One MIND-BLOWING Secret From Every WWE Royal Rumble
2017 - The Start Of A Terrible Trend
By 2017, the Royal Rumble match was showing its age.
While there’s a timeless magic to the attraction, which will forever work as a means of advancing multiple storylines, cool innovations had withered into tropes all those decades later. The ‘Diesel’ run wasn’t the first step towards a massively committed top guy push; it was just the done thing for a hoss to do. The mystery entrant had lost its charm; the fun was forced, the tone too comedic and silly.
At its very core, the purpose of the match had achieved the opposite effect: you were meant to be excited about WrestleMania season, but this was no longer possible when the main event scene was so uninspiring.
In 1992, Ric Flair’s legendary marathon stamina was conveyed to WWF fans by his epic ‘Iron Man’ stint. He lasted one hour and two seconds in a winning performance, and even though the story dictated that he narrowly survived through his expert grasp of the dark arts, he still registered five eliminations.
WWE grew incredibly lazy with this same idea in the years since. The idea was that it was somehow impressive for a wrestler to stay in the match without doing anything, as if Michael Cole updating you on the timer was going to get them over. This reached a pointless nadir in 2017, when Sami Zayn lasted 47 minutes in the match - without recording a single elimination.
Without even trying to be snarky or negative, the only way to describe this booking is as a complete waste of time.
2018 - The Curse Was Broken…Or Was It?
Actual curses are not real - but a wildly improbable statistical convergence is just as fascinating.
It was said for years that the #14 spot in the Royal Rumble was “cursed”. Marty Jannetty (1989) refers to himself as ‘God’s Amusement Toy’, he feels his luck is that rotten. The British Bulldog (1991) and Hercules (1992) passed away at no age at all. The Berzerker (1993) lasted just two more dates with the WWF. Jacob Blu (1995) didn’t last much longer. Doug Gilbert (1996) all but torched his own career with a wild 1999 shoot promo on Jerry Lawler. Dustin ‘Goldust’ Rhodes (1997) spent years battling addiction thereafter.
Some names went unaffected, which renders the theory a load of old b*llocks, but the case of Joey Mercury (2006) is striking; he started the year as #14, and ended it with an exploded face after suffering one of the most revolting in-ring accidents ever.
The “curse” can be explained by two factors.
Firstly, the wave of premature wrestler death was not the result of a curse, but rather an unregulated industry that imposed far too much demand on its overworked contractors.
Secondly, on those who left the company shortly thereafter, the number #14 is itself the explanation. Exciting talents arrive early, to fire up the crowd. Important wrestlers enter later, to ramp up the stakes. Those in the middle are often just midcard acts there to make up the numbers. The most expendable wrestlers are more likely to come out at #14, as opposed to #1, #2, or #30.
But not Shinsuke Nakamura, who broke the “curse” by entering at #14 in 2018 before winning the whole thing. Or did he?
He lost at WrestleMania 34, never won a World title, and spent the next several years as just another bloke on the roster.
2019 - WWE Wanted To Debut The Elite
On December 17, 2018, The McMahon Family - minus Linda, who you wouldn’t have noticed regardless - opened Monday Night Raw.
Ratings were in the toilet, gates were poor, and the product was so unspeakably awful that even WWE, encased in its arrogant bubble, had to apologise, beg for forgiveness, and promise its fanbase that it would get better. Vince McMahon still told the crowd that he knew better than them within seconds, but the fact that he entertained the idea in the first place was incredible.
This wasn’t just a stunt, nor a means of buying some time and goodwill: WWE promised actual, elusive change because the promotion had convinced themselves that they’d just brought in three absolute game-changers: Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks, who at the time were the most acclaimed and talked-about characters in the entire industry. This was a massive coup: WWE had “signed” the three guys who didn’t need its machine to get over. Imagine how successful they’d be, if the machine got behind them.
WWE was convinced they’d got their men because the terms of the deal were unprecedented. Omega and the Bucks were offered main event-level money from the off and a major storyline they would be allowed to approve - which never happened in the NXT era - but the unprecedented part was an “out” clause. If the Elite weren’t happy after the first few months, they would be allowed to leave, no questions asked.
In the January 14 Observer, a look into the launch announcement of All Elite Wrestling, Meltzer wrote “those who work in WWE with knowledge of the deal were certain [Omega and the Bucks] wouldn’t turn it down, and outright told me they would be debuting at the Rumble, and had a Rumble-to-Mania significant storyline”.
