8 Big Modern Formula 1 Crashes

formula 1 crash Formula 1, the pinnacle of Motorsport, is one of phenomenal speed, technology, controversy and, when it goes wrong, some huge accidents. Safety is paramount for all involved, and just a few weeks ago saw a marshal killed in Canada. Whilst not from the accident itself, it occurred during the clearing of the car after the race, it still highlights how dangerous this wonderful sport can be. Now, I could talk about the tragic death of Ayrton Senna, which made worldwide news in 1994 and everybody knows about. But I don€™t intend on that. Instead, I will highlight, in no particular order, eight other big crashes and their implications.

8. Romain Grosjean €“ Belgium 2012

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ur7nwtMPmO8 Cementing his reputation as an unpredictable and dangerous driver, Romain Grosjean first pulled across on Lewis Hamilton€™s McLaren, sending him out of control and then pretty much completely failed to brake going into the first corner, destroying Fernando Alonso€™s Ferrari and coming perilously close to taking his head off as he flew across the nose at high speed. This also involved both Sauber€™s and a Williams, and spread a huge amount of debris across the track. Implications Arguably, this single-handedly cost Fernando Alonso the 2012 world driver€™s championship. Whilst you cannot say absolutely whether Alonso would have scored points, given his record of consistency throughout the 2012 season and reliability of the car, you would have to assume he would have done. Finally losing the title by just three points to Vettel, you have to argue that this incident cost him the title. Also, this accident saw the first race ban handed out since Schumacher in 1995, with Grosjean being suspended for the following race at Monza.

7. Most Of The Field €“ Belgium 1998

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BmOhDtgsPjc At the start of the 1998 Belgian Grand Prix, in heavy wet conditions, after getting through the first turn everything went to pieces behind the leaders, with over half the field being caught up in a massive accident that emerged dramatically from the mist hanging over the track. Carnage ensued as people came together, leaving the track strewn with debris and the red flag was immediately brought out. Despite this being back in the days of spare cars, four drivers were left without a car for the restart, which occurred almost an hour later due to the length of the clean up. The excitement wasn€™t over however, as on the restart Hakkinen spun off, and later Michael Schumacher smashed into the back of Coulthard€™s McLaren whilst leading comfortably when they came together in the spray. Implications The events unfolded to allow Jordan to take their first race win, with Damon Hill leading home rookie Ralf Schumacher in the striking yellow cars. As a Damon Hill fan, it was great for me personally to see his first win since his world championship win at Suzuka in 1996. Overall, this served to show how big and bad Formula 1 accidents can get if things go wrong in just the right way.

6. Fernando Alonso €“ Brazil 2003

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ih9Zi6Wo9nI Mark Webber, racing for Jaguar, dropped it in the wet conditions as he climbed onto the straight, hitting the barriers and coming to stop alongside the tail end of the pit wall. In his wake debris was across one of the fastest parts of the track, most particularly wheels. A safety car was declared, but failed to pick up the leaders before the final corner, which left drivers approaching the accident at top speed. Leading drivers Fisichella and Raikkonen picked their way through, but then-rookie Alonso piled into scene at full tilt, ploughing into one of Mark Webber€™s wheels laying on the track. He was flung into the tyre barrier at the end of the pit wall, and then catapulted back across the track into the outside barrier, covering the track with further debris. The race was immediately red flagged, and after an extended debate was not restarted as a limping Alonso was taken to hospital. It was handy that no restart was attempted, as Fisichella€™s Jordan-Ford caught fire in the pit lane following the initial red flag. Implications The ending of the race meant that, after some confusion and debate, and a post-race investigation, Fisichella was awarded the win, his first, and the last one for the team under the Jordan banner in their 200th Grand Prix. It also arguably affected the highly competitive championship that year. Had Raikkonen been awarded the win, he would have tied on points with Schumacher for the title. Whilst that alone would not have won him the title, with Schumacher having more race wins, it would undoubtedly have changed the approach to other races later in the year.

