10 Greatest Central Midfielders In Premier League History
The most important middle men in the world's greatest football league competition.
Neal Simpson/EMPICS SPORTAny side with ambitions of winning the Premier League title needs to have a solid spine, a dependable goalkeeper first of all, the likes of Peter Schmeichel, Petr Cech or Edwin Van Der Sar. Two reliable defenders willing to put their body on the line for the team, the likes of John Terry, Jamie Carragher, Nemanja Vidic, Sol Campbell or Vincent Kompany. A striker that can put the ball in the back of the net is surely a must too, Thierry Henry, Alan Shearer, Didier Drogba, Wayne Rooney or Cristiano Ronaldo, possibly. But for any great team, perhaps most crucial of all is to have solid central midfield base. One which can fill in and support the defence when needed, but also provide the ammunition for the likes of Henry and Shearer to finish, with an impeccably weighted through-ball or pin-point set piece delivery - they might even be perfectly capable of a grabbing a goal or two themselves. Ultimately, the best midfielders are often the ones who can do a bit of everything; the complete midfielder, you might say. This article will look at the top 10 central midfielders in Premier League history.
10. Michael Essien
Andres Kudacki/AP/Press Association ImagesClub: Chelsea When Chelsea signed Michael Essien from Lyon for £24.4million in 2005, he became the clubs then-record signing, and inevitably there was immediately a huge amount of pressure on the no-nonsense Ghanaian to justify his price tag. With Claude Makelele a permanent fixture in the Blues holding midfield position, Essien was able to perform his preferred role of box-to-box midfielder, allowing him to contribute both defensively and going forward. And he proved to be the perfect foil for Frank Lampard, unsettling opposition players with his tenacious, tough-tackling style, whilst also being extremely comfortable in possession. Essiens main attribute though was his power, as he looked to dominate the midfield area by out-muscling even the strongest of opponents, and in 2007 he won Chelseas Fans Player of the Year award, whilst also being consistently nominated for World Player of the Year during his most successful years. Those years may have passed now though, as the 31-year-old appears to be somewhat past his best since suffering a dreaded anterior cruciate ligament injury in 2008. Nevertheless, Essien will always be remembered as one of the best ever Premier League midfielders.
9. Cesc Fabregas
Neal Simpson/EMPICS SportClub: Arsenal (and now Chelsea) When Barcelona, the best side in the world at the time, pay over £25million to re-sign a player they lost for nothing at academy level, you know that player is a special talent. At the age of just 16, believing that his first-team opportunities would be limited at the Catalan club, Fabregas signed for Arsenal and would go on to spend eight fantastic years there, establishing himself as one of the clubs greatest ever midfielders and even being appointed club captain at just 21-years-old. Fabregas is one of the Premier Leagues all-time leading assist-makers and thats no surprise really given the players unselfish nature and wonderful eye for a through-ball. Not many midfielders can open up a defence with one swipe of a boot like the Spaniard but from next season it is the Gunners North London rivals Chelsea who will reap the rewards. Many Arsenal fans will feel let down by the players decision to join the Blues, but thats probably not entirely fair given that Fabregas would probably have opted to re-join Arsenal had Arsene Wenger not decided against bidding for the 27-year-old. Arsenal have Aaron Ramsey now who could find himself in a similar list of top Premier League midfielders in five years time, should he continue his fine form from the last campaign and so its time for the club to move on.
8. Yaya Toure
Media Image LtdClub: Man City In a poll conducted last season, Barcelona fans voted Yaya Toure as the player they would most like to re-sign, and given that they already have the likes of Xavi, Andreas Iniesta and Sergio Busquets in his position, thats some compliment. The Ivorian powerhouse obviously impressed Barca fans during his three years at the club, and he clearly impressed Manchester City too as they paid around £24million for his services in 2010 a fee which now appears to have been a steal. Toure has led City to two league title wins during his time at the club, often being seen as the teams most crucial and irreplaceable player, alongside captain Vincent Kompany perhaps. The 31-year-olds pace, power and ability to shrug an opponent off the ball and coast past like hes not there sets him aside from any midfielder in world football at the moment. Nonetheless, Toure has had his fallings out with the Sky Blues in recent times, with the players agent claiming that he may leave the club after they failed to satisfactorily wish him happy birthday. If he were to leave, the likes of Barcelona and Paris Saint-Germain would surely be interested in securing his signature, although City fans will be hoping that he goes nowhere.
