Everton: Worst Ever Premier League XI

Thankfully they've all been pushed on to pastures new...

Ever since the Premier League began in 1992, it has quickly become the most successful and competitive of all the European leagues, despite the recent allure of playing in Spain or Germany. With Everton struggling through the 1990s under the reign of Mike Walker and then Walter Smith, Toffees fans were subjected to some truly uninspiring players turning out every week in the famous Royal Blue. When David Moyes joined in 2002, the club's fortunes began to rise as he led the club to European qualifications, their famous Champions League qualification in the 2004/2005 season and an FA Cup final appearance against Chelsea in 2009. His 11 years at the club are widely regarded as successful despite his inability to win a trophy, yet while they continued to grow, the club still managed to have players on their books that the fans would rather forget. So who would make an Everton worst ever Premier League XI? This article will seek that answer, taking in to account on-field performances, appearances, goals and much more.

11. Richard Wright (GK)

After being a club hero at Ipswich Town following his penalty kick save that saw the club promoted to the Premier League in the 1999-2000 season, Richard Wright left for Arsenal in 2001 after amassing 355 league and cup appearances for the Tractor Boys. He originally signed a five-year contract with the Gunners and was seen as the long-term successor to David Seaman, and competiton for backup keeper€™ Alex Manninger. An own goal against Charlton and injury against Deportivo La Coruña in the Champions League meant he was soon shipped out to Everton. His first campaign was an okay one, as the club finished 7th in the table in their first season under David Moyes. A bizarre series of injuries then hampered his career and left him as understudy to veteran Nigel Martyn. The first of these injures was the result of falling out of his loft at home when trying to pack a suitcase, while later in his career he managed to fall over a sign warning players not to warm up in the goalmouth before an FA cup game against Chelsea, severely twisting his ankle. In the end, he featured just 60 times in four seasons at Goodison Park before being released. He later joined West Ham.

10. Alessandro Pistone (LB)

Alessandro Pistone actually began his Premier League career at Newcastle United, signed by then manager Kenny Daglish for £4.5m in July 1997. He spent 3 years at the Magpies, featuring heavily under manager Bobby Robson after being frozen out by Ruud Gullit, scoring his only goal for the club against Middlesbrough in 2000. Despite this, he joined Everton in July 2000 for £3.5m for what would be an injury-ravaged time at the Toffees. He appeared in their first game of the season before a succession of injuries limited him to just 8 appearances in his first season at the club, with him also missing the majority of the following campaign through injury also, although he did score his first goal against Bolton Wanderers. He eventually managed to overcome these injuries and featured in most of Everton€™s successful 2004-05 season, signing a two-year deal when they qualified for the Champions League after initially rejecting a one year deal. Sadly, he would feature just three more times before suffering a cruciate knee ligament injury that ended his Everton career. He failed to make any more appearances at the club, having made just 103 appearances in seven years on Merseyside and was released in 2007.

9. Per Krøldrup (CB)

One of the more disappointing players signed under the David Moyes regime, there was a lot of expectation around defender Per Kroldrup when he signed from Udinese in 2005. A Danish international, he looked to be a bargain at just £5m as Everton looked to strengthen following their Champions League qualification. Unfortunately, things started badly for the Danish defender as he suffered a groin injury before playing a single game for the club, leaving him requiring surgery and missing an extended period. He eventually made his debut against Aston Villa on Boxing Day of 2005, putting in a forgettable performance in a 4-0 defeat that proved to be his only appearance for the club, therefore costing them a princely £5m per game. So bad was his time at Goodison Park, his Everton career is widely referred to as one of the worst transfers in the history of the club and English football itself, with the defender himself later admitting that he struggled to adapt to the pace and intensity of the English game. He was quickly sold to Fiorentina in January 2006, just 31 days after his Everton debut. He would make 117 appearances for the Italians before being released in 2012.

