Sunderland vs Man Utd: 5 Changes Moyes Must Make After Appalling West Brom Defeat

Manchester United travel to the Stadium of Light late on Saturday afternoon knowing that a symbolic steadying of the ship is in order to ensure a bad start does not become a disaster. On the face of it, this seems a perfect time to play the Black Cats, a team who have only picked up 3 points in there last 10 Premier League games, scoring only 8 goals in the same period. This was however, with the eclectic talents of Paolo Di Canio at the helm and Kevin Ball seems to have restored a bit of peace to the side, making them dangerous opponents. Its obtuse to say that Manchester United have been poor of late, being totally outclassed (v Manchester City), uncreative (v West Brom) or adopting a siege mentality v (Shakhtar). Its common knowledge that this is a team in need of change, ranging from the extreme to the subtle. I am also going in to this article presuming Wayne Rooney will make a recovery for the game.

5. Stop Criticising The Players

Personally, I have been reasonably supportive of the new managers start, he showed admirable strength in the Rooney Saga, he showed ambition (albeit misguided) in the transfer window and he showed bravery by appointing his own staff members against popular opinion. His media handling abilities however, leave something to be desired. Problems within the club should be dealt with within the club. Saying that Manchester United lack world class players, whilst evident, is completely the wrong approach. Criticising the players effort, a la Mourinho, is acceptable, but questioning the players actual abilities is an amateurish and unforgivable move. Commentating on the ability of the squad is not the same as commentating on a poor performance or a lack of effort. It is something that will not change, Moyes has to believe in these players otherwise he risks undermining their own confidence. Wingers and attacking players are creatures of confidence, as seen by Nani's fear of Ronaldo's shadow and Valencia rejecting the number 7 shirt for another season, Moyes comments will not instill the necessary confidence that is in order to make these players flourish. Moyes, by being so negative is undermining his position as the boss of Manchester United. As the manager, his job is to absorb criticism, allowing his players to play without the worries of press negativity. Moyes needs to show strength in this role, he needs to be positive. A positive attitude will draw the criticism towards him and away from the players.

4. Play Fellaini And Carrick Together

Fellaini was expensive, too expensive in many peoples opinion. Many critics have labelled him not good enough for the United team, but whilst he is not ideal, he does have some very positive attributes which Manchester United can utilise. United have not had a strong midfielder in his mould since the ill fated spell of Hargreaves. Employing him in a defensive midfield role enables Carrick the freedom to pull the strings and dictate the play. He's probably our best aerial threat as well and giving that the majority of United's goals have come from set pieces, this needs to be a big consideration. He is certainly not perfect, his pass completion rate is somewhat below what is expected in a top central midfielder and he lacks the dynamism and stamina of Yaya Toure or even Flamini. These attributes will improve though, the passing especially. Moyes does not have the luxury to leave him on the bench, he cost a lot of money and while he has divided critics he needs to unequivocally be a starting 11 player for the time being.

3. Do Not play Vidic And Ferdinand Together

Vidic and Ferdinand have been, arguably, the best Central defender partnership of the Premier League era. Vidic the typical bruiser against a more defined colleague in Ferdinand. In wrestling the championship back from Mourinho's Chelsea, these two were as important as the mercurial talents of the Rooney, Ronaldo, Tevez trio. I have not jumped on the bandwagon, labeling both players past it due to age and injuries, I simply believe that playing them together is no longer a tactical feasibility. Basically, they are too slow. Manchester United have been playing with a low pressing line to compensate for the threat of a counter attack. What this does is bring Carrick, Rooney and Van Persie back towards the middle of the pitch. Rooney and Van Persie are not the paciest of front men and all this does is allow the opposition to regroup, severely hampering the midfields ability to be creative. Vidic and Ferdinand should play, in every game if possible, but not together, Jones or Evans should be given the chance to establish themselves as a first choice centre back. They have the pace to compensate for Vidic and Ferdinands deficiency whilst Vidic and Ferdinand have the positional ability to combat their inexperience.

2. Keep Certain Players Away From The First Team

Not just the obvious candidates in Ashley Young and Anderson, but also Buttner, Fabio Da Silva. They all have potential, and in Ashley Young even a possible match winner, but this is a team that needs consistency, a team that needs to win no matter what and these are not the players who give the Red Devils the performance level they need. Anderson is frustrating, he has the ability to be a consistent starter but injury issues have left him unable to keep up a decent level of performance in an area of the pitch that Manchester United desperately need. Ashley Young is in the worst form of his United career and that is a big statement. Whilst he goes through purple patches in which he is consistent and penetrative, most of time he is one gust of wind away from falling to the floor. United need a player who can quickly turn on the break, not a player who would rather stop play to gain a free kick. Rafael Da Silva and Patrice Evra are undisputed starters, understandably they cannot play every match, but when they are fatigued Fabio and Buttner cannot be seem as ample replacements. They possess very little quality when crossing, relying on pace but not much else. If they cannot consistently provide a final ball then there is not much point them playing in Premier League matches. Smalling and Jones do not have much ability on the flanks, but defensively they are well above the level of these two.

1. Change The Formation

Now for the most controversial of all the changes. Manchester United have always played with wingers, from Giggs, to Beckham to Kanchelkis. This is embedded in the culture of the club. My point however, is that wing play should not be as embedded as Winning. Quite frankly, Young, Nani, Valencia et al are not consistent enough to guarantee wins. They may have good days in which United stroll to success (such as Valencia versus Leverkusen) but these are few and far between. This insistence on wing play leaves United without a Plan B when the wing play fails, as the midfield possess too few in numbers to effectively penetrate a defence. This is why Moyes needs to change to a 4-3-2-1 formation, better known as the Christmas Tree. Carrick can play as the deep-lying playmaker, covered either side my Fellaini and Cleverly. These two can pivot between defensive and offensive duties depending on the need for an agile presence or a strong presence. Further forward you would have Rooney and Kagawa, easily the most creative players in the team. They could have freedom to roam to the flanks as they see fit, but these too providing passes through the middle enables Van Persie to play to his strength. The formation has very few weaknesses in the current age, albeit there is a defensive vulnerability on the flanks, but very few teams hug the by-line in recent times, with most wingers preferring to turn inwards towards the centre backs anyway. Fellaini and Cleverly can always provide defensive duties to help out the Full Backs in times of need. I do not really believe Moyes is innovative enough for this system to work but it does enable Kagawa a decent chance to recreate his form in the Bundesliga. A simple look back to the successful Milan teams show how this system can work, with players of comparative skill set; Carrick/ Pirlo, Fallaini/ Gattuso, Roone & Kagawa/ Seedorf & Kaka.

Contributor
Contributor

Lifelong Manchester United fan but hopefully without the bias. Appreciative of football and all sport in general. I have an opinion of everything and have not had to admit a mistake yet. Follow me @James90Abbott on twitter!