11 People Who Probably Most Hated Alan Shearer

"Mary Poppins" wasn't a hero to everyone...

Former Newcastle captain, walking hero and all round working class hero Alan Shearer can probably go to bed happy every night that he will forever be beloved in Newcastle, and is assured of adoration even despite helping relegate the club. He is untouchable, having scored a frightening number of goals for the club, and more importantly giving everything to the cause every game, and looking double-hard along the way, but for a lot of people who don't see through black and white eyes, he's the most hated man in football. For Sunderland fans, Shearer is Darth Vader - the personification of everything wrong about Newcastle United and their fans - and for far more other football figures and fans, he's something of a pantomime villain, but one who always got away with his crimes. That's probably why Aston Villa fans were so happy to see Newcastle relegated under him, and why almost every opposition team as a song about him. They weren't the only ones to hate him though...

11. The Creosote Industry

Alan Shearer Creosote When Shearer admitted dryly that he had celebrated winning the Premier League with Blackburn by creosoting his fence, he started the image of himself as the boring man's boring man, devoid of joy, wit and a sense of fun. Whether he was joking or not (Rob Lee would suggest he was), Shearer indadvertedly also suggested that the very act of creosoting his fence was the most boring thing imaginable, staining the image of the previously unmolested brands and setting the creosote industry back years.

10. Craig Bellamy

There's probably good reason the little Welshman hated his big Geordie strike-partner by the end of his time at Newcastle: under Sir Bobby Robson, the motor-mouth had been signed as a foil for Shearer - replacing the running and energy he no longer had - but he'd never really got the praise he deserved for extending Shearer's career. That was particularly clear when Graeme Souness came in, kissed Shearer's backside in public and basically suggested Bellamy was not a very nice person. Bellamy was being played out of position, and did what his little angry brain told him was the best solution - refusing to play and feigning injury. Instead of putting an arm around him and massaging his ego as Sir Bobby had, Shearer sold the kid down the river, uncovering his fake injury to the press. Bellamy was clearly unimpressed and when he was eventually shipped off to Celtic on loan he reacted badly to Shearer's suggestion in the wake of the 2005 FA Cup semi-final that everyone but him was to blame, so he texted him:
"He wasn€™t the player he had been and now he was trying to pass the buck. I had seen how poorly he performed personally. So I got my phone out and texted him. €˜F****** typical of you,€™ I texted. €˜Looking at everyone else yet again. You need to look at yourself instead. Your legs are f****** shot. Concentrate on yourself and let the team take care of itself.€™ I got one back straight away. €˜If I ever see you in Newcastle again, I€™ll knock you out.€™ €˜I€™m back in Newcastle next week,€™ I texted back. €˜Pop round and say hello.€™ His €˜Big, hard Al€™ act wasn€™t for me."

9. Uriah Rennie

When the Deepdale announcer famously welcomed the teams back on to the pitch with `Welcome back to the Uriah Rennie Show` he really wasn't too far off the mark. The referee was a self-publicist to end them all, and he always seemed more interested in gaining attention for himself rather than actually officiating matches. He went down in history with Newcastle fans by sending off Alan Shearer in his 100th game, showing two yellows for "persistent elbowing" during a game that the ref had let go beyond him early in the first half. The resulting witch-hunt against Rennie - including Ruud Gullit being restrained after the match, somewhat hilariously - changed the image of the referee from respected figure to trigger-happy clown, and his reputation was pretty much ruined. From there, he showed his perceived aversion to Newcastle by refereeing Toon matches with very little skill, and lots of bias (at least from a fan perspective) - and you really have to suspect he held a major grudge.

8. Freddy Shepherd - "Mary Poppins"

It is possibly unfair to say that the man who helped sanction the world record £15m move for Shearer in the '90s could hate him as much as Craig Bellamy did, but the director let his real feelings show during the Toongate Tape scandal that saw him filmed undercover criticising Newcastle fans, Geordie women and Alan Shearer. Shearer clearly wasn't Freddy's type of man, inviting accusations that he was "boring" and the infamous "Mary Poppins" nickname that has stuck with the Geordie legend - particularly with Sunderland fans. Perhaps it was because Alan didn't like brothels - the setting where Freddy has caught on tape - or perhaps it was that he didn't like to socialise with men who took £50m out of the club and pretended to be every Newcastle fan's best friend while emptying their pockets?

7. Roy Keane

There's a good chance that Roy Keane is the most hateful man in football: he probably gets up in the morning, punches the cat and stands in his slippers calling all of his furniture a "tw*t" before he's even had breakfast, if his books are anything to go by. Those books were full of the usual nuggets of information from the now Aston Villa assistant manager, including calling Newcastle fans deluded and arrogant (kettle, pot) and saying for some reason that he hated Rob Lee (how could anyone?!), and he reserved special praise for Shearer. Having established in his career that he disliked Shearer - even being sent off for taking a swing at him (after petulantly throwing the ball at him) - Keane admitted in his book that Shearer was on the hit-list of players Keane kept in the back of his mind as potential targets of violence, along with Lee and David Batty:
"All these players were in the back of my mind: €˜If I get a chance I€™m going to fucking hit you, of course I am.€™"
Perhaps it was all just jealousy?