7. Xabi Alonso
Peter Byrne/PA Archive/Press Association ImagesClub: Liverpool Whats that old saying? You dont know what youve got until its gone? In the summer of 2008, Liverpool manager Rafael Benitez set about signing Gareth Barry from Aston Villa the transfer didnt go through, but it left Xabi Alonso feeling very much like he was looking to be replaced, and next summer the unsettled star left Merseyside for Spanish giants Real Madrid. It signalled the end of what many would consider one of the best midfields in Premier League history Alonso, Javier Mascherano and Steven Gerrard which had come so close to contributing towards a Liverpool Premier League title win in 2008/09. Mascherano, who himself could have quite justifiably made this list of top 10 midfielders, provided the tough tackling alongside one the greatest passers the league his ever seen in Alonso. His ability to pick a diagonal pass and execute it to perfection was better than almost any player in Premier League history; in fact many might argue that he was the best at it. His aptitude at controlling games too was magnificent, and allowed Gerrard to influence the game further forward, safe in the knowledge that he had left the deep-lying playmaker role in capable hands (or feet). It wasnt just passing that Alonso had mastered though, the World Cup winner also had a knack for scoring spectacular goals from his own half. What Liverpool fans would give to have Alonso back at the club next season.
6. Claude Makelele
Tony Marshall/EMPICS SportClub: Chelsea What can be said about Claude Makelele that hasnt been said time and time again already? The guy was a genius, and a true master at what he did, effectively inventing the holding midfield role (in English football at least) and setting the precedent for what it takes to be truly world class in that position. When Claudio Ranieri brought Makelele to Chelsea for £16.8million in 2003 alongside the likes of Damien Duff and Hernan Crespo, he perhaps wasnt the most high-profile signing of the lot, as Chelsea fans got excited about the influx of attacking talent amongst Roman Abramovichs spending-spree. In fact, it was Makeleles supreme discipline which allowed the likes of Duff, Crespo, Frank Lampard, Arjen Robben and Didier Drogba to fire the Blues to two league titles during the Frenchmans time at the club. Chelseas whole system was centred around Makelele and allowing him to dictate the tempo of a game, whilst also being the one to break up play when the opposition attacked and he was quite frankly faultless at performing both roles. Such was Makeleles defensive restraint at Chelsea that he hadnt scored a single goal during his first two seasons at the club that was until he was allowed to take a penalty against Charlton after Mourinhos men had already secured the Premier League title. The former Real Madrid man even missed the spot kick, but bundled the ball home on the rebound to the delight of the fans and his teammates.
Joint 4th Roy Keane & Patrick Vieira
Sean Dempsey/PA Archive/Press Association ImagesHow can you separate Roy Keane and Patrick Vieira? Two inspirational captains who led their respective teams to numerous league titles and cup wins, two truly magnificent players who undoubtedly had the talent to match their leadership qualities the answer is you cant simply separate them. Keane made 326 league appearances for Manchester United and Vieira made 279 for Arsenal, with both quite fittingly leaving the Premier League in 2005 to end what had been a famous rivalry between the two players. Both midfielders epitomised everything that was great about their clubs during their successful periods; the pride, the passion, the never-say-die attitude which was a necessity in order to win the number of trophies they did. Both have a nasty side too though; in 1999 Vieira was banned for six matches for spitting at Neil Ruddock, whilst Keane admitted in his 2002 autobiography that he purposely set about injuring Manchester Citys Alf-Inge Haaland following a career-ending knee-high challenge. He said: I'd waited long enough. I f***ing hit him hard. The ball was there (I think). Take that you c***. And don't ever stand over me sneering about fake injuries. But love them or hate them, the ability of both players cannot be questioned, and they are two of the best footballers the Premier League have ever seen. In a modern era of defensive and attacking midfielders, when players that tend to specialise in either one or the other, these two could do both better than most, they were complete midfielders, even if they did enjoy the odd scuffle.
3. Frank Lampard
Media Image LtdClubs: West Ham And Chelsea Frank Lampard has scored 251 goals in his club career; take that in for a second. Its an unfathomable amount of goals when you consider that he has spent his whole career as a central midfielder. Almost any top class striker would be delighted to score that many goals in their career most dont get anywhere near it. The fact that hes only third in this list, ridiculous as it may sound given his number of goals, should pay testament to the players above him, rather than be seen as a criticism of Lampards ability; had the 36-year-old claimed the top spot on this list then nobody could have batted an eyelid. With 171 goals he is fifth on the list of all-time Premier League goal scorers, 60 ahead of any other central midfielder, but it is not just his ability to put the ball in the net that makes him such a top player, as he has an exceptional passing range and possesses a particularly dangerous set-piece delivery. But theres no doubt that his knack for arriving late into the box and being in the right place at the right time to finish is what has made him such a unique talent over the years. In June, Chelsea confirmed that Frank Lampard would leave the club after 13 years of service, and theres no doubt they will miss the former English Player of the Year winner's goals.
