10 Most Ridiculously Underrated Ex Premier League Stars
Oh yeah, he was really good actually...
It's a cruel game; at least that's how the cliche goes. One lapse in concentration and the game is lost. One bad injury and your career is over. Football isn't fair sometimes. On one hand a portal to fame, fortune and sleeping with your team mate's wife; on the other, a life of all too public clangers, ignominy and embarrassment.
The Premier League has catapulted hundreds of players to super-stardom and mega riches they've spent on trampolines and cars they can't legally drive on British roads. Others, for all the talent they had, drifted mercilessly into obscurity no matter what their awards or their accolades. They might still have their healthy bank accounts, but where is the love?
This article is dedicated to those lost souls. The one's who played for an unfashionable team, missed the big time through injury, or just bafflingly somehow don't get the credit they deserve.
Some have won titles, others spent their careers keeping average clubs from relegation. Which of those things you think is more impressive probably depends on who you support. This article shines a light on their achievements in the hope that someone, somewhere will take notice of their claims to eternal brilliance.
10. Georgi Kinkladze
Kinkladze was a Georgian footballer (already a bad start) best known for his time with Manchester City and Derby County. Arriving at City in 1995, he was one of the earlier foreign imports to the Premier League, and his unpredictable talents were perfect for an attacking midfield role.
Dribbling was always Kinkladze's forte. He is best remembered for the mazy run, ending with a chipped finish over the keeper in a '96 match against Southampton. This wasn't his only great finish. He became known for individual moments of brilliance on a consistent basis.
Unfortunately for Kinkladze, he didn't play for the best teams. City were far from the powerhouse they are today, and the 95/96 season ended in relegation. At that stage he could have signed for Barcelona, Liverpool or Inter Milan but chose to stay on, only for the next season to end in another relegation.
If he'd have jumped ship, who knows what he might have achieved.
9. Harry Kewell
It's easy to forget that Harry Kewell was on the verge of becoming one of the world's best before injury halted his career. Playing for Leeds in the late 90s and early 00s it seemed he was capable of doing anything. Goals, assists and the spectacular yielded to Kewell on a regular basis.
His performances marched an unfashionable team to the semi-finals of the Champions League and almost to a league title, but unfortunately his personal achievements ended there.
When Leeds sank heavily into debt, he moved to Liverpool and the injuries set in. The Australian had always seemed injury-prone but now he couldn't string two games together without a knock or hamstring strain creeping up on him.
In the Istanbul final, Kewell left the pitch with an injury before half time and was booed by his own fans, and sadly, his form and fitness never really returned.
8. Lucas Radebe
For extremely promising careers that didn't quite get going due to injury, first read Harry Kewell. Then read Lucas Radebe.
A South African footballer who moved from midfield to central defence as his career progressed, Radebe wasn't called 'The Chief' for nothing. Another Leeds star, he arrived under the radar as a make-weight in a deal to bring Philemon Masinga to the club in 1994. Unknown and unheralded, his performances quickly saw him eclipse his national team star by some distance.
Soon he was named captain, and along with Kewell helped Leeds to three consecutive top 4 finishes. Ultimately Inter Milan offered £25m for his services that Leeds turned down. From then on it was a familiar - and somewhat inevitable - story. He was out for two seasons with knee and ankle injuries and was rarely seen again, which was a shame given that he was one of the league's finest defenders for a time.
7. Tim Flowers
Before the age of Paul Robinson, David James and Rob Green, goalkeeper jerseys were awesome and England were doing pretty well between the sticks. There was Gordon Banks, Peter Shilton then David Seamen: and the latter is responsible for Tim Flowers making this list.
Becoming one the league's finest goalkeepers at Southampton, he really hit his stride after signing for Blackburn in 1994. The £2.4m fee was a British record for a goalkeeper at the time and it quickly paid off. He was magnificent in a debut season that saw Flowers and Blackburn just miss out on the title. The next season they went one better.
After that the team unraveled: key players left, the manager quit and football moved on. And for some reason Flowers is never mentioned as a top goalkeeper of the era.
6. Rob Lee
The original goal-scoring midfielder who should really have more trophies to his name; before Scholes, Lampard and Gerrard, Lee was the one banging them in from midfield. For a time he was the best midfielder in the Premier League, and his passing skills were as extraordinary as his scoring rate.
Arriving at Newcastle from Charlton in 1992, he helped catapult Newcastle to promotion with a record points tally. His goals were vital, as he supported Andy Cole and David Kelly with 10 strikes of his own.
Once promoted he didn't stop, with seven more in the 93/94 season. Many of these goals were remarkable in isolation, either a deft finish to end a terrific team move or a powerful run and thunderous finish. He made arriving late into the box an art before Lampard got started.