6. Lee Dixon

Nobody likes being interrupted - when it's on national telly, in front of a collected audience of millions of football fans, and it's by an old rival who you probably think talks an awful lot of his trouser region, it's clearly got to be even worse. So bad, in fact, that the interrupted party cannot fail to show their frustration to the host with an exacerbated frown and shrug. Shearer cannot be the best colleague on the pundit's couch: he's not the most articulate, he's never particularly insightful, but he's cherished in the position because of what he's always represented to English football. So there's clearly some unspoken rule that what Alan wants and what Alan does have to be endured: it's just funny that for a brief moment, that entrenched feeling slipped out from the cool surface with Dixon on MOTD: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJTnszMPLXQ

5. Lynne Truss

"Who?" you might say... Officially, Truss writes mostly non-fiction, making her name and fortune from writing about punctuation and how hilariously bad at it you all are. A self-styled pedant, she was once a football reporter for the Times, who saw her objective eye and skill for language as reason to employ her as a Euro '96 reporter, despite her admission that she didn't know anything about the finer points of the sport, like tactics. But since Alan Pardew has managed to become a coach without that knowledge, we can't really hold it against her. Truss admitted in 2006 that she used to love Shearer, but that after a while she couldn't hear his name "without spitting on the floor" because he was able to con everyone that he wasn't a cheat, wasn't a bully, didn't get away with murder with referees, and didn't have too much player power (in that he "kept" getting managers sacked for dropping him). Truss clearly couldn't stand everything he represented, saying he seemed "like a big, waddling, sullen, dirty, immovable and permanently pointing obstacle to beautiful football" and though her self-confessed limited knowledge of the finer details of the sport question her expertise, you really can't question her passion:
"Here are the regular questions I would ask, out loud, in exasperation, at England matches during this period: How does he get away with it? Why is he walking? Why doesn't anyone notice that he raised his arm to appeal for that penalty before he artfully tripped over the keeper? Why doesn't he run? Why is he never rested? Why is he never substituted? Would you call that strolling or ambling? Why is he never sent off? Why is he never even booked? Who died and made him God?"

4. Neil Lennon

The former Celtic manager probably doesn't hate Alan Shearer for the reason you think he does - though the tasty stamp to the head can't have been very pleasant - it's the aftermath that would really have prickled the notoriously fiery midfielder. Called to an arbitration case to give evidence on whether he thought Shearer had done it purposefully - flanked by a tide of former players and managers who were tripping over themselves to say Shearer wasn't a bad man - Lennon actually called for the witch-hunt to end. Inevitably it did, but not before Lennon was cast as the villain of the piece. For some press, Lennon's reputation meant that Shearer's wayward, flailing boot - which would probably have had anyone else sent off, and would have seen someone like Joey Barton immediately arrested on the pitch - was somehow perversely deserved; that he was "asking for it". Over time, doubts would grow about the player, until it culminated in outright abuse in Scotland when he played for Celtic, and where he was accused of being consciously provocative. He might not care to admit it openly, but the whole Shearer affair fed into that unavoidably.

3. Derek Llambias

It's very obvious from the exterior that former Newcastle chief exec Llambias blamed Alan Shearer for Newcastle's relegation in 2009, and indeed that he judged him retrospectively for trying to get Michael Owen to sign a new bumper deal (with even more crippling wages), and the old hate spilled out a few times. Most memorably, Llambias hit back at Shearer after he criticised the sale of Andy Carroll to Liverpool (which still now looks a master-stroke given what happened afterwards):
"Do I care what Alan Shearer has to say? When he ran this football club we were relegated after picking up just five points from his eight games in charge."
Llambias was also recorded at another point saying appointing Shearer at all had been a mistake and that there would never be a right time to appoint him. Sticks and stone eh, Derek?

2. Ruud Gullit

The story always goes that Alan Shearer personally made sure Ruud Gullit left his job as Newcastle manager, and while it's entertaining to imagine Shearer as the aged Hollywood starlet getting the new director fired with an outraged "...and you'll never work in this town again!" the truth is that it was what Shearer represented that made Gullit leave. He was entrenched at Newcastle - part of the furniture, and the club's mascot and flag-bearer - and Gullit clearly wanted that to change after the striker's drop in form (which coincided, suspiciously with Gullit's deeply unsexy brand of sexy football. The Dutchman made a power play to get Shearer out, but he lost a key game and Shearer was instantly martyred, forcing the Dutchman to leave, even though he maintained long afterwards that he was right:
"I still think I made the right decision. Look at the way things have developed. It€™s still the same situation. I spoke to fans on the radio recently and asked if it had improved since I left. They said no, so maybe I was right. The coaches since me have tried to do the same thing and they couldn€™t, because he is so beloved there. That€™s why I thought, €œI cannot change this €“ it€™s better for me to go.€ I€™m sitting here now, and I know I was right. It was six or seven years ago, and nothing has changed. Nobody can prove that I was wrong."

1. Joey Barton

As Gullit found to his dismay in 1999, you don't stand up to Alan Shearer or question his high majesty to any Newcastle fans, let alone to his actual face, but that's precisely what fiery, fearless football philosopher Joey Barton did the season Newcastle were relegated. Having been sent off against Liverpool for trying to kick Xabi Alonso's knee inside out, Barton was told by his caretaker boss that he shouldn't have been on the pitch and that it was a mistake to pick him. Barton, with typical grace responded that he was the best player at the club, and when told he was in fact "sh*t" he called Shearer a "sh*t manager with sh*t tactics". Ignoring the truth in that statement, that was just the start of their affair, as Barton has clashed with Shearer over social media since, calling him a "slaphead" and taking issue with his assessment that he was a thug. Frankly none of the statements on either side seem to be anything but truthful. Who else probably hates Alan Shearer? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.