10 Shocking Newcastle United Failures

Who remembers Lamine Diatta? He's not even number one.

It's not often that I write a list where it's harder to condense ideas rather than devise them but creating a feature involving unsuccessful players at Newcastle United is as simple as getting Brendan Rodgers to talk about himself. The sorting process is relatively simple. You just have to ask three questions. Did the player play during Kevin Keegan's 1995-96 or Bobby Robson's 2001-04? Is the player Alan Shearer? Were they part of Alan Pardew's remarkable fifth place finish in 2011-12? Right, now if the answer is no for each then they were probably a Tyneside failure. Obviously there are a few exceptions (Antoine Sibierski for starters): a handful of players have escaped the shame of being placed on this list as my warm heart believes they were either poorly managed or not really expected to be any good in the first place. For instance, I can't put Fabrice Pancrate in there due to his (only) goal against Watford and Patrick Kluivert's six goals and the fact he is PATRICK KLUIVERT kept him out of the top 10. I believe that Luuk de Jong was continually played out of position; Michael Owen's 26 goals were enjoyable and Jean-Alain Boumsong's first season alongside Titus Bramble was beautiful to watch. All three players are safe whether you like it or not. Finally, Facundo Ferreyra doesn't feature due to the fact that he never played a single minute and therefore could have been brilliant; let's be honest Alan Pardew and John Carver probably just forgot about him...

10. Carl Cort

Signed from: Wimbledon Transfer fee: £7million League Appearances: 22 League Goals: 7 Carl Cort was unfortunate to pick up a series of hamstring injuries during his time at St James Park but after Sir Bobby Robson paid a whopping £7 million for his services, the former Wimbledon attacker was expected to achieve a lot more. A rare blemish on Robson's scouting CV, Cort only managed 22 appearances and scored just seven Premier League goals before being sold to Wolves for £2 million in 2004. He spent the majority of his time on Tyneside injured yet he failed to impress when he was brought into the side.

9. Fumaça

Signed from: Crystal Palace Transfer fee: Free Transfer League Appearances: 5 League Goals: 0 In 1999 Newcastle United joined the Brazilian game. They had admired the likes of Ronaldo, Ronaldinho, Rivaldo and Romario and wanted a slice of the action. In came Fumaca (from Crystal Palace). Not only did he not possess the same attributes as the afore-mentioned superstars he could barely kick a football and spent most of his 6 games on the floor after tripping over the ball rather than trapping it. Having seen him play reasonably well in Germany, Newcastle probably thought they had found the next big thing but after leaving St James' Park he struggled to even make the grade at Carlisle.

8. Geremi

Signed from: Chelsea Transfer fee: Free Transfer League Appearances: 49 League Goals: 2 Sam Allardyce signed Geremi in July 2007 and after successful spells at Real Madrid and Chelsea he was widely regarded by fans as a good bit of business. He was appointed club captain by Allardyce, but lost the armband after new manager Kevin Keegan awarded the captaincy to Michael Owen on 20 January 2008. While Geremi's quality from set pieces is not in question he was simply a shadow of the player we had watched play in Spain and under Jose Mourinho at Stamford Bridge. He made 49 appearances for the club, scoring two goals before being sold to Turkish club Ankaragucu in 2010.

7. Alan Smith

Signed from: Manchester United Transfer fee: £6million League Appearances: 84 League Goals: 0 84 appearances for Newcastle United, zero goals. That sums up Alan Smith's career at St James' Park. Fair enough he wasn't really a striker anymore but if that was the case than why an earth did the Magpies sign him? It wasn't like he was known for his amazing holding midfield ability. Anyway, he signed for Newcastle in 2007 on a five year contract and although playing a big part in the Geordies' return to the Premier League in 2009-10 he spent most of his time playing second fiddle to Danny Guthrie. Imagine that?

