12 Upcoming Wrestling Stories That Are Already Doomed

Excited for these major stories to play out over the next few months? Be wary...

Brock Lesnar John Cena
WWE

There's never been a time in WWE history when the success of a story is guaranteed.

Once upon a time, megalomaniacal Vince McMahon would have blamed his talent for failing to elevate some of the worst material ever presented in the history of professional wrestling. Conversely, across both commercial booms in the 1980s and 1990s, there was action so lacking in... action that it wholly required the excitement generated by the twists and turns penned by creative heads. The machine requires every cog to turn for true perfection. 

Look at Stone Cold Steve Austin's rise and run; he worked with Bret Hart in a story so layered and of-the-time that the pair of them pulled off a gorgeously elegant double turn over a period of months that paid off in the single most important match in company history at WrestleMania 13. A year later and he was WWE Champion and set to tangle with a variety of Mr McMahon-led rivals as the story became more about the big picture war between those two than any of the individual battles along the way. In both cases, the matches met the hype, and vice versa.

These ones? Not so fortunate...

Get 76% off, four free months, and a free Amazon gift card when you sign up to NordVPN here: http://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=564&aff_id=3013&url_id=31010&aff_sub1=WhatCulture. 

12. Brock Lesnar's WWE Return

WWE SummerSlam 2025 Brock Lesnar
WWE

Brock Lesnar is back in WWE as of SummerSlam 2025 - and seemingly heading for a feud with John Cena.

Appearing for the first time since being named in Janel Grant's sex trafficking lawsuit against WWE and Vince McMahon in January 2024, Lesnar attacked Cena after his Undisputed WWE Title loss to Cody Rhodes, hitting an F5. Meanwhile, the Grant case remains open. Lesnar's name is cited 44 times within it.

From a wrestling standpoint, Cena vs. Lesnar will likely benefit from Cena dumping his failed heel run and turning babyface on the 1 August SmackDown. The 48-year-old is a better wrestler as a face, which, per Dave Meltzer, was one of the factors behind his abrupt pre-SummerSlam turn.

But bringing Brock back is a sleazy move by a deeply sleazy company. WWE parent company Endeavor let Dana white off with less than a slap on the wrist after slapping his wife in public. Conor McGregor, the subject of multiple sexual assault allegations, has never been jettisoned. 

They simply do not care.

This will not stop the online backlash that may or may not be reflected in arenas. The live crowd reacted to Lesnar with overwhelming positivity at SummerSlam. Maybe they don't care either. Scruples, it seems, are secondary to "Cinema" and "Moments."

Nonetheless, it is difficult to buy into the fiction of good guy John Cena battling bad guy Brock Lesnar one final time in 2025 when the reality is so grim. Janel Grant claims Vince McMahon used her for sexual favours with Brock, whom Vince was trying to negotiate a new c ontract with. 

(Entry written with additional contributions from Andy Murray)


11. Cody Rhodes Vs Travis Scott

cody rhodes Travis Scott
WWE

To watch WWE Unreal would be to assume that Travis Scott was to be featured into the company's main event plans for the next two or three WrestleManias, such was his bedding in to one of the biggest moments in company history.

When Triple H discusses who he has to bring in on the super-secret group call over turning John Cena heel, Scott gets top billing alongside The Rock, Nick Khan, Cody Rhodes and 'The Champ' himself. In the aftermath of Elimination Chamber 2025 and WrestleMania 41, it appeared to be clear why - the rapper was looking to be more than just a special guest. Having boxed Cody's ears during the Cena turn and eaten a Cross Rhodes as a receipt on 'The Grandest Stage', Scott can be seen on the docu-series saying he wants to change jobs.

He's since changed plans.

When Scott was AWOL in the builds for Cody and Cena's tag battle at Money In The Bank and subsequent singles SummerSlam match, reports surfaced that this was no accident nor conflict of schedules. The two sides weren't on great terms, Scott's attitude was publicly - as public as wrestling can be - questioned, and as quick as he was in at the very top of the card, he was out and nowhere near it. Thus brought about the presumed end of any longstanding programme with Rhodes, or anybody else for now at least. 


