Manchester United returned to winning ways against Cardiff on Tuesday night as fan favourite Ole Gunnar Solskjaer came back to town. Solskjaer is a cult figure at Old Trafford and both sets of fans sang his name throughout, but the former Red Devils striker couldn't sink his former team. An early goal from Robin van Persie - back from a long lay-off and named in David Moyes's side for the first time this year - and a second from Ashley Young in the second half sealed the contest. Van Persie's goal was predatory, a close-ranged nod-in after Antonio Valencia's header against the bar sent the ball his way, while Young's was sublime, a long-range bottom corner finish. And Juan Mata made a fine debut, helping to create the first goal and missing a few chances to score himself late on, substituted to a standing ovation near the end. Cardiff too played their part, Marshall making a number of excellent saves while Fraizer Campbell and Craig Noone looked to hit the home side on the counter attack. But how did the players from each side rate? Here, we analyse last night's performances and bring to you the Man United and Cardiff player ratings.
Man Utd
David De Gea (6) Manchester United's No.1 kept a clean sheet here, but was barely called into action with Cardiff managing just the one shot on target from their seven attempts. Still looks unnerved when dealing with crosses. Patrice Evra (6) Did okay in dealing with Craig Noone, but was beaten by the Cardiff man in the second half too easily down the left and the resulting cross might have led to a goal. Contributed well to the attack. Chris Smalling (7) Given a rough time by Fraizer Campbell at various stages and a defensive mistake nearly let the Cardiff striker in, though Smalling did recover the situation with a good show of pace. Looked composed. Jonny Evans (6) Lack of communication with David de Gea was evident at times though that's mostly down to the goalkeeper's lack of confidence in dealing with set-pieces than it is any mistake from Evans, who was rarely troubled at the back. Rafael (6) Had a quiet first-half but was more active in the second, contributing to the attack well and tracking back, helping Valencia in keeping tabs on Declan John.
Antonio Valencia (7) The winger twice hit the woodwork and was unlucky not to score either side of half time, heading point-blank against the bar in the first period and seeing David Marshall palm a close-ranged shot onto the post. Looked a constant threat. Phil Jones (6) His passing is dubious and definitely needs work but he was tough in the middle of the park alongside Ryan Giggs, though it's the latter who did most of the work here. Ryan Giggs (7) What Jones lacked in passing ability Giggs made up for and the veteran is still pulling the strings. Proved he still has the capabilities to impose himself in a game and make an impact. Replaced by Tom Cleverley. Ashley Young (8) Provided the assist for Robin van Persie's opener and netted the second with a terrifically-taken long-ranged drive that ended Cardiff's resilience on the hour mark. A match-winning goal and just as the visitors looked like scoring. Juan Mata (8) Juan Mata made more passes than any other United player on his debut, with a completion rate of 86.5%. And that's why he's their club record-buy. Subbed off to a standing ovation and made way for Adnan Januzaj. Robin van Persie (8) United have badly missed the Dutchman who hadn't played all year until now. Scored on his return after just 6 minutes and will have a huge part to play in helping his side finish in the top four. Replaced by Wayne Rooney late on.
Cardiff City
David Marshall (7) Could do nothing about van Persie's opener after seeing the United man head in from close range and likewise helpless to stop Young's screamer. Made a wonderful save to get a glove on Valencia's shot late on and tip onto the post to keep his side in the game. Declan John (4) Given a torrid time by Valencia down the left and found himself in one-on-one situations far too often. Failed to stop the United man who by contrast enjoyed a good game. Mark Hudson (4) Also endured a difficult game and hauled off with 20 minutes to go. Seemed to struggle in possession of the ball and couldn't contain van Persie. Steven Caulker (6) Did a better job in tracking van Persie and worked hard to contain the Dutchman. Valencia on the other hand got in behind him far too often. Kevin McNaughton (5) Bombed forward to support Craig Noone whenever possible and sent in an inviting cross in the first half that nearly found the head of Fraizer Campbell. Looked a threat from the back.
Craig Bellamy (4) Failed to put his own stamp on the game and was kept quiet. Didn't get at Rafael as much as he would have liked and had very little impact on proceedings. Gary Medel (5) Looked determined and went in for some pretty beefy tackles on Phil Jones. Gave Cardiff some steel in the middle but couldn't take advantage of Jones's poor performance. Jordon Mutch (3) Had zero impact. Subbed seven minutes after half-time. Peter Whittingham (5) Looked good in possession of the ball but couldn't really disrupt Giggs and Jones's game and largely failed to have any real input. Craig Noone (7) Cardiff's star player in this one, trying to get at United whenever possible with some long-ranged shots and gave Evra a difficult game. Scored, and had a good game against City but things didn't quite some together here. Fraizer Campbell (6) Put in a tireless and energetic performance and might have scored if only he had adjusted his feet in the second half when presented with a tap-in. Other than that though his efforts were fruitless.
Joseph is an accredited football journalist and has interviewed nearly all of the current 20 Barclay's Premier League managers. He is also a correspondent for Bleacher Report and has written for Caught Offside and Give Me Football.