2. Steven Gerrard
Media Image Ltd.Club: Liverpool Liverpool have had some outstanding footballers over the years, the likes of Kenny Dalglish, John Barnes, Jamie Carragher, Ian Rush, Robbie Fowler, Kevin Keegan, Graeme Souness, Luis Suarez, Ray Clemence, Alan Hansen the list is almost endless yet many Reds fans consider Steven Gerrard to be the clubs greatest ever player, and its clear to see why. Time and time again the Liverpool skipper has almost single-handedly driven his club to victory from a seemingly impossible situation, the 2005 Champions League final against AC Milan being a prime example of such, and if there was one player you would want to take a game by the scruff of the neck when hope is almost lost then its Steven Gerrard. That said, there has been the occasional error amongst the brilliance too think of his back-passes to Didier Drogba and Thierry Henry, or the slip which allowed Demba Ba to slot home for Chelsea last season and perhaps if Gerrard had led Liverpool to a Premier League title win then he would be top of this list, because he is arguably the most complete player the Premier League has ever seen. His passing range remains sublime, he is deceptively strong in tackle, his pace and power were, at least in his younger days, surprisingly imposing and he will always be a leader of men. To stop Liverpool over the years has largely meant stopping Steven Gerrard playing, which on his day can be an impossible task. He has been included in the PFA Team of the Year eight times, which is a Premier League record, and joins the likes of Ronaldo, David Beckham, Zinedine Zidane, Ronaldinho, Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi as a former UEFA Club Footballer of the Year winner. Gerrard, like the one player that is ahead of him on this list, has adapted to suit different roles over the years as his team has required him to do so. As well as a box to box midfielder he has played behind the striker, on the wing and most recently as more of a deep-sitting midfielder as the inevitable effects of aging begin to gradually take its toll. Not that you would notice, because at the moment Gerrard looks as good as ever, and Liverpool fans will be hoping that remains the case for a long time yet, and that he continues to lead his team on the pitch.
1. Paul Scholes
Mike Egerton/EMPICS SportClub: Manchester United When two of the greatest midfielders in recent times give their backing to a player like Paul Scholes, its hard to argue that anybody else should be top of this list. In 2010, French World Cup winner Zinedine Zidane described Paul Scholes as the complete player, whilst lamenting the fact that he never had the chance to play alongside him in his career. Likewise, Spanish World Cup winner Xavi said this in 2011: In the last 15 to 20 years the best central midfielder that I have seen the most complete is Scholes. He is a spectacular player who has everything. He can play the final pass, he can score, he is strong, he never gets knocked off the ball and he doesnt give possession away. If he had been Spanish then maybe he would have been valued more.So what else can be said that Xavi has not already highlighted? Not only can Scholes play the final pass but, like Alonso and Gerrard who featured earlier in this list, his long-range passing ability is exquisite second to none, in fact. His capacity to control a game is unparalleled too, when Scholes is at his best you dont get near him, it doesnt matter who you are. Actually, like Gerrard, it was only later in the former Manchester United players career that he began to drop so deep to control games before that he would just control games from all over the pitch except then he had a significant goal threat too, scoring a remarkable 107 Premier League goals during his career. Manchester United have never truly replaced Scholes since he retired, Michael Carrick has generally done a superb job of attempting to fill the void, but hes no Paul Scholes, who is? Such was the extent which United were missing his dominating presence that Sir Alex Ferguson had to persuade him to come out of retirement in 2012, although perhaps that said more about Man Utds lack of quality in central midfield at that time. Then again, how many times have England managers tried to convince the fiery-headed playmaker to come out of international retirement too? This was despite Scholes never quite reproducing his best club form for his country, although maybe that had something to do with him being stuck out on the left to accommodate Gerrard and Lampard at times. Nobody is perfect though, and Scholes did have one flaw, quite an obvious one in fact, his tackling. He became renowned for his infamous mistimed, typical Paul Scholes tackle, often flying into challenges and picking up yellow cards not such a typical Spanish midfielder after all, right Xavi? But he can be more than forgiven for the occasional misdemeanour given that were talking about one of the greatest English players of the modern generation, and surely the greatest central midfielder in Premier League history. Which other Premier League midfielders do you think belong on this list? Share your picks below in the comments thread.