One MIND-BLOWING Secret From Every WWE Royal Rumble

2007 - ECW’s Dismal Night

cm punk ecw reboot
WWE.com

WWE rebooted ECW in 2006, and for once, fans were reasonable to expect Vince McMahon to do the unthinkable, and promote a brand of wrestling for a mature audience that felt different.

The 2005 and 2006 One Night Stand reunion events were incredible, surreal, actually authentic. They were also genuinely successful, hence why the decision was made to introduce ECW as a third brand proper. Surely, with this proof of concept established, Vince would allow Paul Heyman to get on with it, promoting the likes of CM Punk as guys who would have got over in the bingo hall as long-term replacements for the ageing originals.

Nope: you got zombies in big arenas, and the Big Show Vs. Batista receiving a foul-mouthed hijacking at the Hammerstein Ballroom. To put into perspective just how quickly Vince McMahon gave up on the idea of ECW as a credible brand worth following, consider the dire statistics of Royal Rumble 2007.

Not a single member of the ECW roster made the final eight, much less the final four, which was senseless. CM Punk’s involvement in the ECW title picture was obvious: why not use the Rumble to showcase him ahead of that challenge and run?

Moreover, deepening the stigma that ECW might as well have been Jakked, just one ECW act was booked to eliminate somebody from the Rumble match: Rob Van Dam tossed Chris Masters.

A few ECW guys were involved in the classic “multiple wrestlers toss out the big lad” spot, when in tandem with a few others CM Punk, Van Dam, Hardcore Holly, and Kevin Thorn dumped Viscera - but that hardly counts.


2008 - The Argument Over John Cena’s Return

john cena royal rumble 2008
WWE.com

In one of the most sensational moments in the history of the Royal Rumble - and WWE generally - John Cena made his shocking, unannounced return.

This was not even dreamed up as a naive, slim possibility. Cena had torn his pectoral muscle completely off the bone, and only undergone surgery to fix it in early October. For comparison, Cody Rhodes missed over twice the amount of time when suffering the same injury in 2022. WrestleMania was the optimistic return date.

The reaction was incredible, with the discerning Madison Square Garden hardcores so besides themselves at Cena’s magnetism and the surreal situation that they temporarily forgot that he wasn’t cool and that they were supposed to hate him. Cena won the match, last eliminating Triple H; oddly, given how awesome this story was, Cena didn’t end up headlining WrestleMania 24.

Cena’s return was almost nowhere near as fun as it was.

Per the February 4 Observer, Vince McMahon originally wanted to advertise what was, legitimately, a medical miracle. To be boring about it, you can see where he was coming from: the buy number would have improved, not inconsiderably, and it was an incredible feat worth promoting. He was supported in his thinking by head Raw writer Brian Gewirtz and Michael Hayes. Stephanie McMahon felt that the surprise route was the best option, and her case was strong, too: the moment would be incredible, and spark the imagination ahead of future Rumble events. Incredibly, given his infamous reputation as a “yes man”, Bruce Prichard actually sided with Stephanie.

Eventually, of course, Vince changed his mind.


2009 - A Future WWE Champion Was Meant To Debut

Alberto Del Rio
WWE.com

In the late 2000s, Alberto Del Rio was the subject of pro wrestling’s equivalent to a summer-long football transfer saga.

On June 30, 2008, Del Rio made a cameo appearance as a security guard on Raw. According to Mexican outlet Ovaciones, Del Rio (working for CMLL as Dos Caras, Jr.) worked a WWE dark match later that year, after which he was offered a contract. While there is no such record on Cagematch supporting this story, there must have been something in it, given that he ended up working there. Had he signed with WWE, or not?

This was claimed and refuted throughout the next several months. The deal was thought to have been agreed when, on December 22, Caras dropped the CMLL World Heavyweight title to Ultimo Guerrero - just in time for the Royal Rumble. In the Observer, Meltzer wrote, without being adamant about it, that he’d heard talk of this being Caras’ start date.

It wasn’t; Caras announced that he’d signed a new four-year deal with CMLL, who had offered him more money than WWE. In less than half a year (!), he signed with WWE, and was posted to its sole feeder system at the time, Florida Championship Wrestling (FCW).

All of this bother for a man that would ultimately reveal himself to be one of the most bland WWE champions ever. Has anybody won so much, while leaving so little of an impression, as Alberto Del Rio?

His Wikipedia Championship and Accomplishment’s section looks legendary on paper. Del Rio was a two-time WWE Champion, two-time World Heavyweight champion, and won both the Royal Rumble and Money In The Bank matches.

And yet he was never over, his matches peaked at “decent”, and he was responsible for zero moments that anybody remembers or cares for.


2010 - Umaga Was Meant To Re-Debut

Umaga Backlash 2006
WWE.com

Edward Smith ‘Umaga’ Fatu was an excellent monster heel. He played a throwback savage, but transcended the limitations of the gimmick and somehow made a caricature believable. He was intense, impressively dynamic given his gargantuan frame, and his stuff looked outright nasty. He was consistently awesome, when motivated, and was part of one of the very best WWE matches ever: his violent war against John Cena at Royal Rumble 1997.

