Best Premier League XI Ever

As the new season draws closer, who’s the Premier League’s best ever players?

Alan Shearer
Raoul Dixon/epa/Corbis

The Premier League has played host to some great players over the years. Long heralded as the best league in the world for its competitiveness, its unpredictability and its lightning pace, it’s one of the most enjoyable leagues to watch around the world.

Just who would make it into the all time XI though? With so much talent, you could easily make three or four legendary XIs and still leave some huge names out. Narrowing it down to one team is even harder.

As the season draws ever closer, it’s as good a time as any to look back on the all time greats. Though modern managers opt for three up top, and/or a back five with flying wingbacks, here we’ve gone for the traditional 4-4-2. It was a Premier League mainstay for many years, even if it’s dying out slightly now.

This means attacking wingers have been considered for the right and left mid spots, leaving strikers to be out and out centre forwards. There was still a shortlist of nine for those two starting striker spots, which should give some indication of how stiff competition for places was.


Goalkeeper: Edwin Van Der Sar

Edwin Van der Sar
Owen Humphreys/PA Archive

There were a lot of candidates for goalkeeper in this lineup. Joe Hart, Petr Cech, Shay Given, David Seaman and David De Gea all threw their hat (or gloves) in the ring, but realistically it came down to Peter Schmeichel or Edwin Van Der Sar.

The Dutch stopper just got the nod over the Great Dane, for one important reason.

The majority of players here played for the league’s biggest clubs for most or all of their career; it’s what the big players tend to do. However, Van Der Sar did a fantastic job at Fulham for four seasons, before joining Man Utd. The signing was criticised at the time, as Van Der Sar was labelled a has been; he proved those doubters wrong very quickly, notching six fantastic seasons which saw him win the league four times.

In fairness, Schmeichel played for Villa and pre-money Man City, but this was in the twilight of his career, after his legacy was secure. He didn't really do anything at those lesser teams which would put him in contention for this list, while Van Der Sar's stint at Fulham would have put him in the running. Similarly, Shay Given was a contender despite a lack of big team experience.

Both would be comfortably at home in this team, but unfortunately there’s only one goalkeeper allowed.


Right Back: Gary Neville

Manchester United's Gary Neville celebrates after the game
Martin Rickett/PA Archive

Not the most popular player, Gary Neville has become more endearing as a pundit. His short managerial career was marred by a language barrier, but on Sky Sports he displays the insight for the game which made him irreplaceable down Man Utd's right side. As a right back, he was as unglamorous as they come, but with eight title wins, nobody comes close to him.

Having made his debut in the 1993-94 season, Neville went on to feature in another sixteen league campaigns for Man Utd, gelling well with both David Beckham and Cristiano Ronaldo out wide. Frequently found on the overlap, he wasn’t that quick or skilful, but he could make space for his wingers and pick out a cross when called upon.

England’s most capped right back ever, Neville did all the simple things exceedingly well and left the more difficult technical elements to the extremely talented players in front of him.

He hasn’t absolutely nailed down this spot like others in the team, but a lack of real competition sees him safe. There’s only Pablo Zabaleta and Lee Dixon challenging him, with right back/centre back Branislav Ivanovic behind them. None of them can take this spot off Neville.


Centre Back: John Terry

Chelsea's John Terry touches the badge on his chest after the Barclays Premier League match at the Britannia Stadium, Stoke.
Martin Rickett/PA Wire

With Neville and now Terry, this XI isn’t winning any personality contests any time soon. However, they would definitely have won a bagful of trophies with a prime JT at the back.

Mr Chelsea wasn’t everyone’s cup of tea, but he was a brilliant, no nonsense defender, always there when his teammates’ backs were against the wall. Well... maybe not Wayne Bridge's.

A colossal figure in both Chelsea and England’s back line, he marshalled everyone around him to perfection and popped up with some crucial goals when needed most. The first name on the team sheet for years, he was the most reliable Blue around.

His slip did once cost Chelsea the Champions League, but then he’s not the only slipper on the list. Mistakes from Terry were few and far between, and he was a hugely influential, steady hand in Chelsea’s most successful era.

He wasn’t without his naff moments though. Between wearing his full kit to collect the trophy despite being suspended for the Champions League Final, his pre-planned guard of honour after being subbed off on 26 minutes in his final game, and his Villa contract clause that he stipulated he'd never play against Chelsea, it’s easy to see why he wasn’t all that popular - despite his talent.


Centre Back: Vincent Kompany

Manchester City's Vincent Kompany
Tim Goode/PA Archive

Probably the only likeable bloke in the back four, Kompany left the Premier League at the end of last season having secured yet another Premier League title for Man City. Last season was one of the tightest, twistiest seasons ever, and Kompany’s long range piledriver against Leicester was one of the most decisive moments.

