One MIND-BLOWING Secret From Every WWE SummerSlam

28. 1998 | Jerry! Jerry! Jerry!

Bellas Jerry Springer
WWE.com

As poorly as 1998 has aged - if the Rock ever ends up running for President, he best hope that his interactions with Chyna never resurface - Vince McMahon was in inspired form. He completely subverted everything you knew about the WWF. His empire was originally built on the use of celebrities; the Attitude Era tweak on that idea was brilliant, in that it let casual fans in on how much things were about to change. 

At WrestleMania 14, Vince brought in controversial figures like Pete Rose, who had been disgraced by a 1989 betting scandal; Gennifer Flowers, who had achieved renewed notoriety in January 1998 when sitting President Bill Clinton admitted that he had in fact shagged her; and, of course, the convicted rapist Mike Tyson, who acted as the special enforcer for the main event between Stone Cold Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels. This theme was set to continue at SummerSlam 1998. Per the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Vince McMahon wanted to use Jerry Springer in some capacity or other. 

Springer was the star of his own talk show, which was a thinly-veiled excuse for troubled people to fist-fight for middle America’s entertainment. In other words, he was such a perfect fit for WWE that you can’t believe he didn’t turn up until 2010. Which feud could he have mediated in the summer of ‘98?

Sable was still feuding with Jacqueline. Springer often held segments in which homewreckers were confronted (and then battered, obviously). You could argue that such a catfight was too ECW, but this was 1998. That hardly stopped the WWF. 


27. 1999 | The Original Undercard

Road Dogg
WWE.com

SummerSlam 1999 underwent a quite public change in direction - Triple H’s Shane Douglas tribute act not quite being main event-ready is hardly a mind-blowing secret - but the undercard was not finalised internally until the week of the show, either. 

One floated tweak was very typical of the era, in that, per the August 23 edition of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, one bout was set to get an extra participant.

The Hardcore title match between the Big Boss Man and Al Snow was set to include Road Dogg. This Triple Threat match didn’t end up happening, and thank God for that; Pepper was a far better dog than Brian James at this point, because Road Dogg was only truly over in 1998. The singles match was a bit long, but it was of tremendous value. Mostly.

Pepper, Al Snow’s beloved companion, became a key point of the SummerSlam match and, subsequently, one of the best worst storylines of all-time. The material was rubbish, or at least should have been rubbish, but Ray Traylor was absolutely brilliant at portraying a brusque, vile-voiced psychopath who thought doing the worst things imaginable was hilarious. The cackle on the man was evil. Infamously, Boss Man killed Pepper and fed Snow the remains, but it could have been worse: he could have been Billy Gunn, who was murdered in even more gruesome fashion by the Rock around this time. 

Road Dogg did find a way to undermine the match without being a contestant in it. His “roving reporter” live commentator role was excruciating on the rare occasions you could make out what he was actually saying. 

Additionally, the eventual Tag Team Turmoil match at SummerSlam ‘99 was originally conceived as a battle royal before the WWF actually got creative.


26. 2000 | Original Tazz Plans

Tazz WWE
WWE.com

The WWF never got Tazz, or, more accurately, they never wanted to get Tazz. 

As incredible as he was in ECW, he was simply too short for Vince McMahon to ever push to the main event level. He was also broken-down physically by the time he made what was an exceptionally cursed jump. 

It started brilliantly. Madison Square Garden took him seriously as a credible ass-kicker, and Kurt Angle bumped around gleefully for him at Royal Rumble 2000. Then basically nothing happened. By SummerSlam 2000, Tazz portrayed a generic bully, whose comeuppance was dealt by, of all people, Jerry Lawler. Tazz tried to menace Jim Ross, Lawler stopped gawping at knockers long enough to stand up for his colleague, then Lawler, a full-time commentator, won a SummerSlam match that went less than five minutes. An attempt was made to “protect” Tazz, in that Ross smashed a glass jar over his head just before the finish, but it hardly worked or mattered. By the end of the year, Tazz was milling about on the Heat and Jakked C-show circuit. While Tazz won a rubbish Strap match sequel at Unforgiven, that he feuded and went 50-50 with an old commentator did not get him over, funnily enough. The alternate timeline might not have doomed him. 

Per the July 31, 2000 issue of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Tazz was originally pencilled in to wrestle Rikishi at SummerSlam. He’d have probably lost, since Rikishi was a bigger star at the time, but watching Tazz suplex a far bigger dude, always an awesome sight, might have earned him some new fans. 

Alas, a match against Cratered Ass Jones never did come to pass.


25. 2001 | A Second Storyline For WHO?!

Undertaker Sara
WWE

In one of the worst and most destructive storyline developments ever, Diamond Dallas Page was revealed to be the stalker of the Undertaker’s wife Sara. In addition to the obvious plot hole - many fans would have sold a kidney for Kimberly Page to look at them in disgust - Sara was an astonishingly poor wrestling actress. She developed rigor mortis whenever she was called upon to bump, and the sight of her putting up the dukes made Eva Marie look like Dump Matsumoto. She was so poorly equipped in the art of performance that she practically muttered every line. Incredibly, the WWF thought it would be a capital idea to book Sara in a second storyline. What? 