8. Li Weifeng (CB)

The signing of Li Weifeng was an odd one to say the least, and he became another centre back that would only make a handful of appearances, two to be exact, before moving on to pastures new. When Everton signed a new sponsorship deal with Chinese telecommunications company Kejian in 2002, it was clear that the loan signings of Weifeng and fellow defender Li Tie were a thinly veiled attempt at promoting the club€™s brand in China, with the Blues clearly trying to capitalise following the World Cup in South Korea and Japan. Weifeng made just two appearances for the Toffees, featuring in the Premier League against Southampton and the League Cup against Wrexham before a broken nose meant he returned to China over the Christmas period that year. He would fail to return to Merseyside, with then manager David Moyes stating that he had found it harder to settle in England than compatriot Li Tie and the defender later saying he had lost his confidence being on the bench and not playing for the first team. He has since played for a whole host of clubs in his homeland, his latest being Tianjin Teda where has played 92 times and scored three goals.

7. Lars Jacobsen (RB)

Lars Jacobsen is a name that many Everton fans are likely to have forgotten quickly. The Danish defender signed in August 2008 on a free transfer from German side Nurnberg, signing an initial one-year deal. After missing most of his first season at the club because of a persistent shoulder injury suffered while on international duty with Denmark, he eventually made his debut against Portsmouth in March 2009 and featuring in a 3-1 win against West Ham in May of the same year. His most notable appearance was as a substitute in the 2009 FA Cup final against Chelsea, replacing an injured Tony Hibbert and somewhat helping to nullify the threat of a rampant Florent Malouda. Despite having made only 13 appearances for the club, and failing to shine in any of them despite his efforts in the FA Cup final, Everton were reportedly keen to keep hold of the Dane. He eventually joined Blackburn Rovers in June 2009 of that year, joining West Ham a year later before returning to Denmark with FC Copenhagen.

6. Niclas Alexandersson (LM)

Swedish midfielder Niclas Alexandersson actually featured more prominently as a right-winger for Everton than on the left, but as someone much worse than the Sweden international occupies that position in this team he will inhabit the left wing berth in this side. The winger initially began his time in England at Sheffield Wednesday, signed by then manager Ron Atkinson for a fee of £750,000 from Swedish side IFK Göteburg. He quickly became a fan favourite in his three seasons in Sheffield, winning the Player of the Season award in the year that saw the team finish nineteenth and be relegated from the Premier League after nine successive seasons of top division football. Following that relegation, he signed for Everton in a £2.5m deal where he played from 2000 till 2003. He initially featured regularly in his first two seasons on Merseyside, before losing his place after a succession of injuries and the arrival of David Moyes. He struggled with fitness and form, unable to break into the Everton side and spent some time on loan at West Ham United before returning to Sweden with his second club IFK Göteborg, where he made a further 124 league appearances before retiring in 2009.

5. Alex Nyarko (CM)

Alex Nyarko actually arrived at Goodison Park amid much optimism having been likened to Patrick Viera in both stature and technique, with Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger rumoured to be interested at the time, and former midfielder Olivier Dacourt recommending him to manager Walter Smith. Signed from Ligue 1 side Lens for £4.5m in 2000 and signing a five-year contract, despite rumours suggesting he had only been given a four-year work permit. The midfielder went on to make just 33 appearances in four seasons with the club, before being released by new manager David Moyes following four years of abject performances and a deal that backfired spectacularly for the club. In one the more bizarre moments of his Everton career, he was confronted by an invading fan in a 4-1 defeat to Arsenal, with the pitch invader asking to swap shirts with the Ghanian, such was the lack of effort he was showing for the Toffees. He immediately asked to be substituted and transferred from the club, threatening to quit football altogether. He eventually got his wish, joining French sides Monaco and PSG in separate loan deals before eventually returning to Everton, where his contract was not renewed because of work permit issues.

