Sunderland Transfers: 10 Greatest Ever Bargain Buys

Who says the brightest stars have to cost the Earth?

What truly makes a player a true bargain buy? Not so many years ago, Sunderland operated on a shoestring budget season in, season out where unearthing bargains was a must. Those were the days: it kept expectations low or it should be said, realistic, while in recent times, over different managers and the changing face of the club, the Black Cats haven€™t proved anywhere near as successful at polishing up those diamonds in the rough. Even with managers who have come to the club with a reputation for spotting cheap and cheerful buys, like Steve Bruce, real bargains still alluded the Black Cats, while others, like Martin O'Neill simply signed expensive flops. Meanwhile, the jury is pretty much still out regarding anyone purchased since - after all, a short spell of form does not make the player a great servant to the club. Take note Connor Wickham. Club policy has changed, perhaps in pursuit of making the next level in the Premier League: instead of bargain hunting at lower levels, attention has turned to other cost-effective means of recruiting, with frees and loans the order of the day. But it wasn't always that way, and Sunderland have managed to play both domestic and foreign markets to success and brought in cheap players who went on to have a major impact on the club. With that in mind we're looking back at the biggest bargains in Sunderland history, not including those signed on loan, or who were Bosmans. To set some further ground-rules, a fee has to have been involved - so all free transfers have been counted out - and it's important to remember that what might constitute a bargain amount today may have been a club record not so long ago.

10. David Connolly - £1.4m

Newcastle United€™s shrinking violet, Malcom MacDonald once scoffed at Sunderland while at their lowest ebb with the zinger €˜Billy Connolly has just turned down the chance to join the Black Cats.€™ It came on the day Middlesbrough had signed an exciting young Italian forward for a large fee and Newcastle had signed Patrick Kluivert. Well, he who laughs last€ Fast forward a couple of years, and Sunderland snapped up David Connolly at the second time of asking on the final day of the transfer window. Despite him not appearing to be as prolific as some of his fellow Sunderland striking cohorts over the years, the goals he did score were all important. Roy Keane€™s rebuild of Sunderland appeared to be as much reliant on numbers as it was ability, in an early (and possibly accidental) pre-cursor to the Moneyball system. But during the promotion push there were one or two reliable regulars who had galvanised things, and Connolly with his 13 goals during that season was certainly one of those. His calmness when taking a penalty would also prove invaluable, which was especially true when he was called upon during the game that would ultimately confirm the club's promotion back to the big time. During a bizarre first-half, Connolly€™s nerve from the spot would be tested more than once as he stepped up to the plate, perhaps not getting the credit he deserved. After promotion however, Connolly€™s heroics the previous season would be overlooked as Keane added David Healy and Andy Cole to the already swelled forward ranks ahead of him. But had he been allowed his opportunity, Connolly surely couldn't have proved any more disappointing than those other two, surely?

9. Don Hutchison - £2.5m

At the time, the fee involved may not have looked like a bargain compared to Sunderland€™s transfer policy back in 2000, but in Premier League standards it certainly was for a player of Huchison€™s abilities; after all, over £5m had already been splashed out for a teenage forward by then. While it was only the same amount paid for another Geordie who€™d left the Stadium of Light under a cloud. After Sunderland€™s entire midfield had struggled to muster more than a goal apiece the previous year, Hutchison found the net regularly, once he had got off the mark. He€™d celebrated scoring at Newcastle, put Chelsea to the sword at the Bridge and thumped one past his old club, Liverpool, and he€™d make it to double figures by the end of the season and declare how happy he was to be at Sunderland. That undying love for the red and whites wouldn€™t last beyond the summer though, as Hutchison€™s head appeared to be turned; perhaps it was just a case of money, or maybe Sunderland€™s summer spending wasn€™t as ambitious as he would have liked. Whatever the reason, the Scottish international had decided he was off. His goals the previous term had helped the club to another seventh place finish while the New Year had promised so much more. But given that, as well as the club more than doubling its money in only one year, at £2.5m, Hutchinson, although the most expensive on this list still proved to be a bargain, of sorts.

8. Danny Collins - £140,000

Few defenders have a song sang about them, as Danny Collins had, and though the lyrics towards the end are quite unrepeatable, and a fib, he certainly wasn€™t that skilful. What Danny Collins actually was though was a hard grafter, and he had to be in several workmanlike Sunderland sides. And the fact he survived from the Mick McCarthy time, through the revolving door period of Roy Keane - during which time he established himself as a regular in the Premier League - was testament to the player. His never-say-die attitude gained him the recognition of the fans as he was voted player of the season during another turbulent year for the club. On Collins€™ arrival on Wearside - mainly as a utility player given his willingness to fill in as comfortably at left back as play centrally in defence - he could never have dreamed of becoming a regular in a Premiership side as he eventually did. Indeed, Sunderland were struggling to get out of the Championship at the time, but during his spell at the Stadium of Light, Danny Collins would win promotion with the side twice, later gaining call ups from Wales. Collins was by no means the most talented left back or centre back to play for Sunderland. but he put his all into his game, he kept his head down and emerged as one of the most improved players during his career at the club. It was almost a little melancholy when he left for Stoke, but by that point the Black Cats made a hefty profit on a player signed for absolute peanuts €“ having played 150 matches for the club.