Signed by Mark Hughes as a lesser known holding midfielder from Hamburg, Kompany went on to become one of the Premier League’s finest defenders. Man City have had flair ever since the money arrived, but they’ve counted on Kompany’s grit numerous times to get them over the line.

As well as his Leicester screamer, his header against Man Utd which turned the tide in 2012 is right up there. For all their huge money signings, bargain buy Kompany was City's heartbeat.

It goes without saying that he was an unbelievable defender, always in the right place at the right time. City haven’t just lost a talent with him, but a role model for their younger defenders too.

Rio Ferdinand, Nemanja Vidic, Jamie Carragher and Tony Adams can count themselves unlucky to miss out, but they can console themselves on massive piles of medals, can’t they?


Left Back: Ashley Cole

Ashley Cole Chelsea Header
Anthony Devlin/PA Archive/Press Association Images

After the nice, gentlemanly break of Vincent Kompany, we’re back to the pantomime villains with Ashley Cole. Having enjoyed success at Arsenal and Chelsea as well as being the world’s best left back for stretches of the ‘00s, Cole was practically an automatic pick, despite his unpopularity.

Denis Irwin and Patrice Evra are his only real contenders, and they’re both quite a way off Cole’s standards.

When Cristiano Ronaldo was asked who his toughest Premier League opponent was, the Portuguese wide man answered Ashley Cole in a heartbeat. Not as gung ho going forward as modern day full backs, nor as good whipping the ball in as Gary Neville, Cole was simply a brick wall for wingers.

Though capable of drifting forward, he was at his best holding firm, making sure nobody got past him, recycling play through Patrick Vieira, Claude Makélélé or Michael Essien in the middle of the park.

With three titles to his name and countless other cup wins, it’s safe to say that Cole’s style was incredibly effective.


Right Mid: Cristiano Ronaldo

Cristiano Ronaldo Man Utd Champions League
Martin Rickett/PA Archive/Press Association Images

Considering Ronaldo grew into arguably the best player in the world during his time in the Premier League (then somehow went to Spain and got better), there can be no doubt of his place in this team. His penultimate season saw him score 31 goals in 34 games, although he blew the doors off that stat at Real Madrid with an eye watering 48 goals in 35 games five seasons later. Even if Man Utd didn't get the supercharged Ronaldo Real Madrid did, he still walks into the team. He was just that good.

He moved more into the centre during his later years at Man Utd, but was a traditional right mid number 7 most of his time there. He showed no signs of feeling the pressure of replacing David Beckham, and after some early immaturity and a tendency to show style over substance, he annihilated all opponents.

Despite having his best years away from the Premier League, he’s still in the conversation for greatest Premier League player ever, regardless of position. He's guaranteed to go down as one of the game's all time greats and Man Utd have never really found a number seven since.

In fact, Utds 7’s (Owen, Valencia, Depay, Di Maria, Sanchez) have scored a combined 14 goals in the shirt since he left; Ronaldo has scored 332.


Centre Mid: Frank Lampard/Steven Gerrard

Frank Lampard Chelsea
Bernat Armangue/AP/Press Association Images

England’s Golden Generation proved these two couldn’t play together, and choosing between them was just too difficult, so it made sense to have them both.

Each was the heartbeat of their team for the best part of a decade, true box to box players known for barnstorming runs and hammering the ball into the top corner. Lampard fared better in goals, fourth on the all time list with 177. Stevie G is some way behind, finishing on 120 in 18th place.

Lampard was playing in a better team though, and you could certainly make the argument Gerrard was more important to Liverpool than Lampard was to Chelsea. Still, twice Lampard scored the goals which mathematically won Chelsea the league (though neither season was particularly in doubt), showing how vital he was to Chelsea's wins.

Unfortunately, Gerrard’s defining moment was probably his slip, with his legendary Liverpool moments coming more in the FA Cup and Champions League. Hopefully, he’ll be remembered for his ups more than that infamous down.

If it really has to be one, Lampard’s three Premier League medals to Gerrard’s zero splits the tie in Frank’s favour, but only just.


Centre Mid: Roy Keane

Roy Keane, Manchester United
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

Whether it’s Lampard or Gerrard getting picked in one central position, it was impossible to look past Roy Keane for the other. With Terry, Kompany and one of the forwards all being some of the Premier League’s most formidable captains, this XI isn’t short of leaders.

Still, Keane’s steel in the middle of the park couldn’t be overlooked. He wasn’t the most entertaining player to watch nor the best centre midfielder in possession - not even in the top ten or arguably twenty in those categories.

