celtic team were good enough to compete in this season's group but we were exposed to a number of weaknesses. There are plenty of reasons for Celtic to crawl out of Group (of death) H with their heads held high but I believe the following areas will need to be addressed before next season's European adventure...

5. Defensive Sleepiness

Kaka scored Milan's first goal on Tuesday. An unmarked header from a corner whilst inside the 6 yard box. There were 7 of Celtic's 11 inside the 6 yard box but Kaka still managed to stand still and let the ball bounce of his head and into the bottom corner. I sympathise a little, it was a gorgeous delivery and the ball seemed almost magnetised onto Kaka's forehead but Van Dijk has completely misjudged the flight of the ball, Sameras hasn't anticipated the cross creeping into his 'zone' and Forster should be punching anything inside the 6 yard box really. Celtic's goals conceded were poor this year. If Messi runs rings around 6 players and scores 4 goals you hold your hands up and admit defeat but all 5 of Milan's goals were preventable! Other than the goals I think our defence performed admirably. I've heard countless complaints about not replacing the spine of the Celtic team but Virgil Van Dijk seems to be a far superior player to Kelvin Wilson, and Efe 'Bomb Scare' Ambrose has matured significantly this season. Although an improvement is needed for next season I believe the pieces are all there. With big Forster, Lustig (who has been immense), Ambrose, Van Dijk and Izaguirre Celtic certainly have a Champions league level defence, we just need to iron out those breaks in concentration and maintain the perfect organisation which was so successful last year.

4. Scott Brown

Yeah it was a sending off. Neymar got booed out of Glasgow but let's be realistic, he's behaved exactly the same way as Sameras would've. I know Brooney's barely touched him but violent conduct carries a 2/3 match ban and our captain should've known better. He was lucky not to get a ban after the Shakhter Karagandy game! I don't want to laud too much criticism on Brown because he knows better than anyone how foolish he was. Hopefully he'll learn from this tough lesson. Scott Brown as a player has developed so much over the last few years and I really see him as the heartbeat of the squad. After the England vs Scotland game Frank Lampard praised Scott Brown's performance and such recognition from a high profile peer was long overdue in my eyes. Had this rush of blood been vented on a hard tackle or kicking the ball away Scott Brown would've been on hand for the moments when our concentration seemed to slip. He was sorely missed against AC Milan and in both Ajax games. In replacement we fielded Beram Kayal who I think looked closer to his best since 2010 but Brown's influence on the team was irreplaceable.

3. Fire Power

I've converted 3 of my good friends to the Celtic family, and they were all stunned at the level at which Celtic performed in the opening game against AC Milan. The passing was fluid, the structure was rigid, the players all understood their roles and Milan were dominated by a club ran at perhaps a 10th of their salary budget. But despite such an almost flawless game plan our chances were incredibly limited. Usually this can be blamed on either a lack of creativity in midfield or a lack of fire power. For Celtic I believe it's a combination of the two but critically, we lack a commanding centre forward. In the summer we signed Teemu Pukki and Amido Balde to fill the boots of the departed Gary Hooper and although I am impressed with aspects of both of their abilities neither replace what he offered. Hooper's movement was phenomenal in big games, whether chasing channelled balls, linking up with the midfield or scoring goals he offered a dynamic versatility that could adapt to playing in the Nou Camp and then to Nou Douglas Park that Celtic simply haven't replaced. Anthony Stokes was responsible for a little bit of brilliance in our final qualifier so he justified his place in the games he played but he just isn't the type of player we needed to poach a goal and his hold up play was poor. Of what we've seen from Pukki so far he could be the answer to our prayers. The ex-Schalke striker has a split reputation amongst Celtic fans but I side with the optimismists (i know it's not a word). His technique is good and he doesn't give the ball away very often. Hopefully he'll fuse with the squad this season and prove me right. I'm sure Neil Lennon is well aware that we were lackluster going forward this year and it doesn't take a genius to identify the weakness when the only 2 goals we scored were a penalty and a lucky deflected shot!

2. Luck

OK so Kayal's goal was lucky but that was the only luck we had in the 5 group games. I don't want to say 'base your approach on the best teams in the world making mistakes' but Celtic really haven't had the rub of the green this season. Players need to be on the very top of their game and mistakes are frequently punished in the Champions League. If we look at last season; Xavi missed a simple clearance for Tony Watt's goal against Barcelona, Benfica & Spartak missed a couple of glaring opportunities in the 0-0 draw and 1-0 win, Messi hit the woodwork a handful of times, Common's penalty crashed off the underside of the bar and across the line, etc. Now I wouldn't dare take anything away from last season because I am so proud of my beloved club reaching the last 16 but there are certain elements of luck that it would be ignorant to ignore. This season, such luck evaded us completely. Izaguirre deflected a shot which would've probably hit the corner flag into the bottom corner of the net, Valdes made an incredible save from James Forrest at 0-0, Van Dijk, Kayal, Forrest & Mulgrew each had opportunities to score against Milan this week and Brown had a big chance against Milan in the first game. Sure these can be addressed as poor finishing / great goalkeeping but there's no way Valdes makes that save 10/10 times, we were just unlucky! I'm bringing a monkey's foot, a four leaf clover and Harvey Dent's mangled coin to the Nou Camp. Do your worst Neymar.

1. Investment

I use the term investment lightly. Celtic's scouting system has worked wonders over the years, and has recently sourced players who have left for over 10 times their purchase value. Ki, Wanyama, Wilson and Hooper have collectively generated over £20m in profits and because of which we are a very financially balanced company. However, I feel as though Celtic are forever burrowing for the diamond in the rough, and although players like Hooper & Wanyama are a testament to a fantastic scouting system lets not forget the awful signings. Players like El Kaddouri, Bangura, Brozek, Daryl Murphy, Ibrahim Rabiu, Miku and Lassard, have all failed to impress and we've released them all for next to nothing. I appreciate all teams make bad signings, and it may be difficult to bring proven quality to play in the Scottish Premiership but I believe Celtic should be investing in players with proven abilities. If Amido Balde turns out to be the next Ibrahimovic then Lennon is a genius but if not we can comfortably afford a £7-8m player on £25-28k a week but we seem adamant on unearthing a superstar and accept the costs of bringing a donkey in who looked like a stallion on YouTube. I know a lot of people will disagree with me. Celtic are a buy-to-sell club and I suspect the board are probably against higher risk spending when you can spend low to sell high, but without investing in players with proven abilities at Champions league level you're just relying on signing Henrik Larsson for £600k again and how many people win the lottery twice? Let me know what you think, have i missed anywhere else that Celtic need to improve?

Contributor

I'm Aaron from England and I've got for football what Russell Brand had for sex and heroin. I follow Celtic & Barcelona religiously and spend hours watching the majority of televised games. Kinda depressing when you write it down but i'm happy with my existence.