10. Ava, The General Manager Of NXT

Ava NXT
WWE

Since Triple H took over WWE creative in 2022 following Vince McMahon resigning in disgrace, authority figures have been scaled back to the point where they almost meet the impeccable standard set by best-in-class version Jack Tunney.

For the too young or simply uninitiated, on-screen WWE President Tunney was administration to such a degree that it scarcely suited his persona when he stepped out of the office and into the ring during his tenure on top between 1984-1995. Steadfast more than he was charismatic, Tunney did the paperwork it was easy to believe was required to run a wrestling company, without trying to put his foot on the throats of heels or babyfaces for no particular reason. Only when Eric Bischoff and Vince McMahon became so effective in the villainous role did it become an infuriating (and senseless) archetype, and scaling back the profiles of Adam Pearce, Nick Aldis and Ava across Raw, SmackDown and NXT respectively has worked wonders for the credibility of wrestlers and in two cases, the GMs.

For the five years she's spent in the developmental system, Ava's progress as a performer has been minimal at best. Attempts to wrestle have been limited to (as of writing) just six matches, and her verbal displays have been lacking enough that she's been given two assistants to do half of the work in backstage promos. There's always going to be extra time allotted to second generation stars, and in wrestling you never say never, but "doomed" feels generous for whatever outcome she might ultimately arrive at in her increasingly limited spot. 


9. Austin Theory's Babyface Run

Grayson Waller Austin Theory
WWE

A development that could scupper two stories at the same time, the current likelihood of an Austin Theory babyface turn lighting the territory on fire is about as plausible as WWE making good on the incredible heel turn by Xavier Woods and Kofi Kingston on Big E in December 2024.

To recap, the former pair divorced themselves from the latter in a shocking and hugely emotional segment, cruelly brushing off E's potentially career-ending neck injury as him abandoning them when they needed him most. The transgressive act should have propelled them to spots as the entire company's top heels, but they were instead marginalised as comedy stooge villains, and a WrestleMania 41 Tag Team Title win felt hollow due to the sheer lack of interesting competition in the division.

And speaking of that, A-Town Down Under hadn't fared much better. A novelty WrestleMania 40 tag title win felt more than months ago when Grayson Waller started hanging out with Woods and Kingston and burying is partner, and when the split was made official in July 2025 without Theory even appearing on screen, it didn't bode particularly well for his future.

The lowkey severance is in line with where Theory's allegedly been rocking houses as a good guy in the making. Occasional posts of his Main Event pops might say something, even if he's not somebody Cody Rhodes might currently be concerned about, but with deep roots as the smug goof, his chances of success in a particularly stacked field seem slim. 


8. The Hardys' WWE Return

Hardy Boyz Fraxiom
WWE

Matt and Jeff Hardy weren't the first ex-WWE stars to use the market leader's relationship with TNA to potentially work their way back into a full time job there, but their two-match run on NXT served as a particularly strange audition.

In almost direct opposition to how the rest of the deal between the two sides has gone so far, Matt and Jeff arrived as TNA Tag Team Champions, got a win over regulars No Quarter Catch Crew, defeated then-undefeated NXT Tag Team Champions Fraxiom in a bout where only the TNA straps were on the line, and promptly exited stage left back to the Impact Zone.

The programme was weirdly one-sided, perhaps in some sort of concession to Total Nonstop Action ahead of both Trick Williams and Jacy Jayne winning gold and Joe Hendry and Mike Santana featuring prominently on Tuesday nights. It might be that The Hardyz were hoping that at some point they could rock up on SmackDown and return the favour, but no such booking has been forthcoming - there's been no mention of the veterans on the developmental brand or main roster since they snuck back in through the side door, and though the business relationship continues, the multiple roster overlaps haven't featured the WWE greats. 


7. Another DIY Glory Run/Breakup

WWE Tag Team Titles Johnny Gargano Tommaso Ciampa DIY
WWE.com

As both heels and babyfaces in the Triple H era of WWE, Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa have had a consistent presence in the tag division, even scoring blue brand gold along the way. But something else has been ever-present too - a troubling lack of noise for much of their work.

