5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (8 Aug - Results & Review)

Cody Rhodes gets a new challenger; WWE makes several big matches for Clash In Paris.

Drew McIntyre Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Drew McIntyre is the next in line to challenge Cody Rhodes on WWE's coming Clash In Paris PLE. Most would agree that the 'Hot Scot' is a fine choice for the role, especially after witnessing his menace play out towards the climax of this week's SmackDown. A killer spot and some supreme facial expressions from McIntyre told the full story of his desperation to reclaim gold.

Triple H also lined up an interim bout for John Cena before he meets the returning Brock Lesnar. Logan Paul finally gets his wish - he'll tangle with 'Super Cena' over in France, and that should be a tidy effort too. Indeed, SummerSlam fallout and lining up some tasty bouts for Clash was at the forefront of WWE's minds on Friday's show.

Sami Zayn stopped by to get a Montreal-sized pop, Chelsea Green clowned herself like only she can (that woman knows her role, eh?!), Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss continued to work miracles by making the former an actual bonafide babyface, and there are even new contenders in the tag-team division.

Downsides came in the form of spotty logic on the women's side of the fence. Tiffany Stratton came across as the bittiest of bit part players on SmackDown, and then the writers made Michin look like a moron. Similarly, the writing did Carmelo Hayes no favours elsewhere. Finally, those who'd hoped R-Truth comedy would give way to Ron Killings-led seriousness should be concerned.

Here's all the good and bad from a largely fun outing for the blue brand in Canada.

Get 76% off, four free months, and a free Amazon gift card when you sign up to NordVPN here: http://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=564&aff_id=3013&url_id=31010&aff_sub1=WhatCulture


Downs...

4. The Glaring Missed Opportunity With R-Truth

John Cena R-Truth Ron Killings
WWE

On the plus side, John Cena and R-Truth looked like they were having a blast by mirroring one another. Then, Cena turned things upside down by claiming that it was actually Truth who turned heel in March and then spent the best part of 5 months being a jerk to everybody. That left Ron Killings with a typically confused expression on his face.

Now, the downside.

So, Truth is officially back to being little more than a hapless comedy character. Personally, this writer is not into the thought of that, but only because he'd hoped to see WWE explore the more serious edge to Ron Killings. That hasn’t been there for a while, admittedly, and it sucks that creative has just ditched the whole idea without a second thought.

Sure, he worked a funny skit with John Cena here, but it ultimately exposes that Cena's own heel turn achieved nothing. Yikes! WWE normally wait a while before pointing the finger at themselves and acknowledging their own nonsense, but this still feels super raw and unsatisfying. There's never going to be any explanation from Cena or The Rock about why they joined forces at Elimination Chamber, is there?

Seeing Truth return to his old hijinks is deeply unsatisfying too. He carried an air of danger and a real threat for the first in well over a decade after returning at Money In The Bank. Just over 2 months on from that PLE, he's already hitting the reset button and pretending none of that happened.

Nah, WWE shouldn't get a pass for wasting everyone's time.


3. More Wyatt Sicks Blabbing

The Wyatt Sicks WWE
WWE

Uncle Howdy and his Wyatt Sicks appeared in a pre-tape to say people haven’t seen anything yet and make more ominous, cryptic threats. Got to admit, this guy is personally over the whole gimmick. Making grandiose promises time and time again only gets an act so far, especially when the leader speaks in riddles. 'You haven't seen anything yet', 'We're coming for everyone's souls'. Blah, blah, blah.

BLAH!

Here's the deal: The Sicks leading the SmackDown tag division as champs will strangle it, so hopefully they don’t have a lengthy reign with the belts. It was interesting when they first showed up to butt in on the competition that was already rife on Fridays, but things have become less and less compelling by the week, and they were arguably the weakest aspect of SummerSlam’s TLC match. This was just more of the same old, same old from the group.

They're completely at odds with everything else going on. DIY are moaning that no-one else has done enough to fight them off, and there's real human impact stemming from TLC bumps for acts like The Street Profits, Motor City Machine Guns and even Candice LeRae. Then, you've got Howdy and gang - they exist in their own universe, and have been completely unaffected by one of the most dangerous stunt shows of the year.

It's hard to take any of this seriously. What's the point if they can't show fragility after going through hell at TLC, y'know? These promo skits are an exercise in dull repetition.


2. Well That Didn’t Take Much Convincing!

Carmelo Hayes The Miz
WWE

Carmelo Hayes was rightly miffed at The Miz for dipping out on him for a while there. On Friday, Miz surprised him by coming out of the GM's office (even thought Nick Aldis wasn't inside) and revealing that he's snagged them a tag match next week. That wasn't true, because Miz then asked to speak with Aldis when the General Manager did show up wondering what all the noise was about.