He passed away on December 4, 2009, as a result of a heart attack incited by acute toxicity resulting from the combined effects of hydrocodone, carisoprodol, and diazepam. He was just 36 years old. To the disgust of many, his death was ignored on WWE television, not acknowledged with a ten bell salute, nor the bare minimum of a memorial graphic.

Fans inferred that, since Umaga’s drug use had contributed to his death, WWE wanted to disassociate itself from him. It could be interpreted as yet another indictment on the promotion, from which he had been released because he was considered a disciplinary liability. The weird and sad thing is that Umaga was in fact associated with the company, or very close to it.

According to the December 4, 2009 Observer, Umaga had reached an agreement to return to WWE, “where he was scheduled to debut at or around Royal Rumble time”.

Hulk Hogan wanted him to go to TNA, but Umaga told Hogan that he felt “a degree of loyalty” to Triple H and Stephanie McMahon - which makes the lack of acknowledgement even more grim in retrospect.


2011 - History Repeats Itself Yet Again

Diesel Kevin Nash Royal Rumble 2011
WWE.com

As mentioned, the WWF wanted to thwart the XWF when bringing Curt Hennig back. Missing from the prior entry is the report that WWE’s initial move for Umaga was spurred by his key spot in Hulk Hogan’s tour of Australia, which presumably was generating a little too much interest for their liking (WWE retained their interest after the fact).

WWE was at it again in 2011.

WWE never took TNA all that seriously as a threat - certainly not on the scale of AEW. WWE never actively counterprogrammed TNA. Few snide references were made to TNA on their own TV show. But if WWE was going to interfere with the XWF, TNA was not going to emerge unscathed even from such a grotesque competitive mismatch.

In two awesome moments, both Booker T and Kevin Nash appeared as surprise entrants in the Royal Rumble match. The latter’s spot was particularly well-received and inspired; a repeat of the 2002 trick, bringing Nash back under the old Diesel persona made him feel, for a few fleeting moments, like the legend born again.

Both wrestlers were brought back to spite TNA; the promotion was interested in Book and Nash to join a babyface Main Event Mafia, teased as ‘They’, to oppose Immortal. This was ambitious on TNA’s part, since Booker had been in talks with WWE for a couple of months. Nash was different; TNA was expecting him to come in, and Dave Meltzer’s sources were told that Nash had committed to TNA. But he had signed nothing.

LOLTNA had booked an angle without those involved in it under contract, leading to a farce in which the Fortune stable turned face and were revealed to be ‘They’, even though they were fretting about ‘They’ days earlier.


2012 - WHO Was Getting The Diesel Push?!

Brodus Clay
WWE.com

Brodus Clay was meant to debut as a big monster heel in early 2012.

This was no secret; WWE aired several vignettes on television teasing his arrival. It was generic fare - Brodus Clay vows no mercy against his foes, etc. - but this stuff went on for weeks, which half-made you think the guy would be presented as a big deal. Add to that the fact that he was very large, Vince-sized, and there was a tentative optimism surrounding the new character. This was 2011, remember, something you might recall as the “stop/start era”. Any push, any reason to actually engage with the product, would have sufficed back then.

Onscreen authority figure John Laurinaitis kept delaying the debut, which was odd, but taken by some as a way of building anticipation. All those dithering is just gonna piss the big feller off, leading to even more destruction!

Meltzer was thinking along these lines too, or was told, writing in the January 9 Observer “Brodus Clay, if he actually does start on TV this century, is being talked about as far as being the Kane/Nash monster who cleans the ring in this year’s Rumble”.

While it was nice that WWE seemed to care about a newish full-time wrestler for once, this seemed ambitious. Anybody who watched NXT knew that Clay, despite his mean face and impressive size, was somehow not remotely intimidating. He was bobbins in the ring even before the big guy standard was raised throughout the decade.

A shockingly prescient WWE seemed to grasp this; cutting out the obligatory half-push before the big lad became a novelty act, Clay was immediately presented as a prehistoric funk enthusiast nicknamed ‘the Funkasaurus’.


2013 - John Morrison Was Rumoured To Be A Surprise Entrant

John Morrison
WWE

This was a strange one.

John Morrison left WWE, as the company itself acknowledged, on November 29, 2011. He wasn’t released; his contract had expired, and as he revealed to Steve Austin on his podcast in 2015, his neck was banged up and he was creatively frustrated.

He’d been in WWE for a long time, felt stale, and had done everything he seemed capable of doing. Never a main event-level talent, Morrison was good for a good midcard match, but had done that endless loop over and over again.

It was reported in the January 28, 2013 Observer that “the word within wrestling is that Morrison will be in the Rumble as a surprise”.

What?

John Morrison didn’t seem to fit the mystery cameo criteria at all. He had only missed just over a year of TV, meaning there hadn’t been anywhere near enough to time miss him and bask in any nostalgia. And, not to be too harsh, it wasn’t as if there was any fervent clamour for his full-time return. Does he even get a pop?

