Liverpool: 10 Highly-Rated Talents Who Threw It All Away

From hero to zero in double-quick time.

Liverpool are one of the most historically significant football teams in the world: they are five-times European Champions and have no fewer than 19 league titles to their name with fans who follow the team spread across the globe. Every player who plays at Anfield reveals how special it is; how the atmosphere overwhelms with a dogged spirit and an over-arching desire to succeed. The club has also had some epic players in the past to match the majesty of the Kop: Kenny Dalglish is a bona-fide hero on Merseyside, much like Steven Gerrard, Ian Rush and Jamie Carragher, and the impact they had on the Liverpool team of their generation will never be forgotten. However, it is not always like that for players at Anfield and there has been many a player who initially came in with massive potential and who could have become an icon on Merseyside before unfortunately throwing it away by either under-performing or because of their behaviour off the field. So with that in mind, we're looking back at the players who could have gone down in Anfield history alongside the likes of Dalglish and Gerrard if they had ever matched their incredible potential...

10. Steve McManaman

Having broken into the Reds first XI in 1990 aged just 18, the former winger had the world at his feet when he was at Liverpool. He became an instant hit on Merseyside and was a breath of fresh air for an underwhelming, declining side who had been European giants just five years ago. The academy graduate was one of the most gifted players to play for the Reds: he had pace and skill that would dazzle defenders and was awarded many-a man of the match award along with perpetually being compared to Manchester United's Ryan Giggs. However, after nine years of being one of Liverpool's best players, Real Madrid came in looking to sign the boyhood Everton fan, and with a big transfer fee and a lucrative contract agreed, McManaman hopped on an plane to the Santiago Bernabeu. Despite winning two La Liga titles and two Champions Leagues, the winger was not as much as a key player as he had hoped as he had the likes of Guti, Luis Figo and Santiago Solari ahead of him in the pecking order a lot of the time. Even if he was classed as a cult hero, the grass really wasn't that much greener for the Scouser in Spain. Eventually, McManaman moved back to England and joined an average Manchester City side where he ended his career. His success is highlighted through his career assists - 182 overall with 142 of them coming for Liverpool. Clearly, the move away from Anfield saw him throwing away his days when he was in his peak.

9. Bruno Cheyrou

In 2002, Liverpool boss Gerard Houllier signed Bruno Cheyrou from Lille for a fee of £4.5M. The Frenchman had been successful for his former club, netting 31 goals from 111 appearances and was a highly touted youngster over a decade ago. He was, in fact, dubbed the 'new Zidane' by the then Liverpool manager, but how wrong he turned out to be. Whether it was the hype that put too much pressure on him or just not being good enough, Cheyrou failed to adapt to English football. He did not accept the physical demands of the game and often shied out of tackles and aerial balls. But then, out of the blue in the Christmas period of the 2003-04 season, Cheyrou finally lived up to his reputation, netting four goals in five games and provided a few assists. Many fans thought that something had finally clicked and that the winger was going to be great at the club. Unfortunately, the three time France capped midfielder failed to build on his excellent progress and was loaned out the season after, eventually leading to a move away from Merseyside. That Cheyrou had talent is indisputable, but unfortunately he failed to put it all together on the pitch. Since the Frenchman has represented clubs such as Rennes and Nantes in his home country, however has been without a club since 2012.

8. Salif Diao

After putting some mighty impressive performances in for Senegal during the 2002 World Cup, Diao arrived at Anfield with many believing Liverpool had a top class player on their hands. He had, after all, kept the great Zinedine Zidane quiet when his country snatched a 1-0 victory over France in the group stages. Nonetheless, his time at Liverpool was much different. Steven Gerrard and Jamie Carragher say in their autobiographies that the French-speaking players secluded themselves at the club, with Diao being one of them. He never took to Liverpool, and Liverpool never took to him. Ultimately Diao never displayed the form that had been displayed on a global stage and probably made more mistakes than positive moves. Often, he through in clumsy challenges in dangerous areas of the Liverpool goalmouth and also didn't do anything when his side were going forward. His passing was quite frankly terrible with many going either out of play or to an opposition. Reds fans were glad to say the least when he left for Stoke City in 2007.

7. Mark Gonzalez

In 2007, Gonzalez arrived at Liverpool with one major selling point, on which his reputation had been built - speed. His extremely fitting surname matched the Looney Tunes character, as the Chilean was blessed with extreme pace. Although he displayed this on occasions, they came few and far between: he had one superb game against Manchester United once when menacing Gary Neville for 60 minutes of the game, with his blistering pace, however that is the only positive memory most fans would even have of him. He looked afraid to get involved within the physical side of the game and shied away from tackles all too often. The Chilean had a real chance at Anfield to become an elite player, yet his inability to become accustomed to the English style saw him throw his big chance away and settle for a football career of mediocrity. For all of the potential that was hyped around him before his move to Liverpool, it was disappointing. The left-wing was a position wide open for the taking yet Gonzalez didn't make his mark on the position.

6. El Hadji Diouf

Much like his fellow countryman Diao, earlier on this list, El Hadji Diouf, too, threw pretty much everything away at Liverpool despite a high billing. He was a key member of the Senegal side who reached the 2002 World Cup quarter-final and manager Gerard Houllier opted for Diouf instead of Nicolas Anelka. After a bright start at Anfield, when scoring two goals on his home debut, Diouf never managed to live up to his early form. He struggled to gel into the Liverpool side and was often dumped wide on the wing instead of up-front. His form was poor and he was involved in several controversial incidents including spitting at a Celtic fan during a Uefa Cup game. To say he wasn't much of a fan favourite was something of an understatement. The forward never looked like he gave 100% on the pitch and did little when closing players down to win the ball back for his team. Eventually he left for Bolton Wanderers and it was very much good riddance for the Anfield faithful. His early games at Anfield highlighted what a player he could have been as he had all the ingredients to be a superb player, however his attitude let him down. And frankly it is for good reason that he is still considered one of the most hated men in football.