5. Robert Kubica €“ Canada 2007

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AtrzvwayniM Following a safety car period at one of Formula 1€™s best circuits, Kubica had a horrendous crash on the restart. Whilst trying to overtake round the outside of the kink into the hairpin, his front wing made contact with the rear right wheel of Jarno Trulli€™s Toyota, breaking it and destroying his downforce. He immediately understeered off the track and was launched into the air by a kerb, tearing off his front wheel on the end of a concrete wall, just missing a parked Torro Rosso and then hitting another concrete barrier almost head off, before tumbling down towards their hairpin and coming to rest in the barriers, bringing out the safety car again immediately. The car was absolutely destroyed, to the point where his feet were hanging out of the nose. Kubica miraculously only suffered a concussion and a sprained ankle in the biggest Formula 1 crash in recent memory, demonstrating how strong modern F1 cars are now and the advances in safety, as arguably that same accident just a few years earlier would have left him severely injured. Implications Whilst this accident seemed like it would have no particular implications on the championship or sport in general, it had a rather profound one. Due to his concussion, Kubica was unable to participate in the US Grand Prix a week later at Indianapolis. Because of this, BMW Sauber used their junior driver, Sebastian Vettel, giving him his first race start in Formula 1. He went on to finish in the points, becoming the youngest ever points scoring driver in Formula 1, aged just 19. It also demonstrated, yet again, that solid concrete barriers have no place being on the outside of high-speed corners at Formula 1 circuits.

4. Felipe Massa €“ Hungary 2009

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jhz2Tpl7ZVs Whilst this accident may seem a little innocuous, it highlighted a serious issue with open-seat racing and danger of debris. Just prior to the throttle drop, you can see an item in the air. This was actually a suspension spring from the rear of Rubens Barrichello€™s Brawn car, weighing about 1kg, which had flown off hundreds of metres ahead during qualifying. Somehow, it continued to bounce along the track, and then was in the air when Felipe Massa struck it doing around 160mph, with the spring hitting him above the left eye, smashing his helmet and almost knocking him out, leaving him unable to brake until just short of the barriers. He was airlifted to hospital following the incident, and placed in a medically induced coma. Implications This accident put Felipe Massa out for the rest of the 2009 season, and he has never quite been on the same form since. Following his heartbreakingly close 2008 season, he was in great form and looking to bring Ferrari their first win of the season in a car somewhat off the pace prior to this. This incident also occurred just a week after the tragic death of Henry Surtees, son of the legendary John Surtees, in Formula 2 at Brands Hatch, who also suffered head injuries caused by debris. He was struck by a wheel, which had broken its safety tether from another accident and bounced back into the path of the drivers. Together, these two incidents reopened the debate into the safety of open-seat racing, and the protection needed for drivers. Formula 1 is still discussing a move towards protective devices for their cars, with prototype devices being developed now.

3. Olivier Panis €“ Canada 1997

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-i7yO7IzFYY After a very promising start to the 1997 season with Prost, formerly Ligier, Olivier Panis was looking on the cusp of becoming a leading driver. Following his win at Monaco the previous year, he was threatening the front of the grid and looked as though he might take a pole position or race win soon against the leading Williams and Ferrari€™s. After losing the back end of his car, Panis was buried in the tyre wall, crushing the nose of his car and breaking both his legs. The race toured under the safety car for some laps before being red flagged, awarding the win to Schumacher. Panis was extracted from the car and then taken to hospital for surgery. Implications Primarily, it highlighted the need to increase the strength of the nose in Formula 1 cars to protect the drivers, given tyre barriers are intended to do exactly what they did here by absorbing the impact. Cars improved shortly after this, and accidents following this showed a vast improvement in leg protection, with the last incident being Michael Schumacher€™s leg break at the 1999 British Grand Prix. Sadly however, it cut short the seemingly unstoppable growth of Panis to becoming a new French Formula 1 superstar. Panis had surgery to insert pins into his legs and he missed the following seven races of the season, returning for the final three of the year. Whilst he was hampered by poor cars and had odd moments of excellence, he was never the same driver again, and fundamentally was unable to reach the heights we knew he was capable of.

