8 Ways Triple H’s WWE Is JUST LIKE Vince McMahon’s

Is Triple H much different to Vince McMahon? No chance in hell.

Triple H As Vince McMahon Thumb
WWE

Across 2023 and 2024, WWE was a white hot babyface promotion in the midst of a genuine boom period. 

Cody Rhodes flat-out no-sold the Rock’s botched interference spot to finish the story at WrestleMania 40. He was positioned as the greatest babyface of the century. He vanquished Roman Reigns with the help of those he had wronged - and the Undertaker, since Stone Cold Steve Austin didn’t fancy making the trip - in a brilliant, feel-good flex of Triple H’s storytelling muscle. Every detailed, overlapping narrative thread converged to craft a thrilling season finale of Triple H’s first era as the main roster booker. As the year unfolded, WWE fans lived through what are now the good old days. 

Rhodes was such a great champion and talisman that it didn’t matter that his stuff was a bit rote and predictable. It helped that Levesque, in parallel, booked the most personal-feeling saga in years between CM Punk and Drew McIntyre. 

Underneath, countless wrestlers became stars. Rhea Ripley was a babyface sensation so well-liked that her tormentors Dominik Mysterio and Liv Morgan ascended to a level nobody had thought possible under Vince McMahon. Gunther was operating at such an awesome level that WWE was taking AEW to a broadway of match quality. IYO Sky, already phenomenal, developed into a superstar through WWE’s packaging magic. Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens were the Randy Savage and Bret Hart types of this ‘Renaissance Era’; artistic greats whose drawing prowess is all too often overlooked. 

Now, WWE more closely resembles the dismal days of the late 2010s than the place to which CM Punk shockingly returned at Survivor Series 2023. 

What happened…?

8. Punishment Booking

WWE Raw Dragon Lee Rey Mysterio Big Cass
WWE

Big Cass made his return to WWE Raw on August 3, 2026. By October (!), the run was already close to a disaster. 

As Big Bill, Cass was very fun in AEW. His heat sequences were creative and funny. He looked like he was having the time of his life being a prick. That he was immediately presented as a dour guy intent on redeeming himself in WWE was already ominous. Big Cass was set to be boring. This would have been significantly better, somehow. 

Cass has since lost on television to Dragon Lee and Rey Mysterio after his beat-downs of Je’Von Evans didn’t get over. One of two things happened here. 

1) Triple H thinks it’s a good idea for his motivated returning monster to look weak and idiotic, or

2) Big Cass is getting the dreaded punishment booking of yore to teach him some sort of lesson. 

It’s 2, isn’t it? 

What does anybody get out of this bizarre Vince McMahon trademark display of spite? 

If you’re a kid in the crowd who doesn’t know any better, the big guy is no longer scary, and his opponent is more lucky than good. If you’re old enough, you automatically think that Cass is in the doghouse. Dragon Lee gets nothing out of it because it’s more about Cass getting humiliated than it is about Dragon Lee winning.

Cass might just be swell in the long run, once Triple H has worked his evident frustration out of his system, but this sort of thing is spiteful, stupid, and pointless. It’s not just the individual prospects of Big Cass that are of concern; WWE was the babyface company in 2024, and this sort of thing takes an ax to what’s left of that idea.


7. Crap Comedy

WWE Raw Je'Von Evans Dominik Mysterio JD McDonagh Funko Pop
WWE

Vince McMahon was notorious for booking excruciatingly awful comedy segments. By the PG Era, Vince’s idea of comedy was R-Truth wearing a set of fake hillbilly teeth and crossing his eyes. 

Triple H never had much of a sense of humour, either. He had decent comedic timing, which he confused for being funny, but that’s about it. The man spent years enjoying Vince’s company. The two men probably weren’t reading the complete works of PG Wodehouse together; they were sh*tting their pants and trying to make Gerald Brisco sick with the stench. 

