Cardiff City Under Malky Mackay

Cardiff City Football Club has been through a lot in the past few years; from promotion to well-publicised changes in ownership, stadium, club colours and crest; with the most recent incident being the sacking of manager Malky Mackay. With Ole Gunnar Solskjær now the man chosen to steer the good ship bluebird away from a relegation dog fight, it's important to look at just how solid the hull is. In the interest of deciding whether Solksjaer can save the club, and whether Mackay's dismissal was right, this article will look at where Cardiff City was as a football club when Malky Mackay became its manager, and where it is now. I've also interviewed a couple of long term Cardiff City fans, to get their perspective on one of the clubs most turbulent yet rewarding times. In order to rate Mackay's tenure as Cardiff manager, we're looking at four key areas - the specific results of each season he was in charge, and finally the legacy he leaves for Solskjaer.

4. 2011-2012

As always the best place to start is at the beginning, and it was June 2011 that sees Malky Mackay succeed Dave Jones and join Cardiff from Watford. The Scot had a reputation of putting together competitive sides on a strict budget, and that was the order of the day, with Cardiff losing no less than 12 players leaving little over 10 seniors at the club. Amongst those who left was their top goalscorer for the season Jay Bothroyd, and he followed Gavin Rae, Martin John and promising Welsh youngster Adam Matthews out the door. There were also 7 on-loan players, who all returned to their parents clubs, including bluebirds talisman Craig Bellamy. With the debt at the end of the 2011-2012 season reaching a reported £83m, and Malaysian backer Vincent Tan still in the early stages of financially stabilizing the club; there was not a great deal of money with which to buy players. In fact of the 15 players Mackay brought in 4 were loan players, 7 were free transfers and 5 players were bought for just under £2.5m. Given that the estimated transfer value of the players brought in was around £14.7m, a solid Championship squad had been assembled. Notable arrivals were Ben Turner, Aaron Gunnarsson, Joe Mason, Don Cowie and Kenny Miller, who all made 40+ appearances throughout the season. In Mackay's first season in charge the bluebirds make it to a second consecutive play-off semi final, but are comfortably beaten by eventual play-off winners West Ham 5-0 on aggregate. The team did make it to the League Cup final, narrowly losing on penalties to Liverpool. Looking back at the season, Cardiff Fan Tim Wood said:
"The squad he (Mackay) had when he turned up wasn't quite good enough, and there was a number of players with question marks on their heads. With money not being available promotion wasn't going to happen overnight. He had to put his own stamp on the side."

3. 2012-2013

The 2012-2013 season was a bitter sweet one for Cardiff fans. It saw the promotion to the premier league for the first time in 51 years, but also saw a 104 year tradition come to an end. Yes, I'm talking about the decision to change the clubs colours from blue, to red. As part of a double edged sword the club would be re-branded, with owner Vincent Tan deeming a red kit and dragon crest luckier and more marketable in Asia. In return Mackay would be given a (stand by for cliché) 'war chest' to spend on players. With the changes made, money was certainly spent. Roughly £11.5m was used to bring in 9 players, with a further 4 free transfers and 3 loan players. Amongst the new recruits were several notable names, Jordon Mutch, Bo-Kyung Kim, Matthew Connolly, Craig Noone, Fraizer Campbell and the full time return of Craig Bellamy. It's fair to say that the majority of these signings were made with one eye on the premier league, with many of them still featuring in the current campaign. In particular Mutch and Campbell have shown to be shrewd signings by Mackay and his staff; whilst forward Etien Velikonja has only made 3 first team appearances - although there are reports that the £1.7m signing was not made by Mackay and his team. It was this season that Malky Mackay would cement his popularity with the fans, by taking the championship title with 89 points, 8 points clear of second place Hull. Cardiff were dominant throughout the championship season, reaching the top spot at the end of November and staying there until they lifted the league trophy. It's this season that Mackay will be remembered for as Cardiff City manager, and it's why so many fans still protested and chanted his name right up until he was fired. Avid Cardiff supporter Shaun Lawthom pointed to the change in mind set at the club under Mackay:
"You look at the year we were promoted, I'd say 40% of our games we didn't play brilliant. It wasn't free flowing fantastic football, but every time we needed to grind out a win, we would find a way to win. That's the belief he put into the players."

