Newcastle United PREDICTED XI (And Score) Vs Swansea

Vurnon Anita has trained this week but will he line up against Garry Monk's side this weekend?

Firstly, I owe you an apology. You put your trust in me last week to predict Steve McClaren's first Newcastle United eleven and I failed. I claimed I was Mystic Meg and you guys came along for the ride. I don't blame you, I'd spent the entire summer writing about the Magpies' new boss and convinced myself that I was on the same wavelength as the Eredivisie Man of Courage.

I hold my hands up; Steve is a hard man to read and without criticising his selections (after all, he did get a 2-2 draw with Southampton) let's take a peek at some of the more questionable decisions he made. Don't worry, I'm not going to go all Mike Williamson again as I've been presented with incontrovertible video evidence from last September (where the Saints beat Newcastle 4-0) strongly suggesting that the 31-year-old would not have contained Graziano Pelle's majestic aerial ability any more efficiently than the selected centre-backs.

The decision to play Georginio Wijnaldum in the No 10 role surprised me, as did the decision to start Gabriel Obertan (and not even bring on Ayoze Perez or Rolando Aarons). But both selections worked. When former PSV Eindhoven midfielder Wijnaldum grabbed a heroic debut goal, making a cross-battlefield 60-yard pitch-dash before firing a bullet-header past Maarten Stekelenburg, it was Obertan who had selected the ammunition and cocked the weapon with a killer half-volleyed cross - and the pair were generally impressive throughout the match.

Newcastle's team spirit was clearly strong against Ronald Koeman's organised Southampton side and it would be unwise to disrupt a confident group, but Swansea pose different questions and posses fast wingers (just ask Branislav Ivanovic), ball-playing midfielders and the supremely talented Andre Ayew.

Here at WhatCulture.com/NUFCwe predict the starting eleven for Saturday's fixture, outline their specific duties and give our opinions on the scoreline.


1. Goalkeeper - Tim Krul (Southampton Rating - 6)

This week Tim Krul has been predicting things and believes that Newcastle United can be a "surprise package this season". The 27-year-old made two brilliant saves last Sunday and his reaction stop from Mayo Yoshida's header subsequently led to the Magpies' second goal. The Dutch-keeper was sharp throughout and could not be blamed for either of the two goals that he conceded. Speaking to the Mirror Sport, Krul said:
"Because of what happened last year, nobody is expecting anything. We will surprise a few people and it€™s great to be the underdogs. €œLet people talk about other teams and think we won€™t be anywhere - we know different."

2. Right-Back - Daryl Janmaat (Southampton Rating - 6)

Despite starting very well, Daryl Janmaat struggled with the pace of Southampton's Sadio Mane in the second-half and (although the whole defence looked a bit ragged) the Dutch defender will need to be more positionally aware against Swansea, who will likely play Jefferson Montero on the left. The Ecuadorian winger was exceptional against Branislav Ivanovic last weekend and Janmaat will certainly not be underestimating the 25-year-old's ability.

3. Left-Back - Massadio Haidara (Southampton Rating - 5)

With Paul Dummett racing back to fitness, Massadio Haidara needs to convince Steve McClaren that he is worthy of a first-team spot. Unfortunately for the 22-year-old he will be marking Andre Ayew - who demonstrated his class last weekend bu putting in one of the best performances of the weekend and scoring against Chelsea on his Premier League debut. Haidara's touch let him down against Southampton and, given the Swans' counter-attacking ability, he can't afford to make the same mistakes or he will be punished by Ayew, Montero or Gylfi Sigurdsson. I think Steve McClaren will have a more disciplined approach away from home and will restrict Haidara and Janmaat's attacking presence against Garry Monk's side. If both full-backs play as high up the pitch as they did against the Saints then the game could be over by half-time.

4. Centre-Back - Fabricio Coloccini (Southampton Rating - 4)

Fabricio Coloccini and Chancel Mbemba's relationship is still blossoming and it's the Argentine's job to hurry up the process. They have both introduced themselves, been out for dinner and maintained a textual exchange throughout the week but now it's time to up the chemistry. As club captain, the 33-year-old needs to re-discover his commanding leadership skills and nurture the former Anderlecht central-defender. Against Southampton, it was the opposite, Mbemba seemed to be delegating jobs, passing the ball out from defence and bringing the defence forward. Coloccini looked unfit, sluggish and unable to challenge for anything in the air. Against Swansea this needs to change, the pair will be faced with the physical presence of Bafetimbi Gomis, who will play as a the central-striker, and Andre Ayew, who will be given a free role from the right-hand-side.

