Newcastle 0-0 Stoke - Match Report & Player Ratings

Jack Butland take a bow...

Newcastle United returned to a nervous St James' Park banish the memory of last weekend's derby humbling at the hands of Sunderland. The Magpies huffed and puffed but failed to find a way past an inspired Jack Butland on a very frustrating afternoon for Steve McClaren's team. For the second week in a row they failed to take their chances. The home side all the early openings with Aleksandar Mitrovic testing Jack Butland and his Stoke City defence. Chancel Mbemba also could have arguably done better from a set piece header after seven minutes. Although, Stoke could count themselves slightly unlucky not to have a penalty after Paul Dummett seemed to clip the heels of Bojan with the Spaniard working his way into the Magpies' box. Newcastle failed to test the England keeper enough though as Moussa Sissoko and Vurnon Anita failed provide that final ball after finding themselves in fantastic positions. This allowed The Potters to get a foothold in the game, they came dangerously close to taking the lead but Jonathan Walters couldn't quite reach a stunning Charlie Adam cross. Quite literally nothing happened for a good while as both teams huffed and puffed in possession until a great cross from Sissoko on the left met the head of Mitrovic, United's number 45 hit the post before the ball bounced across the line with Butland doing well to scramble it clear. Georginio Wijnaldum was then flagged for offside during the follow-up. Ayoze Perez then jinked his way past two Stoke players and was hauled to the ground in what looked a stone-wall penalty, referee Roger East, however, gave nothing. You would have thought the referee - who blocked a Newcastle counter attack chance with Perez in the clear - would give anything to allow the game to gain some sort of spark. The first half petered out as 48,000 people inside the stadium fell into a slumber. The second period started with sustained pressure from the away side, although it was Newcastle who worked the first real opening with Perez bending one just wide from all of 25 yards. Gini Wijnaldum them won himself a free kick on the edge of the area which Butland pushed comfortably over the bar. Stoke then created the best chance of the afternoon as a deep cross landed on the head of Walters, but the Irishman couldn't find a way past his international colleague Rob Elliot who spread himself well to make the save. United went up the other end with Mitrovic playing Sissoko in who was bearing down on Butland's goal, but once again the keeper came out on top saving with his feet. Mbemba came close with another header from the resulting corner. Ayoze Perez then stung the hands of Butland once again with a fierce drive from range. We then saw the worst of Mitrovic as he attempted to wind up the Stoke back line, only to find himself in the book after a comical tumble to the turf. However, the big Serb continued to cause havoc in the Stoke defence, seeing his effort blocked with the goal gaping - a passage of play that was wrongly ruled offside. Stoke continued to show some threat, with Anita making a fantastic sliding block to deny a marauding Glen Johnson. Captain Coloccini would do the same on Arnautovic. As boring as the game was, Jack Butland was on top form as he kept a strong Sissoko drive from heading into the top corner. The England stopper then denied a flying Jamaal Lascelles header. You just new nothing was going in for Newcastle then. A bore draw...

21. Rob Elliot - 7/10

Didn't put a foot, or hand wrong all afternoon. Indeed, he didn't touch the ball in the first half, but was excellent in the second. The Republic of Ireland stopper thwarted Jonathan Walters with a Peter Schmeichel-esque save, while providing a calming influence for his defence by claiming numerous crosses.

22. Daryl Janmaat - 6/10

United's most potent attacking threat in the first period, while looking very shaky going the other way. What's new? Very quiet in the second before he was forced off through injury.

18. Chancel Mbemba - 7/10

Could've done better from a header early on, and made a crucial interception as Stoke looked to counter. Solid as a rock in the first half with Stoke only creating one clear cut opening. Could've scored another header in the second but his work going the other way meant he was the stand out performer in the Newcastle back-line. A move to right back didn't phase the Congolese international who proved what a clam customer he is on the ball. A very good display all round.

2. Fabricio Coloccini - 6/10

While Mbemba dominated everything that came his way the captain played more of a holding role in the heart of the Newcastle defence. Nevertheless, the central defensive pairing only allowed Stoke through once which showed how good they can be when allowed to stay on the pitch... Although, Xherdan Shaqiri made him look an utter fool down at the Gallowgate end in the second half mind...

3. Paul Dummett - 6/10

A bit of a nervy start that saw Bojan give the Geordie nightmares was soon forgotten as a couple of hard tackles was the only thing that got Newcastle fans out of their seats in the first half. Again, solid. Although Shaqiri did get the better of him on a couple of occasions in the second period.

7. Moussa Sissoko - 4/10

Didn't looked fussed in the first half, and didn't start the second much better after missing a one-on-one with Jack Butland. There was a distinct lack of effort from the Frenchman who allowed Marko Arnautovic a direct path to Daryl Janmaat. Moussa also found himself in fantastic positions on a couple of occasions in the first half but failed to provide that killer ball.

24. Cheick Tiote - 3.5/10

Useless. Too many touches, too many loose balls, too many slips on his a*se.

8. Vurnon Anita - 5.5/10

Another tireless display from Vurn without the ball but he lacked that necessary class on it. Once more, he found himself doing the dirty work for his midfield partner who was way off the pace... The wee man's work off the ball continued to be as impressive as ever in the second after a fantastic sliding block to deny a marauding Glen Johnson.


5. Georginio Wijnaldum - 6.5/10

Very quite from the Dutchman who failed to get on the ball in the first half. He started the second looking a different player, taking the game by the scruff of the neck and winning a free kick on the edge of the Stoke area which he got in target.

17. Ayoze Perez - 7.5

United's best player in the first half. Although, not even Ayoze and those tricky little feet of his could work an opening for the home side. Should have had a penalty, though... A couple of long range efforts showed his intent in the second period although he couldn't find a way past Butland who was keeping Stoke in it.

45. Aleksandar Mitrovic - 6.5

Had all of United's early openings but failed to get past the sizeable frame of Ryan Shawcross. The big Serb also showed flashes of Papiss Cisse as he was caught offside more times than I'd care to mention. Mitro was desperately unlucky not to give Newcastle the lead after he hit the post following a wonderfully crafted header. We would go on to see the bad side of Mitro as he attempted to wind up the Stoke back line, only to find himself in the book after a comical tumble to the turf.

Substitutes:

Freddie Woodman - n/aJamaal Lascelles - Came on for the injured Janmaat and forced the best out of Jack Butland with a header from a free kick. Massadio Haidara - n/aYoan Gouffran - n/aFlorian Thauvin - n/aSiem de Jong - Came on for Tiote and looked a little off the pace, it's fair to say. Papiss Cisse - n/a

Head Coach - Steve McClaren - Must Do Better

We can't really moan at Steve's team selection as he had no other option, but the way he set his side up left a lot to be desired. Newcastle were slow, static and failed to provide any sort of hope to their depressed fanbase. Things did get better after the break but Newcastle couldn't get past Jack Butland. Flat.

Content Producer
Content Producer

Video & written Content Producer for WhatCulture Wrestling. NCTJ trained journalist. BA Hons, Sports Journalism.