It’s no surprise that Triple H’s attempts at booking comedy are as wretched as Natalya’s flatulent ar*ehole - but it is a surprise that he bothers in the first place, when it’s such an easy way of avoiding comparisons to a terrible time. 

The Miz blasting Minihausen with a Skull Crushing Finale: that was incredible patter, fair play. But then Danhausen electrocuted the Miz, and the Miz, lobotomised, just said his old catchphrases over again. It was awful. Watching the Miz in this state could actually be interpreted as a razor-sharp satire of how WWE can’t write real characters, but that’s not what they were going for. 

At the same time, a Gingerbread Man character was introduced when Trick Williams made fun of Sami Zayn for being a redhead. This is precisely what Jon Moxley talked about when he buried Vince on his legendary 2019 appearance on Talk Is Jericho; somebody made a comedic aside, and instantly, it was run into the ground through non-stop prop comedy. 

Similarly, later in 2026, Joe Hendry started calling JD McDonagh a Funko Pop, because he has a large head. This was more Vince-coded babyface bullying, witless and mean and not remotely amusing. 


6. Colossal Baffling Failures That Result In Rage-Quit Threats

Randy Orton Pat McAfee
WWE.com

Vince McMahon became synonymous with booking some of the worst wrestling moments ever in the years before he resigned in disgrace. 

Babyface Roman Reigns winning the 2015 Royal Rumble match against a backdrop of perpetual, tormented groans, as if the crowd was being audibly tortured in hell. A referee throwing out a Hell In A Cell match when Seth Rollins threatened to use a smaller hammer than the mallet teased by the Fiend earlier in the match. Jinder Mahal: WWE Champion. 

Vince’s twilight years booking was so catastrophically awful that it was almost helpful; these moments, and several others, were the impetus for many longtime fans to finally rid themselves of a hobby that no longer provided them with joy. They were not merely bad; they were life-changing. Incredibly, given that he isn’t a 76 year-old brain-wormed lunatic, Triple H has booked some of his own. 

John Cena’s heel turn, with his “each and every one of you” speeches, might as well have been shadow-booked by Vince himself. The use of Travis Scott at WrestleMania 41 was a quintessentially ‘WTF’ moment that spiritually belonged in 2019. When Pat McAfee turned heel and aligned with Randy Orton ahead of WrestleMania 42, on the basis that we all needed to get back to the Attitude Era, the development might have made less sense than anything Vince did that same year. Orton debuted after the Attitude Era had ended, for starters, and what was that talk of 5’ 5” guys doing 45 minute Iron Man matches on SmackDown? Not only has that never happened ever, what did any of his inscrutable nonsense have to do with Cody Rhodes?

When Vince McMahon got desperate, he went nuts. Under pressure to sell more tickets by TKO, Triple H does this too. 


5. NXT > WWE Pipeline Is Still Broken

Kiana James
WWE.com

This is the most inexplicable similarity between Triple H’s WWE and Vince McMahon’s WWE. 

The failure of the original NXT > main roster pipeline was thoroughly expected. Triple H recognised that the old WWE audience was split into two tribes - John Cena’s fans, and the millennial hardcores who wanted WWE to adopt a more wrestling-forward approach - and geared his NXT brand towards the latter. 

It might not be too cynical to state that Triple H was more interested in getting high off critical acclaim than building new stars that Vince would realistically promote. Vince was never going to see anything in Johnny Gargano, was he? 

Bizarrely, the system was disjointed by design. NXT was meant to stand alone as the cult wrestling brand and supply the main roster with talent simultaneously. It did not work. It was impossible for it to work. 

How to explain the chasm between Triple H and Shawn Michaels’ philosophies? 

They’re meant to be close friends. In 1997, they shared the same wrestling brain, constantly urging Vince McMahon to embark on a new, edgier direction. Neither Triple H nor Shawn are volatile, brain-rotted old men with one fixed way of doing things. And yet, the same old problems persist. 