She was absolutely horrendous. She was the worst person to work onscreen with the Undertaker, and the Undertaker feuded with Giant Gonzalez. 

And yet, according to the May 28, 2001 issue of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, there were plans for Steve Austin and the Undertaker to work a match at SummerSlam on the back of a programme “involving both men’s wives”. Again: what? 

Debra was the worst part of the WrestleMania 17 build. Sara was the worst part of the Invasion. Any time a wrestler defends the honour of their wife is cringeworthy in the extreme. This might have been the worst thing to happen to wrestling in 2001, just edging out a WWE monopoly for the top spot. 

Sara almost worked double the amount of storylines as several ECW and WCW wrestlers. That’s mental. How was the Invasion storyline almost worse?!


24. 2002 | Hulk Hogan Vs. ?

Hulk Hogan Vince McMahon
WWE

WrestleMania 19 was an alarming failure at the box office. 

The show was built primarily around the meeting between Hulk Hogan and Mr. McMahon, the premise of which seemed ideal for WrestleMania - at least as an upper midcard attraction. Who was responsible for the success of the Grandaddy of Them All? 

The contest should have been a Fatal 5-Way that also involved Mr. T, Cyndi Lauper and Richard Belzer on that basis, but it was a strong concept that, if nothing else, underscored the extent to which the brand had grown over the years. The match itself was fantastic black comedy - Vince’s blood-soaked leer was one of the best ever facial expressions from the doyen of the craft - and a smoke-and-mirrors masterpiece that complemented the big star match-ups and technical feasts elsewhere on the card. Folks were happy to see it in the building, but weren’t frantically making calls to order it at home; just 560,000 people purchased the event, which was the worst WrestleMania number since WrestleMania 13 in 1997 (237,000), and was bettered every single year until the launch of the WWE Network in 2014. Even then, with WrestleMania 30 available for a tenner - on top of a complete PPV archive and thousands of hours of WWE content - the traditional buy amount was still 684,000. WWE might have drawn a stronger number for ‘Mania 19, had they not went so big promoting a fun sideshow, and this was almost the case. 

According to the June 3, 2002 edition of the Wrestling Observe Newsletter, Hogan Vs. Mr. McMahon was first planned for SummerSlam 2002. 

This of course didn’t happen; Hogan was removed from TV at his own request because his back and knees were shot. It was thought that a lengthy hiatus might arrest his rapid decline as a drawing card. 

This didn’t happen, either.


23. 2003 | SummerSlam Basically Happened One Month Late

Randy Orton Shawn Michaels Survivor Series
WWE.com

Provisionally, WWE had planned to book Triple H Vs. Goldberg for the World Heavyweight title at SummerSlam 2003. It was a worthy main event, but, faced with zero competition, the so-called Ruthless Aggression Era kickstarted WWE’s now-standard booking habits of delay and filler. WWE thus opted to bring back the Elimination Chamber gimmick at SummerSlam, pushing back the singles meeting to the September special, Unforgiven, in order to pop two PPV buys. While it made boring financial sense, this dithering was key in slowing down Goldberg’s momentum. What, then, did WWE originally have planned for the remaining Chamber participants? 

According to the June 23, 2003 issue of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Randy Orton was set to go one-on-one with Shawn Michaels. This was good, forward-thinking booking; in this timeline, before plans changed again, early conversations around WrestleMania 20 centred around a Triple H Vs. Randy Orton main event. Orton needed a big, statement-making win to legitimise him to the audience. A suddenly job-happy Shawn Michaels, who didn’t think his schedule aligned with that of a World champion, was the ideal opponent. WWE also delayed that match to Unforgiven - to its cost. 

Unforgiven, basically the original SummerSlam card in many respects, drew 360,000 buys - down from the two most recent B-level PPVs Vengeance (July 27, 365,000) and Badd Blood (June 15, 385,000). 

Fans attach a certain sense of prestige to the big four/five PPV events. Goldberg and Orton winning at SummerSlam would have declared a more emphatic vision of WWE’s short and long-term future. 


22. 2004 | A Decade Later And Nothing Learned

Mordecai WWE
WWE.com

At SummerSlam 1994, the Undertaker faced a version of the Undertaker: an imposter, portrayed by Brian Lee, brought in by the Million Dollar Man Ted DiBiase. 

At just nine minutes long, it still felt like at least an hour. It took six years for Vince McMahon to realise that the Undertaker would excel as a relentless killer babyface only if the correct opponent, Mick Foley, created movement by attacking him viciously and bumping like mad. It was at least something of a very basic spectacle when the Undertaker fought a giant and - eventually, right at the very end - took them off their feet. Brian Lee offered absolutely nothing; he was brought into mirror the methodical version of ‘Taker, resulting in the pro wrestling equivalent of two frigates attempting to bypass one another in an especially narrow canal. You might think that Vince McMahon would have learned from this; after all, whenever the promotion puts itself over for the success of the Attitude Era, WWE drones on and on about how they tapped into the pulse of the youth market and developed a show that was better than Jerry Springer and South Park combined. 