5. Centre-Back - Chancel Mbemba (Southampton Rating - 6)

Perhaps I was a little harsh with Chancel Mbemba's rating against Southampton but, despite some tidy interceptions, I felt the defender lacked composure and was at fault for Graziano Pelle's opening goal. He certainly demonstrated flashes of his talent against the Saints and made a number of high-quality tackles and passes from the back and it will be interesting to see how he fares against Bafetimbi Gomis' physical presence.

6. Midfield-Pivot - Jack Colback (Southampton Rating - 6)

The double-pivot will be up against Jonjo Shelvey and either Ki Sung-yeung (who is suffering from a hamstring injury) or Jack Cork. Shelvey's performance against Chelsea was fantastic and proved that he can compete against the best holding-midfielders in the world, consistently troubling Nemanja Matic throughout the game. Gylfi Sigurdsson will also be a nuisance for Newcastle's holding-midfielders who will have to keep an eye on the Icelandic international's ghosting runs and accurate through-balls. Jack Colback was solid in midfield but his partnership with Vurnon Anita (if it is to be a regular occurrence) needs to be perfected. Like Fabricio Coloccini and Chancel Mbemba, the double-pivot needs to be more structured with each player knowing who they are marking. Too often against Southampton, Sadio Mane and Dusan Tadic found it easy to get in behind the midfield and create chances for the attackers. Swansea represent the same talent across midfield and will punish the Magpies if they're not positionally aware.

7. Midfield-Pivot - Vurnon Anita (Southampton Rating - 6)

Vurnon Anita has trained this week despite being stretchered off after 60 minutes during the Magpies€™ clash against Southampton on the opening day of the season. Speaking to NUFCTV assistant coach, Paul Simpson said:

€œHe€™s had a little bit of grief about that, because it€™s been a proper miraculous recovery - stretchered off on Sunday and fit to train on Wednesday.

€œBut it was a real concern at the time because he took a real heavy, awkward landing in his fall. I€™m going to have to give credit to the medical team - they€™ve laid their magic hands on him and he€™s made a really good recovery.

€œHe joined in training (on Wednesday), hopefully there€™ll be no reaction from that, and we€™ll have a clean bill of health going into the Swansea fixture.€

Anita's substitution has been widely regarded as the turning point of the Southampton fixture as the Magpies became overrun in midfield after he departed and the Saints managed to grab an equaliser. If the 26-year-old is deemed unfit to play then Cheick Tiote will be the most likely replacement although given his level of performance at the weekend, Steve McClaren could consider a tactical switch and play Georginio Wijnaldum as the pivot and bring Siem de Jong or Ayoze Perez into the No 10 role.


8. Attacking-Midfield Right - Moussa Sissoko (Southampton Rating - 7)

Despite Swansea's midfield strengths their holding-midfield positions can be exploited and especially with the possibility that Ki Sung Yeung could be a doubt for the fixture. Jonjo Shelvey isn't a natural tackler and can be positionally clumsy at times, Sissoko's physical presence could cause him problems and lead to Newcastle grabbing a goal on the counter-attack. There were also absolutely no signs of him not wanting to play for the club against Southampton and he gave 100% effort throughout. One problem (considering he is playing on the wing) is he can€™t cross the ball particularly well and should look to ghost inside while looking for Daryl Janmaat's overlapping runs.

9. Attacking-Midfield Left - Gabriel Obertan (Southampton Rating - 7)

Many would have predicted that Gabriel Obertan would have been swapped for Rolando Aarons or Ayoze Perez after being trusted with a first-team place against Southampton. Yet, based on his performance against the Saints he simply can't be dropped. He was a constant option for the central-midfielders, looked confident going forward and grabbed himself a brilliant assist for Georginio Wijnaldum's well-timed header. The French midfielder will be up against Swansea's Kyle Naughton, who dealt with Eden Hazard and Willian very well last weekend.

10. No 10 - Georginio Wijnaldum (Southampton Rating - 8)

Georginio Wijnaldum would certainly have been the name on everyone€™s lips as they left St James€™ Park on Sunday. The new signing moved the ball well, retained possession and scored a fantastic headed goal after making a typical box-to-box run at the beginning of the second-half. It's likely that the Dutchman will drop slightly deeper than he did against Southampton as Newcastle will look to defend for longer periods and aim to hit Swansea on the counter-attack.

