15 WWE Break-Ups That IMMEDIATELY Backfired

Undo! Undo! Undo! Undo! WWE watched these split stories backfire in a hurry.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE have an undo button. Of course they do. The company has gone back on itself and put things right countless times over the years, but they don't have the luxury of making mistakes then privately deleting them with one simple click. This isn't Photoshop! Millions of people around the world see WWE's errors happen in real time, and there's often a lot of shaking heads when creative try to rectify their poorest decisions after the fact.

Advertisement

It's the wrestling equivalent of, 'Well look who came crawling back'.

Some WWE break-ups are genuinely heartbreaking. They're even more heart-wrenching when you don't see them coming, but a lot of splits have paid dividends in the long run. For example, Shawn Michaels needed the heel springboard of tossing old Rockers pal Marty Jannetty through a barber shop window. Without that memorable angle, HBK as we know him might not exist.

That one definitely didn't backfire, but so many other break-ups have. This pain isn't exclusive to tag teams either - there are full on factions here, as well as loved up on-screen couples who went through some hellish splits before WWE realised that they'd made a mistake by pulling the trigger far too soon or even at all.

It wasn't long until everyone glanced around the room with a nod as if to say: 'Yep, we might need to fix this and put things right pronto'. It can't be nice when writers have good intentions for the WWE roster but watch their scheming go wrong within minutes/hours/days/weeks.

These WWE break-ups all backfired for various reasons.

15. Cryme Tyme Become Enemies (2014)

Naturally, a fair number of tag team splits go under the lens here. That age old trope has been done to death, but a predictable schism between former buddies can launch promising singles careers if proper thought is put into a follow-up push. Then, there's the sad tale told by Cryme Tyme (spelling for copyright is important) back in 2010. They were treated with about as much care as a used beer cup at a music festival.

Advertisement

Shad Gaspard attacked JTG following the pair’s 44-second loss to John Morrison and R-Truth on the 2 April 2010 SmackDown. The story to this one was that Shad didn’t think he needed his partner anymore - he could thrive on his own. Standard stuff, right? yeah, well a ’Strap Match’ between them at Extreme Rules was dull, too short to really mean anything to the pay-per-view, and it was obvious to anyone watching that the split wasn’t properly thought out in the first place.

JTG hung around the main roster until 2014, but Shad was released in 2010 and tragically died in 2020. WWE has done a heartfelt job of honouring his memory since. That's worth saying. 15 years ago, the promotion split a fun babyface tag for next to no reason though, then wondered why neither man thrived on his own.

If Gaspard was supposed to be a bruising heel who thought JTG was holding him back, then he looked foolish for immediately being demoted back down to developmental for seasoning. Meanwhile, J drifted around on the 'B' and 'C' shows before spending some time in NXT.

What a fail. Cryme Tyme dwindled in popularity instantly as soon as they went separate ways.

14. The Hart Dynasty Loses Its Way (2010)

Some tag splinters need to happen. They just do. For a prime example, look at that aforementioned issue between The Rockers. Shawn Michaels was heading for bigger things, and everyone reasoned that Marty Jannetty could work well as a singles too before personal problems ruined that for him. Similarly, Bret Hart was the clear solo star of The Hart Foundation. He'd outgrown Jim Neidhart by the time they started doing their own things in 1991.

Advertisement

Nothing of the sort could be said for The Hart Dynasty, a more modern Foundation offshoot. Tyson Kidd and David Hart Smith were some tag team who complemented one another well in-ring, and Natayla was an excellent addition to the trio as manager/women’s division representative. Things looked to be going well for the trio before the 15 November 2010 Raw rolled along. That's when Kidd refused to tag in during a match vs. Justin Gabriel and Heath Slater, and this Dynasty started to fall apart.

Here's the kicker: Afterwards, WWE ended up putting both guys back in tags anyway! Smith teamed up with the likes of Yoshi Tatsu, and Kidd formed a new team with Cesaro before a cruel injury ended his career. Dissolving The Hart Dynasty when the writers did made no sense, and it didn’t lead to anything worthwhile for either male member longer term.

It was idiotic, to tell the truth.

Kidd and Smith looked to have years ahead of them as a popular duo. Worse, neither guy had the singles upside that the likes of Shawn or Bret did a generation before. It was a knee-jerk decision to split them, and one that WWE would come to regret. The fools.

13. Ronda Rousey & Shayna Baszler At War (2023)

The best storylines in wrestling have time to breathe. There's an excellent kickoff chapter at the start, a satisfying (and hopefully lengthy) middle portion that builds camaraderie then tension, and a steam-filled split that leads to a blistering feud. Ronda Rousey and Shayna Baszler can only claim to have the first part down. Their union in October 2022 made a heck of a lot of sense.