You’d be wrong. 

10 years removed from SummerSlam 1994, the Undertaker almost faced a version of the Undertaker: his exact opposite, portrayed by Kevin Fertig, a self-professed figure of purity who vowed to rid the world of sin or whatever. If ‘Taker was the darkness, Mordecai, a hypocritical heel, was meant to represent the light. 

Dave Meltzer reported in the June 21, 2004 issue of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter that Undertaker Vs. Mordecai was scheduled for SummerSlam. This direction was dropped when WWE realised how rubbish Fertig was. 


21. 2005 | The Pre-Matt Hardy Plan

Edge Matt Hardy Summerslam 2005
WWE.com

On April 11, 2005, WWE released Matt Hardy from his deal. 

His partner, Amy ‘Lita’ Dumas, had engaged in an affair with Adam ‘Edge’ Copeland. The fall-out was vicious and bleak. As awful as this must have been for Hardy, his public meltdown, of which WWE wanted no part whatsoever, brigaded countless fans into slut-shaming Lita. It was deeply unpleasant business. Hardy’s sympathy eroded as Edge, belatedly, generated momentum as an actual heel. He got to have Lita, and you didn’t. He got to keep his job, and Matt didn’t. This proto-incel stuff was ugly, but no less fascinating, and, because this is wrestling, an angle was born. Hardy returned on the July 11 episode of Raw. And, because this was WWE, Edge beat Hardy in less than five minutes at SummerSlam. Hardy’s return wasn’t planned. Like a good carny, he worked a work out of his heartbreak and got his gig back after an online campaign. So what was planned for SummerSlam before the midcard was hurriedly revamped to accommodate this half-real blood feud?

Per the July 18, 2005 issue of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Edge was meant to challenge John Cena for the WWE title. He was replaced by a wantaway Chris Jericho, who fancied exploring avenues outside of wrestling and, never fussed about doing a job, happily put Cena over on the way out. 

A returning Triple H Vs. Ric Flair was also scheduled for SummerSlam - but Meltzer reckoned that Triple H removed himself from the show. There were two working theories in play here: either Triple H wanted to take time off to refresh his character after a long old run on top, or he was scared that Hulk Hogan’s return, originally envisioned to be full-time, would force him down the card. 

You decide. 


20. 2006 | One Last Match

Kurt Angle ECW
WWE

2006 was a terrible year for WWE’s onscreen product - and big juicy soaped-up rumours, it would seem. It’s just as well that 2007 yields something utterly phenomenal in the theatre of the mind. 

The subject of this list isn’t the Undertaker Vs. the Great Khali, but that is the most prominent lost match of SummerSlam 2006. If your brain is capable of retaining information from two decades ago, you’ll probably recall that Khali laid down the challenge for a Last Man Standing match at SummerSlam, to which ‘Taker said “Can we do it on telly instead, mate? My hip is giving me bother and I need to take a month off.”

If you trawl through several pages of Google too many, contemporary reporting from Lords of Pain suggests that there was talk internally of adding Kurt Angle to the ECW World title match between the Big Show and Sabu. This would have improved what was a pretty tame affair, but there was just one problem: by the time SummerSlam happened, Angle was no longer with the company. He had been released and was bound for a wildly unexpected jump to TNA; the darkest rumours suggest that Vince was frightened that Angle, with his legs blackened by horrific injury, might die on his watch. 

Angle was in no condition to wrestle at SummerSlam, but this was a different time. He was somehow considered healthy enough to work a house show on August 14, 2006. In his last WWE match during his first run, he wrestled Danny Doring.


19. 2007 | Vince McMahon Vs. WHO?!

Mr McMahon Royal Rumble
WWE

It feels gross putting him over in 2026, but the best Mr. McMahon matches were phenomenal entertainment value. He was as over as any WWE performer ever, and as a heel, his facial expressions were priceless. He was superb at twisting his face into a nasty scowl, and was even better at registering the moment he knew he was in deep sh*t. He was the least athletic big name “wrestler” ever, but he compensated for that by taking absolutely stupid bumps and gruesome weapon shots. The black comedy > slapstick comeuppance formula was near-perfect, and, if the June 11, 2007 issue of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter is to be believed, Mr. McMahon almost squared off against the opponent you never realised was near-perfect. At SummerSlam 2007, McMahon was meant to wrestle Rey Mysterio. 

This event was the site of Mysterio’s big return from knee surgery, so it’s not that far-fetched (even though his actual televised comeback match ended up in a predictable revenge plot scenario against Chavo Guerrero).

Rey Vs. Mr. McMahon would have been wild. Vince would have been terrific at tearing apart Rey’s mask, with that malicious expression on his face. Then again, he might have worn one of his own in the storyline build to generate some xenophobic heat, so swings and roundabouts. Rey, one of the best in-ring babyfaces in history, would have made Vince’s own weapon shots look like crimes. 

McMahon was always great at selling concussed confusion. The sight of him dangling over the middle rope, vulnerable to the 619, would have made for quite the moment. 


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!