5. Emile Heskey

In March 2000, Heskey broke Liverpool's transfer record when moving from Leicester City for £10M. He had been a prolific goalscorer at the Walkers Stadium, winning the League Cup with the club twice, however he pretty spectacularly failed to convert his form to the Reds. Many believed that he would form a prolific partnership with Michael Owen up front, however he was far too inconsistent to do so: he would often lose the ball too easily and looked overweight and under-fit for a lot of his time at Anfield and his finishing in front of goal wasn't as deadly as it should have been. In patches, Heskey showed his true ability and scored some magnificent goals. Nonetheless, after scoring 14 in his first full season during the 2000-01 campaign, that tally got lower and lower until netting just seven times in his final year on Merseyside that led the former England International eventually moving to Birmingham City. His chance to form an excellent partnership with Owen was very much the most disappointing factor of Heskey throwing his chance at a top club away, as the pair had the means to make a great force up front.

4. Andy Carroll

After the sale of Fernando Torres to Chelsea on deadline day in 2011, Liverpool were left in a tricky situation and forced to sign Carroll for a whopping £35M from Newcastle United. Although it was a hefty price-tag, it was by no means at the time a terrible signing: he had aided his former club to win the Championship one season earlier and netted 11 goals in 19 games in his first top flight campaign. Carroll was an option that Liverpool to not have previously - an aerial threat - but unfortunately, the striker never found his form at Anfield. Despite struggling with injuries in his first season, he found the net just four times during the 2011-12 season from 35 Premier League games. Carroll never looked settled at Liverpool and always looked overwhelmed to live up to his vast price-tag and had off field problems when arrested a few months before his move due to allegedly assaulting his girlfriend. He eventually left from West Ham United in 2012 and it now seems that his chance to play for another top class club could be well and truly gone.

3. Robbie Fowler

For a man nicknamed 'God' by Liverpool fans, it may be surprising to see Fowler on this list. He was one of the most gifted players the club had ever seen in front of goal, showing so much calmness when in one-on-one situations. Fowler was loved by Reds fans and quickly became a cult hero at the club. However, when boss Gerard Houllier strengthened his attacking options by signing Emile Heskey and Jari Litmanen, it saw the academy graduate pushed to the back of the pecking order and he eventually left for Leeds United in 2001. It baffled football fans why Fowler did leave Anfield - he was clearly the best strike option they had at the time with Michael Owen as Heskey was inconsistent and Litmanen was ageing. Fowler didn't do much at Leeds nor at Manchester City and his career never recovered from the move away. It would have been better if he had fought for his place. He clearly had the class to do so, which everyone knew and instead saw his career quickly go on a down-slide.

2. Stan Collymore

For many, Collymore is one of the most gifted footballers to throw his career away. After being a prolific goalscorer at Nottingam Forest, Liverpool broke the British transfer fee and signed the striker for £8.5M. Despite netting 41 goals in two seasons on Merseyside, that number could have been much greater. Together, he and Robbie Fowler formed a fantastic partnership up front and became one of the most feared pairing in the Premier League. However, that was only when Collymore wanted to be in his best form: the forward very much played when he felt like it and often sulked around the pitch not helping his team-mates. He was involved in a number of off-field controversies - from staying out late at night, to saying that he was not getting the service he wanted at Liverpool; a quote that did not go down too well with his team-mates. His manager at the time, Roy Evans, said that Collymore didn't turn up to training during his second season on Merseyside and knew a move away was closing in. Collymore had a chance to become a Liverpool legend and be compared to the likes of Ian Rush and Kenny Dalgish. He certainly had the talent, however not the attitude to become a great at Anfield and become very much a journeyman and is now more famous for being a host on TalkSport.

1. Michael Owen

Owen is well and truly one of Liverpool's greatest strikers and currently sits eighth on the club's all time goal-scorers list. But he still left the club at the tender age of just 24. Owen broke into the Liverpool side when he was just 17 and became an instant hit at Anfield. He became a regular at the club, winning countless trophies including the 2001 treble, netting twice during the 2-1 FA Cup final win against Arsenal. He also became on of Europe's elite players and took home the Ballon D'Or in 2001. However, in 2005, there was strong interest from Real Madrid. Despite Liverpool having a new manager in Rafa Benitez and signing some exciting new players that included Xabi Alonso, Owen opted for Spain. There, he spent most of his time on the bench with Raul and Ronaldo the preffered strike partnership. Just a season later, Owen returned to England and signed for Newcastle United, however he was riddled with injury and his career very much began to be on a downward spiral in the North-East. To make matters worse, Liverpool won the Champions League the very season Owen joined the Spanish side. At just 24, Owen was very much on his way to become an Anfield immortal: he was destined to become the club's all-time top goalscorer and surpass Ian Rush's record. However, a move to Madrid - when Owen knew he would be behind Raul and Ronaldo at the club - saw his career go downhill from thereon in. Which of these players deserves to have taken the top spot? Share your own thoughts below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

All things sports - usually writing about Liverpool, Everton and the gee gees.