Advertisement

Both Ronda and Shayna had cut their teeth in the MMA world, and they were believably badass. Together, fans believed this no-nonsense pairing would deliver some realistic matches that rescued the women's tag division from its frequent slumber. On the 29 May 2023 Raw, Rousey and Baszler became the brand new Women's Tag Team Champs, and they were off to the races.

WWE chose a 100m sprint, not a 10k.

The submission-based pals held those belts until Money In The Bank in July when Baszler nonsensically turned on Rousey. Their follow up feud was a dud, and the ‘MMA Rules’ match at SummerSlam was brutally bad. It might even be one of the worst gimmicked bouts in WWE PPV/PLE history.

Sadly, Shayna didn’t even benefit from beating Ronda and effectively sending her packing from WWE. The creative squad forgot about her overnight after SummerSlam, and her Pure Fusion Collective stuff with Sonya Deville and Zoey Stark pre-release was nothing to write home about.

Since leaving the company, Rousey has also badmouthed it at every turn. Sorry, 'Rowdy', but you take some of the blame for how woeful your second run turned out. Some, but not all. WWE themselves fumbled what should've been some cool MMA-inspired content.

12. Stardust Stabs Goldust In The Back (2015)

The Stardust character has gone down in infamy as something Cody Rhodes ultimately rejected in order to better his career and come back to WWE stronger. He deserves a lot of praise for believing in himself and doing that, he really does. Back in February 2015 though, Cody's Stardust turned on his brother Goldust to kick start a rivalry between them that Vince McMahon didn't seem to even want.

Advertisement

Why book it then? Vince wouldn't give the brothers a one on one match against each other at WrestleMania 31...even though the split had happened shortly before the biggest event of the year. Work that one out. So, they entered a mediocre showing at Fastlane, then the newly heel Stardust leapt into a storyline with actor Stephen Amell and then fell into bed with The Ascension as ‘The Cosmic Wasteland’.

Neither idea worked, for the record, and Stardust slid further down the card. If his turn was supposed to cement Cody as a Goldust beater, then that failed. He’d leave the company due to creative frustrations in May 2016, and the rest is history. Rhodes diligently went back to basics on the independent circuit, had a blast doing so, then helped form AEW before returning to WWE in 2022 and becoming poster boy.

2015's split from Goldust was one thing, but choosing to persist with a gimmick Cody himself didn't really want to play (and one that made no sense now he was away from Dustin/striking out on his own) was madness. Sheer madness. The only "wasteland" around here was the creative thought process for Rhodes.

11. Team Rhodes Scholars Get Dunce Treatment (2013)

Stardust silliness wasn't the first strike against WWE's creative forces from one Cody Rhodes. In 2013, his fun Team Rhodes Scholars tag team with Damien Sandow went to the dogs, albeit initially for a constructive reason: Vince McMahon had handpicked Sandow to win the Money In The Bank briefcase on the pay-per-view of the same name that year. Better yet, he wanted Cody to play a part in the story.

Advertisement

Rhodes was booked to be jealous of Sandow's success. He wanted the case for himself, so Team Rhodes Scholars turned into 'Team Yesterday's News' and officially split on the 15 July 2013 Raw when Cody attacked Damien out of spite and jealousy. So far so good, right? It wasn't long before the half-baked parts of WWE's storyboarding screeched into view.

Sandow went on a baffling losing streak before failing to cash in properly on John Cena during the 28 October Raw. So much for that major singles push, and so much for Rhodes benefitting from warring with somebody who had been headed to the top. The fact that both members of the team seemed like less of a big deal following their split and Sandow’s cash-in flub is something that WWE should've been ashamed of at the time.

There was no need to have Cody turn on Damien. Seriously. Both intelligent jocks could've squeezed a lot more out of their union had Rhodes been supportive. By the time Sandow had failed to cash in, there was nothing left for the pair to do as friends or rivals. What a mess.

Boo.

10. D-Generation X’s Confusing Split (1999)

D-Generation X was the WWF's answer to WCW's brilliant nWo. It was a cultural phenomenon that birthed catchphrases like, "SUCK IT" and turned crotch chops into everyday gestures you'd see at school, work...everywhere! By 1999, the promotion started to dabble with the thought of ditching DX for a while. So, Triple H joined The Corporation in March at WrestleMania XV by helping Shane McMahon beat X-Pac.