6. Duncan Ferguson

Signed from: Everton Transfer fee: £8million League Appearances: 30 League Goals: 8 In an attempt to recreate the powerful Ferdinand-Shearer duo that brought so much success at St James' Park during the Kevin Keegan era, Ruud Gullit acquired Duncan Ferguson in 1998. Unfortunately the difference was that Les Ferdinand was pretty much always fit. Other than Ferguson's sensational volley against Manchester United, the Scottish forward spent more time in the treatment room than on the pitch and was labelled as "sick note" by chairman Freddy Shepherd. The towering striker made 30 league appearances, scoring eight goals before being shipped back to Everton for less than half what the Toon Army had paid for him.

5. Albert Luque

Signed from: Deportivo Transfer fee: £9million League Appearances: 21 League Goals: 1 Who remembers THAT Youtube video? Of course you do. Graeme Souness must have been licking his lips as Albert Luque burst through the St James' Park doors for the (based on the video) cheap price of 10 million large ones. Apparently the Spaniard was one of the best players in La Liga but despite a decent debut against Manchester United he simply wasn't good enough. He struggled with a hamstring injury that he picked up in his second game for the club and never adapted to life in the Premier League. Could he do it on a cold night in Stoke? No, he couldn't do it anywhere in any weather. The striker scored 1 goal in 21 appearances and was sold to Ajax in 2007. He did score against Sunderland though...

4. Silvio Maric

Signed from: Dinamo Zagreb Transfer fee: £4.2million League Appearances: 23 League Goals: 0 Newcastle United faced Dinamo Zagreb in the 1997-98 Champions League qualifying round (a game the Magpies won 4-3 on aggregate with a brace from John Beresford in the home leg) and were mystified by the Croatian side's attacking playmaker. Now, either Newcastle signed the wrong man or Silvio Maric had remarkably lost all of his talent during the year that Newcastle waited before signing him. The midfielder was far too lightweight and in 23 appearances he failed to score a single goal and although having a nice touch and style of play he drifted into the reserves before being sold to Porto in 2000.

3. David Rozehnal

Signed from: Dinamo Zagreb Transfer fee: £2.9million League Appearances: 21 League Goals: 0 Newcastle defender David Rozehnal left St James' Park just six months after moving to Tyneside in 2007, signing on loan with Lazio for the rest of the season. The Czech international, who played 25 times for the Magpies, joined from Paris St Germain for almost £3m but was guilty of a number of errors during Sam Allardyce's reign and failed to impress new boss Kevin Keegan.

2. Lamine Diatta

Signed from: Besiktas Transfer fee: Free transfer League Appearances: 2 League Goals: 0 After a recommendation from Habib Beye, Newcastle snapped up the former Senegal captain after he bought himself out of his Beskitas contract in March 2008. Widely regarded as the forgotten man, the centre-back only played twice before being released at the end of his first season. After a failed spell in Scotland with Hamilton, he spent time in Qatar and Tunisia before joining fellow countrymen El Hadji Diouf and Beye at Doncaster in 2011. He retired from football shortly after and didn't actually make an appearance under Rovers' boss, Dean Saunders.

1. Xisco

Signed from: Deportivo Transfer fee: £5.7million League Appearances: 9 League Goals: 1 Xisco arrived at Newcastle United for a fee of £5.7 million and was reportedly given a weekly wage of £50,000 a week. Now the Spaniard only made nine appearances for the club but he was on the books for five whole years. So, 52 weeks in a year X 5 = 260 X 50,000 = £13,000,000. Overall this means that Xisco's one goal for the Magpies cost the club eight figures... His only goal came on his debut against Hull but it quickly became apparent that he wasn€™t fit for purpose as a Premier League forward. Four months later we had an attempt to flog him blocked by FIFA who didn€™t allow a player to be registered to three clubs in one season and he spent the next couple of years going back and forth to Spain for various loan spells. He did briefly return to the club at the start of the 2010/11 campaign and assisted Andy Carroll€™s hat-trick goal in the 6-0 demolition of Aston Villa €“ a rare highlight. Eventually he was released on a free transfer in January 2013 just four months after scoring a surprise treble of his own in a reserve match against Stoke.

Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-accredited football writer with an MA in Sports Journalism. What Culture football editor. Write for the official Newcastle United programme. Former video reporter at North News. Featured and published in the Sunderland Echo, Shields Gazette, Mail Online, The Mirror, The Sun and others.