4. Tobias Linderoth (CM)

Yet another Swedish midfielder on this list, Tobias Linderoth arrived under the radar in 2001, signed for a paltry £2.5m in order to help ease Everton€™s crippling midfield injury crisis at the time. If his plaudits were to have been believed, he would prove to be a steal for the club. Sadly that did not prove to be the case, as an unremarkable spell on Merseyside that was marred by injuries ended after just three years. He made just 40 league appearances for the club in that period, with his only goal coming in a League Cup fixture against Charlton Athletic. Sadly the Swedish midfielder just failed to establish himself at Goodison Park with many fans claiming he was simply anonymous in most of the games he played. He left for FC Copenhagen in the summer of 2004, with many sources claiming that David Moyes was happy to see him leave so the club did not have to pay another £200,000 to Staebaek, the club he had signed from. He played 82 times in the league for the Danish club winning two titles and qualifying for the Champions League, before moving to Turkish giants Galatasary in 2007 where he retired after just 13 appearances in the Turkish league.

3. Andy Van de Meyde (RM)

Probably the most illustrious of names on this list, Andy Van de Meyde is the best example of how some footballers go on to waste their prodigious talent. Formerly of Ajax and Inter Milan, the signing of Andy Van de Meyde was actually met by optimism from the Goodison faithful who were aware of his talents. At a paltry £2m fee, this could have turned out to be one of the smartest signings by David Moyes, especially considering he had managed to beat both Monaco and Tottenham Hotspur to the winger€™s signature. Ultimately though Moyes will have wished he hadn€™t, as off-field antics proved the undoing of the Dutchman, who preferred partying to playing football, all of which meant he ending up spending more off the pitch than on it. His only notable contribution to the Everton cause was an assist to Dan Gosling in the goal that helped the side beat Liverpool in the FA Cup in 2009. In four seasons at the club, Van de Meyde only managed 20 league appearances for the club, with issues with cocaine and drinking problems causing him to be unfit for large parts of his time on Merseyside. He later joined Topklasse amateurs WKE before retiring in 2012.

2. Brett Angell (ST)

The less said about Brett Angell the better as far as Evertonians are concerned, and that is why he makes his way on to this list. Everton have had some poor strikers over the years, but Angell is certainly the worst of the bunch. The less said about Brett Angell the better as far as Evertonians are concerned, and that is why he makes his way on to this list. Everton have had some poor strikers over the years, but Angell is certainly the worst of the bunch. The striker endured two awful loan spells and one full season with Everton in the mid-nineties, despite never having proved to be anything near the quality needed in the Premier League. It didn€™t all start badly for Angell though, as at previous clubs Southend and Stockport County he had amassed 75 league goals in 185 games. That attracted the interest of Everton, who duly signed him for £500,000 only to soon learn it was money down the drain. The 6€™4€ striker would make just 20 league appearances for the Blues in his three spells at Goodison Park, scoring a solitary goal in the process and proving to be equally inept with the ball at his feet as he was in the air, with many using the word lumbering to describe his performances. Somehow the club managed to sell him for a profit to Sunderland, where he also struggled before joining Stockport County once again. He retired in 2003.

1. Ibrahima Bakayoko (ST)

Ibrahima Bakayoko actually proved to be more of an astute signing on computer simulation game Championship Manager than in real life, and he certainly failed to make an impact in his on year at Everton. After scoring a notable 25 league goals in 76 appearances for Montpellier in France, Walter Smith was convinced to pay £4.5m for the Ivorian€™s services in October 1998. However, he failed to impress on Merseyside, making just 23 league appearances and scoring a paltry four goals in the process, with just seven in all competitions. He did manage to score twice in a 2-1 defeat of Blackburn Rovers in his most impressive Everton display, but it was not enough to convince Smith to retain his services in the long term. So unimpressive were his performances for the Toffees, Everton fans referred to Bakayoko as €˜Baka-joke-o€™ due his poor performances and lack of goal scoring abilities. Surprisingly, the club managed to sell him to Marseille for an impressive £4m, recouping most of what they had paid for him less than a year earlier. He would later have spells in Spain, Italy and Greece before joining current club Stade Bordelais in the summer at the age of 37.

Contributor
Contributor

Everton fanatic. Comic book reader and Spider-Man idoliser. Film watcher and TV binger. A smorgasbord of interests.