Shawn’s NXT is a dumb, heightened show that has as much in common with a teen drama, with its wacky personal growth arcs, as it does with the main roster. Michaels is teaching these wrestlers to be actors - bad actors - who exclusively wrestle rushed, sub-AEW-style matches. These skits get them out of their shell. That’s one way to look at it. But they look lost in a big arena doing actual wrestling matches, so what’s the point?

Triple H presents NXT acts in almost the exact same way Vince did. He debuts them cold, mostly in undercard positions, with no great fanfare, simply expecting the fans to know who they are or care about them. Even if these bad acting lessons make a certain weird sense - Triple H does like his “cinema” - Triple H doesn’t seem to trust Shawn’s guys at all, with a few rule-proving exceptions. Oba Femi and Tiffany Stratton have done well. Bron Breakker gets hyped, but how close is he to headlining WrestleMania?

And after four long years, who else is there? 


4. The Actual Wrestling Is Still Bad

WWE Sunday Night's Main Event Baron Corbin Trick Williams
WWE

Actually, you can add Trick Williams to the aforementioned list - but his wrestling ability holds him back. He’d have been better off not learning his trade in the Performance Center, the curriculum of which amounts to ‘Aura Farming with Terry Taylor’. 

This is a major problem, one that partly explains WWE’s middling at best in-ring output. It might be worse now than it was under Vince McMahon. The fundamentals are almost non-existent. Almost every strike thrown ahead of a counter is delivered with zero intent. It’s not meant to connect, but the audience doesn’t need to know that. The pin attempts are diabolical; in some cases, a wrestler will even visibly help their opponent escape. WWE wrestlers use taunt-spamming in place of wrestling psychology of any real substance. The exaggerated facial expressions are bad enough; worse still when the wrestlers emote to the exact same spots and tropes every week. 

Because long and complex sequences are apparently still “in”, many WWE wrestlers go about a match with their heads down, trying to do what they’ve been told to memorise, and don’t feel at all present. The fans rarely seem engaged as a result. 

A lot goes into this. The limited schedule prevents a wrestler from developing confidence and muscle memory. Those who started their training in the PC had to work mostly in its forgiving environment, closer to a studio with audience members than a wrestling crowd, and are not equipped to win a hostile or uncaring set of fans over. 

What really does not help is the idea that Triple H senses that the fans don’t care about the actual action most of the time. Jey Uso got more over than Johnny Gargano. This sparked a doomy cycle. 

At the start of his main roster booking run, Triple H did recognise the value of great wrestling on a wrestling show; Gunther was presented, brilliantly, as the absolute master of the craft. Those days are over. With the wrestling de-emphasised, even the best talents on the roster have succumbed to bad habits for an easier life. CM Punk does finisher theft far too much; the Cody Rhodes finishing stretch is basically just several Cross Rhodes kick-outs. The current crew of road agents seem brainless and derivative, too. 

What’s nuts is that, even in the same month in which the McMahon family had to resort to apologising for how awful the product was, Vince booked a sensational match between Daniel Bryan and AJ Styles at TLC in December 2018. It feels sometimes like Vince cared more then than Triple H does now.


3. Screwy Finish City

WWE Raw The Judgment Day Stephanie Vaquer Rey Mysterio Raquel Rodriguez Roxanne Perez Liv Morgan Dominik Mysterio JD McDonagh
WWE

Barely an episode of WWE television passes by without some bullsh*t going on somewhere. It is relentless. It’s a grim echo of the late 2010s, during which Vince didn’t seem to fancy any of his wrestlers, and just had them trade meaningless wins, usually by booking heels to cheat, as if that even worked to get substantive heat. 

The Judgment Day run through the same distract the ref, slide a belt to a stablemate routine every single week. The Vision does the exact same thing, only with a pair of brass knuckles. 

Vince McMahon developed an awful habit of making his babyfaces look like petulant children who pranked their heel opponents - you might recall Ricochet stealing Sheamus’ clothes and hat - and in 2026, Bayley is similarly insufferable. She likes to hide under the ring to taunt Lyra Valkyria. This Christ-awful rapscallion gimmick sucks sh*t.