In an era where so many characters are greeted with euphoric cheers, boos and chants, the former NXT Tag and Singles champions get hardly anything at all. The black-and-gold comparison is only more damning, not least because of the time between then and now too. Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock's entire main event runs could just about fit in the space between the pair's One Final Beat pandemic disasterpiece and 2025, and there aren't too many wrestlers more diametrically opposed in terms of megastar aura than 'The Texas Rattlesnake, 'The Great One' and DIY.

Triple H remembers just how massive the pair were as he reached the apex of his stint as NXT booker in the 2010s, but fans filling main roster buildings don't seem to have the same nostalgia. Many of the disillusioned millennials he courted back then migrated to All Elite Wrestling, replaced (eventually) by a younger crowd hip to the WWE of today rather than what came before. Gargano and Ciampa are the type to fulfil potentially crucial roles as gatekeepers for tomorrow's stars, but any chance of them experiencing the glory themselves looks long, long gone.


6. Golden Lovers Reunite

GOLDEN LOVERS
NJPW

The returns of Kenny Omega and Kota Ibushi from serious health issues and injuries in 2025 have been extremely satisfying to watch play out. 

In the case of Omega, the true and full extent of his diverticulitis-related absence makes wrestling seem relatively trivial in the grand scheme of things, whereas Ibushi's 2023 matches were remembered more for what he could no longer do than what he was still capable of. That, years removed from low ebbs, they are back performing in All Elite Wrestling and hanging with some of this era's best and brightest is encouraging, but it may be wise to temper expectations about a fresh run for the pair.

Ultimately, while tag team wrestling typically halves the workload, the Golden Lovers come with expectations higher than most and a legacy both men will presumably want to preserve. For all the fantasy booking options that exist with AEW's large and varied roster, the prospect of the pair falling even slightly below the in-ring standard they set in the 2010s stands to do worse than simply leaving the team in the corridors of history.

Odd matches and one more potential clash with The Young Bucks might be fun exhibitions to add extra value on pay-per-view, but any hopes for an extended run are probably best left parked before being outright dashed. 


5. The Wyatt Sicks

Andrade Rey Fenix The Wyatt Sicks Joe Gacy Dexter Lumis
WWE.com

The Wyatt Sicks can now be condemned as a noble failure, and the nobility is absolutely worth lingering on.

A group led by Uncle Howdy that featured Nikki Cross, Joe Gacy, Dexter Lumis and a returning Erick Rowan was a worthwhile continuation of Bray Wyatt's legacy, and their formal introduction in 2024 sought to maximise the love Wyatt's fanbase had for the lore by giving each member logical explanations as to why they'd embraced the darkness. Separately and together, they were oddly credible in spite of the presentation, and an early programme with the listless Final Testament was - if nothing else - an easy way to flesh the gimmicks out bell-to-bell and try to get them off to a winning start.

Alas, WWE creative appeared to tire of all of that, and the group went AWOL beyond the odd (and typical to the point of being dull) teases of their imminent return. They snared tag gold on SmackDown in a division playing hot potato with the belts, and all babyface sentiment was flushed as they became cheating heels that used their added psychological edge to...pull the referee out at two and run distraction finish plays.

The end may not be in sight anytime soon, but it was clear from that point we had reached the beginning of it. 


4. Rusev Vs Sheamus

Rusev Sheamus
WWE.com

Rusev's 2025 WWE return already felt like it was faltering before he went 50/50 with Sheamus in matches that got very little from the audiences despite the hard-hitting bombs lobbed between the former League Of Nations partners. 

It was another case of the market leader not really acknowledging exactly who was buying the tickets in all those full buildings, but the fact that it happened twice suggests that it was part of a wider plan from the company and we can expect more of it until something gives between one of them. There's been blood, sweat but no tears yet - and the only ones likely to be shed are to be from superfans of both rather than the majority viewers tuning in patiently waiting for one of the bigger stars to arrive.