10. Forward - Papiss Cisse (Southampton Rating - 7)

If Papiss Cisse hand't scored against Southampton then I would have considered putting Aleksandar Mitrovic up front this week. The Senegalese striker was quiet throughout the second-half and, although finally looking fully-fit, his touch and finishing let him down on a couple of occasions. Bu, he did score and his confidence will be high going into the Swansea fixture. Speaking to the Chronicle this week, he said:
€œHaving other strikers makes me work harder. €œI know that there are two players behind me who want to play. €œOnly hard work shows the gaffer what I can do, whether in the game, or in the training sessions. €œI want to show him I want to play. I want to score goals to help this team get the wins.€
Click on the next page to see Newcastle's best options from the bench...

11. Top Options From The Bench

David Nelson Sports Photography

Siem De Jong

Siem de Jong has admitted that he is raring to get going this season and offers Steve McClaren a great option off the bench against Swansea. He was relatively quiet against Southampton when he came on but has revealed that he is now fully fit and will want to prove that he can challenge Georginio Wijnaldum for a place in the first team.

Rolando Aarons

The winger consistently impressed pre-season but was not involved agaisnt Southampton, Steve McClaren will be looking to see how quickly Rolando Aarons can succeed at Premier League level.

Ayoze Perez

Many thought (especially the writers at WhatCulture.com/NUFC) that Ayoze Perez would start against the Saints last weekend but Gabriel Obertan and Wijnaldum are currently occupying his spot. It's difficult to pin-point Perez's best role in the current team and it will be interesting to see where McClaren chooses to play him if he makes an appearance against the Swans. Click on the next page to see our writers' predictions for the game...

12. Swansea City Vs Newcastle United - Our Writers' Score Predictions

Chris Waugh (NUFC Editor) | @ChrisDHWaugh Unfortunately for the Magpies I think this game will come far too early in their development. The Swans are a well-drilled outfit and, although they have a definitive passing philosophy, Garry Monk has created a versatile squad who can adapt their style to get the better of the opposition. Newcastle's obvious weakness in the air defensively will cost them, with Bafetimbi Gomis netting two headers and Andre Ayew also grabbing a goal against a club who monitored him for years. The visitors will breach the Swans' defence, most likely through Moussa Sissoko, but it will be merely a consolation. Prediction: Swansea City 3 - 1 Newcastle UnitedMatt Smith (NUFC Writer) | @ElasticoChop Both teams will be happy with their opening-day performances but Swansea will be determined to back up their well-earned point at Stamford Bridge with three at home to the Magpies. There is no doubt Steve McClaren will have to approach the game more cautiously and this will mean Gabriel Obertan and Moussa Sissoko will have to contribute much more defensively. If Newcastle stay disciplined and react to McClaren's more restrained philosophy then I think they could snatch a point, if not and they continue to press the full-backs high then the game could be over before half-time. Prediction: Swansea City 1 - 1 Newcastle UnitedRoss Tweddell (NUFC Writer) | @TwedzTweets The Liberty has been "one of those grounds" for United in recent years, with last season's point all The Magpies have had to shout about since THAT Papiss Cisse brace in 2012. This will be a meeting of two "footballing" sides with the Swans far-more familiar with what is expected of them by Garry Monk. There were plenty of positives to come out of last weekend€™s 2-2 draw with Southampton for Steve McClaren - but Swansea could and arguably should have beaten Barclays Premier League champions Chelsea in their own back yard which shows they are a step or two ahead of "the new" Newcastle at the moment. Ultimately, the difference in the game will be Andre Ayew. Of course it will. Newcastle were linked with a move for the former Marseille man for the best part of a year as his contract in France winded down, so of course he is bound to score a hat-trick after a very impressive debut and goal at Stamford Bridge last week. Cisse loves the liberty and I can see him bagging a brace for the third time, but it won't be enough.Prediction: Swansea City 4-2 Newcastle UnitedFor all the latest NUFC News, Views and Transfers make sure to follow WhatCulture.com/NUFC on Twitter and Facebook.

Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-accredited football writer with an MA in Sports Journalism. What Culture football editor. Write for the official Newcastle United programme. Former video reporter at North News. Featured and published in the Sunderland Echo, Shields Gazette, Mail Online, The Mirror, The Sun and others.