2. 2013-2014

And so it came to pass that Cardiff City kicked off their first ever premier league game away to West Ham on Saturday the 17th of August 2013. They would lose that game 2-0, but I wager in 10 years time it will be their first home game that fans will still talk about. But before that; a football club is not much use without any players, so lets take a look at how Malky Mackay spent the best part of - what is now a contentious issue - £36m to £50m. 10 players were brought in with Cardiff's transfer record being broken 3 times in the process. The big three were Andreas Cornelius, Steven Caulker and Gary Medel. Of these three record signings, only Caulker and Medal have featured regularly and are regarded by fans as strong signings. However Andreas Cornelius has only made 8 appearances in the premier league, all coming from the bench. With 20 year old Cornelius commanding a price tag of around £7.5m, many fans have regarded the transfer as a signing for the future, when the club needed players for the present. Out the door were mostly players reaching the end of their contract, however several players were sent out on loan, most notably promising young forward, Joe Mason. Despite getting to the premier league being Mackay's greatest achievement with Cardiff, the first win of the season will undoubtedly come close. The date is the 25th of August, and Cardiff are hosting title contenders Manchester City. Things looked ominous for the bluebirds - down on possession with several attempts on their goal, a 52nd minute strike from Edin Dzeko put the blue half of Manchester in front. However a six yard strike on the hour mark from fan favourite Aaron 'Iceman' Gunnarsson levelled the scores. Then, in sync with the 'pinch me I'm dreaming' banners held by Cardiff fans in the crowd, Fraizer Campbell got on the end of a Peter Whittingham corner and put his team ahead in the 79th minute. He repeated the feat in the 87th, leaving Manchester Cities Alvaro Negredo's effort only a consolation goal during the 6 minutes of injury time. Following the Manchester City game several pundits commented on the outstanding support and atmosphere at the stadium, further emphasising the belief many have stated Mackay had given to the club. If Cardiff's premier league credentials were being questioned, Mackay seemed to have the answer - "we deserve to be here" he said. Or so it would seem. The beginning of the end for Mackay's time at Cardiff can probably be said to be as early as October, when his right hand man and head of recruitment Ian Moody is placed on gardening leave by owner Vincent Tan. The man brought in to replace Moody is unknown Alisher Apsalyamov, allegedly a friend of Tan's son's and formally on work experience painting the stadium walls. The facts of this are unknown, with rumours circulating from unconfirmed sources that Moody defended players in a bonus' row with Tan - leading to his departure. The press speculated that Mackay could walk following the incident, but the Scott - no doubt buoyed by the unrelenting support from Cardiff City fans - continued in his role. Following a comment from Mackay on a radio show that he would like to add to the squad during the January transfer window, Vincent Tan issues a statement saying he would not be providing a single penny in funds. On the 21st of December Malky Mackay is sent an e-mail from Tan, stating that he either resigns, or he will be sacked. After refusing to resign, some poor results - notably a 3-0 home loss to Southampton - gives Tan the fuel he needs and Mackay's time as Cardiff City manager runs out.

1. Mackay's Legacy

It's impossible to deny that under Malky Mackay Cardiff City as a football club made huge strides. Featuring in a league cup final, returning to top flight football, beating the 2011-2012 Premier League winners Manchester City and winning the first ever Premier League Welsh Darby. It's a list that many a manager would envy. But it's also fair - although not popular - to say that a large part of this is due to the financial backing of Vincent Tan. Undoubtedly Mackay is a fantastic manager who's talents are plain to see, but were it not for the stability - all be it monetary - his task would have been far tougher. Yet the poison chalice of owner Tan was both the catalyst and the inhibitor of Mackay's success. This is not to say that Malky couldn't have achieved this without Tan, simply that the financial position the club was in before the Malaysian businessman came on board would simply not have allowed it. So goes the argument of club owners who are all business but no football, a discourse for several other articles no doubt. For the stats' fans Mackay was manager for 125 games. This included 54 wins, 37 draws and 34 losses, giving him a win percentage of 43.2% - higher than any other Cardiff City manager in modern times. So now the bluebird baton passes to Ole Gunnar Solskjær, with the majority of fans and pundits supporting his appointment. His managerial pedigree is certainly a strong one, having managed Manchester United reserves under Sir Alex as well as winning two Norwegian league titles and a cup with Molde FK. As ever the legacy left by a manager can be found in the testimonials of the fans, and so I will leave you with some words from the supporters I interviewed for this article. Tim:
"He will always be rated as the best manager we've had so far, simply because he got us up into the premiership."
Shaun:
"I honestly believe that he's the best manager Cardiff have ever had. Not just in my lifetime, literally ever. He wasn't allowed to finish the job he started, and I think that's the biggest regret everyone will have."
What are your opinions of Cardiff City under Malky Mackay? Please feel free to comment below.

Contributor
Contributor

I'm a 26 year old Welsh psychology graduate working in PR & Journalism. I enjoy writing, films, TV, games, sport, philosophy, psychology and mixing them all together. I occupy time and cyberspace on twitter @simcolluk