Hayes just…sort of went along with it without much protest, for some reason. So much for Melo being miffed! WWE clearly just don’t know what to do with the guy, and that's sad to see. He's in a constant state of flux between singles action and this tag-team thing with The Miz. Honestly, pick a lane and stick to it with both. The yo-yoing back and forth is doing Carmelo zero favours.

There might be an upside to this if 'Melo Don't Miz' wins next week and gets involved in the tag title hunt too, but that's wishful thinking. No, WWE will probably heat them up again for a few episodes before forgetting about the team when somebody sticks a hand up during creative meetings with an idea for Hayes.

If anything, Melo should've told Miz to cram his tag match where the sun don't shine. Why would he trust somebody who bailed on him right when it looked like they were finally starting to click? Hayes needs a little bit of Kevin Owens-inspired realism to his character. Someone get Kev on the phone to pen these skits, or something.

There are worse ideas!


1. Michin’s Flawed Logic

Jade Cargill Michin
WWE

The women's division could use some of KO's logic too.

Tiffany Stratton was cutting a nothing promo about being champ but got interrupted by Jade Cargill. Then, Kiana James and Giulia muscled in on the action with a proposal - James offered her services to Jade, but Cargill declined. Michin walked in to nab the card and said she’d use it to get herself a Women’s US Title shot.

Erm…about that. It’s Kiana’s card, and she represents Giulia...who is the Women’s United States Champ. Why would contacting her get Michin a title shot against a fellow client? Nobody thought this one through. It was just time filler, and not even good time filler. Tiffany came across as a bit part player with nothing meaningful to say, the idea of Jade challenging her again after losing at SummerSlam is boring, and then there was the Women's US Title fluff.

Perhaps only James and Giulia can point to this segment with a smile. Kiana trying to recruit a star like Jade certainly makes sense if she's looking to make waves as a manager in the division, and Giulia is walking, talking proof of current success due to the fact she has gold over her shoulder.

Michin's puzzling lack of logic and Cargill not just shredding the card up right then and there though? No and no to that. This is the kind of skit somebody pieced together on a napkin in catering. It was 2022 AEW Rampage fare, and that's not meant as a compliment at all.

Sort it out, Trips.


Ups...

5. MFTs In The Tag Title Hunt

Talla Tonga Alex Shelley
WWE.com

On paper, Talla Tonga and JC Mateo beating the Motor City Machine Guns would have folks scratching their brain boxes wondering what on earth creative is smoking. However, the story going in was that the Guns were banged up from TLC at SummerSlam, so they couldn’t really get going or do their usual smooth as silk teamwork. Solo Sikoa's MFTs took full advantage of that.

JC and Talla came across as big destroyers here, which is exactly what should’ve happened. That's especially true for Talla. No-one should have an issue with these guys getting in on the tag title hunt, and this loss won’t hurt Chris Sabin or Alex Shelley one bit. For what it's worth, the MCMGs sold their butts off here. Shelley, in particular, did God's work when selling for Tonga's strikes and slams.

Talla owes Alex dinner for how much of a shift he put in to make the new enforcer look like an absolute monster. Meanwhile, Mateo looked better in tag action than he has in singles. This could be Jeff Cobb's role in WWE - tag bruiser alongside the bigger Talla Tonga. Give yours truly that over The Wyatt Sicks any day of the week!

You've got to love when WWE presents a tidy, compact story for matches that'd otherwise have nothing else going on. The Guns were hurting, so Solo had his troops seize the initiative and force their way into the title conversation. Sikoa mentioning the belts during his post-match promo is also rather encouraging, because it shows that's where the company plans to go next.

Bring it on.


4. Sami Zayn Gives The People What They Want

Sami Zayn Solo Sikoa
WWE.com

There's no point in complaining about the way Raw stars come to SmackDown or vice versa as things stand in August 2025. WWE just doesn't give a toss about the Draft, and it won't until its ready to crow about another one. It's annoying as all hell, but it is what it is. Also, at least they had the decency to bring somebody awesome over like Sami Zayn. He improved Friday's show, and that's all you can really ask for from one of these surprise stopovers.

Zayn entered a pretty basic babyface underdog performance here, but that’s not meant as criticism. It was exactly what Montreal wanted from his match vs. Solo Sikoa. The MFTs at ringside gave Sami the means to fight from underneath, then Zayn got the crowd-popping win with a quick roll up. It's doubtful that this will lead to anything longer term between Zayn and Sikoa, but Solo is the kind of heel who can eat this sort of loss then bounce back through delusional self-belief anyway.

In other words, what a fun little diversion for SmackDown.

