The Premier League's 10 Worst Ever Strikers

Couldn't hit a cow's backside with a banjo...

Andriy Shevchenko, Chelsea
Sean Dempsey/PA Archive
Every fan wants to see their team spending huge sums of money on flamboyant, exotic, foreign imports who have torn apart the biggest leagues all over the world. As soon as the slightest rumour appears, thousands of fans will take to Twitter to say how well they know the prospect and how perfect he will be for their team (while hammering away at Football Manager) as Wikipedia editors change the player's page playfully and often prematurely. That's the kind of excitement these players inspire. Surely these men and their glowing reputations can't fail in the English Premier League? Surely they will bring their goal-scoring boots to these fair shores to prove themselves on the biggest and best league stage of them all? Well, no, unfortunately: more often than not it seems, the more expensive players fail. It takes more than just a talented footballer to cut it in the top flight of English football. It takes someone with the mental and physical strength to deal with the pace, intensity and pressures of life in the Premier League, and to live up to the expectations of their price tag. That's why cheaper players tend to do better. For every fantastic homegrown player, like Alan Shearer, Wayne Rooney and Andy Cole, there seems to be three foreign flops, like Albert Luque, Andriy Voronin and Ricky van Wolfswinkel to name but a few. And they are far from the only ones...

10. Xisco

Xisco, Newcastle United
Owen Humphreys/PA Archive

Rating: £5.8 million

£5.8 million transfer fee. £50,000 per week. 5 years. 9 appearances. 1 goal.

Good riddance.


9. Marco Boogers

West Ham's Marco Boogers (left) about to feel the weight of a Leeds United's Rod Wallace tackle during their FA Carling Premiership match at Upton Park today (Saturday).
by John Parkin/PA Archive

Rating: £250,000

West Ham United's Boogers disappeared for a while but was eventually found cowering in a mobile home on a Dutch caravan park after a shocking tackle on Gary Neville had the national media hounding him.

After denying he was mental, Boogers managed three more appearances for The Hammers and failed to score. West Ham were forced to buy Iain Dowie of all people as a replacement, that's how bad he was.


8. Bosko Balaban

Bosko Balaban, Aston Villa
Neal Simpson/EMPICS Sport

Rating: £6 million

Balaban managed to make eight appearances for Aston Villa without scoring a goal.

Villa Chairman Doug Ellis, who is notoriously tight with his money, splashed the cash for Balaban in 2001 but saw no return on his money. Villa lost patience with the striker and sent him on his way. This looked a little bit foolish as he enjoyed a number of prolific spells before retiring in 2012.


7. Stephane Guivarc'h

Stephane Guivarc'h, Newcastle United
Barry Coombs/EMPICS Sport

Rating: £3.5 million

Stephane won the World Cup, you know.

Kenny Dalglish signed the forward from Auxerre and a goal on his debut against Liverpool signalled good things for the Frenchman.

However, he couldn't convince new manager Ruud Gullit he was up to scratch and was astonishingly sold to Rangers for £3.5m in November 1998, just months after arriving on Tyneside.


6. Andreas Cornelius

Cardiff City's Andreas Cornelius during game against Cheltenham Town in the pre-season friendly at the Abbey Business Stadium, Cheltenham.
Nick Potts/PA Archive

Rating: £8 million

Cornelius netted an impressive 18 goals in just 34 league games during his breakthrough season at FC Copenhagen at the age of just 19. Cardiff City bought the big Dane to lead their attack.

The forward managed just eight league appearances for Cardiff and he did not find the back of the net in any of them. Just six months after arriving in the Premier League, he was sold back to FC Copenhagen at a substantial loss for Cardiff.


5. Tomas Brolin

Tomas Brolin, Leeds
Aubrey Washington/EMPICS Sport

Rating: £4.5 million

Brolin felled Graham Taylor's England with a superb strike in Euro '92.

Leeds United paid a relatively huge fee in 1995 for the Swede's services but saw little return on their investment. Brolin scored four goals in 20 league games before being loaned out to various clubs.

He returned to England with Crystal Palace in 1996 but couldn't score in 13 appearances.


4. Afonso Alves

Afonso Alves, Middlesbrough
Tony Marshall/EMPICS Sport

Rating: £12 million

A brace on his Middlesbrough debut against Manchester United seemed to justify the Brazilian's move from Heerenveen.

Alves scored 45 league goals in 39 games for the Dutch side but could only manage 10 in 42 for Boro. That was despite collecting a mammoth £50,000 a week on Teesside. Boro were relegated at the end of the 2008-09 season and Alvez was soon out the door.


3. Andriy Shevchenko

File photo dated 11-05-2008 of Andriy Shevchenko, Chelsea.
Rebecca Naden/PA Wire

Rating: £30 million

The Ukraine international was on course to become one of the greatest strikers in history during his time at AC Milan but a big money move to Chelsea ended a prolific spell in Italy.

Shevchenko scored just nine Premier League goals in 48 games between 2006 and 2009.


2. Ade Akinbiyi

Leicester City's Ade Akinbiyi (centre) celebrates scoring the first goal with Trevor Benjamin (left) and Andrew Impey (right) during the Premiership game between Leicester City and Sunderland at Filbert Street, Leicester. ONLY - THIS PICTURE CAN ONLY
Nick Potts/PA Archive

Rating: £5.5 million

Akinbiyi failed to score in 15 Premier League appearances for Norwich City between 1993 and 1994. Fast forward a few good seasons in the lower leagues and Leicester City bought the striker for a ridiculous amount.

He was soon labelled 'Akin-panic-biy' by supporters as he became renowned for missing absolute sitters. Ade managed just 11 goals in 58 Premier League games.


1. Jo

File photo dated 01/12/2010 of Manchester City's Joao Alves Jo.
Martin Rickett/PA Archive

Rating: £19 million

Jo cost Manchester City close to £20m in 2008. Fast forward a few uneventful months and the Brazilian, that was part of their squad at the 2014 World Cup, was down the pecking order behind the likes of Benjani, Felipe Caicedo and Ched Evans.

He was shipped off to Everton on loan but things didn't get much better for Jo. He left English football with a record of five goals in 27 games.


Content Producer
Content Producer

Video & written Content Producer for WhatCulture Wrestling. NCTJ trained journalist. BA Hons, Sports Journalism.