12 Times WWE Buried Its Own Champions
Becoming champ should suggest that WWE management is behind you. SHOULD.
'Business must be in the toilet if we're putting the belt on ***insert wrestler here***'.
That loosely-transcribed, but totally cutting phrase was reserved for one worker in particular. He's right here on this list, and he's joined by a bunch of other champions that WWE crowned then badly let down. On paper, you wouldn't think that the company's top brass would even bother to stick a title on somebody if they didn't think they could cut it, but that sometimes doesn't ring true.
At times, it's almost like Vince McMahon, Triple H and other bosses wanted to test the roster by seeing how they'd adapt to pressure or an unwanted helping of disappointing booking. If that sounds like a counterproductive way to go about things, then that's surely because...it is. Everybody's supposed to be on the same side and striving for the same thing, but nobody should ever disregard the cruel political backbiting that goes on behind the scenes.
Then, on other occasions, champs were just afterthoughts who were never going to succeed despite being pushed early on. They might've been the apple of creative's eye before bagging belts, but then writers moved onto their next project like some 5 year old ripping open a pile of Christmas presents.
Of course, wrestlers themselves have to take some responsibility for things going south, but it'd be bold to imply that anybody on this list deserved to be buried. All of them did their best and all of them were/are talented - they were simply let down by a machine that cheerfully criticised them or pushed them aside whilst they were key champions.
12. Karrion Kross Makes NXT Look Less-Than
At the risk of making Karrion Kross sound like Gene Snitsky, it wasn't his fault.
Kross was reigning NXT Champion when he was called up to the WWE main roster and debuted on the 19 July 2021 Raw. Anyone excited by the thought of this would soon come crashing right back down to earth when the menacing heel champ lost to Jeff Hardy in around 2 minutes. Ouch. This wasn't quite the Raw debut that anyone had envisioned for the guy, to say the least.
From there, Karrion dropped his NXT belt to Samoa Joe at TakeOver 36 on 22 August and officially joined the main touring crew after that. Not content with jobbing his new man out, Vince McMahon changed up Kross's look to include some goofy props that sort of made him look like the cast member of a 1990s children's TV show.
Everything that had turned Karrion into such a force on NXT immediately vanished. Scarlett wasn't by his side, and he lacked the presence he'd had by the bucketload down in developmental. It was a masterclass in stripping away everything that had made Kross viable for a promotion in the first place. Baffling.
Worse followed. Both Karrion and Scarlett got released on 4 November, and the pair wouldn’t return until August 2022 under Triple H's watch. Another so-so spell followed before Kross watched his contract tick down. He claims that WWE only gave him a short window to agree fresh terms, and that they didn't want to sign Scarlett. So, he decided to leave instead.
That second saga is a sorry one, but it's nowhere near as pathetic as what happened in 2021.
11. Zack Ryder Looks Totally Stupid
Imagine Kit Wilson gets himself over organically on socials/YouTube with his 'Toxic Masculinity' gimmick in 2026, but Triple H sighs at the thought of having to push the Pretty Deadly man. 'You went and got yourself over when we didn't plan to push you. What were you thinking?!'. That's the attitude Zack Ryder faced as a struggling midcarder in 2011.
Ryder got over with a casual audience away from episodes of Raw and SmackDown by running content on his own YouTube channel. WWE bizarrely seemed to resent that he’d connected with fans though. Think about that for a second. It doesn't make any sense! Despite being angry that someone showed initiative (how could he?!), bosses put the United States Title on Zack at TLC 2011, then shoved Ryder into a crummy romance storyline with Eve Torres that blended into John Cena’s rivalry with Kane.
It was as messy and uncoordinated as it sounds.
Management gave up on the Zack attack quickly. He dropped the US Title to Jack Swagger on the 16 January 2012 Raw due to kayfabe injuries suffered from Kane’s attacks. That wasn't even the biggest problem: Throughout his romance angle, Ryder just looked like a total dope for trusting Eve (who turned heel) and for following Cena around like a lost puppy to some diminishing returns.
People didn't want Zack to become a cheerleader for somebody else. They wanted to root for him and see a legitimately fresh faced pushed to the top of the cards. WWE/Vince McMahon disagreed, so 'RyderMania' was fleeting and his United States Title run became an afterthought.
10. Big Show Becomes Midcard Champ
Paul Wight went from being the new sensation on WWF telly to being called an out of shape waste of time within 12 months. That's actually rather impressive in a warped way. WCW behemoth The Giant signed on the dotted line with the fed in February 1999, and he was WWF Champion by November - the redubbed Big Show on the belt by replacing Steve Austin vs. Triple H and The Rock at Survivor Series '99.
