5 Goals That Could Have Changed Newcastle United Forever

There's nothing harder on football fans than a "what if...".

Highs and lows elicit any emotion you'd care to mention, but they're all matter of fact. They go into the record books, and in 100 years time they'll still be there, completely unchanged, for you happily or therapeutically reminisce over. But the near-misses, they come only with a thick fog of interpretation that means they'll be debated for as long as arguing in pubs is considered a valid use of one's time. All without an definitive answer ever being found. With perhaps the exception of general elections and ex-girlfriends, nowhere are these oh-so-nearlys quite as extensively poured over as in the world of football. For a club like Newcastle United, whose realities seem to defy belief at the best of times, who knows what the present might have held if the past had only panned out slightly differently. Namely, if a few games had finished with more favourable results, and specifically these attempts on goal had somehow made their way into the net. There could have been titles and trophies of course, but entire chapters of the club's recent history have been set in motion by something as variable as which side of a post a ball rolls over. Click "next' below to get the ball rolling...

5. Les Ferdinand (0-1 vs Manchester United) - Premier League 1996

What better place to start this little jaunt than Newcastle's most famous fruitless flirtation with glory: The 1995/1996 season. Having previously held a now historic 12 point lead over their rivals at the top of the table, Newcastle went into this game with their lead down to just 4 and Keegan's "Love it" rant still ringing in their ears. David Batty and Faustino Asprilla were both making their full debuts for the club, Andy Cole made his first return, and despite it only being March there was a genuine feeling amongst the fans that this was it. Win this and it's ours. What followed was probably one of the finest performances under Keegan, as Newcastle showed their claws and tore wildly at the throat of Manchester United from the very first whistle. Philippe Albert rattling the frame of the goal with a free-kick and Peter Beardsley finding Schmeichel at full stretch with a 20 yard drive. But the one genuine opening for Newcastle came within the opening five minutes, when Les Ferdinand raced into the box and squeezed himself a vital few yards from a panting Steve Bruce. Again Schmeichel rushed out to block the shot and, more in hope than expectation, made his frame as awkward as possible to hit a ball past. Ferdinand's shot clipped the top of his upper arm, and when the goalkeeper regained control of his limbs a moment later he found the ball dropping harmlessly into his grasp.
The game was won by Eric Cantona, who showed the sort of clinicity required to win both these contests and the Premier League. Had Ferdinand have been the difference instead, Newcastle would have pulled 7 points away and likely gone on to win their first league title since 1927. Who knows, the higher pedigree across Europe which that honour would have brought might have seen a more suitable manager replace Keegan, and the club not endure the slump that it never fully recovered from in the late 90s. Or it might merely have won the league, which would have been nice too.

4. Alan Shearer (0-2 vs Arsenal) - FA Cup Final 1998

Arguably the easiest inclusion on this list was the last time Newcastle United got within touching distance of a major honour. Although they would find themselves back at Wembley the following season, the pasting they received by a Manchester United side on their way to a domestic and European treble makes it hardly worthy of mention, but for a brief spell in the 1998 cup final, there really was a golden opportunity to end the long wait for silverware. Arsenal were favourites going into this game and had the better of the early exchanges, culminating in Marc Overmars shrugging off Alessandro Pistone to sneak in for the opening goal, but as the first 45 drew to a close Newcastle were starting to see progressively more of the ball. The momentum continued after the restart and Rob Lee's cross was headed off the bar by, of all people, Nikos Dabizas, and Arsenal retreated further and further back into their own half. Then the chance came. Tony Adams mis-controlled on the edge of his own box and presented the ball to Alan Shearer, his ensuing panic at the situation robbing him of all balance and chance of recovery. Shearer took a few strides forward and, from a rapidly vanishing angle and on his weaker foot, lashed his shot past David Seaman only to be greeted by the cold, deflating thud of the post.
In the end, Arsenal's quality and Newcastle's adventure for a goal led to Nicolas Anelka wrapping things up on the counter attack some minutes later, and the huddled sunburned masses from Tyneside headed back home with nothing to show for their day save a souvenir programme and hole in their wallets. But the balance and flow of a football match is a funny thing, and had Newcastle carried all the confidence going into the final third of the game that an equaliser would have brought, they'd have been the more likely to win it.

3. Kieron Dyer (0-1 vs Partizan Belgrade) - Champions League Qualifier 2003

If there's one moment that can so precisely pinpoint where Newcastle went from being genuine contenders for the Premier League, to the shambles of big egos and bigger wages that were relegated in 2010, it's their failure to progress to the Champions League group stages in 2003. Coming off the back of Robson's best season at the club, which had seen them finish third in the table and given the fans some of the most memorable European nights in their history, Newcastle had the straightforward task of a two-legged tie with Serbian side Partizan Belgrade standing between them and back-to-back Champions League campaigns. They rolled up for the away leg and dispatched their opponents 1-0, giving them a precious away goal to bring back to St James'. Things looked, as they often did, quite promising. What was served up on the night of the return leg however remains one of the most uninspiring and gutless performances ever associated with Newcastle United. After plodding around for the entire first half, seemingly without any idea how to break their opponents down, the second period started with a shock, but ultimately deserved goal for the visitors. That levelled the tie up on the night, eventually taking it to extra time and penalties - where Newcastle would somehow conspire to miss four of the bloody things. But immediately after the goal Newcastle had their best chance of the night. Alan Shearer scurried to the edge of the box to receive a pass from the onrushing Aaron Hughes, flicking it on and into the path of Kieron Dyer, who'd slipped his marker. Dyer took a touch inside the last defender and found himself a mere 7 yards from goal with only the goalkeeper to beat. He stumbled and flicked a leg at the ball, seemingly trying to toe-punt it into the near post, but the goalkeeper was just equal with his reactions, and eventually gathered the ball at the second attempt. In the ensuing 75 minutes of football, Newcastle barely threatened again.
Money earmarked for player recruitment was shelved, the club stuttered back down the league, Robson was gone little over 12 months later, and Newcastle have never since darkened the door of Europe's elite club competition. It's arguable that a result in this game would only have postponed the inevitable, but the lift qualification would have brought, as well as the players who would have joined the club, could have had almost any effect on the future of the side and its manager.