As a ball winner who dominated the game and symbolised the classic Premier League style, Keane demanded to be included. English football has caught up with its continental rivals recently, but Keane is a throwback to the British bulldog spirit... even though he’s Irish, not British.

Keane’s teammate Paul Scholes and longtime rival Patrick Vieira are unlucky to miss out here, along with Man City trio Kevin De Bruyne, David Silva and Yaya Toure. N’Golo Kante and Claude Makelele are in the Keane mould, but they can’t depose him.

Xabi Alonso, along with Scholes, was possibly the most technically gifted Premier League player ever, but no one sums up the league’s trademark grit like Roy Keane.


Left Mid: Ryan Giggs

Ryan Giggs, Manchester United
Martin Rickett/PA Archive

Yeah, definitely not the most likeable bunch, this lot. However, when he wasn’t having an affair with his brother’s wife, Ryan Giggs was winning title after title with Man Utd.

Giggs has the second most appearances ever, beaten only by Gareth Barry who - let’s be honest - was getting nowhere near this team. He’s also top of the assists charts and despite never being a prolific scorer, managed to notch 109 goals thanks to his longevity.

His most famous goal came against Arsenal in 1999, although that came in the FA Cup, not the league.

Even without that, Giggs was a crucial part of so many legendary Man Utd squads over the years. First, as one of the kids you’ll win nothing with, then as a key player in the side which dominated the early ‘00s, and finally as an elder statesman towards the end of his career.

An out and out wide man with a killer cross, Giggs made it impossible to pick anyone else.

Gareth Bale, Robert Pires and David Beckham are probably the three standout also rans for left and right, but of the more advanced 4-3-3 style wingers you’d have to throw Eden Hazard and Gianfranco Zola in there too. If they keep their current form up, Mo Salah and Raheem Sterling will be in the conversation before long as well.


Striker: Alan Shearer

This picture can only be used within the context of an editorial feature. Alan Shearer celebrates after scoring for Newcastle United as they knocked Tottenham Hotspur out of the FA Cup Semi-Final.
John Giles/PA ArchiveIt

It had to be Big Al up top. The only real rival to Roy Keane for who sums up the Premier League spirit, the all time top scorer was an automatic selection. He might have only won the league once (with Blackburn Rovers, no less), but that just makes his stats all the more impressive.

Geordie hero Alan Shearer spent the bulk of his career at boyhood club Newcastle, winning absolutely nothing. It’s doubtful that bothers him too much, as it established him as a local legend and didn’t hold him back in the goalscoring charts.

Shearer has 260 Premier League goals, 52 more than second placed Wayne Rooney and 96 more than nearest playing competitor, Sergio Aguero. Most famous for his penalties, headers and fox in the box finishes, his netbusting volley against Everton is one of the league’s best ever goals too.

In terms of technical ability, Shearer wouldn’t even be in the top ten for strikers. Realistically though, strikers are there for one reason: to score goals. Nobody was better at that than Big Al.


Striker: Sergio Aguero

Manchester City's Sergio Aguero celebrates his goal during their English Premier League soccer match against Sunderland at the Stadium of Light, Sunderland, England, Wednesday, Dec. 3, 2014. (AP Photo/Scott Heppell)
Scott Heppell/AP

Yes, this means no Thierry Henry. Along with Wayne Rooney, Andy Cole, Dennis Bergkamp, Didier Drogba, Robbie Fowler and Robin Van Persie, the Frenchman was in the running, and does constitute the obvious choice. Shearer, as top scorer by some distance, was a dead cert, but there was plenty of competition for his strike partner.

In legends teams like this, the odds are stacked against newbies. It’s similar to how no band will ever be better than The Beatles, no film better than The Godfather. It doesn’t matter anyone’s personal opinion on the matter; it just seems to be an unwritten rule.

Long established as the Premier League’s best foreign striker, Henry suffocates competition. Compared to Aguero though, it’s easy to see him as slightly second best.

Aguero has eleven fewer goals, but he’s also played 51 fewer games, giving him a much better goals per game ratio. He’s won the league four times too; double the amount of Henry. It's true that Henry was a huge part of the Invincibles, and there's definitely an argument to be made that only having Ashley Cole from that legendary team does them a disservice. If Shearer's in on the back of his goals though, Aguero will soon eclipse Henry and shows no signs of slowing down.

Away from the comparison, no one can argue Aguero’s talent. He plays the poacher as easily as he pops it in the net from 25 yards. A fluid, thoroughly modern player worthy of a place in the XI.


Contributor

Self appointed queen of the SJWs. Find me on Twitter @FiveTacey (The 5 looks like an S. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the 5?)