Solo is becoming more of a utility player for WWE than a top guy, and that’s perfectly fine. Not everybody can be a main event focal point. Conversely, it does look like Sami is slowly building his way towards a future World Heavyweight Title reign. Royal Rumble triumph along the way en route to WrestleMania 42? Don't bet against it.

Zayn can work this kind of match in his sleep. Again, that sounds negative but isn't meant to. He's just really, really, really great at what he does.


3. Charlotte & Alexa Continue Clicking (Chelsea Entertains)

Charlotte Flair Chelsea Green
WWE.com

The segment with Charlotte Flair wishing Alexa Bliss a happy birthday by introducing the Charlie/Charly doll was cringy on purpose, but that kind of dynamic is working a treat for the pair. By all rights, that in-ring promo should've bombed hard, but fans seem to be enjoying what this duo have going on, and Flair is finally over as a babyface. Hands up who else didn't see that coming.

Following Charlotte's cake and doll reveal, she hit the ring for a match vs. Chelsea Green that clearly showcased everything right with Green’s act. The heel got some good stuff in here, then took that birthday cake to the face. You knew that was coming as soon as WWE showed the traybake on camera, eh? Pretty entertaining stuff here overall.

Bonus points for Joe Tessitore’s laugh, by the way. Man found that Unprettier onto the cake to be the funniest thing in human history. He was in hysterics, and it's highly likely one Wade Barrett had to immediately mute his microphone so he didn't snort live on air. Bless you, Joe Tess - the ex-NFL anchor is having the time of his life as a WWE play-by-play man, and he's already part of the furniture on SmackDown.

More babyface goodness from a likeable women's tag, then Chelsea Green doing her bit to echo sentiments from WWE Unreal on Netflix. She just gets it. The woman knows what she's on this roster to do, and she does it gladly. There are few better clowns than Chelsea. She's the female Santino Marella.

Bless her too.


2. Brock Lesnar’s “John Cena Problem”

John Cena
WWE.com

SmackDown kicked off with a top opening promo from John Cena. His sugary sweet speech was a masterclass in crowd manipulation, babyface vulnerability, and then fire once he started addressing Brock Lesnar's attack at SummerSlam. WWE are keeping that match back, because they've got something else in mind for Clash In Paris. Sorry, France, but it doesn't look like you're seeing 'The Beast'.

Cena then asked for somebody to come through the curtain because he was in a fighting mood. Logan Paul answered the call to set up the main event tag and a match vs. John at Clash. Cool. This was a different kind of revolving door promo, 'cause Cena actively encouraged it rather than being outraged he got interrupted mid-rant.

Personally, this fan is also glad they addressed the coming Lesnar vs. Cena match. WWE kinda had to, because that was one of the biggest (and most controversial) takeaways from a memorable SummerSlam weekend. Some folks online are predicting that the writing team will ride this all the way to Survivor Series. Hmm, maybe, but WWE also has a huge show in Australia before that.

Crown Jewel takes place in Perth on 11 October. If they fancy it, WWE could take both Cena and Lesnar down under and headline the PLE with their first match in years. It's either that or Survivors - John won't be around come Royal Rumble or WrestleMania 42, so they can't hold off until those blockbusters.

Cena's promo was a fab way to jumpstart the show regardless. He motored through a ton of business in a relatively short space of time, and the live crowd seemed thrilled to see him.


1. Solid Main Event & A New Contender

Drew McIntyre Cody Rhodes Claymore Kick
WWE.com

Later, Cena teamed with Cody Rhodes vs. Logan Paul and Drew McIntyre. They combined to produce a fun, house show style main event tag that ended via DQ when Paul hit a low blow on Cena. Those Clash In Paris rivals then brawled to the back like they were on a timer, which left the floor clear for Drew and Cody to set up their own marquee match for the next PLE.

McIntyre managed to stake his claim for a WWE Title shot by cracking Rhodes with the belt, then he smashed Cody with a Claymore Kick through the side of the announce desk. That looked absolutely killer. Replay angles didn't even expose it; it looked for all the world like Drew had caved in the side of the champ's skull with his boot, and the table splintering made some noise.

There’s your title bout for Clash In Paris then. That should be another fun one, and it's a match WWE teased months ago. On the 14 February episode, Drew warned Cody that he'd be coming for him and his title eventually. Of course, Rhodes went on to drop the gold to Cena at WrestleMania 41, but McIntyre has come good on his word now Cody has reclaimed the thing.

Love it when a plan comes together.

Drew came across as a major threat to Rhodes on Friday night. The match itself was background noise to this angle. If you're going to set up a title bout mere weeks in advance for a 'B' level PLE, this is how you do it.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 10 New Directions For WWE After SummerSlam 2025 and 15 Things We Learned From WWE Unreal!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.