2. Michael Owen (0-0 vs Portsmouth) - Premier League 2009

When I look back on all the other chances on this list, my one consistent feeling is that I wish they'd all gone in. Whatever it is Newcastle might have won or achieved in that moment, I'm sure that it's a good thing. However with the benefit of nearly 5 years of hindsight, I can look back on Newcastle's relegation season as, ultimately, a force of positive change. That expensive squad of charlatans, most of whom arrived with reputations dwarfed only by their wage demands, promised so much in the post-Robson era but ultimately left the club in ruins. Demotion to the Championship was hard to take, but it did expedite the departure of all these rotten apples. But it was close. Memories may have fuzzed over in the years since but the end of the 2008/2009 season saw Newcastle, in 18th, finish just a point behind 17th placed Hull, and with a goal difference better than everyone up to 14th. Improving any single result over the course of the season would have seen them survive. That last afternoon at Villa Park never once saw them threaten, and a goal in the 0-3 hammering at Anfield would have made little odds, so it's hard to find a "what if" moment there. Arguably the best chance one could mention would be Nicky Butt's sliding effort that Fulham's Mark Schwarzer somehow palmed away, but it would be impossible to talk about this Newcastle side without a contribution (or lack thereof) from Michael Owen. The scene is St James' park and Newcastle are 8 games without a win entering the final 5 of the season - they sit 19th. After a PR offensive by the club that saw the redistribution of scarves and a special rendition of the Blaydon Races pre-match, Alan Shearer set up with three forwards in Viduka, Martins and Michael Owen to desperately get the goals that would drag them out of the mire. The former two wasted good chances at the start of the second half, but a few minutes later the latter found himself free of his markers, just inside the box, with a panicked goalkeeper stumbling towards him. The Michael Owen who cost the club £16.8million would have lashed a shot into the unguarded corner of the goal, the Michael Owen who scored 18 goals in 15 starts at Real Madrid would have cooly lifted the ball over the despairing head of the goalkeeper, and the Michael Owen who won the Balon D'or would have... well.. whatever, he should have scored. But the Michael Owen who played for Newcastle United stabbed a tame effort straight at the legs of David James. 0-0, two points dropped, and relegation followed just under a month later.
In a parallel universe somewhere Newcastle avoided the drop that year, and no doubt the likes of Owen, Martins, Duff, and Geremi continued to collect in excess of £60k a week for at least another year. A fall was coming though, and getting it out of the way in 2009 may well have saved the club from either asset stripping all their talent, or simply being another Leeds. A near miss for Owen, but an even nearer one for the club.

1. Demba Ba (0-2 vs Manchester City) - Premier League 2012

Given the positives that can be taken from Newcastle's shock 5th placed finish in the 2011/2012 season, it seems odd to end this list with one of the closing games of that season, but as flights of fancy go this is one that's stuck with me for some time. Going into the final fixtures of an extraordinary campaign - the one which won Pardew that LMA Manager of the Year trophy he keeps next to a can of pledge - Newcastle had won 7 of their last 8 games and found themselves within spitting distance of a Champions League spot. This from a club who regained their top flight status less than two years ago and failed to replace two of their best players in the summer. The mathematics of the situation were complicated, with Spurs and Arsenal both a point or two ahead, but Newcastle could more or less guarantee entry into Europe's premiere club competition with another 4 points. Manchester City had their own ideas of course, with the intoxicating scent a first ever Premier League title in their cavities, maximum points from their last two games was vital. The two teams met on largely equal footing, and the resulting game swung back and forwards for the better part of an hour. Chances were at the proverbial premium for much of that, but early in the first half, after being slipped in by Guiterrez, Demba Ba had the best chance for the game. With City's defenders scrambling desperately to recover, Ba allowed the ball to roll across his body before whipping around to shoot, Zabaleta and Lescott both peeling the other way try and cover the run of Papiss Cisse, only Gael Clichy remained in close enough attendance to attempt a block. Ba, so composed in front of goal that season, could have cut back inside to present himself with an unmissable chance, but instead cannoned his effort of the outstretched foot of the Frenchman, forcing Ben Arfa to attempt a rebound from an angle that had become unfavourable at best.
That remained the side's best chance of the afternoon, and looking back at the highlights it seems odd to pick it out as a moment that could have changed the club forever, but can you just imagine, even for a moment, how both the club and the league would have changed had Newcastle cashed in the Champions League payday over Liverpool and Chelsea? The following season was one of incredible turmoil for the club who, after only really adding Vurnon Anita to the squad in the summer, stalled and struggled their way to a pitiful 16th placed finish. Demba Ba departed for Chelsea, dissent reemerged amongst the supporters, and the club's still not showed a fraction of the promise it did in the closing stages of 11/12. 4th then would have been a gifthorse even Mike Ashely wouldn't have looked in the mouth, and surely some finances would have been speculated to potentially accumulate a consistent top 4 side. Then again, we might have got Partizan Belgrade in the qualifier...

Managing Editor
Managing Editor

WhatCulture's Managing Editor and Chief Reporter | Previously seen in Vice, Esquire, FourFourTwo, Sabotage Times, Loaded, The Set Pieces, and Mundial Magazine