7. Carlos Edwards - £1.5m

Edwards didn€™t have the lengthiest of Sunderland careers, nor did the latter stages prove the most productive, but it€™s hard to underestimate the added spark or impact he had upon his arrival to Roy Keane€™s promotion push. Recommended by international teammate Dwight Yorke, Edwards filled Sunderland€™s problem right wing and always possessed an element of danger to opposing defenders, though he was perhaps a little too lazy at times to take them on. Edwards€™ potential to shoot explosively from distance always left defenders on the back foot,and his fearlessness to take even impossible looking shots on excited the crowds no end and he€™d quickly added a new dimension to Keane€™s side. After Edwards had fired two or three highly important goals in the weeks after he€™d joined the club, Sunderland were on the brink of promotion. It was Roy Keane€™s biggest match in charge of the Black Cats, at home to Burnley €“ a win would be vital. However, Burnley hadn€™t read the script: Sunderland were pressing hard well into the second half but the score was still level, but then Edwards popped up from virtually 30 yards out with a thunderbolt of a strike. The Sky cameras were present, as Chairman Niall Quinn leapt from his seat in celebration, and that would be the undying image of that night as Sunderland won another promotion, perhaps the most important in its recent history. The signing of Edwards towards that success and promotion was no doubt as important as the loan signing of Jonny Evans from Manchester United or moving Nosworthy alongside him in defence. While given the financial rewards gained, £1.5m appears a bargain in many people€™s books; certainly Niall Quinn€™s, Roy Keane€™s and Sunderland€™s the moment Edwards€™ infamous strike bulged the net that night back in 2007.

6. Allan (Magic) Johnston - £550,000

Few players are held in such esteem as €˜Magic€™ Allan Johnston is around these parts of the North East, England€™s hotbed of football. He arrived at the club late in the ill-fated 1997 season where he scored his first goal €“ a stunning strike €“ in the final league match at Roker Park, and it would be the first of many classy finishes from a two-footed winger with the ability to turn a defence inside out. An entertainer with an array of tricks and skills to get him out of the tightest spots, he also possessed an accurate curling shot, which many a time got the crowd to its feet. Upon the arrival of another right winger, Nicky Summerbee, Johnston made the permanent switch to the left flank. Operating from there, he and Michael Gray linked up for two seasons memorably as the pair tore gaping holes in opponent€™s defences, turning them one way and then the other. With Johnston ahead of him, Gray came of age and won England recognition at the nation's Achilles Heel, left back. Johnston too received call ups for Scotland, but it was in red and white that the combination were truly exhilarating to watch; Gray€™s young legs never missing the opportunity to get forward or bomb on ahead of Johnston, ready for another killer pass. It was only a shame Johnston€™s contract disputes put pay to all of that before Sunderland had the chance to unleash the pair of them on an unsuspecting Premier League. Despite that, the memories of his goals curled in from outside the box or him tricking a defender to the point of bewilderment remain quite simply €“ magic.

5. Phil Bardsley - £850,000

Not the most popular Sunderland player of the last couple of seasons, with one thing or another, Paulo Di Canio actually declared Bardsley would never play for Sunderland again - wrongly, as it tuerned out. If the Italian had remained in charge that may well have been the case, but when his successor, Gus Poyet arrived, he could see that Bardsley had the gumption lacking in Sunderland up to that point. Originally a signing of Roy Keane€™s, after a reasonable start he fell a little out of favour and Steve Bruce signed a right full back with Bardsley struggling for form. However, when necessity forced Bruce€™s hand, Bardsley was pigeonholed into the problem void at left-back, and the right footed full back thrived for the season making the birth his own. Unlike with Chris Makin though, it was never going to be a permanent thing. Nevertheless, Bardsley had proved a point and was back in contention on his favoured right flank. In his final two seasons on Wearside the club twice narrowly avoided relegation due to shot shy midfielders and strikers, Bardsley added a goal scoring side to his game. It was Bardsley that Sunderland cheered in the dying stages at Old Trafford in extra-time of the League Cup semi-final scoring a squirming effort which caught out the United keeper with the Black Cats only shot on target. United would force penalties as the goal-scorers€™ mind was on the final, but days later he would help taunt Newcastle in the opening stages as Sunderland recorded another famous victory over the black and whites. Hopefully, they€™ll be the two abiding memories of Sunderland€™s record Premier League appearance maker and not his words or the image of him on the floor of a casino.