And yet, almost in protest of the lack of heat, it persists. 

The best case scenario for both men is for this to end up going the same way as The Bar and giving them a dependable run as a doubles act in a Raw tag scene that could desperately do with some fresh blood. If a best-of-[insert number] doesn't at least provide that, what's this all been about?


3. Chase U 2.0

Chase U
WWE

The original Chase University idea was one of the wackier ones from a period of NXT where such things were normalised, and like a lot of things that go to the trouble of simply sticking around in wrestling, it started to get over.

Andre Chase and Duke Hudson made genuinely pleasing Tag Team Champions, while Thea Hail found herself as the beloved nearly-woman of the women's division and played her part in an oddly charming - if completely illogical - subplot alongside Jacy Jayne. Much was illogical about an American University named after its leader operating within an existing wrestling "Performance Center" though, and it spoke to the eventual strength of feeling that so much of it was waved away.

Indeed, parting brought sweet sorrow when Ridge Holland dismantled the stable, and the sense that a mistake had been made resulted in a reboot to give Chase something to do and brand new members Kale Dixon and Uriah Connors something to sink their teeth into. If only Shawn Michaels and his team agreed. A lack of clarity on what exactly the new recruits are supposed to be learning, or indeed if learning is part of the syllabus is enough of an issue to stop them getting booked to wrestle. And when they do, they lose, fundamentally undermining the wider purpose of the...uh, academic institution.

You see? It's too silly without some credibility, and there looks almost none forthcoming any time soon. 


2. Roman Reigns vs. The Rock

The Rock Roman Reigns
WWE.com

The Rock believed that audiences were so desperate to see his match against Roman Reigns main event a tentpole WrestleMania that he booked himself to take Cody Rhodes' spot in the middle of the ring on SmackDown.

Underestimating just how connected WWE fans were to ongoing storylines and the longstanding quest Rhodes had been on since losing to the 'Tribal Chief' one year prior, it proved to be one of the funnier screw-ups of 'The Great One's latter-day career. Stuck in the past (and up his own hole) Rock's certainty and hubris being shattered was amusing, but it did go some way to diminishing the excitement around a contest that had indeed had years of Bloodline lore attached. Rock and Roman Reigns were hypothetically positioned next to and against one another for most of Reigns' topline run, but the more Roman finally found himself as WWE's actual top guy, the less a battle with his most famous family member felt all that crucial.

Removed from the drama of the WrestleMania 40 build, the two could easily reheat a major match, but Rock's persistent verbal diarrhoea and moving of goalposts has done so much to wreck what was once a genuine slice of familial magic. And it's not the only mega money Johnson dream match that now seems like it can't possibly live up to expectations...


1. Cody Rhodes vs. The Rock

The Rock Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes and The Rock seem destined to go back and forth with one another per the latter's whims if the WrestleMania 40 and 41 builds are anything to go by, but it's precisely this reason why there will never be a pot of gold waiting for any of us by the time the pair take all of Dwayne Johnson's 20 steps (or however many it is now) to the end of the rainbow.

It's been three decades, and still, Rocky sucks. Enveloped in the idea of self-satisfied storyline "chaos" whilst instead just serving to legitimately tear through whatever plans happen when he's not around, Johnson is a rotten fit when he makes his creative presence felt. That's not to say good things don't spring forth from some of his interjections, with 2024's 'Final Boss' iteration in particular making good on perhaps his best ever temporary return to the weekly product. But he repeatedly sets or creates half-baked expectations that can't be met, is very clearly most concerned with the integrity of his own detached persona more than anybody else's, and effectively stands now as the figure of influence most reminiscent of WWE's creatively bankrupt nadir. 

Rock pinned Cody at WrestleMania 40, 24 hours before he became WWE Champion. Cody told Rock to "go f*ck" himself at Elimination Chamber 2025 when Rock wanted his soul, having put him over glowingly at the Raw Netlfix premiere just a month earlier. They will surely have a match down the line, but like everything else, it will reek of something else made up as they went along rather than a detailed, elegant story spanning years. 


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.