Once Ruud Gullit arrived at Newcastle however, his career wound down, as he was inexplicably excluded from the squad and denied a shirt number for the 99/00 season. Lee was restored to the team once Bobby Robson arrived but he was a bit long in the tooth by then, and his move to a more defensive midfield role failed to recapture the old magic, though it was effective in the short term.
5. Stan Collymore
Stan Collymore has been seriously underrated for all sorts of reasons, many of them impossible to mention on a website like this.
When he signed for Liverpool from Nottingham Forest in 1996 for a British record £8.5m fee, he was among the most highly rated forwards in a golden age of attacking play. Shearer, Sherringham, Ferdinand, Fowler and Cole lit up the division with an extraordinary volume of goals, and the feeling was that Collymore had the potential to be better.
Aside from the ability to score 20 plus goals a season, he was cultured, with genuine technical ability and brilliant strength and pace. He scored the winning goal in perhaps the most famous Premier League match of all time, when Liverpool came from behind to beat Newcastle 4-3 and deny them the title.
Unfortunately off the field problems took their toll: notable for his party lifestyle, even among team mates labelled 'The Spice Boys' in the mid 90s, he eventually checked into The Priory. A lack of discipline and injury resulted in Collymore never fulfilling his potential.
4. Steve Bould
The Arsenal back four of the late 80s and 90s is generally considered one of the finest defensive set-ups in British history: Dixon, Adams, Keown and Winterburn. But, actually, Steve Bould played a considerable part and rarely gets the recognition he deserves. Currently a defensive coach at Arsenal, they're looking more organised now Bould is working on them, and it's not hard to understand why.
Making almost 300 appearances for The Gunners between '88 and '99, Bould was a defender of real substance. He didn't take free kicks like David Luiz but he did read the game, organise the defence and dominate in the air.
It was this ability which helped the Arsenal back line become the finest of its era, yet people often forget the part he played. While Keown got the England caps, it was more often Steve Bould who partnered Adams in central defence, and in the double winning season of 97/98 he was probably the most consistent performer.
Unfortunately it seems you can win every trophy going and still get forgotten about.
3. Ledley King
Ledley King will always be worshiped by Spurs fans, but there is a real danger of general football fans forgetting just how good he was. During his career England had an astonishingly secure defence, with Terry, Ferdinand, Campbell and Carragher all ready to step into the fray, and there's still a suspicion that King was better than all of them.
A one-club man, he made his debut in 1999 as a midfielder, before dropping into defence and retaining that technical ability. It wasn't long before his performances marked him out as one of the league's bright stars, and he was capped for England in 2002. Unfortunately injuries plagued him from the very beginning.
For most of his career, King's knees were so fragile he was unable to train: he'd play beautifully for 90 minutes, then be wrapped in cotton wool. Often he couldn't even manage that.
Respected players have agreed King's achievements were remarkable under the circumstances, as he was Tottenham's best player for over a decade on just one leg.
2. Matt Le Tissier
Underrated, undervalued and brilliant: all words which follow the mention of pointy-toothed, overweight and technically gifted Matt Le Tissier. Another player who spent a career at one club, 'Le God' said he owed Southampton after they dug him from obscurity on the island of Guernsey.
Le Tissier consistently held his own Goal of the Month contests in a career, which spanned twenty years, often resulting in the whole country shaking its head in disbelief. He once told Tim Flowers before a game he would hit the towel hanging in the side-netting of his goal. He proceeded to do so from 40 yards.
He curiously saved his best goals for Blackburn and Newcastle games, but there really are too many 'worldies' to mention.
Then there are the penalties: unusually for an Englishman he didn't miss. Well, apart from once, but he scored 47 of the 48 he took and still never made it to a major tournament with England.
Ultimately loyalty was his undoing, as he routinely rejected moves away from Southampton to bigger clubs. It's for this reason he's rarely mentioned as true Premier League great, despite his gifts.
1. Peter Beardsley
What do Gary Lineker, Kevin Keegan, John Aldridge, Ian Rush and Andy Cole have in common? They played the best football of their careers with Peter Beardsley.
By the time the Premier League arrived in ‘92 Beardsley was approaching his mid-30s. Remarkably enough he was entering a golden phase: re-joining his home town club of Newcastle, he partnered Andy Cole in the most lethal strike-partnership the competition has even seen (55 goals in a single season). The newly promoted club finished 3rd, a feat impossible to imagine today.
It wasn’t the statistics, however, that made Beardsley special - everything about the way he played was extraordinary. Whether for England, Liverpool, Everton or Newcastle, he had an intelligence, and a desire to create which made good players around him look great. He said himself he found assists more satisfying than goals.
Yet goals are easier to judge: a quick YouTube search and you’ll see him walk past three defenders and round the keeper a dozen times. The same goes for chips and volleys, not to mention the 25 yard cannonballs. The full repertoire is there.
Notably ugly in an age of misshapen attackers and gnarled defenders, Beardsley’s looks might have contributed to his lack of recognition as a true great, while arriving a little late on the scene can't have helped.