4. Jody Craddock - £300,000

A big, strong centre-half, quick across the ground with a reasonable searching pass, Craddock formed one quarter of the youngest back four in the club's history in his fine debut year on Wearside during the exhilarating, though ultimately disappointing 1997/98 season. While circumstance would dictate for the next two seasons that Craddock would remain side-lined in favour of experience in Sunderland€™s central defence. There were exceptions and Craddock was in the side during one of Sunderland€™s most memorable displays at the Stadium of Light €“ alongside his defensive partner from 1998, Darren Williams €“ as the Black Cats impressively demolished Chelsea 4-1. Then just as in his first season, Craddock would again be thrown in at the deep end when injuries depleted the Black Cats' defensive options, and just as before, the young centre back would grab his chance. This time he€™d strike up a partnership with club record signing Emerson Thome to forge one of the tightest defensive units Sunderland have had. With the rock-solid Brazilian dictating the back line and Craddock€™s pace cleaning up where necessary, the pair possessed all the attributes required as Peter Reid€™s men surged up the Premier League table to second mainly on the strength of their tight defence. But when that partnership was broken up due to injury, the pair would never find that kind of form again as the club went into the start of a dip. After narrowly avoiding relegation one season, the Championship beckoned the next. With Sunderland in serious financial difficulty as a result and prize assets sold off for a fraction of their worth, everyone hoped on the eve of the new season Craddock would be retained to build the club around as captain. Yet again though, Sunderland were over a barrel as an offer for the centre half came in, and unfortunately Craddock left the club. To realise just how highly regarded he was here, just look at his testimonial recently where a large section of the record-breaking team from 1999 turned out as the opposition at Wolves. Not bad for a kid who arrived from Cambridge for a mere £300,000 initial outlay.

3. Wes Brown - £1m

Despite his red cards last season and his injury record, at £1m in today€™s money, Wes Brown was still an absolute snip. Touted over a decade ago as the finest young defender in the league, Brown unfortunately never quite scaled the heights his ability should have allowed, and his many injuries have surely put paid to that. That said, class is permanent and flows through his cool, calm €“ at times €“ footballing veins, as he has proved unflappable at the heart of Sunderland€™s defence. While he's not the best or most prolific passer, there is little that fazes him, while his central defensive partner, O€™Shea, looks his age and leggy at times, Brown stands tall and reads danger well. Comparisons could even be made with another of Brown€™s former teammates Rio Ferdinand, and Brown emerged favourably now. Though comparable with age and injury problems over recent years, Ferdinand looks laboured when he runs, and he has lost some sharpness, whereas Brown has grown like a fine wine, only getting better with age and adding more confidence to his game. As a rock in Sunderland€™s sturdy rear-guard for the majority of last season, how Martin O€™Neill would have loved to have had him available more during his stint as Sunderland boss, as Brown€™s experience could have made all the difference.

2. Simon Mignolet - £2m

There are goalkeepers that could have made this list, who were possibly even cheaper, but in truth, how many come close in terms of ability or quality? Mignolet arrived on Wearside as an unknown Belgian prospect, one of many that the country has produced over this last generation. Manager Steve Bruce was very excited to have the young lad aboard, believing -given 18 months - that he would be up to speed and ready to challenge for a first team place. But these things seldom work out in that way, and Mignolet was pressed into action far sooner than expected or hoped. Though the young Belgian stood up well considering his inexperience at Premiership level. He was always going to make the odd blunder as all keepers do and would come in for a little criticism, though all in all, that would be forgotten as he became one of the finest young keepers around. His heroics at St James€™ Park, saving from the penalty spot and making ever more impressive saves had gotten him noticed. As his reflexes played a key role in retaining Sunderland€™s Premier League status at the end of the 2012/13 season, it was inevitable there would be big clubs circling. So as the large cash offer from Liverpool arrived, despite being first choice and being highly unlikely to replace him with someone to match his abilities, Sunderland accepted. The fee was around £9m, potentially rising to £12m some reports have suggested.

1. Kevin (Super Kev) Phillips - £350,000

Back in the days when Sunderland were finishing seventh in the league, Peter Reid suggested how €˜signing Phillips for £7m or £8m would have €“ in some fans€™ opinion €“ proved he was doing his job right.€˜ However, plucking Phillips from obscurity before turning him into a household name and a capped England international within three years actually had already showed how remarkable a job he had done. After an initial outlay of £350,000 for the unknown forward, Phillips took little time to show his instinct in front of goal, scoring on his league debut at the Stadium of Light for the Black Cats. Though Sunderland made a rather stuttering start and despite picking up goals early in his Wearside career, it wasn€™t until Reid€™s side started to go in the right direction that Phillips proved a lethal marksman. The manager had the vision of a strike combination of Quinn and Phillips. Reidy believed, €˜I knew once we got the pair of them together, we had a chance.€™ So it proved, from an unremarkable start to the season to perhaps the form side from January, Sunderland made up ground on the sides above them, bolstered by Phillips€™ hot streak in front of goal. Super Kev had well and truly paid his fee back surpassing the 30 goals mark en route to a Wembley play-off final which he would also grace with a goal. In fact, it would be his 35th of a brilliant debut season. That final goal of the season for Super Kev would cost the club an extra £300,000 of agreed fees but over time he would become the club's post-war record goal scorer with 130 in total. Super Kev would be the finest bargain buy of all time. Had he cost ten times his value, the club would still have underpaid for one of the most remarkable players to ever pull on the red and white stripes. Which other low cost heroes deserve mention on this list? Share your own thoughts below in the comments thread.

Contributor

Gary Engel hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.