Wrestlers are very paranoid, gossipy people. They think everybody is working them in some way. They are quick to latch onto any narrative whatsoever. This makes sense of the reasoning Dave provided: “Morrison is only working the first night of the three Dragon Gate shows in California”.

A few wrestlers who talked to Dave must have connected some dots here, and jumped to a poorly thought-out conclusion. They might have been high - and on that subject, the Godfather was 2013’s actual mystery guest.


2014 - WWE Was Actually Doing What You Wanted

Daniel Bryan
WWE

WWE’s booking felt antagonistic under twilight-years, worm-brained Vince McMahon. A lot of it was, too; former WWE creative writer Dave Schilling has revealed that Vince said “f*ck ‘em” when he was told that fans hated the idea of the Kurt Angle Vs. Baron Corbin retirement match at WrestleMania 35.

WWE’s reputation was so low in 2014 that fans developed a paranoid, siege mentality - which was mostly entirely justified - but according to the February 3 Observer, WWE wasn’t trying to piss you off at Royal Rumble 2015. Well, they were, but not for the lols.

Apparently, WWE did not withdraw Daniel Bryan from the Rumble because they were scared that his popularity would dwarf Batista’s: Bryan was never once intended for the Rumble because WWE wanted the Yes! Movement to unfold deeper into the year. Royal Rumble 2014 is considered one of the most humiliatingly out-of-touch nights in WWE history - but the company actively sought this response. Bryan was meant to use his absence from the Rumble as fuel to drive his anti-Authority storyline in the aftermath of WrestleMania 30. WWE had hoped, by not announcing Bryan for the Rumble match and installing him on the undercard, that fans would grasp the idea and wait.

The problem was that WWE fans did not trust the company to execute the long-term plan. Batista’s (rejected) return in the babyface role was terrible, timing-wise. He looked too much like Bryan’s antithesis. Also, WWE had already alienated fans with its overthought, meta booking in late 2013. It felt like Triple H was having too much fun mocking Bryan.

WWE cried wolf: the company that had buried fan favourite talent buried a fan favourite, and expected a patient, trusting response.

Not best for business.


2015 - The REAL Origin Of AEW

The Rock Roman Reigns
WWE

In the pre-Triple H era, with the audience shrinking, many jaded fans had their own “I’m out” moment.

The Summer of Punk cooling off the most bold character WWE had pushed in years. The repeated, destructive use of Brock Lesnar in the late 2010s. The debacle that was Hell In A Cell 2019.

These are examples of anecdotal, impulse reactions. One wrestling analyst tracked the actual data, and the ramifications of it might well have altered the landscape of the industry.

Roman Reigns won the 2015 Royal Rumble match, throughout which he was presented as “he’s at least more popular than Kane and the Big Show”. The Attitude Era dinosaurs tossed out the internet darlings like they were bags of trash. Really, there’s no need for the simile there; this is precisely how the physical act looked. And that was the point: WWE told you that your favourites are rubbish, and you need to get behind the heroic Roman Reigns. This inspired the hysterical #CancelWWENetwork hashtag, which drew the usual response - stop being dramatic, you won’t stop watching - but according to the pattern Brandon Thurston of Wrestlenomics drilled into, you actually did.

Thurston determined that this was the moment that you and your friend Mark actually did stop watching: Raw’s viewership drop outpaced the wider decline of TV trends, and the flagship programme informed the worst WrestleMania season ratings drop-off since 1996.

Indirectly, this might have ultimately created the demand for an alternative, allowing AEW to enter the marketplace. AEW doesn’t exist if WWE fans are happy - and they were at their least happy in January 2015.


2016 - "The Boys" Thought Daniel Bryan Was Coming Back

WWE WrestleMania 34 Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

The 2016 Royal Rumble wasn’t as egregious as the prior two events - or maybe that’s because fury had mutated into apathy.

For the third year in a row, the match was pitched to ultimately put over a musclebound office favourite in an age of the hardcore darling going mainstream. Triple H won the match, and the WWE championship, with the very predictable and even more unpopular aim of putting Roman Reigns over at WrestleMania 32. The Big Dog Era continued. This was quite literally a punishing time to be a WWE fan: you could not have been more vocal or explicit in telling the company what you did not want to see, and not only did you get it anyway, you got it in the least dramatic and most insulting way imaginable. Roman Reigns, the ultimate WWE project, going up against the Authority?

What?

A rather cruel rumour surfaced - thankfully - after the Rumble. If it had made the rounds before the PLE itself, Roman would have been even less popular. He was already the 2016 Josh Briggs.

As Dave Meltzer wrote in the February 1 Observer, “at least some of the talent was expecting Bryan to return at the Rumble”.

People jumped to conclusions here based on the idea that Bryan had just been cleared by UCLA doctors. WWE and Dr. Joseph Maroon would not clear him until, in a medical miracle, he was good to go in 2018, when NJPW got hot stateside and the inaugural All In had been announced.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!