Advertisement

People were shocked, but the fed had grand plans. They wanted to turn Trips into a headliner, but management also planned big pushes for Billy Gunn as King Of The Ring winner, and for Road Dogg and X-Pac as a tag team. By October, Triple H had reunited them as a heel unit and it was like none of that other stuff had even happened.

'The Game' was rising up the ranks, sure, but the DX split did nothing for other members; Gunn tanked as KOTR winner, Road Dogg trundled along, and X-Pac felt largely directionless. Meanwhile, Chyna (who had also leapt to The Corporation with Hunter) was doing her own thing and started co-holding the Intercontinental Title with roster newbie Chris Jericho.

A lot happened in a short space of time for the degenerates.

By the turn of the year into 2000, nobody was really talking about Trips turning on Pac or the D-Generation X split at all. Like many others on this list, it was an unnecessary snap decision centred around shock value over substance. Then, the WWF realised that they kinda liked having DX around as part of the product.

Strong merch sales can't have hurt.

9. Nidia Sees Through Jamie Noble (2004)

'WE'RE RICH, BABY!'.

Advertisement

The skits and promos worked by Jamie Noble (boy) and Nidia back in 2002-2003 were good, clean fun. Both hammed up stereotypical trailer trash gimmicks and showed significant chemistry, but nothing lasts forever in wrestling. When Nidia was kayfabe blinded by Tajiri’s mist on the 16 October 2003 SmackDown, Noble willingly put her in harm’s way to save his own skin. Thats's when Rey Mysterio told her what was going on, and the couple split.

It was risky, but initially it seemed WWE's plan would pay off; Noble beat Nidia in a ‘Blindfold Match’ at No Way Out 2004, but that was the last time both were featured heavily in their respective roles. Nidia was drafted to Raw and did nothing of note (other than cut a few Spanish-speaking promos) before being released on 3 November, and Noble was already released by that point. WWE cut him in September.

Jamie's since returned as more of a backstage agent and has carved out a successful career for himself in the spot, but his in-ring career was never the same once Nidia left his side. Looking back, WWE should've just kept the duo together for as long as possible. They easily could've reconnected after the blindness angle, and it would've been some laugh to see a broken hearted Noble pining after her.

The pop when he then won the Cruiserweight Title back due to Nidia would've been fierce, but it wasn't to be. WWE binned their characters with a view to making Nidia a bigger star on her own, then they binned her completely when that didn't click.

8. The Wyatt Family’s Senseless Split (2014)

Bray Wyatt needed a bloody statue built in his honour for repeatedly offsetting dire WWE booking and still finding a way to connect with the fanbase. Genuine, heartfelt statement incoming: Bray's creativity and zest for being an all-round entertainer bailed the company out several times. On occasion, it was like they were going out of their way to spoil his fun.

Advertisement

In 2014, The Shield’s split was impactful and memorable, but the same can't be said for The Wyatt Family. That was just flat out confusing. Bray announced on the 29 September 2014 Raw that he was setting both Luke Harper and Erick Rowan “free” from The Family, and it was wholly unnecessary. Harper joined The Authority and Rowan kicked about doing very little until they reunited as a team anyway.

Then, WWE went back on their own plan by reuniting The Wyatts at Battleground in July 2015. With a twist. Braun Strowman was installed as a brand new member, and he was clearly more intimidating than either Harper or Rowan from the off. Truthfully, plans for Rowan and Harper without Wyatt as their on-screen leader were half-baked and flimsy. Luke becoming part of Triple H and Stephanie McMahon's power base didn't sit right somehow, and Rowan just had no sense of purpose.

Bray could've done with both troops when feuding with The Undertaker heading into WrestleMania 31 too. That would've made it more believable that he was about to double down on 'Taker's streak pain by adding another loss to the icon's previously unblemished record.

This was one split that helped exactly nobody, including fans who had been enjoying The Wyatt Family.

7. The Corre “Takes Over” From Nexus (2011)

How did WWE go from pushing Nexus as one of the most threatening and urgent acts in the entire industry to turning them into such a bad joke? John Cena burying the faction just because he could at SummerSlam 2010 has to take a fair share of the blame for that - even Chris Jericho and Edge thought the head boy was nuts for squashing a top heel faction so readily.

Advertisement

After SummerSlam, Nexus didn't carry the same threat it had since June. Wade Barrett was later ousted from the power position in his own stable by CM Punk, so he darted off to seek sanctuary on SmackDown and formed The Corre on the 21 January 2011 episode. No need to sugar coat that one. Even Wade would understand. The Corre sucked.