Show struggled to convince as champ immediately, but he wasn't really given much help. Amongst other things, he only beat Kane by countout, went to a no contest with The Rock, and lost to Mankind by DQ on TV. To top it all off, his first pay-per-view title defence vs. Big Boss Man at Armageddon wasn’t even the main event. Triple H vs. Vince McMahon was.
A disastrous first reign ended at the hands of Trips on the 3 January 2000 Raw. To summarise, Show's title reign had been a waste of everybody’s time, and the man himself was booked like a midcard attraction more than a proper WWF Champion. Full federation focus went on the in-fighting between McMahon and Hunter.
Announcers might as well have said: 'Oh yeah, and Big Show is your WWF Champion. We forgot!'. The WWF made a lot of noise when they signed Wight, and there were bullish jibes fired at WCW for 'not knowing how to book a giant'. Then, almost hilariously, the McMahon family proved that they had no clue how to book Show themselves.
His title reign remains one of the worst ever.
9. Daniel Bryan Gets Humbled In 18 Seconds
Bryan Danielson will be remembered as one of the finest technical workhorses of his generation, but he was never supposed to breakout and become the success he did as WWE's Daniel Bryan. To hammer home that point, the writers had him do the job to Sheamus in a mere 18 seconds at WrestleMania XXVIII.
The goal was clear: Humiliate an internet darling on the grandest stage, and push an in-house pet project over someone who'd torn it up on the independent scene. WWE didn't bank on a groundswell of support for Bryan though. They accidentally set wheels in motion for a babyface turn here, because fans rallied behind the heel.
Clearly, those in positions of power had wanted to embarrass him then watch D-Bry tumble back down the card. "B+ Player", and all that. The WWE audience rebelled against that scheming - they embraced Bryan as a pet project of their own, and the promotion eventually became powerless to resist being swept away in the rising tide of DB fever.
Behind the scenes, the decision makers knew how much Bryan would be looking forward to a 15-20 minute clinic vs. Sheamus at 'Mania, so they whisked that away from him. He'd go on to have the last laugh, but not before being casually buried whilst World Heavyweight Champion.
The whole deal was akin to putting Bob Backlund's rapid fire WWF Title loss to Diesel from 1994 on pay-per-view. Dan's fate didn't just happen on PPV, it happened on the biggest event of the calendar year. Somehow, he survived then thrived.
8. Bret Hart Isn’t The Priority
If you've never had the pleasure, then check out Bret Hart winning his fifth WWF Title from The Undertaker at SummerSlam 1997. The pair meshed well together on an underrated PPV, and Shawn Michaels was on top form as a special guest referee toying with both workers. Scenes, people. Scenes.
Of course, Bret would later be screwed out of his belt at Survivor Series in a devious plot that's strangely never mentioned (ahem), but his path to that controversy-drenched clash with Michaels was pure milquetoast. The WWF pushed the 'Taker vs. HBK rivalry ahead of anything Hart was doing, and that's something he picked up on then wrote about in his celebrated autobiography.
Here's the layout between SummerSlam-Survivors: Bret worked on the undercard at In Your House: Ground Zero and Badd Blood in September and October, then again at One Night Only over in the UK. Worse, the 'Hitman' was booked against midcard man The Patriot, and Shawn/DX claimed he was racist towards the Nation Of Domination on episodes of TV.
It was hardly a banner reign for Hart on his way out the door. Burying the top title in the company underneath a non-title feud (at first) like Undertaker vs. Michaels was puzzling, and semi-assassinating the character of a top star like Bret had many scratching their heads too. Vince McMahon was perhaps trying to prove a point that he didn't need him to be the main man, but then...why bother sticking the strap on Hart for a fifth time in the first place?
Nobody on the planet was going to point to Bret vs. Patriot over HBK vs. 'Deadman'. It felt deliberate and calculated.
7. Seth Rollins Succumbs To Mind Games
2019 was not a good year for WWE creative, but things surely dipped to the lowest of lows when Seth Rollins met Bray Wyatt's alter ego 'The Fiend'. Their feud was torture to sit through, and it was clearly torture for Seth to work. He's admitted that he wanted to throttle Vince backstage following events at Hell In A Cell.
There, Rollins and 'Fiend' infamously went to a non-finish inside the titular Cell. It was a disgraceful call, one that made Seth look like a chump as champ. Later, he lost the Universal Title to Bray at Crown Jewel in another match that suffered from WWE's cartoonish desire to present 'The Fiend' as otherworldly.
