10 Idiotic Decisions Made By Former Newcastle Players

And they thought joining Newcastle was their biggest mistake...

When it comes to making decisions and looking after themselves, modern footballers aren't always the best influence on themselves. That's precisely why the biggest stars - and Nicolas Anelka - surround themselves with the toxic gaggle of advisors, agents, financial assistants and distantly related family members to help guide their careers to the big time. Inevitably, as with any company that tries to rule by committee, a lot of the decisions that result from the consultation period end up being ill-advised - Demba Ba chased Champions League football to Chelsea and was rewarded with a permanent place on the bench after all and he was notoriously assisted by any number of advisors. But it isn't just the outside influences who are a problem: those characters were only able to get a grip on players because on their own they're capable of far worse feats of idiocy. Why else would Paul Merson join Middlesbrough only to come to his senses? Why would Clarence Acuna choose to drink drive dressed as Captain Hook? It might be a cliche to say it, but footballers prove themselves not to be the smartest bunch all too often, and the decisions made by players leaving Newcastle - or those who had already moved on - are astonishingly good at proving just that point...

10. Loic Remy Joined Chelsea's Bench

We should probably all have read the signs. As soon as mercurial Frenchman Loic Remy decided that a big pile of cash was all the footballing reasons he needed to join QPR at the last minute instead of moving to Newcastle as planned in January 2013 it should have been clear that he wasn't a good idea. But then with QPR inevitably relegated and Newcastle missing Demba Ba, Joe Kinnear pretended he'd pulled off a master-stroke to bring the player back to the club - initially on loan - and everyone forgave the mercenary for following the cash South. After that though, Remy lost some fans by refusing to entertain the idea of coming to Newcastle permanently, choosing Liverpool and the chance to watch Rickie Lambert bang the goals in from the bench. That bid fell at the last hurdle, and Remy was again linked to Newcastle, with fans again willing to forgive and forget, before Remy did what he does best and signed for Chelsea, where he will be a near-permanent fixture on the bench with Diego Costa on fire ahead of him in the pecking order. Remy won't stay at Chelsea wrong, and in footballing terms - the terms he claims matter to him most - his decision to join them is a silly one, as his opportunities to play will be severely limited. He could have been a hero at Newcastle, and instead he's opted to be just another number on a payroll.

9. Tino Asprilla Showed His Love Of Guns A Little Too Publicly

Columbian striker Tino was never shy of attracting controversy, even when he was at Newcastle United: he was a big fixture on the social scenes, even before games, and continued to make appearances on the bongos in any nightclub that would have him years after he left. But it was away from the football pitch - and thankfully, mostly after he left Tyneside as a player that he became the unhinged character that he is now generally known to be. Asprilla famously has something of a fondness for guns, having taken a toy gun into training and "motivate" team-mates, and in 2008 used his hobby to gain vengeance against some over-zealous security guards who refused to let his friends through a check-point. Rather than writing a strongly worded letter, Tino went to confront the guards with his machine gun, and peppered their security post with 29 bullets. Immediately afterwards, he seemed to suggest that he was being framed:
"In fact, it reminds me of a movie that I once saw called Minority Report with Tom Cruise, in which people end up in jail even before you've committed the crime or even been tried."
Inevitably, he was arrested, though he bizarrely later claimed that he was released for being too difficult:
€œI spent 10 days in prison, then they couldn€™t handle me anymore..."
Tino did somewhat redeem his image by turning his back on a move to Darlington however, leaving definitely-not-dodgy George Reynolds gutted.