Barrett, Justin Gabriel, Heath Slater and Ezekiel Jackson comprised the new offshoot group, whilst Punk led a New Nexus over on Raw. It wasn't a satisfying solution for either side. Punk's new incarnation of the rebels felt neutered and like the whole Nexus thing had run its course, whilst The Corre had a rubbish name and carried even less menace than the likes of Barrett, Gabriel and Slater had before being crushed under the all-conquering boots of 'Super Cena'. 

Splitting Nexus in two (effectively), sprinkling in some new members (Jackson, Mason Ryan, Michael McGillicutty) for both and generally expecting any of this to fly with the audience was poor. Surely, that second 'r' in The Corre's name stood for "rubbish". That word really can't be used enough to describe what WWE pulled in January 2011.

'Corre, what a load of rubbish'.

6. Enzo Amore & Big Cass Go From Over To Extinct (2017)

Flatlining one of the most popular teams in the biz and then failing to follow up on it with something satisfactory? You can't teach that. Enzo Amore and Big Cass were on top of the world together in 2016-2017. Then, Cass faked that he’d been attacked to redirect suspicion about Enzo’s mystery attacker elsewhere. It turned out he’d been the aggressor all along.

Advertisement

He did it for The Rock! No, wait, that's not right. That line belongs in WWE face and heel turns that immediately backfired, not here. In truth, the initial shock reveal on that 19 June 2017 Raw was effective. Cass said that he was sick of Enzo holding him back and constantly getting them into trouble with his big mouth, which was believable, but the follow up was wishy washy and went nowhere after that.

Amore attached himself to the Cruiserweight division, and Cass failed to convince as a heel before personal problems wrecked his once-promising WWE career. Thankfully, and to his credit, he’s been able to bounce back from that somewhat to earn a spot on the AEW roster, but he and Enzo went from being one of the most over acts in wrestling to largely forgotten as individuals.

Some fans thought Enzo and Cass would go on to rule the tag ranks for years to come, but they didn't even get a run as champs never mind anything else. Amore's personal life and legal fallout has tarnished fond memories of their highs for a few, but WWE scripting a split without either side really being ready to strike out on his own was ill-advised. 

Kinda SAWFT, actually.

5. The IIconics Can’t Survive Alone (2020)

Bayley and Sasha Banks were really the only concrete duo WWE's new Women's Tag Team Title division had for a while when the idea launched in 2019, but something special was brewing on NXT. Peyton Royce and Billie Kay were turning heads and earning rave reviews for their delusional antics on the developmental brand, and it seemed like destiny that they'd inject some much-needed heel life in these new belts when they arrived on the main roster.

Advertisement

After debuting on SmackDown in April 2018, The IIconics memorably won the titles one year later at WrestleMania 35. This should've been the beginning of a dominating period, but it wasn't to be. By August, WWE had moved on to Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross as the new champs. Later, The IIconics split due to a storyline on the 31 August 2020 Raw, and both appeared teary and emotional during a sit-down promo with WWE's YouTube channel afterwards. 

Weeks later, they'd gone their separate ways in the 2020 Draft - Kay went to SmackDown, and Royce stayed on Raw. Splitting these real-life mates who had come up in the wrestling business together and still had so much to offer collectively was a mistake. Neither one stayed the course individually, although Billie did try to make something of herself as a buffoonish comedy act before being released.

Some combos just need each other. This 'Iconic Duo' (their original name on NXT) fit into that category. Overnight, WWE cost themselves one of the only positive things fans had to say about the usually ineffective Women's Tag Team division. Terrible decision, lads.

Not very IIconic.

4. Lana Leaves Rusev (2015)

Prepare for a double pack of 'Ravishing Russian' attack.

Advertisement

Things seemed to be going swimmingly for Rusev and Lana until he blamed her for losing an 'I Quit' match to John Cena at Payback 2015. On the 18 May Raw, Ru-Ru tore strips off of Lana for quitting on his behalf. Sensing the chance to cause serious problems in someone else's relationship, so-called babyface Dolph Ziggler started flirting with Lana. "Good guy", eh?

On commentary, announcers alleged that the ‘Ravishing Russian’ was being “Americanised” by Ziggler. Jealous of somebody else earning Lana's affection, Rusev brought in Summer Rae as her replacement. That casting call made for a messy, confusing story which backfired on creative quickly. WWE were forced to end all of this once Rusev and Lana announced their real-life engagement later in the year.

Apparently, Vince McMahon wasn't happy about that. Yeah, apparently it was for the best that Lana and Dolph continued their Danny and Sandy from Grease-style teenage romance. Arguably the worst part of this entire story arc was that Ziggler looked like a meddling git for rushing in and stealing Rusev's would-be wife. Why? Because they were having an argument about a painful pay-per-view result? Again, what a guy.