Obviously, this didn’t happen, but it was a clever play; even if the Elite did bail after signing, their romantic aura as the wrestlers who stuck it to WWE would have tarnished the launch of AEW, if it was still able to even get off the ground.
2020 - The Choice Of Winner Went Down To The Wire
In 2018, WWE’s standing was so wretched that the McMahons apologised for the product in a notorious televised segment.
2019, somehow, was much worse - an inscrutable mess of dropped storylines and asinine creative choices. WWE was never critically acclaimed for long stretches of time after 2001, but in 2019, the promotion was drawing unfavourable (and thoroughly warranted) comparisons to 2000 WCW. In 2019, Cedric Alexander posed as a janitor that Shane McMahon and Drew McIntyre had selected as Roman Reign’s partner as a joke. Cedric took the fall. He still celebrated as if he’d just concocted some diabolically clever ruse. In the same year, ‘Big Dog’ Roman Reigns was presented as a literal hound as Baron Corbin smothered him in dog food.
Obviously, WWE was hardly awash with over babyface stars at this time. One year on from the apology and the promise of improvement, the WrestleMania 36 card looked bleak, nonexistent even, on paper.
WWE had two choices as Brock Lesnar’s opponent; both were categorised as “babyfaces they hadn’t ruined yet”. In an indictment, one of those guys had just turned. Drew McIntyre, or Aleister Black?
While Black had received strong support internally, backed by Paul Heyman in particular, WWE opted for Drew very close to the wire. WWE made the correct decision; Drew McIntyre was a serviceable champion in a cursed era, and the fact that he was unable to celebrate his big moment in front of crowds informed one of the better characters under Paul Levesque’s regime.
2021 - We Nearly Saw A Sequel To A Famous Cinematic Match
At WrestleMania 36, WWE presented a ‘Firefly Fun House’ match between Bray Wyatt and John Cena.
It was hardly a match at all, rather a pandemic-enforced short film, and it was weirdly incredible for what it was: a shocking exploration of John Cena’s flawed psyche. It was visually arresting, the only time an empty arena WrestleMania actually felt worthy of the name, and the reveal that Cena was a politicking bully all along was catharsis for all those awful years of his mean-spirited top guy run. It wasn’t just stunning for what it was; it was stunning that WWE would do it.
The Fiend’s programme with Randy Orton deeper into 2020 was less well-received. That’s probably because the Fiend created a demonic doppelganger of Orton, who was never seen afterwards, before the real Orton murdered the Fiend with fire. It culminated at WrestleMania 37, during which Alexa, sitting atop a “box-like structure”, turned on Wyatt with a goo-assisted distraction.
It was meant to be advanced at the 2021 Royal Rumble; in a report originally written by Ringside News and corroborated by the January 4 Observer, a Firefly Fun House match had been added to the schedule. Obviously, this didn’t happen - but what might it have looked like?
Cena’s rep took a beating in the first Fun House match. Wyatt depicted him as a homophobe and fake good guy who did nothing more than punch down at his opponents. How would the Fiend have tormented Orton in that mental prison?
Perhaps it might have included a Brian de Palma-length take of Orton’s chinlock to mock how boring he is. We’ll never know.
2022 - Forgotten Memories Of The Night Shane McMahon Lost His Head
It was torturous enough, when Shane McMahon turned up in 2016 and decided that he was Royce Gracie. The man thought he was Pat Patterson when he was inexplicably tasked with laying out the men’s 2022 Royal Rumble match.
This was such a bizarre happening, particularly since Shane didn’t seem factored in; he’d lost to Braun Strowman at WrestleMania 37 and promptly disappeared. You’d have expected him to return, if at all, in some midcard feud or other. The talent was brought back from the void as the high-ranking executive responsible for setting the stage for WrestleMania (!).
What you’ll probably remember is that Shane wanted to portray himself as a total badass in a competitive spot with Brock Lesnar. It was of critical importance to Shane that you thought he was a tough guy. You might also recall that Vince disagreed with Shane’s idea, which caused Shane to allegedly throw a backstage tantrum when his father sided with Brock. As funny as this might seem - a billionaire’s hyperhidrosis-afflicted kid crying when he didn’t get his own way - there was probably some very bleak familial psychological trauma rising to the surface here.
What you might not remember is that, per Fightful Select, Shane wanted to come out as #1. That is mental. Shane wanted to be Haku and Shawn Michaels at the same time: a living overpowered CAW.