Triple H doesn’t like beating guys that he sees something in. He also won’t pull the trigger on those guys for years and years, which results in a constant load of rubbish, predictable finishes. He sees a lot in Bron Breakker, which is fair, but since Bron is still error-prone and hasn’t yet wrestled an unqualified success of a breakthrough singles match, virtually all of his finishes are tainted. 

He lost to Penta on the October 20, 2026 episode of Raw after Je’Von Evans interfered. His match against Trick Williams on the October 9 SmackDown went to a no-contest. He lost to Je’Von by disqualification on the September 21 Raw after yet more Vision interference. 

Breakker is a wrestler whose matches and finishes do not matter at all, because Triple H learned the “art” of the holding pattern from dad-uh.


2. The Tag Team Division Is Now A Total Afterthought

Damian Priest R-Truth Fraxiom
WWE.com

At time of writing - October 20, 2026 - Tama Tonga and Talla Tonga are the WWE Tag Team Champions. They have held the belts for 67 days. Throughout that time, they have defended the titles on television once. 

The World Tag Team Champions are Bron Breakker and Austin Theory. They have held the belts for 103 days. Throughout that time, they have defended the titles on television zero times. 

With the arguable exceptions of Fatal Influence and Tatum Paxley and Alexa Bliss, not one team in either division is particularly over, as evidenced by the ants pissing on cotton every time the likes of Shinsuke Nakamura and KYOKI make their entrance. Bron Breakker is over, but, underscoring the wider point, he has outgrown the title, and his popularity has precisely nothing to do with the fact that he holds it. If anything, he is taken seriously in spite of a championship reign that for all intents and purposes is not actually happening. 

There is no actual division on Raw. There is an excellent team on SmackDown. That team is Fraxiom. Fraxiom have not wrestled a tag team match on SmackDown since July 17.

These are not opinions or insights crafted to form a persuasive argument. These are facts. 

WWE has promoted the Women’s Tag Team titles with a bit more conviction, but match quality has peaked at “passable”; otherwise, 2026 was defined by botchy disasters involving the Irresistible Forces and Brie Bella and Paige. They were sent out to die on a weekly basis because Triple H does not care. 

Triple H cares as much about tag team wrestling as Vince McMahon did. It doesn’t matter that Triple H once booked a thriving tag team division in NXT, launching the careers of Chad Gable and FTR. That was 10 years, 120 months, 521 weeks, and 3,652 days ago. 

In 2026, Triple H cares as much about tag team wrestling as Vince McMahon did.


1. Triple H Likes To Take The Credit

WWE Unreal Triple H CM Punk
WWE/Netflix

The word “genius” is associated with Vince McMahon mostly because he used it to describe himself so frequently. While Vince did this a lot under the guise of his Mr. McMahon character, the gimmick was barely fictionalised. WWE’s revisionist history in the documentary medium furthered this narrative. 

Vince never missed an opportunity to let you all know that he took wrestling out of the smoky bingo halls - the biggest lie WWE ever told, incidentally - and how much he kicked WCW’s yokel yahoo ass. It was when Vince started bragging about this relentlessly that he grew mad with power, entitled, arrogant and lazy. 

As bad as Vince was at sucking himself dry, he never once kicked off a WrestleMania event by referring to the next phase of programming as ‘The Vince McMahon Era’. Stephanie McMahon said that we’re in “the Paul Levesque Era” on Triple H’s behalf at the beginning of WrestleMania 40. 

You can trace the creative decline of Triple H: main roster booker to the Netflix roll-out, as part of which he aimed to promote himself as the great genius powering WWE’s cinematic popularity. He was the man on the headset telling his talking props exactly when to milk a moment for maximum dramatic effect. When you really think about it, those were all his pops. 

Triple H has since over-thought multiple storyline developments, plunging WWE into a chaotic mess of worked shoot injury angles and botched generational heel turns, all because he needs to be seen to have so many wonderful, genius ideas. 


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!