It was evident instantly that Lana meant less without Rusev and vice versa. They'd been a superb package deal on TV, and it didn't seem logical to put a red pen through that just to explore Lana acting like she'd never tasted hamburgers or apple pie before. Red, white and (this) blew.

3. Lana Leaves Rusev A Second Time (2019)

File this under 'WWE storylines that didn't make a lick of sense'.

Advertisement

Why let logic get in the way of a good story though, right? Yes, well Lana and Rusev's second on-screen split wasn't a good story. It wasn't even close to being one. It was the worst of latter day Vince McMahon running wild. On the 30 September 2019 Raw, Lana kissed Bobby Lashley and revealed that she was going to get back at Rusev's sex addiction by...having a sexually charged affair with someone else.

Make it make sense. Like the first breakup, this second one only hammered home how much Rusev and Lana needed each other to work as characters at the time. The aforementioned ‘sex addict’ storyline WWE cooked up for Ru was rather awkward as well. Lana lambasted him for wanting to get freaky in a tank at WrestleMania 31, then cavorted with Bobby in hotel rooms with cameras present. The whole premise was typical for Vince in 2019 - it was half mapped out, then the old boss said: 'Ah, who cares about details anyway? Let's just have some fun!'. Sorry, but not many were having fun listening to Lana's hysterical shouting or seeing Lashley ask her back to bed as Rusev seemed to be getting some sort of perverse enjoyment out of the whole ordeal like he'd lost his marbles.

By April 2020, Rusev was gone from WWE and the storyline was scrapped. It'd been losing steam by the week anyway.

2. The Hurt Business Close Shop (2021)

The Hurt Business became one of the best aspects of WWE's closed door "ThunderDome" programming from late-2020 into 2021. MVP and Bobby Lashley recruited both Shelton Benjamin and Cedric Alexander as new members in July and September respectively, and business looked good. Alexander, in particular, got over for the first time in his WWE career by appearing as a sharp-suited but still vicious contender with bad intentions for everybody around him.

Advertisement

Suddenly, MVP and Lashley ruled that Cedric and Shelton weren’t pulling their weight on the 29 March 2021 episode of Raw. Bobby attacked both guys and dumped them out of the group like they were nothing. It became clear immediately that both Benjamin and Alexander were rudderless without THB, and it was obvious that the group still had a lot of juice so the split irked fans who'd invested.

Perhaps realising the error of their ways, WWE put the band back together on the 27 September 2021 flagship, but split them again on 10 January 2022. Yuck. Just yuck. This constant yo-yoing of fan interest was stupid. So, mind you, was the thought that Shelton and Cedric were angry with each other for getting unceremoniously dumped out of the group.

The timing couldn't have been worse: Lashley had just won the WWE Title on 1 March, so he should've been surrounding himself with heavies. Surely that would've been something MVP tried to do on his man's behalf? Instead, the manager exposed his own client during a period when he had a big ol' target on his back.

Make it make sense x2.

1. The Dudley Boyz Go Separate Ways (2002)

Vince McMahon knew he needed some seismic splits to make his first ever brand extension matter. On the 25 March 2002 episode of Raw, red GM Ric Flair picked Bubba Ray Dudley and made it clear he planned to pick D-Von next. Muscling in and ruining that thought, Vince took D-Von to SmackDown with him. The Dudley Boyz were to be split up on WWF television for the first time since signing in 1999.

Advertisement

A short backstage segment showed the pair looking visibly distraught. Then, they shook hands and Bubba walked off as D-Von looked heartbroken. The WWF moved on to the next segment like nothing had happened. Later, Bubba-Ray's run on Raw as a would-be Dusty Rhodes type proved to be bang average (although it did produce some cool hardcore matches), but it was really D-Von's new direction that stole eyeballs.

He was repackaged as Reverend D-Von, a corrupt man of the cloth who stole donation money rather than gifting it to good causes. Maybe the only positive one could say about this character was that it gave Batista his main roster debut. Even that was almost disastrous, but thankfully big Dave said no to McMahon's sickening backstory.

The Dudleyz weren't coping on their own, and they were decidedly less-than as individuals. So, without any warning whatsoever, D-Von ran in on a match at Survivor Series '02 to help Bubba out, and the boys were back in business. Madison Square Garden erupted for that, and the fed quietly pretended they'd manufactured this all along.

That's eh...that's what we wanted to happen! Enjoy!

What other WWE break-ups and splits backfired? For more wrestling content, check out 15 WWE Title Changes That IMMEDIATELY Backfired and 100 Greatest WWE Matches Of All Time (Ranked)! 

Advertisement