In truth, Seth had been overexposed as a babyface before bumping into Wyatt, but WWE certainly didn't need to go out of their way to make things worse. Some of the going nowhere promos that Rollins cut on TV did enough damage, and yet he had credit in the bank with audiences due to inspired wins over Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 35 and again at SummerSlam.
The feud with 'Fiend' was a nosedive moment for Rollins in 2019.
He bumbled his way through clumsily-produced segments at the 'Firefly Fun House', and the story lacked that gritty underdog reality he'd worked vs. Brock. Suddenly, suspending one's disbelief enough to enjoy the show became impossible. HIAC knackered the rivalry, then Crown Jewel smacked Seth around the chops for daring to think that he could become the man around these parts.
The less said about Rollins teaming up with real-life flame Becky Lynch the better too.
6. WWE Totally Forgets About Tiffany Stratton
It was big news when Tiffany Stratton cashed in Money In The Bank on Nia Jax to become Women’s Champ during the first SmackDown of 2025. That 3 January episode ran on 'Tiffy Time'. After that, she defended her newly won gold vs. Bayley and Jax in hot matches before embarking on a heated rivalry with Charlotte Flair going into WrestleMania 41.
WWE sort of forgot they needed to book Stratton strongly after that. Her summer was woefully inconsequential, and included her fan-girling for Trish Stratus as arguably the main highlight. Then, Tiffy lost out to Stephanie Vaquer at Crown Jewel before being squashed by Jade Cargill on the 1 November 2025 edition of Saturday Night's Main Event.
Nah, not exactly the reign Tiffany would’ve been hoping for. It fell off a cliff post-Charlotte and never recovered. Triple H and his creative squad somehow managed to take one of 2025's biggest breakout title success stories and turn it into a run so sour even Stratton's loudest supporters weren't too fussed when she was squished by Jade at the end of it.
Episodes of SmackDown came and went without much spotlight for the Women's Champ. She cut samey promos behind the curtain and occasionally stepped foot in the ring for nothing matches few cared about. WWE weren't even trying to bury Stratton here - they did so passively, probably because they'd outright failed to build credible challengers for her after burning through the controversial Flair storyline.
So, rather than try to course correct, Hunter and pals gave up and moved on.
5. Kevin Owens Can’t Cut It
The live crowd went crazy when Triple H hit a kick > wham > Pedigree on Seth Rollins to hand Kevin Owens the new Universal Title on a plate during the 29 August 2016 Raw. KO was shocked and stunned by all of this, but pinned Seth to capitalise on the chaos and cement his place at the top of the flagship's tree.
Then, rather typically, the story went absolutely nowhere. Hunter didn't become a mentor to Owens for longer than a cup of coffee, and Kev started buddying up to Chris Jericho instead. Together, they ensured that Owens remained champ. It was fine for KO to lean on Jericho for help. A lot of heels do that. However, the end of his reign truly was brutal.
Goldberg hammered Owens at Fastlane 2017 to win the belt, and that was that. A promising split story between Kevin and Chris was shoved down to United States Title level whilst Goldberg worked a rematch vs. Brock Lesnar. Lord only knows why WWE seemed so dead set against following up on the newsworthy start to KO's run as Universal Champion.
The short build towards a match with Bill also portrayed Owens as somebody who had next to no chance against the ex-WCW squash match master. In promos, Goldberg acted like Kevin was some independent wrestling scrub who got lucky and didn't belong in the ring with him. Then, the match at Fastlane reflected his attitude.
It was one WWE apparently shared for real. Otherwise, they wouldn't have buried KO like they did.
4. Rey Mysterio Gets Booked As An Emotional Fluke
Firstly, it's important to say that Rey Mysterio has always been a world class worker who fully deserved a push once he joined WWE in 2002. Higher-ups put the mask WCW had taken away back on him, and Rey slotted in on a packed roster nicely. He worked excellent matches with Kurt Angle, Chavo Guerrero and countless others early on.
It's not outlandish to suggest, however, that Mysterio was (at least partly) pushed to World Title status as a reaction to Eddie Guerrero's passing. That happened in late-2005, then Rey won the 2006 Royal Rumble and grabbed the big gold at WrestleMania 22. It was sensational, but WWE's interest in treating Mysterio like a top guy was never going to last.
Things slowed dramatically after he'd won at 'Mania. Rey lost matches to everyone from Mark Henry to Finlay, and he was never protected as champ. Then, he dropped the strap to King Booker at the Great American Bash PPV and his flirtations with being cast as the poster boy of Raw dissipated in a heartbeat.
So much for that, huh? On commentary, announcers started to speak in Vince McMahon's voice by wondering whether or not Rey was just an emotional fluke who'd been riding the crest of a wave whilst determined to pay tribute to his fallen friend. He still got to enjoy the fruits of his labour, sure, but at what cost?