2. Jacques Villeneuve - Australia 2001

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zB-AcTjAgac In the opening laps of the Australian Grand Prix from Albert Park, Villeneuve was racing with Ralf Schumacher in the Williams. Under braking, he was caught out by the Williams slowing as Ralf braked early, and hit the rear wheel. The BAR-Honda was catapulted up into the air, then struck the outside safety barriers and fencing before tumbling into the gravel trap. Both drivers were fine, however in the incident one of the wheels of the BAR flew through a small gap in the safety fencing, striking marshal Graham Beveridge and killing him. The safety car was out for ten laps as he was treated track side before being transferred to hospital, but sadly was pronounced dead. Implications This incident had very tragic consequences, and showed how loose debris, particularly wheels and tyres, at high speed can easily have tragic outcomes. It showed that marshals need protection at track side and that any exposure to the track is dangerous, and contributed to the continued progress in safety in Formula 1 that had really accelerated since Black Weekend at Imola in 1994. This was the last death in Formula 1 until the 2013 Canadian Grand Prix two weeks ago.

1. Roland Ratzenberger €“ San Marino 1994

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cXHxGBQIJh0 I raise this, as Ratzenberger is the forgotten casualty of Formula 1€™s Black Weekend. The worst weekend in memory for the sport contained three casualties, though most only remember the loss of the great Ayrton Senna. Racing for MTV-sponsored Simtek, Ratzenberger was in his debut season in Formula 1 and attempting to qualify on Saturday when he missed a corner and then smashed head on into a concrete safety barrier at 196mph, fracturing his skull. He was flown to hospital but died from his injuries, a basilar skull fracture, a common injury in Motorsport that has killed numerous drivers. On the previous lap he missed a corner and hit a kerb, which damaged his front wing, which then failed on the following lap, causing him to go off into the wall as he lost downforce. He was the first driver to die since Elio de Angelis in testing at Paul Ricard in 1987, and the first at a race weekend since Riccardo Paletti at Canada in 1982. This, combined with the incident that killed Senna and following incidents like aforementioned accident for Robert Kubica, demonstrate why solid concrete walls should not be lining high-speed corners of Formula 1 tracks. This is something that still exists, in places such as Canada, and I find unacceptable as it guarantees maximum force will be applied to car and driver in an accident. Implications Black Weekend cast a shadow over Formula 1 and raised many questions about safety. Ratzenberger€™s tragic death followed an accident on Friday that nearly killed rookie Rubens Barrichello, when he flew into the air and over the top of a barrier, knocking him unconscious, where he nearly choked as his airway was blocked. He was unable to compete with a broken nose and arm, and this was already enough to highlight safety issues with the track. Following Roland€™s death, the race weekend should have been cancelled despite drivers willingness to race, which would have prevented the death of Ayrton Senna in the race less than 24 hours later. The implications of this horrific weekend are long reaching, as it pushed the focus on safety in Formula 1 to new levels. The old Imola circuit was never used again, being drastically changed for future appearances on the calendar, and car strength and driver protection improved massively. The Grand Prix Drivers Association was reformed, regulations to slow cars, technology in helmet design and features such as the HANS device to protect the head and neck of drivers have been introduced. Formula 1 is the safest it has ever been, and rightly focus still remains on it despite the pursuit of speed and sport. Fundamentally, it took the tragic loss of the too-often forgotten Roland Ratzenberger and great Ayrton Senna to bring about such a drive for the sport, serving as a wake up call that has transformed the sport for car, driver and circuit. Black Weekend had an impact akin to that of the 1973 Dutch Grand Prix, another incident when Formula 1 and its safety was utterly shamed by the tragic death of Roger Williamson, asphyxiating in his overturned car as marshals failed to act while a heroic David Purley battled valiantly to save him alone from his burning wreck. That heart-wrenching footage can be found on Youtube.

In this post: 
F1
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Self-confessed Geek; Aerospace Engineer with a passion for Formula 1, Engineering, Science and Cinema.