West Ham United: 10 Managers Who Could Replace Sam Allardyce
Big Sam's out, but who'll pick up the Hammers?
On May 24th 2015 West Ham United announced that they would not be renewing the contract of their manager, Sam Allardyce.
Allardyce himself has stated he felt it was probably the right time for him to go - for both him and the club.
He had four fairly successful seasons at Upton Park, guiding them to promotion from the Championship in his first season and securing strong mid-table finishes in the next three, finishing 10th, 13th and 12th respectively. However, his time at the club has been plagued by criticism over his style of football, with suggestions that the owners, David Gold and David Sullivan, wanted the team to play in a more entertaining, attacking style.
West Ham are also due to move into the Olympic Stadium in August 2016, and it is thought that the owners want a new manager to oversee the club as they move to a new stage in their history. Maybe even to push them to the next level of consistent top-ten finishes and European football.
Whatever the reasons behind Allardyce's departure, he's left big shoes to fill. Whoever takes over is going to be under some serious pressure to get results and build on the finishes Big Sam managed. Here are ten contenders. why they would be good for the job, and why they might not be.
10. Nigel Pearson
Why He Should: Pearson masterminded Leicester's miraculous escape from the drop having been bottom for months, guiding the newly promoted side to a respectable fourteenth-placed finish. Seven wins out of their last nine games helped them to climb their way up the table, putting them second in the form guides, with only champions Chelsea ahead of them.
Pearson also comes across as quite a strong-willed character, sticking to his opinion and not bowing to anyone in the press. He'd be able to instill a fighting spirit in the West Ham team - a quality that's always useful when pushing to secure top flight status or sneak into Europe.
Why He Shouldn't: Pearson might have managed to save Leicester from the drop, but he was also manager for the long months that they were rock bottom before that. Given they've consolidated their Premier League status and become a solid mid-table team, that won't be a position West Ham want to risk being in. With that in mind, Pearson may not be the man to push the Hammers higher in the table.
He's had a number of PR problems over the course of the season, appearing to strangle James McArthur and calling a reporter an ostrich being just two of them. Gold and Sullivan will have to wonder whether they want a manager with that reputation for outbursts.
9. Harry Redknapp
Why He Should: When Redknapp resigned as Queens Park Rangers manager earlier this season there was a growing sense in the press that this was probably his last job. However, he has a long history with West Ham and a lot of affection for the club, having started his senior playing career there and managed them from 1994-2001, so it's difficult to see him rejecting the role if offered to him.
His time at Portsmouth and Tottenham also shows that he's a very successful manager; he won the FA Cup with Portsmouth and took Tottenham from bottom of the table to a Champions' League quarter-final over the course of his time there. Does this mean he has the experience to lift the Hammers higher than mid-table? Absolutely.
Why He Shouldn't: That sense in the press that he might be done could be key. There's a feeling that his best days as a manager might be behind him. While this is something Redknapp would be keen to dispel if he did take the job at Upton Park, it makes him more of a risk for Gold and Sullivan.
He did get relegated with QPR, and their return to the Premier League was also disastrous. He only got nineteen points from twenty-three games, and zero from away games, lending some credence to those claims he's past it.
8. Brendan Rodgers
Why He Should: Despite a disappointing season with Liverpool and a lack of trophies in his time with the Reds, Rodgers is still a good young manager with an attacking style. He gets his teams to play free-flowing, passing football of the type the Upton Park boardroom craves. His time at Swansea - and indeed finishing second with Liverpool last season - suggests that he has what it takes to do well at West Ham.
Additionally, Rodgers himself has admitted that he is under pressure at Liverpool, and would even leave if that's what the Reds' owners want. This means that he could be available, and if he is he'd be a coup for the Hammers.
Why He Shouldn't: It's still debatable whether or not Rodgers would want to come to West Ham from Liverpool. He's likely to stay with the Reds if the owners don't kick him out, and even if they did he might see the East London club as a step down from a club pushing for the top four.
His ability in the transfer market has also come under question, a number of his signings this season (and before) not having the impact that Liverpool fans had hoped. Will West Ham be willing to give him the money to invest, seeing how he used the cash he was given at Anfield?
7. Eddie Howe
Why He Should: Having guided Bournemouth to the Championship title and Premier League status for the first time in their history, wildly defying pre-season expectations, Howe has built himself a reputation as a manager able to get the best out of a group of players. This is a vital skill to have for a good manager, and getting more out of the Hammers players could propel the club onwards and upwards.
He's also widely regarded as one of the best young managers in the country and, while he may not have the big name status as some of the others on this list, his appointment would allow West Ham to build a solid foundation for future success.
Why He Shouldn't: It's highly unlikely that Howe will want to leave Bournemouth at this time. This is the club that he's spent most of his career at, that gave him his first chance in management, and that he has guided to three promotions over two spells at the club. He's unlikely to give up the dream of managing them for their first season in the top flight.
Added to that, he's never managed in the Premier League before, and it remains to be seen how he handles the step up. It would be a huge gamble for the Hammers if they signed him before he shows he can handle it.
6. Steve McClaren
Why He Should: People forget just how good Steve McClaren was in his time at Middlesbrough. He guided them to consistent mid-table finishes, won the League Cup in 2004 and led them to the UEFA Cup final in 2006, granting the North East clubs one of their most successful spells. Additionally, his managerial comeback with FC Twente led to the Dutch club lifting their first ever Eredivisie title. showing that McClaren can defy the odds to win silverware.
He's also learnt from some of the very best. He'll have picked up a lot during the time he spent as assistant manager to Sir Alex Ferguson at Manchester United, and while working with Sven-Göran Eriksson in the England setup. This knowledge would set him in good stead at West Ham.
