2. Michael Vick

While Vick's track record in regards to the police isn't as long as some of the other superstar athletes on this list, it's the crime that Vick was accused of was so shocking that it featured in headlines across the world, and even lead to a News correspondent, Tucker Carlson, to call for Vick to "
be executed":
"I'm a Christian, I've made mistakes myself, I believe fervently in second chances, but Michael Vick killed dogs, and he did in a heartless and cruel way. And I think, personally, he should've been executed for that."
Vick was picked up as a first round draft pick for the Atlanta Falcons from Virginia Tech as a promising Quarterback. During his time with the Falcons, he quickly became popular for his performances, and was selected for 3 Pro Bowls. In only his second year, Vick threw 16 touchdowns, and rushed another 8, for a total of over 3,500 yards gained. However, in late 2007, as Vick pleaded guilty for his involvement in a dog fighting ring, he was suspended from the NFL without pay. The incident sparked a national outcry as media outlets spilled the gory details on the ring that Vick had operated out of his own back yards, including cruel stories about dogs being viciously injured during the fights and locked in cages in Vick's backyard. The story turned the tide against Vick from being one of the most beloved sportsmen in America for his skill and work ethic to one of the most hated, for his treatment of animals. Vick pleaded guilty and co-operated with the investigation, leading to a 23 month federal imprisonment with a 4 year probation following his release. After being released, Vick returned to the NFL, signing a one year contract with the Philadelphia Eagles, and after only a year back, he returned to his career best form - passing in 21 touchdowns in 2010, and added another 9 rushing touchdowns, throwing only 6 Interceptions the entire season.