WWE cast Mysterio as an opportunistic underdog who was impressive but ultimately couldn't sustain himself in the hyper-competitive World Title mix.
3. Yokozuna Gives Way To Hulkamania
WWF chiefs can't really be blamed for giving 'Hulkamania' another go in 1993. Keep that in mind as you read this, because 2 things can be true at once; the fact they wrecked Yokozuna's momentum sucked, but Vince needed to find a money-making hit and decided to lean on something that had worked for him throughout the 1980s.
The timing of Hulk Hogan's re-ascent couldn't have been worse, right enough. Yoko was a force to reckoned with heading into WrestleMania IX. Nobody could beat him, and few even managed to sweep the big powerhouse off his feet. Only a handful of top stars had achieved that, including Randy Savage during Yokozuna's '93 Royal Rumble win.
At 'Mania, Yoko steamrolled through Bret Hart to end the night as WWF Champion. Or so people thought. Hogan came out to protest, then Bret half-Hart-edly encouraged Hulk to accept a challenge from Mr. Fuji. 20 seconds or so later, and order had been restored to the pre-1993 status quo.
Squashing Yokozuna was a big risk that didn't pay off. Hogan was gone again by summer, but him putting Yoko over at King Of The Ring felt a too little too late. The federation had sacrificed their biggest fresh heel at the alter of Hulkamania, and they did so without any long-term plan beyond, 'Well...Hulk worked before!'.
Commentary claims that Yokozuna looked better than ever after KOTR fell flat, because he'd been humbled on the biggest show of '93 by a relic the McMahon family planned to move on from. The 'New Generation' was off to a rough start.
2. Chris Jericho’s Reign Reflects Backstage Feeling
Remember that cutting line from the intro? 'Business must be in the toilet if we're putting the belt on ***insert wrestler here***'. That wasn't word for word what Vince McMahon said to The Undertaker in front of Chris Jericho backstage, but it's eerily close. Jericho wrote about how embarrassed he felt about this conversation in one of his books.
McMahon was referring to booking plans that'd see Jericho beat both The Rock and Steve Austin on the same night at Vengeance 2001. It was hardly a vote of confidence. He was likely ribbing 'Y2J' as hard as he could in front of a respected veteran, but it was a knee-knocking wobble for the champ to be. He knew ahead of time that the boss didn't have faith in him to succeed.
Great.
That feeling of uselessness persisted throughout Jericho’s stint on top until he dropped the title to Triple H at WrestleMania X8. As champ, he was never allowed to look like Hunter’s equal, and Jericho actually played second fiddle behind Stephanie McMahon during the feud. Her issues with Trips were far more important to creative/Vince than anything else.
Here's something: If the World Title match had to go on last at 'Mania X8 to protect the belt's legacy (ahead of The Rock vs. Hollywood Hogan), then why didn't they make the actual bloody story surrounding that headliner more of an ongoing concern?! Instead, 'Y2J' looked like a midcarder playing pretend atop the throne. He wasn't even the main obstacle Triple H had to overcome. Stephanie was.
Making Jericho look like a joke backstage and in front of the cameras was some call.
1. CM Punk Is In Over His Head
CM Punk's MITB cash in on Edge come the 30 June 2008 edition of Raw should've seen him arrive as a top WWE star. Should've. Sadly, he was just the latest experiment that those calling the shots didn't properly believe in. The way Punk was handled for the rest of his title reign (and indeed the rest of the year) proved that there was zero faith.
The entire story of his World Heavyweight Title reign was thus: Punk had only lucked out by taking advantage of Batista's handiwork to pin Edge. His briefcase win at WrestleMania XXIV gave him a fast track to the top of the card, which CM certainly wouldn't have been able to do the hard way. Seriously, that was WWE's narrative for their new World Champ.
On TV, JBL called him a flash in the pan who couldn’t live up to the hype, and others like Batista outright laughed at Punk’s claims as champion. Then, as if things couldn't be any worse for him by then, Punk wasn’t even involved in the ’Scramble Match’ that saw his belt change hands to Chris Jericho at Unforgiven 2008.
He'd been attacked in a promo skit backstage and replaced in his own pay-per-view showing. Wow.
The disrespect was outrageous. From first minute to last, WWE battered Punk and his fanbase around the head with a loud and clear message. Your hero can't cut it, and he's beneath practically every other main eventer.
What other champions did WWE bury? For more like this, check out 15 MORE Incredible WWE Attitude Era Moments Nobody Ever Talks About and 15 MORE Incredible WWE Ruthless Aggression Era Moments Nobody Ever Talks About!