Why He Shouldn't: McClaren's reputation was in tatters after he failed to secure qualification for Euro 2008 as England Manager, and it's something he's never really managed to get past. His return to Premier League management would invite a lot of scrutiny and pressure, which the West Ham owners may wish to avoid.
Furthermore, his managerial renaissance has hit a few bumps recently. His second spell at Twente wasn't as successful, and he was sacked by Derby County on the 25th of May having failed to make the playoffs. Do West Ham really want someone recently fired by a Championship team?
5. Slaven Bilić
Why He Should: Rumoured to be one of the frontrunners for the job, Bilić has a history with West Ham. A classy and reliable defender, he was brought to the club by Harry Redknapp in 1996 for the then record price of £1.3 million. He fast became a fan favourite, and was voted as the runner-up player of the 1996-7 season. He's still highly regarded by fans, so he'd be a popular appointment in East London.
He's also had some managerial success, most notably with Croatia. He guided his home country to the quarter-finals of Euro 2008 (qualifying for the tournament at the expense of England) and the group stages of the 2010 World Cup and Euro 2012. This means he has what it takes to carry the Hammers to the next level.
Why He Shouldn't: Bilić has no experience of managing in the Premier League. While this hasn't stopped other managers coming from abroad and being successful, it's something for the West Ham owners to bear in mind.
Additionally, his club record since leaving Croatia has been rather hit-and-miss. He was sacked by Locomotiv Moscow having led them to ninth place, their worst ever finish in the current iteration of the Russian League. He's done better with Besiktas, coming third twice, but his reign has been marred by outbursts at referees that are a cause for concern.
4. David Moyes
Why He Should: Given the criticism he gets for his short spell at Manchester United, it's easy to forget just how well Moyes did at Everton. He guided the Merseyside club into the top four and Champion's League qualification as well as an FA Cup final, and won the League Managers Association Manager of the Year award on three occasions doing his time there. He's also been gaining praise while at Real Sociedad, suggesting he has the ability to be a good choice for West Ham.
Furthermore, taking Everton into Europe means that he may well be able to repeat the trick and take West Ham to the next level too.
Why He Shouldn't: Moyes has said that he would prefer to stay at Real Sociedad and complete his goals there before returning to the Premier League, so it might well be the wrong time for West Ham to make their approach.
On top of that, his reputation has been damaged as a result of his time at United, where he didn't live up to fan or media expectations. His return to the Premier League would be under immense scrutiny and inviting that added pressure would be a risk for West Ham.
3. Jürgen Klopp
Why He Should: One of the biggest news stories of the season was that Jürgen Klopp would be leaving Dortmund at the end of it. A manager loved by the media for his erratic ways, he has a reputation for bringing young players through and crafting teams that were well set up - even on a budget. He'd be a great choice for West Ham as he could set them up for the future.
He has a reputation for taking underdogs and winning trophies with them, having won the Bundesliga twice and the German Cup once in his time with Borussia Dortmund. This would be encouraging for Hammers fans if they got him, as in a country containing both Manchester clubs, Arsenal and Chelsea - as well as others - they'd be considered underdogs often.
Why He Shouldn't: Klopp has suggested he wants to take a break after Dortmund to consider his next move. This may mean he isn't available quickly enough for the Hammers, who will want to appoint someone soon to maintain stability.
It'll be a challenge to get him, anyway. Klopp has been linked with clubs like Liverpool and Real Madrid, as well as big money offers from the likes of Brentford (which apparently failed). Most clubs around Europe would be happy to have him. West Ham would face an uphill battle for his signature.
2. Carlo Ancelotti
Why He Should: Reports suggest that the Hammers are preparing an audacious approach for sacked Real Madrid manager. Ancelotti had been facing a lot of doubts over his future in Spain and Madrid pulled the trigger on May 25th. He'd certainly be the marquee name the West Ham owners would want to lead them to their new stadium.
He's got Premier League experience, having managed Chelsea for two seasons. guiding them to a domestic double, adding to an array of other honours with some of the biggest clubs in Europe. He's one of a select few to win the Champions' League three times so he could guide West Ham to the next level.
Why He Shouldn't: It's not certain whether Ancelotti would want to go to West Ham - he usually manages Europe's elite, and West Ham aren't anywhere near that level yet. He's also suggested he wants to take a sabbatical after his time with Real and the East London Club will want a manager sooner than that.
He might not be the right choice for the long-term. He only stayed for two years at Chelsea and Paris Saint-Germain, and even though that involved being sacked from the blues, it's a worrying record. He'd also be expensive. The £6.5 million a season he earned at Chelsea may be out of the Hammers' price range.
1. Rafael Benitez
Why He Should: Until recently, Benitez was reputedly West Ham's first choice for their new manager, suggesting he'd be a favourite for Gold and Sullivan. He has extensive Premier League experience having managed both Liverpool and Chelsea, becoming a fan favourite and club legend at the former.
He's a proven silverware winner, having won trophies at nearly every club he's managed, most famously the Champions' League with Liverpool and La Liga (twice) with Valencia. This would be a good prospect for the Hammers, as he could move them towards the success the fans and owners seek. He'd also be the big name manager the owners are after to take West Ham to their new stadium.
Why He Shouldn't: The reason Benitez stopped being the favourite to take over from Sam Allardyce was that he was linked with taking over from Carlo Ancelotti at Real Madrid - in fact, he's expected to be confirmed for the role on Sunday. Being a Madrid man, it's very hard to see him turning down that opportunity. Even if he didn't get the role at Madrid, he might be looking for a club in Europe.
He's also no stranger to controversy. While at Liverpool he fell out with other managers like Sir Alex Ferguson and Allardyce himself. That could generate negative publicity which the East London club would hope to avoid.
West Ham fans, who do you think should take over at Upton Park? Let us know by leaving a comment below.