8. Charles N'Zogbia Went Looking For Champions League Football... At Wigan

Despite being a fan favourite for a while at Newcastle, Charles N'Zogbia's profile took a couple of serious dints towards the end of his time on Tyneside. First, he fell out with Andy Carroll, earning himself a sore face from the notoriously quick to violence striker and then Joe Kinnear "hilariously" came out and called him Charles Insomnia, earning accusations of disrespect and an almighty grump from the player who demanded to leave. In fact, the Frenchman had wanted to leave the club already, and his lack of first-team opportunities was just the catalyst he needed in 2008 to say, rather self-servingly, that his sights were set on a bigger club and a bigger stage for his talents. With Arsenal and PSG linked, he told L'Equipe: "After four years at Newcastle, I want to reach a higher level of ambition. I don't think that is possible here. I have given my all to the club, and I will go on to do so as long as I play. But I would like to reach a new level by finding a new challenge at a new side." N'Zogbia flirted outrageously with Arsenal in the hope of making a move to a Champions League side, and then hilariously ended up at Wigan, where he impressed, but not while playing at the "higher level" club he so openly craved.

7. Pretty Much Everything Nile Ranger Has Ever Done

You'd have thought that Nile Ranger's arrest and imprisonment at the age of 15 might have turned him away from a life of controversy, but having been given a second chance at Newcastle - signed by fellow bad-boy Dennis Wise no less - the gangly striker took it upon himself to upset as many authorities as possible. First he was arrested on suspicion of assault (found not guilty), then he was charged with being drunk and disorderly twice in Newcastle, and this came after he was cautioned by the club over his posing with a replica gun in a photograph. He's also been fined for homophobic comments on Twitter, arrested for assault several times and criminal damage and common assault, and then he annoyed his new club Swindon - who he joined after being released by Newcastle - with his disrespectful attitude, leading to him being sacked. Even after two sackings, he was again arrested for criminal damage (twice) and drew controversial attention for apparently punching a female companion in the face. The now Blackpool player has all but thrown away his talent - and it was once thought to be sizeable - thanks to a series of idiotic lifestyle choices, and an inability to moderate his temper, and he can probably look forward to a second rate career as a journeyman striker with a tarnished profile.

6. Jose Enrique Joined Liverpool And Grew A Hitler Tash

Newcastle fans are rarely treated to anything as instantly gratifying as what happened to Jose Enrique when he left for Liverpool and the promise of European football and title challenges: his new side famously finished below Newcastle and he suffered the indignity of having to go in goal after Pepe Reina was sent off at St. James Park in a heart-warming Liverpool defeat. He was jeered, his decision insulted and the grass proclaimed far less green on Merseyside. And even though Enrique's team have now overcome those issues under Brendan Rodgers and only just missed out on the title last season at the last hurdle, but their renaissance has been very much despite the Spanish defender. He has been dropped, injured or unfancied, and is far from first-choice at Anfield, and it looks like he made the wrong decision entirely in joining Liverpool when he could probably have gone elsewhere. And then if that wasn't enough, he's just published a picture of himself on Instagram with what can only be described as a Hitler moustache.

5. John Carver Tried To Fight A Fanbase

When Alan Pardew talks endlessly about his players fighting for him and for the team, it's easy to roll your eyes and dismiss the bluster, but when it comes to John Carver, the statement is a little closer to the truth. Though not exactly a famous former player - he failed to make a first team appearance in two years at the club - the assistant manager was once highly rated as a coach, especially by Sir Bobby Robson, but has devastated his reputation this season by being a little too pro-Pardew for some Newcastle fans. And his backing of the manager came to a head before the Southampton game - inevitably surrendered 4-0 - when the notoriously fiery Geordie offered out any fan who didn't agree to take down Sack Pardew banners in the crowd. Annoyed that the protests could affect the team - rather than being concerned how his own coaching was doing the same thing - Carver was told in no uncertain terms to leave it alone, he reacted by telling fans to come to the training ground on Monday to "sort it out". He was inevitably forced to retract his statement and apologise, and didn't turn up for one fan who genuinely took up his offer:

"I was disappointed to see banners that could, in my opinion, distract the players and take focus away from the job in hand - namely winning the match.

"I went over to our fans to ask them to help us and requested that they take the banners down... I was met with abuse from one supporter and I regret that I responded inappropriately. I sincerely apologise for any offence caused by my reaction. Every fan is entitled to an opinion, positive or negative, and I respect that. I hope fans will understand that I, like them, only wanted what was best for the team."