Also, Shane was meant to enter after Randy Orton as #29. For whatever reason, the order was switched, and per Fightful Select, Orton via “verbal cues” instructed Shane to ignore the original plan and go out when his music hit.
Did Orton say “Stupid, stupid, stupid”, or “Get the f*ck out there now”?
You decide.
2023 - Incontrovertible Proof That Vince McMahon SUCKED
Remember in the late 2010s, when you couldn’t criticise WWE’s irredeemable slop without running into some woeful “six stars in Tokyo Dome” joke? And then in 2022, when Triple H took over creative, those same defenders were really glad that Vince McMahon was gone, now that WWE had been saved?
Saved from what: the great action that you were biased for thinking was abject rubbish?
Halcyon days.
Vince McMahon killed the joy of the Royal Rumble match. 2022’s edition might have been worse than even 2015: it was a total waste of an hour dedicated almost exclusively to a booking troll-job. Lesnar won LOL. At least in 2015, Vince had a harebrained idea to get a new babyface over. In 2022, he executed the least inspiring idea possible, and took an eternity to get to it.
In stunning contrast, the 2023 Royal Rumble was a record-breaking smash of a PLE that formalised the third WWE boom.
According to the February 6 Observer, Dave Meltzer was told that “two million people watched [on Peacock]” - meaning that it was seen by more people than WrestleMania 28, which, in drawing 1,219,000 buys, was WWE’s most successful PPV ever. The higher cost of the 2012 show shouldn’t be ignored, but regardless: the 2023 Royal Rumble was a monster of a smash. Moreover, the gate out-drew the previous Rumble high by a staggering $2.5 million.
This is more subjective, but the scene in which Sami Zayn turned on Roman Reigns was one of the most well-received angles in WWE history. Triple H restored faith in the event at the first time of asking.
2024 - WWE Wanted An Attitude Era Star
The surprise entrant in the men’s 2024 Royal Rumble match was Pat McAfee. While popular amongst many fans, this felt more like another sign that McAfee is now fully integrated into the backstage “boy’s club” than a well-intentioned treat for the fans.
A year later, YouTube star IShowSpeed was selected for the spot, and as awesome as it was, it represented a shift in direction. Gone are the days of a wrestler from a previous generation doing a tight five for a nostalgia pop. WWE wants to go viral. They don’t want to raise a smile on the faces of the older ultras; there are too many young fans to aggressively target.
This might not be a forever change, though, since a star from yesteryear was rumoured to appear in 2024 in a surprise capacity - and there was substance to the report, too.
Sean ‘X-Pac’ Waltman downplayed the talk on his own X account, saying that, while he can still go “at the drop of a hat” and perform virtually all of his old repertoire, there was “zero chance” he’d be in the Rumble, since he was at least a month away from confidently taking his shirt off in public. While this type of thing is dreamed up by optimistic fans every winter, Meltzer reported in the January 22 Observer that “there was interest in him from the WWE side”.
Hopefully, this interest has not waned; few deserve the pop more than the guy unfairly defined by growing stale. X-Pac didn’t have a great 2000 - but there wouldn’t be a stylistic revolution without his early 1990s.
2025 - A TNA Legend Was “So Close” To Entering
A few times, WWE didn’t need to fly anybody in to cast an old feller as a surprise entrant; as an example, in 2021, the Hurricane made his second appearance as a ‘Legend’. This was cheap and easy to facilitate, since Gregory Helms was working as a producer. He was already there; he just needed to bring his gear to the show.
On that basis, Joseph ‘Abyss’ Park could very feasibly enter the Royal Rumble; he too is currently employed as a producer. Longtime fans would love to see Abyss get his “moment” in a WWE ring. Park did play the “statistician” of AJ Styles, in a cute “if you know, you know” cameo, but it hardly counts.
They aren’t alone.
As recently revealed on the What Do You Want To Talk About? podcast, Cody Rhodes attempts to force the issue on an annual basis. Kevin Owens supports him on this crusade, and without specifying when this happened, said “it came so close one year”. As wonderful as the idea sounds, would Abyss get the pop he deserves for doing great work under the mainstream radar in the 2000s?
This is a new WWE audience, and it’s hard to pinpoint what they’re into or are even aware of. Jordynne Grace got a pop at the Royal Rumble, but, of all fans, the post-WrestleMania crowd barely seemed to recognise Rusev this year.
There’s another reason why it’s very unlikely to happen; as Owens himself said, Park has lost too much weight, and shambles around the gorilla position with the retired wrestler’s walk.