4. Yohan Cabaye Went For Greener Grass In Paris

Despite being classed as a hero who was sold from under Alan Pardew's nose, destabilising the team and sending them into the spiral of poor performances they are currently still in, Yohan Cabaye never wanted to stay at Newcastle. When he was given the chance to sign for Arsenal, he had no interest in staying at Newcastle, and when PSG came in with a £20m ish offer, he also had no interest in staying at Newcastle. He might say now that he is behind Alan Pardew, and can't see why the players aren't just pulling their fingers out, but this - remember - is the same player who sulkily went on strike when he wasn't allowed a move away last season. But for all of his happiness at signing for PSG, and public statements that he definitely doesn't regret leaving Newcastle, the France international is no more than a bit-part player at PSG and sees his first-team appearances severely limited by the expensive talents vying for his position. And now he openly admits that if this continues and begins to affect his chances of playing for his country he will have to evaluate. Meanwhile every Newcastle fan with half a brain is resisting the urge not to shout "we told you so!!' across the Channel.

3. Andy Carroll Went Through The Door He Was Shown

There was a lot of talk about Andy Carroll being forced out of Newcastle when he was sold from under Alan Pardew a few years back, but the truth is that the striker was merely shown the door by the club's owners, he did not have to go through it to Liverpool. Yes, there probably was some pressure on him with the transfer fee being so high, but the Gateshead-born striker was contracted to the club and time was on his side as the last hours of the transfer window ebbed close. He could and should have stayed and built his profile at Newcastle, rather than going to Liverpool to compete with Luis Suarez for top billing in a situation that he could never have hoped to emerge victorious from. Carroll's decision to join Liverpool was nothing short of disastrous for all parties - other than Newcastle ironically - and as the player now faces the prospect of being West Ham's fourth choice striker, as Newcastle fans continue to entertain the idea of him coming home.

2. Hatem Ben Arfa Went To Hull

Obviously there has to be some understanding in Ben Arfa's decision to cut his losses and leave Newcastle at the end of the most recent transfer window, but did it really have to be Hull? Over the course of the window the player definitely turned down Birmingham City, probably turned down an unnamed Middle Eastern side (where he'd have been given lots of money probably) and allegedly turned down Besiktas after Demba Ba recommended him (though the Turkish club countered by saying they were the ones who turned him down). And with other options presumably available - he's got a good agent after all - what on Earth possessed Ben Arfa to go to Hull, where he wouldn't be guaranteed any first-team football thanks to an over-packed midfield, and where he was unlikely to be put in the shop window for a bigger move this summer? If Ben Arfa's end-game is for another big money move at the end of this season, he would have been better served moving to Birmingham City where he could have been the best player on the books - the same way Tom Ince chose to go on loan to Palace last season. He might as well have stayed at Newcastle for all the good the Hull move will do him.

1. Going To America (And Not Hiring An Censor) - Paul Cannell

Paul Cannell is the most outrageous Newcastle player you don't know existed (if you're a younger fan). No more than a middling player at Newcastle - where he was underused - the striker made his name in America as part of the ex-pat influx to the newly formed MLS, earning himself the first ever Nike sponsorship and the adulation of American fans. But it was off the pitch where his antics really entertained. In his ridiculous but hilariously entertaining autobiography "F*ckin' Hell It's Paul Cannell!" the Geordie spills the beans on accidentally having sex with a male friend during a threesome, dating an American president's daughter (and dumping her because her bodyguards were a drag), his drug use and Jerry Lee Lewis punching waitresses. He might have got away with it for a while, but it can only be a matter of time before the brilliantly funny striker attracts the attention of some disgruntled party - like the American secret service for instance - thanks to some sordid revelation or other, and he would have been preotected by consulting a censoring editor. But thank God he didn't. Which other idiotic decisions by former Newcastle players belong on this list? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.